Not only that, but O1 is just easier to work with!
Alan DuBoff
>Derek wrote:
"A2 steel holds an edge better than O1 (2-4 times as long). D2 holds an edge twice as long as A2. The downside to these steels is that they are progressively more difficult to hone. So it is a case of priorities."
Speaking for myself, I can work O1 much easier than I can A2 or D2 in the sense of being able to forge, fabricate, temper, and hone. Not just honing, but getting the blade to a working state is much easier with O1.
A while ago, Ron Hock made a comment to someone on the oldtools list, which I haven't subscribed to in a quite a while, but he asked someone why they used junkyard steel (5160) and why they didn't go out and get some decent O1. I had to ponder about that for a while, as I have never bought a clean piece of steel to forge, I have always used coil springs, plow discs, wagon wheels, leaf springs, tractor pins, axles, etc...but recently I have realized that it makes sense to work the steel you can readily buy and that is the most workable for the person. This is all very similar to the type of wood we select to use on a project, I prefer to use premium quality hardwoods in most cases. Made me realize that maybe I should use some decent material to forge...so O1 is on my list of steel to forge.
O1 is very similar in qualities to 5160, or what is commonly referred to as tool steel found in junkyards. Tool steel tempers with oil, hence the O in O1 (W1 tempers with water for instance). A2 and D2 are very different and much harder, and I think less desirable in the sense that for the average person it is harder to work with, including honing. I just don't see the advantage.
Also, Barr uses D2, and it is tough stuff, and it does hold an edge longer than most other common tool steels, but he also does a lot of power hammering, grinding with huge power machines, etc...and I suspect he does more grinding than he does forging. These steels are very difficult for the average person to work with.
I had a piece of S7 given to me by a friend. S7 is interesting in that it not only tempers with oil, but with air also. It also air hardens as you work it. This means the stronger you forge it, the more it hardens on you. Very interesting steel to work. I could barely budge the stuff with a 4 lb. mini-thug of a hammer. As it gets smaller it is easier to forge, but getting it small is difficult, at best. Yet another steel to stay away from, IMHO. HSS is also difficult to work/forge, I have tried to forge an old Oliver 24" planer blade, and I could start to move it a little, and it would start to disintegrate with splinters flying around the smithy...the other smith at the time didn't care for that too much...*grin*
And because I prefer O1 for workability and ease of availability, that doesn't mean the next craftsman will prefer the same. I have seen many people touting that A2 holds an edge much longer, ok, and how long does it take to touch up an edge again? A lot shorter time than it takes to dull it, in my experience...;-)