Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Nice butt! Cheap, too! *LINK*

Posts

Nice butt! Cheap, too! *LINK*

#1

Nice butt! Cheap, too! *LINK*

David Barnett - SW Florida

>For those of you who still haven't tried a horse butt strop, Siegel of California sells them for $11.95 per pound (one butt). Their description:

_________________________________________

Tannage: Vegetable-Tanned

Uses: Holsters, Strap Goods, Chap Tops

Weight: 7/9 oz

Average size: 5 sq ft

Very tight grained and accepts dye & oil easily. Irregularly shaped; typically 45"long x 4" wide at narrowest point & 10" wide at widest point. Far superior to cowhide for durability and very economically priced. We have been selling this item for in excess of 30 years and we have always had excellent response to this little known leather. These butts are Hard-Rolled OR Soft-Rolled (indication of amount of pressure used to jack leather).

*Order by the pound. 1 lb roughly equals 1 horse butt.

_________________________________________

They do have a twenty-five dollar minimum order, so maybe buy one or two and some harness needles and thread for other leather projects. One butt is a lot of leather for stropping and they don't wear out.

Be sure to specify 'soft' when you order. It's plenty dense. Hard jacked horsehide makes for frustrating results. The fibers can't do they voodoo.


Horse Butts

Re: Nice butt! Cheap, too! *LINK*

#2

Self Deleted my own post

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>

Re: Nice butt! Cheap, too! *LINK*

#3

Re: Nice butt! Cheap, too! *LINK*

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>I have a couple of very nice horse butt strops from Joel at TFWW. A bit more expensive but finished and ready to use.

(It's the shorter one in the picture. 15"x3" and 1/8" thick).



Some use these loose as double-sided (one rough, one smoother). I prefer to glue them to a flat surface to avoid any dubbing. The leather is very hard. One is used with Veritas green rouge (.5 microns) and the other is plain.

Regards from Perth

Derek


TFWW

Re: Nice butt! Cheap, too! *LINK*

#4

Re: Nice butt! Cheap, too!

Alan DuBoff

>David,

Yeah, but a nice butt could cost in end...(is that a double pun ? I better rear out of this mess...;-).

How is the thickness on it? I noticed with bellies for instance, the thickness varied quite a bit, where the shoulder was more consistent.

The 16oz I have is so darn thick, it's almost like wood.

These butts would be one of the most reasonable way to line vises.

Others should heed your advice, leather is good to have. That's an excellent deal, especially to line vises.

I think Robin or ThomD pointed me to that leather site in a message recently, they have some nice stuff there. If you moisten up the hard leather, it becomes very pliable. Do you know what the difference is that causes the soft or hard grain? I have a piece that is softer and more pliable, but most seems harder. I asked Tandy about that but he said that most all of the veg tan'd is the harder grain side. I was using an antler to mold around a small piece of wood, as a test earlier, leather is fascinating stuff...

Thanks for the tip of the cheap piece of a...whoa, I mean nice cheap butt...;)

Re: Nice butt! Cheap, too! *LINK*

#5

Re: Nice butt! Cheap, too!

BobStrawn

>The harness is largely based on how much pressure they put on the rollers. I prefer the hard rolled, rough side up glued to a paddle.

Soft means more dubbing. You can also glue up and then lap your butt.

If you want it really hard, then wet it and let it dry without disturbing it.

If you buy $75 from Siegel the shipping is free.

Bob


img

Re: Nice butt! Cheap, too! *LINK*

#6

Nice little setup!

Alan DuBoff

>Bob,

Nice little setup you've got there. Is that the diamond paste you mentioned before? Or is that different weight oils?

Re: Nice butt! Cheap, too! *LINK*

#7

I must respectfully dissent...

David Barnett - SW Florida

>...on hard vs. soft jacked. I have both and my experience differs.

Before horse butts go to the glazing jack, the direction of the collagen fibers are ideally aligned for stropping. The surface, however, for most other purposes, benefits from consolidation.

Believe me, soft butts aren't nearly so soft as you must think. They're plenty hard and dense, indeed. We're not talking about the glovey 'hand' of the leather here but the almost wooden hardness of the 'jack' boot, with its purposes of toughness and resistance to the elements*.

The extra compression in hard jacking (glazing, sleeking, whatever), smashes the fibers to the extent little desired structure remains. Given that waxes and other compounds are added to further seal and consolidate, one might as well strop with maple (also very good) or some other hard substrate with enough tooth to hold a charge**. When viewed in cross-section under a microscope, the evidence is plain.

I also find that the hard jacked leather takes longer to break in and requires compound from the start. Not so easy to charge, too (before I found diamond paste). Another advantage to the soft: one can, as you noted, harden, compress, and further glaze should one desire (I wouldn't).

First thing I do is remove whatever's in the sleeked surface and use abrasives to get a thoroughly velvety 'tooth' You can do this to the harder jacked leather, too, but it still will be too dense. My soft jacked strop is so hard I sometimes strop my gravers to get a brighter cut. Not even the high sectional density of a graver tip harms this leather. I still have my oldest strop from the 1970s and, as a former bookbinder, am fairly particular with my parers and skivers - no dubbing on my 'soft' strops. So while I don't doubt your experience, I'll stick with and advocate for the soft jacked.

*The Cordovan 'shell', the true and best part of the butt, is stuffed before jacking and ends up with an altogether different character.

** And I certainly can't believe the natural silicates come into much play with the hard and probably not even in the soft.

Re: Nice butt! Cheap, too! *LINK*

#8

You've shamed me, Bob...

David Barnett - SW Florida

>...into straightening up my sharpening stuff. It really is strewn all over the place. Problem is, I use it in all my 'venues'. Maybe I'll make a caddy or something.

Are those scrapers? Or are they something else for sharpening, like those thin credit card sized diamond hones? As for strops, I have a bunch and they take up bench space, so I may have to go with a "wall o' butts" to bring order to the chaos.

Re: Nice butt! Cheap, too! *LINK*

#9

Re: You've shamed me, Bob... *LINK*

BobStrawn

>I have to agree the hardness of the soft is still very hard. When stropping I instinctively want to use a heavy hand. Very bad instinct. So I need hard to avoid dubbing. If one can glide the blade across without rocking or pressure,the dubbing can be kept at a minimum.

I use 0.0-0.25 micron diamond dust on my strops. The natural silica's do fine with some steels, but M2, Carbides and other more more wear resistant steels seem to ignore the silica. Sad since I think the silica will allow an even keener edge than the ultra fine diamond.

The plates are steel with various grits of diamond paste. The oral syringes are a range of diamond grits in water, except for one that has baby oil in it.

Bob


Diamond Grit Sharpening

Re: Nice butt! Cheap, too! *LINK*

#10

Re: I must respectfully dissent...

BobStrawn

>I will happily defer to your experience. :)

Since I am charging with diamond grit, in just about every case, my experience is likely to be different. I only use the plain strop with O1 or spring steel, so my experience with using the natural silica's is less. I only use an uncharged strop when I am experimenting on methods of measuring sharpness.

Dubbing will occur when pressure is used on a flexible surface. I am convinced that due to flex of the steel being sharpened, that dubbing can occur when pressure is used even on cast iron. Dubbing is not all that bad, it does reduce bite, and keenness, but it makes a more damage resistant edge in many cases. Since a lightly dubbed blade can still shave or make clean pine end grain cuts, perhaps a slight dub is not such a bad thing.

Bob

Re: Nice butt! Cheap, too! *LINK*

#11

Re: Nice little setup! *LINK*

BobStrawn

>Thanks,

Diamond paste mostly, but saying paste is perhaps going a bit strong. When the diamond dust settles, there is but a thin layer in the water. Since these powders are so fine, when shook up and a drop is put out, a beach worth of grit is placed on the plate. I sometimes have to add more water to spread out the grit.

Bob


Diamond Grit Sharpening

Re: Nice butt! Cheap, too! *LINK*

#12

Outstanding article. Excellent system.

David Barnett - SW Florida

>Because I have a RayTech faceting machine, I use rotating laps for some of my narrow edge tools, but for wider blades I lean to meehanite plates & loose diamond or pastes. You're right, Rob Kulakofsky's sites have just about anything you'd ever need and my favorite is LapidaryPro High Grade Friable Diamond Powder. Man, is this stuff good for stropping and you can get it down to 1/8 micron, if you thought it'd do any good.

I keep very sharp collodial silica flour in 200 and 350 mesh (for refractory moulds used for casting p�te de verre) and have tried the finer mesh on strops. While it works only on very simple tool steels, it has little but cosmetic value on harder blades, so I'd say you're right. Besides, that stuff's dangerous without a mask. It's cheap but diamond's far better.

Re: Nice butt! Cheap, too! *LINK*

#13

I'm pretty sure you're right about dubbing...

David Barnett - SW Florida

>...even on iron laps. In fact, I'm pretty sure dubbing of steel happens on ceramic laps with spray diamond.

As for dubbing being a good thing, I recently mustered the nerve to try the Seki City-made "Feather" double-edge razor blades. These things have a reputation for being perhaps too sharp (they use them for tissue section and in microtomes). You'll get a close shave but they do remove a layer of skin.

Some aggressive shavers have had less than pleasant experiences. I did just fine but I sure could sense the difference and felt really stressed. Some say the edge calms down after the second or third shave, but that remains to be seen. I'll find out about dubbed Feathers later today. I doubt I'll buy more after these run out, as they're darned expensive, too.

I'll never get a chisel that sharp - not a chance - so I don't know if 'too sharp' is a woodworking possibility unless it's more about the time it might take. I'll have to settle for 'sharp enough'.

Re: Nice butt! Cheap, too! *LINK*

#14

Chances are you'll only need one... *LINK*

David Barnett - SW Florida

>...so Joel's strop is fairly priced and ready to go. Jeffrey Peachy sells bookbinders a slightly shorter piece for $20, but for two bucks more Joel gives you an extra 3" of runway for plane blades and long chisels.

Joel apologizes for the cost of his product. He needn't. The costs for sourcing, fabricating, marketing all add up to not making very much on a rather rare and previously hard-to-find product. Whoever clicks these rectangles has to work around considerable irregularities in surface, shape, and thickness.

And Siegel has a minimum order, so you'd have to buy three butts, with $15 for shipping to the East coast. I use these butts for lots of things other than stropping (hinges, work-holding, mallet faces, forming silver, and so on), so it makes sense for me. If you just need one strop (two sides, of course), by all means buy it from TFWW.

Sorry about that, Joel. And thanks, Derek, for pointing that out. What I was really meant was to compare Siegel's great price to other retail leather dealers, such as the one linked below, where you'd have to pay three times as much for a hard-jacked butt strip.


Left side of the page, scroll down a bit.

Re: Nice butt! Cheap, too! *LINK*

#15

The single shoulders at Tandy seem reasonable!

Alan DuBoff

>David,

The single shoulder I got at Tandy was quite reasonable, it only costs me about $25-$30, but is a nice large piece. It was on sale, normally $5/sq.ft. so that would have normally been close to $45. At the sale price it was a nice piece of leather.

Took my first baby stitches last night. Started to get the hang of it after a few stitches. First I need to finish my saw, then I'll stitch up a case for it.

Re: Nice butt! Cheap, too! *LINK*

#16

Ah, that answer the number question...

Alan DuBoff

>Bob,

I see it is microns now, and I was wondering that when I saw the numbers on the side of the syringes.

I did do some stitching last night, and it seems getting the awl to line up with front and back is the tricky part.

The Osborne awl I got works much better than the craftool in the stitching kit. Just easier to punch. I think it has to do with the tip/point, it's just a tad thinner. I need to sharpen the tip on both.

Thanks for the pointer on the diamond paste, I'll have to get some.

Re: Nice butt! Cheap, too! *LINK*

#17

That's not even from a horse, much less its butt.

David Barnett - SW Florida

>

Re: Nice butt! Cheap, too! *LINK*

#18

Bravo on the stitching

David Barnett - SW Florida

>"Took my first baby stitches last night. Started to get the hang of it after a few stitches."

Stitching isn't really so hard and is kind of relaxing. Getting stitches even takes a bit more practice but is entirely doable. A tip: if you're marking with a stitching wheel, go back over the finished stitches with it a few times and everything will look more even and defined.

Re: Nice butt! Cheap, too! *LINK*

#19

My most difficult part is in the awl punchin'...

Alan DuBoff

>I seem to have most problem in trying to line things up to the stitching wheel, on both sides. I am starting to see how you can punch and watch the opposite side to turn/twist/direct the awl to get closer to the mark.

The other thing is that the emmert horse isn't optimal and I need to pay attention to the thread loops getting caught in the hardware/handle.

I'm doing it like shown in the Stohlman stitching book, holding the needles between the first/second fingers with the awl in the right hand. The Osborne is lighter and smaller tip, and seems easier to manipulate. I can see that making a nice awl handle could be in the future...these commercially bought ones are spit out at some plant in China most likely...*sigh*

I notice the trick is in punching just a big enough hole to allow the needles to pass through, without enlarging it to much. Otherwise it leaves a larger gap around the thread.

It sure seems to be a great skill to have, being able to work with leather, as there is quite a few things to do with it for tooling, either cases, bags, sheaths, etc...but also in utilitarian use such as the lining of a vise jaw.

Very nice for any forged tools, and even for wrapping handles as well.

Any tips you can think of while I'm ramblin', please offer them. Now it's time to fire up the 'ol 'que, the weather's nice, I have a couple days off work and playing with metal and wood...life was good until I misplaced my mineral spirits...? (probably that smarky comment about the naphtha which I fat fingered anyway...:-/).

Re: Nice butt! Cheap, too! *LINK*

#20

Thanks!

BobStrawn

>It is good to get feedback from someone else who knows diamond!

I have played a bit with friable, and I think for a final finish it is the dream. The only thing faster than diamond grit is friable diamond grit. I don't like it for the courser grits, since I want to be able to reproduce my results. Using diamond grit on plates, a few carats will last a very long time, even if you recharge the stuff well before you need to. So I don't really miss the friable. When you really need the sharp grit is when you get really fine anyway, so I like friable for the finish.

The problem with friable is that you end up with a mixed grit, but that is no issue if you are already at the finest stage. The fun part about friable, is that it may start at 1/8 micron, but it will end up being wildly finer, and still remove metal quickly.

I just bought three cast iron griddles at a Mexican Grocery. I plan to lap the backs of them against each other for flatness, and then use them as diamond grit lapping beds. If they work out, I will end up getting one for each grit and a few extra.

Bob

Re: Nice butt! Cheap, too! *LINK*

#21

Re: My most difficult part is in the awl punchin'.

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Do you use a creaser to make a channel for the thread? Do you hammer your stitches? I use a diamond shaped awl and align the long part with the stitches, it is very sharp. Even the buttons on your shirt will catch the loops of thread.

Stephen

Re: Nice butt! Cheap, too! *LINK*

#22

Yes, but haven't used the diamond tip...

Alan DuBoff

>Stephen wrote:

"Do you use a creaser to make a channel for the thread? Do you hammer your stitches? I use a diamond shaped awl and align the long part with the stitches, it is very sharp. Even the buttons on your shirt will catch the loops of thread."

I used a groover before I run the oversticher through it.

In the Stohlman stitching book they show to angle the stiches slightly, but to punch them through straight. I just need a bit of practice. The front side I punch from looks better than the back...:-/ (it is getting a bit better the more I do it)

I've used a couple different shaped awls, but bent the small round scratch awl in trying to use it with the thick leather, I did get it mostly back into shape...:-/ Best results are coming from the Osborne tip, which is kinda a chisel tip I guess, less on the sides like the diamond. I haven't used the diamond yet, but since it's thicker I thought it would be harder to push through. I will try that when I revisit later...I'm doing some metal work at the moment...well, I'm typing at the moment...:-)

Re: Nice butt! Cheap, too! *LINK*

#23

Not yet but I will...

Alan DuBoff

>Stephen wrote:

"Do you hammer your stitches?"

I haven't yet, but I will. I have a cobbler's hammer that I need to dig out, I have used it for dovetails in the past, although it's not a great hammer for that, I always liked the shape of them.;-)

Thanks for mentioning it though, I keep meaning to do that...do you moisten the leather before you hammer?

Re: Nice butt! Cheap, too! *LINK*

#24

Oh, here's a pic...

Alan DuBoff

>DB,

Here's a pic of the poor stitching in question...:-)

I'm not worried, and know it will get better.

I still need to dye it and there's a hole for a double sided rivet, you can barely see the hole if you squint and turn the lights down low...


img

Re: Nice butt! Cheap, too! *LINK*

#25

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Yes, but haven't used the diamond tip...

Jack Guzman from Maine

>I haven't done any leather work in years but when I did,I did most of my stitching freehand(no wheel marks).My tool of choice was a glovers needle,which has a three sided tip.The only time I needed an awl was for places where the stitch had to pass through more than two layers at once.A good glovers needle is sharp so it slices a hole with three flaps.The thread (I used simulated gut)passes through easily and it closes back up nicely.I'm not sure what you're calling a diamond tip but a three sided awl tip worked best for me.An awl that doesn't slice stretches the leather around the hole and as a result is harder to push through.Of course it does leave a neater hole.Just my $.02.---Jack