Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

A2 vs High Carbon Plane Blades

Posts

A2 vs High Carbon Plane Blades

#1

A2 vs High Carbon Plane Blades

James Blandford-Baker

>I've been using both a LN A2 plane blade and a Clifton High Carbon blade in different planes for some time. It seems to me that however careful one is in preparing and sharpening it always feels as though the high carbon blade sharpens sharper (if that makes sense).

Is this a known phenomenon? Or is it just me imaging things? Is it like the difference between a TCT Router Cutter and an HSS one?

Any thoughts or technical knowledge would be welcome. Or indeed if there are ways of compensating for the difference through some sharpening technique (I always us the David Charlesworth method; I am a slavish follower of his excellent techniques)?

Many thanks

James

Re: A2 vs High Carbon Plane Blades

#2

Preliminary question

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>Hello James,

What sharpening media are you using? Oil stones, water stones, ceramic, etc?

Thanks, Wiley

Re: A2 vs High Carbon Plane Blades

#3

Re: A2 vs High Carbon Plane Blades

rarebear

>HC will get a sharper edge that A-2..

A-2 has a larger grain than HC steel but we are taking really fine grain.. Myself I dont notice a whole lot other than A-2 is harder to sharpen becuse it takes more effort..

Re: A2 vs High Carbon Plane Blades

#4

both can be equivalent

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Steve Elliot's seminal work on this topic has established to my satisfaction that most, if not all, the tool steels can be sharpened to the same degree of refinement if the correct abrasive is used. In the case of high vanadium, and hence high abrasion resistant steels, diamond is essential. I don't know the minimum it takes to get A2 properly sharpened because I use diamond for everything. But I do know that during sharpening that A2 is more abrasion resistant and hence can be more difficult to sharpen than O1 if the abrasive is slow to cut.

If you are not getting equivalent edges then there is something lacking in your technique or equipment. You may decide, as others have, that the possible benefits of A2 aren't worth the effort to change sharpening technique or equipment.

Once Lee Valley offers cast iron plates to be used with loose diamond powders, sharpening any steel will be easy for anyone willing to buy the necessary stuff. For Phil and I, M2 or even M4 is hardly any more effort to deal with than O1. We have a electron microscope picture of a diamond scratch right through a vanadium carbide grain. Vanadium carbide is the hardest of the carbide alloying elements.

Re: A2 vs High Carbon Plane Blades

#5

Chris Scholz

Re: A2 vs High Carbon Plane Blades

Chris Scholz

>James,

yes, that's pretty well established that given conventional techniques HCS sharpens to a keener edge than A2 and similar modern steel types. Of course you can get all blades pretty much equally sharp if you are willing to spend the time, effort and spare no expenses.

Also note that the Clifton blades are forged (as opposed to blades that are cut out off a pice of rolled sheet metal), and thus have a finer grain structure. It might be the same chemical composition as other HCS blades but the grain structure is quite different.

Chris

Galoot-Tools.com

Re: A2 vs High Carbon Plane Blades

#6

Where does Cast Steel or

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Crucible steel fall in the continuitum? And how is steel effected when it is forged welded onto a wrought iron blade? Does the forge welding compact the grain?

Stephen

Re: A2 vs High Carbon Plane Blades

#7

Re: Where does Cast Steel or

BobStrawn

>On the scale of relative hardness, cast, crucible, d2 or 01 are to diamond as sheetrock is to tool steel. If you use diamond, then d2 takes about ten passes on a plate, and O1 takes about seven.

I use diamond to sharpen. It is the least expensive option I could find for sharpening. Diamonds don't last forever, but they will last for quite a few sharpenings, and but a few carats of dust will last for years and years. Diamond is outrageously fast as well.

If you get a few small inexpensive cast iron skillets, and level the backs with a belt sander, and then rub them against each other with a reasonable coarse grit, you can then get them quite flat as long as you swap between three or more. The you have some nice plates to sharpen with, and you can season a plate just like you would a skillet, hang them on a hook, regrind them against each other, and keep your grits separate.

Bob

Re: A2 vs High Carbon Plane Blades

#9

Re: A2 vs High Carbon Plane Blades

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi James

As mentioned by others, I think that differences in "sharpeness" between A2 and O1 will be most experienced by those that use honing mediums that find A2 harder to manage. The extra chromium in A2 makes this steel more abrasion resistant.

I am interested in the conditions under which one would want to use a particular type of steel. It is not simply the case of one being more capable than another at attaining a finer edge. Since the issue of durability of edge must also come into the equation, the focus must also include selection of blade with wood. Here we may begin to decide whether the LN A2 and the Clifton HCS (O1) is to be preferred (and just as an aside - I have both).

Here in Oz there are many woodworkers who like to use HSS steel because of its ability to hold an edge in our very hard and abrasive timbers. Whether it can take the best edge is of lesser importance. It is more important that it can take a good enough edge but hold it long enough to complete a task.

So if O1 steel has a finer crystaline structure and may be honed to a higher level of smoothness (= sharpness), then this is preferred for those times when a really sharp edge is necessary and where it is not needed for a longer period of time. Such as with a block plane or perhaps a smoother.

A2 steel holds an edge better than O1 (2-4 times as long). D2 holds an edge twice as long as A2. The downside to these steels is that they are progressively more difficult to hone. So it is a case of priorities.

I am building a jack plane using a monster D2 blade. I have ground and sharpened a few of these blades to date, and I can say that they can get very sharp indeed. I guess that it comes down to the methods and technique that you use (diamond works well on D2). They will not be for everyone. I cannot imagine the benefit for someone that just works softwood, or moderate hardwood. O1 would last well enough and be easier to re-sharpen. Similarly, I imagine that some would experience A2 to be a major effort, and stop short of honing that extra bit that creates a fine edge.

I do see D2 coming onto the market. It is not just in the Ray Iles mortice chisels. It is also in his infill smoother, as it is in at least one of Philip Marcou's smoothers. Does this mean that we will need to invest in new sharpening mediums?

Where I like to see A2 is in areas of hard wear - jacks (especially) - scrubs, and smoothers (for abrasive timbers). Also lesser used planes, such as routers, shoulder planes, and ploughs where one does not want to spend time preparing a blade each time it is used. I have O1 blades and they get used, but they are mainly reserved for smoothers and block planes ... and of course all my vintage combination planes and woodies (but I know you are asking about new blades).

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: A2 vs High Carbon Plane Blades

#10

Not only that, but O1 is just easier to work with!

Alan DuBoff

>Derek wrote:

"A2 steel holds an edge better than O1 (2-4 times as long). D2 holds an edge twice as long as A2. The downside to these steels is that they are progressively more difficult to hone. So it is a case of priorities."

Speaking for myself, I can work O1 much easier than I can A2 or D2 in the sense of being able to forge, fabricate, temper, and hone. Not just honing, but getting the blade to a working state is much easier with O1.

A while ago, Ron Hock made a comment to someone on the oldtools list, which I haven't subscribed to in a quite a while, but he asked someone why they used junkyard steel (5160) and why they didn't go out and get some decent O1. I had to ponder about that for a while, as I have never bought a clean piece of steel to forge, I have always used coil springs, plow discs, wagon wheels, leaf springs, tractor pins, axles, etc...but recently I have realized that it makes sense to work the steel you can readily buy and that is the most workable for the person. This is all very similar to the type of wood we select to use on a project, I prefer to use premium quality hardwoods in most cases. Made me realize that maybe I should use some decent material to forge...so O1 is on my list of steel to forge.

O1 is very similar in qualities to 5160, or what is commonly referred to as tool steel found in junkyards. Tool steel tempers with oil, hence the O in O1 (W1 tempers with water for instance). A2 and D2 are very different and much harder, and I think less desirable in the sense that for the average person it is harder to work with, including honing. I just don't see the advantage.

Also, Barr uses D2, and it is tough stuff, and it does hold an edge longer than most other common tool steels, but he also does a lot of power hammering, grinding with huge power machines, etc...and I suspect he does more grinding than he does forging. These steels are very difficult for the average person to work with.

I had a piece of S7 given to me by a friend. S7 is interesting in that it not only tempers with oil, but with air also. It also air hardens as you work it. This means the stronger you forge it, the more it hardens on you. Very interesting steel to work. I could barely budge the stuff with a 4 lb. mini-thug of a hammer. As it gets smaller it is easier to forge, but getting it small is difficult, at best. Yet another steel to stay away from, IMHO. HSS is also difficult to work/forge, I have tried to forge an old Oliver 24" planer blade, and I could start to move it a little, and it would start to disintegrate with splinters flying around the smithy...the other smith at the time didn't care for that too much...*grin*

And because I prefer O1 for workability and ease of availability, that doesn't mean the next craftsman will prefer the same. I have seen many people touting that A2 holds an edge much longer, ok, and how long does it take to touch up an edge again? A lot shorter time than it takes to dull it, in my experience...;-)

Re: A2 vs High Carbon Plane Blades

#11

Re: Where does Cast Steel or

ThomD

>You probably didn't mean this, but just so a new myth isn't started harbeness is determined in heat treating, once you get into the tool steel range

Re: A2 vs High Carbon Plane Blades

#12

Why D2?

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Sounds like you have some D2 experience. We have not tried this steel. The knife makers claim a D2 edge micro chips yielding a serrated edge- good for knives and less so for planes. But then I take all statements from knife makers with some reservation. Are its properties better than M2 for a plane iron? Or to work another way what factors led yo to D2 instead of any of the other possibilities? Curious minds like to know these things.

Re: A2 vs High Carbon Plane Blades

#13

Re: Where does Cast Steel or

ThomD

>Crucible steel is a method of making steels of fine purity and in relatively small batches, what steel is made and how it is subsequently worked is also determinative. Cast steel is also an input and not an outcome, but I find it often works out to be similar to O1, easy sharpening, easy to get fine edge, professional level of edge holding, but not the ultimate level. I find tools that are cast and O1 work well in the same set, same expectations, same sharpening tools.

"Does the forge welding compact the grain?"

While something about forging leads to this idea that grain is being compacted, there is apparently no scientific basis for it. You can't compress the steel. You can get very significantly different outcome in heat treating that forging can partially affect, and that may be what is going on. This often has to do with simulating soak times you might get in a furnace, with different exposures to the fire that occur during forging. So what the smith learns over time is he is able to get better hardening results through the process he uses to form the steel prior to or on through heat treating. This result gets attributed to the hammer when it is part of the heat treating if you were to run similar heat cycles in a furnace, but because it is easy to hold soaks in a furnace nobody bothers.

With welded blades the attachment of iron has several impacts, one is the well known ability for the carpenter to work with steel that is harder than would be practical for toughness levels of that steel without the iron attached. You have a composite of hard and soft that works like a softer metal but cuts like a harder one. You also get the wider bevel that is not hard to grind which raises the possibility (in conjunction with blade contours on some Japanese blades) of higher levels of hand sharpened sharpness. Finally you get an effect on hardening where the steels in an oil hardening range can be hardened in water, which leads to a very high initial hardness for an open forge process. This also works with swords where laminated swords harden in water like 1080 steel does.

Re: A2 vs High Carbon Plane Blades

#14

myth busting diamonds.......

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>"if you are willing to spend the time, effort and spare no expenses."............

I appreciate that persons that are already satisfied with a sharpening process are not going to change. This information is for those persons that are still searching.

For those that may have joined this sharpening debate late I am going to don my Myth Buster tee shirt and respond to Chris's statement repeated above.

My sharpening technique, good for any steel know to man, consists of hollow grinding on a 7" power grinder, edge straightening on a fine fixed diamond stone and honing on a cast iron plate charged with diamond powder.

Time & Effort: During a recent demo we reground the bevel on a plane, and then sharpened it in less than 2 minutes. The diamond part took about 30 seconds. Seldom do I pull the tool more than 10 times down the abrasive surface to complete that sharpening step. Other than dressing the wheel occasionally there is no maintenance.

Expense: It is a myth that diamond sharpening is expensive. Most everyone already owns a grinder if for no other reason that lawn mower blades. So I will assume that part of the equipment already available. A suitable wheel can be had for $15-$30. I have decided that the 1/2" surface grinder wheels are the way to go and they are cheap. I use a 6" fixed diamond plate costing $25 retail. If I replace it it will be with a 12" at $66 retail. My cast iron plate was $20 and a lifetime supply of diamond powder was $25.

I have probably spent $300 experimenting with various sharpening techniques to arrive at this point. In the very beginning when I was consulting with abrasive companies on how to abrade tool steel they all recommended diamond. I too was biased into thinking that diamonds would be expensive, inconvenient, etc, so it took us a while to try them. The purpose of this communication is to convince you that diamonds are not some exotic sharpening procedure.

Re: A2 vs High Carbon Plane Blades

#15

Because some folks are masochists!

Alan DuBoff

>

Re: A2 vs High Carbon Plane Blades

#16

Re: Preliminary question

James Blandford-Baker

>I am using waterstones to sharpen. An 800 to get a wire edge and then 6000 to hone at 2 degree higher angle.

Many thanks for the many responses to this post; it seems that my hunch is probably correct. I do appreciate the wonderful expertise out there.

One interesting aside to this is that I recently bought a 12X magnifier just as I was preparing the back of a new LN chisel. Using this showed up some persistent scratches which I wasn't spotting were still there before moving to finer grit. So a bit more time spent flattening and erasing higher grit scratches has led to a sharper edge on the A2 steel. I suspect that using the magnifier on the back of A2 plane blades might well help in getting the amount of work necessary right.

James

Re: A2 vs High Carbon Plane Blades

#17

Steels and abrasives *LINK*

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>Hello James,

Thank you. The reason I ask is that each steel will sharpen differently on each abrasive. So it's useful to think in terms of 'steel/abrasive combinations' rather than 'which steel gets sharper'--it all depends on the abrasive used, as Bill Tindall points out.

A person who has done some pretty methodical work on steels and abrasives is Steve Elliott. Take a look at the link below summarizing some of his results on 'Initial Sharpness'. Specific to your situation , look at Steve's results for an LN A2 iron. The Norton 8000 stone did not get that iron as sharp as a Shapton ceramic stone, which in turn did not achieve as sharp as result as 1/2-micron diamond or CrO. This is all relative, of course, to Steve's sharpening test.

The issue pointed up by Steve's testing is whether a given abrasive will cut a particular alloy carbide. As Steve says in his writeup, he was not able to sharpen a Holtey S53 high alloy blade with a Norton 8000 stone for love or money. I have done the same thing with manmade Japanese water stones, and you can sharpen that S53 or M2 blade all day, and not get it really sharp. Because AlOx doesn't cut vanadium and molybdenum carbides. But you can with diamond media--as Bill T points out, he's got a photomicrograph showing where diamond cut through a vanadium carbide on a CPM 3V (vanadium alloy) blade. It's qualitatively the same issue with A2, although A2 is nowhere near as mean as S53 or CPM 3V, and Steve's results show the progression of effectiveness of different abrasives on LN's A2 steel, as you go from Norton to Shapton to diamond and CrO.

One other anecdotal thing I will mention, especially in regard to your observation of coarse scratches left on the back of an LN chisel after you are done sharpening it....This has to do with skipping from a coarse grit--800g or 1000g--to a finish stone of say 6000g or 8000g. My anecdotal observation is that as the abrasive begins to get marginal with respect to its ability to cut a particular steel, that it takes more intermediate grits to remove the early scratches. For example, let's say you're using manmade waterstones: You can skip from 1000g to 8000g on most high carbon steel, but when you try to do the same thing with A2, the 8000g will no longer remove the 1000g scratches. You need a middle stone. On the other hand, if you go to a very strong abrasive, like diamond, you can again skip over some intermediate grits, even on very difficult alloy steel. Bottom line: the more marginal the abrasive relative to the steel, the more intermediate grits will be useful to you.

Anyway, I would suggest you read through Steve Elliott's results, and take note of the cutting power of the different abrasives, with respect to the different steels. That is the answer to your question.

Wiley


Steve Elliott's 'Initial Sharpness' results

Re: A2 vs High Carbon Plane Blades

#18

Re: myth busting diamonds.......

Chicago Bob

>Bill,

where did you purchase the cast iron plate and diamond powder.

thanks

Bob

Re: A2 vs High Carbon Plane Blades

#19

Re: Where does Cast Steel or

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Thanks Thom,

I suspected the cast steel was harder (from hardening) than blades made of solid steel, since they would be brittle.

Best of both worlds.

Stephen

Re: A2 vs High Carbon Plane Blades

#20

Pardon my skepticism...

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>But somehow I'm still confused as to the laminated Japanese steel.

I've experienced that in Japanese chisels the quality stuff takes a very keen edge and keeps it for a very long time. AFAIK anyone outside Japan can access the same kind of steel the Japanese do, I don't know if it's a question of cost, but the results are there. Quality Japanese chisels are harder yet don't chip, I can see that the steel has something to do with it, but I can't accept that the steel alone is the reason.

Also, with a 1/8" thick hard steel piece forge-welded to a soft steel blank, I can't believe that the soft part can support a thin wedge 1/8" away. There has to be something more in play here...

DC

Re: A2 vs High Carbon Plane Blades

#21

Re: Pardon my skepticism...

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Denis,

I am not sure I have seen laid steel that thick except on axes, adzes and great big slicks. Most of the laid steel blades are much thinner than that when measured from the back side.

A long bevel will show an eight inch, but measured on the side they are thin pieces of steel. Steel was costly and the laid blades are veneers of that costly hard material.

Stephen

Re: A2 vs High Carbon Plane Blades

#22

Re: myth busting diamonds....... *LINK*

BobStrawn

>I have to agree with Bill entirely. Diamond is cheap, fast, and allows you to use metals that are not good options with conventional stones. Powder is inexpensive and precise.

A lot of folk look at my sharpening setup and think I spend a lot of time sharpening. Truth is I don't take that long, and because I have a wide range of grits, I often take longer to clean my blades between grits, than I do to sharpen. Using good range of grits, speeds up sharpening. Using diamond powder speeds up sharpening.

The edge that you can get is extraordinary, and if you are using a fine grit, the metal removed is also less.

Grain size in a blade matters as a limit to sharpness, if your sharpening media cannot slice carbides well. Diamond can. Fine grains still have huge advantages and do hold an edge much better.

Bob


The poor man's path to sharpening perfection.

Re: A2 vs High Carbon Plane Blades

#23

Re: Why D2? *LINK*

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Bill

I am definitely not an expert on D2 steel. I know enough to be wary of it, and was curious enough to want to try it out.

To quote a source, "D2 is a cold work die steel with a much higher alloy content than A2, specifically the chromium and carbon percentages are both increased to generate a large volume of chromium carbide". (link below) The high level of chromium (12%) creates a steel that is close to stainless.

Several members of the Ubeaut (Aus) forum decided to get together and build some blades. The aim was to find something that was extremely durable. Consideration was given to several steels, including HSS. In the end the vote went to D2 for its very high abrasion resistance.

Although I was aware of its use in plane blades by Ray Iles, and had discussed D2 with Philip Marcou, who is quite a fan of D2 (and also uses it in one of his smoothers), I was skeptical since I anticipated that it would be very hard to grind.

I have prepared three 8mm thick (!) 2" wide blades so far, grinding each from a solid, heat treated (!!) bar. Talk about a masochism.... I don't want to talk about it. I will say that they got very sharp on diamond paste.

One of the blades is mine. I plan to build a jack plane around it as its durability will make life easier when preparing some of the local hardwood boards. I will be able to say whether the experiment was worth it when it is done.

Regards from Perth

Derek


D2 steel

Re: A2 vs High Carbon Plane Blades

#24

Hear, hear! But with that said...

Alan DuBoff

>Derek wrote:

"I have prepared three 8mm thick (!) 2" wide blades so far, grinding each from a solid, heat treated (!!) bar. Talk about a masochism.... I don't want to talk about it. I will say that they got very sharp on diamond paste."

For most people under normal conditions, if they acquire a tool that has D2 steel, they will most likely never need to regrind, unless they want to change the angle of the bevel, for instance. So, it is possible for people to love this stuff, if you just never have to change it from how it comes to you.

It is just very hard to work, regrind, sharpen, etc...it really is not for the faint at heart, IMO.

Speaking for myself, from a forging aspect, one would have to work it like Barr, with all power tools. I don't enjoy that aspect of being a blacksmith, nor do I like the "removal techniques". By "removal techniques", this is akin to the differences between forging a blade into shape, or grinding material away to form the blade. I prefer the prior, working the steel by hand, with a hammer.

D2 is very difficult to work in that fashion, almost impossible for the average backyard smith as myself, unless you want to resort to power hammers and grinders. I've always been more of a traditionalist to accept that as being "best practice".

I also should add that I do have some blue steel matsumura chisels, and I was using them last night, I actually haven't used them in a long time. They do obtain a nice edge on them, and they feel nice in my hand, and although I will not re-work any of them, I do like the feel of them. Japanese chisels also come in increments of 1/16", and that is nice. Given that my 1/8" chisels requires some patience and less smacking in use, a 1/16" would be even that much more sensitive, IMO. But I would like to have a 1/16" chisel, I have had times where it would have come in handy.

Re: A2 vs High Carbon Plane Blades

#25

1/16" chisels are available

Andrew F in Australia

>HI Alan,

A 1/16" chisel is available, known in the trade as a skewer.

They're about 3/8 - 1/2" high, used for cleaning out stringing lines and other delicate work.

The ones I see look to be 50 year old Sorby chisels, judging by the shape of the handle.

You could, of course, easily knock one up using an old power hacksaw blade.

Cheers,

Andrew