Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Axes, hatchets, etc.

Posts

Re: Axes, hatchets, etc.

#26

Re: Choosing

ThomD

>I have a newish Japanese hatchet. It has that extreme bearded construction, and i would love to see someone knowledgeable use it because it seems too extreme to hold up, but it has to be a technique or use thing, I imagine.

The digging would go a lot easier with a metal detector, that might be something to try...

Re: Axes, hatchets, etc.

#27

Re: Choosing

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>My Japanese hatchet is of indeterminate age, has those three forging rays and a twine/rope wrapped handle, seems very well balanced. It's in the bedroom now waiting for something exciting to happen, right beside the small fire extinguisher. :)

Pam

Re: Axes, hatchets, etc.

#28

Todd has some very interesting stuff...

Alan DuBoff

>I have seen pics once of a mummy head that Todd has. It wasn't as creepy as I thought it would be, but it made me realize why Frankenstein was the color he was...:-/ (the head actually looked pretty peaceful;-)

My wife wouldn't let me keep something like that in the house, even if it was locked inside of a vault...:-/

Re: Axes, hatchets, etc.

#29

Usually ain't hard getting women to leave Japan!

Alan DuBoff

>

Re: Axes, hatchets, etc.

#30

Re: Usually ain't hard getting women to leave Japa

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>I'd guess not. Forgot to mention that the reason Kayoko told me Yataiki didn't welcome me with open arms was that he made her tell me.

Pam

Re: Axes, hatchets, etc.

#31

oxymoronic phrase, that

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>"keep the faculty in line" - ha! No such a thing.

Re: Axes, hatchets, etc.

#32

Define "a line." :)

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>

Re: Axes, hatchets, etc.

#33

Can I ever relate! *LINK*

Alan DuBoff

>Pam,

I studied Japanese with a very nice woman in L.A. before I moved to Japan in '82. Dianne, my teacher, moved to Japan while I was living there and we had dinner several times.

She was born in Japan, but moved to the U.S. when she was 3 years old. She also went back and studied at a Japanese university, so she was very well versed in Japanese and did translating for the most part, a very hard profession to do on the fly, it's stressful.

She only lasted about 6 months, and left before I did. Her reason was she just couldn't take the treatment towards women in Japan, and living in America had allowed her to forget just how annoying it was.

Most American women that visited were sick of it after only a week or two...

The Japanese women are some of the most polite in the world, IMO, and it takes a while to understand the Japanese culture, I don't claim to be any expert in that field, but do understand it some...

I have never seen a craftswoman in Japan for any type of work.

I'm certain the only reason is just because they will not allow them to do so. I have always encouraged my wife to break the mold, but she will always be influenced by her upbringing. She is one of the most wonderful people, a wonderful Mother, most excellent wife...but she will forever be Japanese at heart. I have to understand that. We are two very different people, I am to such an extreme of her, but somehow we balance each other out and keep each other in check, so to speak.

It is changing in Japan, when I lived there in the '80s it was pretty un-heard of for women to hold executive positions, and that has been changing. Maybe one day there will be some women smiths in Japan. Probably a far fetched idea, but could happen. I just won't hold my breath.;-) OTOH, there's some incredible women smiths in America, I have much admiration for people like Lorelei Sims, her book has excellent pictures in it and she is one great smith. See linky...


img

The Backyard Blacksmith by Lorelei Sims

Re: Axes, hatchets, etc.

#34

And BTW, he can keep his scrap steel, IMO!

Alan DuBoff

>Pam,

I have to say that I feel folks like Yataiki can keep their scrap steel, his saws used to be reasonably priced until mongers like Kayoko marketed the heck out of them and drove the prices up. Yes, I do blame folks like Kayoko for pouring fuel on the fire, so to speak. A local friend was commenting on this at the LN Hand Tool event, in how all the marketing people are looking for ways to drive the prices up. As a case in point he showed me some type of Japanese measuring/framing square that was used in NorCal, could have been the same event you're talking about. Hida sells the same tool online for about $300, and you can buy it direct from Japan for about $120. He had one a friend brought to the show to give to him.

As long as American's keep eating it, the marketing people will keep serving it, IMO. ;-) This is no dis on the Japanese craftsmen at all, they are certainly fine craftsmen. It is how they are exploited because in most all cases the actual craftsman sees very little, if any of the $$$s. Most get paid by the piece until they somehow reach the esteem that folks like Yataiki did. Those are few and far between, IMO.

Re: Axes, hatchets, etc.

#35

anvils

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>Todd doesn't collect anvils, he just piles them beside his driveway. If he "collected" them he would set them in the barn.

Re: Axes, hatchets, etc.

#36

Sure, anvils stack easy, and plentiful in the east

Alan DuBoff

>But how many people do you know that have a real mummy head?

I have learned one thing about Todd over the years, that he is the real thing...he has one face, and it's real. I have grown to admire that attribute of Todd. I like real, and honest people, call me old fashioned...

Re: Axes, hatchets, etc.

#37

Re: Define "a line." :)

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>To my amazement, there are 64 definitions in dictionary.com for "line," and an additional 18 idiomatic uses of it in phrases. I think the closest definition to what I was thinking is "in conformity or agreement."

However, at most universities, you could get the faculty in a conga line, once they finished debating whether to step on the left foot or the right foot on the downbeat - but that debate would involve considerable, discipline-based discussion.

Re: Axes, hatchets, etc.

#38

Re: Can I ever relate!

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Thanks, Alan, for both your experiences and the book. I'll check it out.

Pam

Re: Axes, hatchets, etc.

#39

Re: And BTW, he can keep his scrap steel, IMO!

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Generally I look at most Japanese hand made tools as bargains, even Yataiki's saws. If you think about the time involved alone, they're not making so very much per hour. Did they used to be cheaper? Yes. Today, just the price of shipping is truly outrageous. I finally found a great seller in Japan, but once you add on shipping.... So, I'm not buying much of anything these days. Fortunately I have most everything I need and then some.

Pam

Re: Axes, hatchets, etc.

#40

Re: And BTW, he can keep his scrap steel, IMO!

Alan DuBoff

>Pam,

I think in general, the Japanese craftsmen produce some of the last quality work. It is too bad how they have been exploited. I 'spose that Kayoko was caught up in the game as well, probably still is.

They certainly take their crafts seriously, and that's is something to admire.

I have some Japanese tools, some are bargains on any market, like some of the awls, small scrapers, stuff like that, they have great stuff. I have some blue steel Matsumura chisels, but tend to use my vintage Stanleys as they're much cheaper and I have more of them. Maybe now that I have built a new bench I'll use my Matsumuras more if they are out and in front of me.

I don't care for most of the saws, although a good Mitsukawa is about entry level for a Japanese saw, IMO, as it requires that type of saw to be able to work hardwoods effectively. I mostly work hardwoods.

I know a person that has 18 Yataiki saws. That is not a typo, eighteen.

Re: Axes, hatchets, etc.

#41

Re: And BTW, he can keep his scrap steel, IMO!

ThomD

>Doesn't sound like he has adapted to the new paradigm. In the craft world prices were controlled by controlling entry as goes on broadly to this day in America and everywhere else. If you can also exclude a gender, that has to be good for the bottom line. In the teaching Gaijin to butcher wood business the opposite rules apply. I suppose you could argue that the mere fact of teaching a woomen might blow back somehow, but really a buck is a buck is a buck.

I think Japanese tools are underpriced for what Americans would charge for the same thing, if US art knife prices are any idication. And there probably isn't any US art knife maker who has any claim to a sustained tradition in the stuff he makes.

Re: Axes, hatchets, etc.

#42

Re: And BTW, he can keep his scrap steel, IMO!

Alan DuBoff

>Thom wrote:

"I think Japanese tools are underpriced for what Americans would charge for the same thing, if US art knife prices are any idication. And there probably isn't any US art knife maker who has any claim to a sustained tradition in the stuff he makes."

I'm not sure I believe that. Sure the knife makers charge for their work, but their pattern welded steel is quite different. The Japanese swords are on the same level and priced much higher.

Teaching Gaijin has nothing to do with teaching their own people, just pointing out that I have never seen a craftswoman of any type in Japan. I'm sure there could be, I mean if you go to Japan Woodworker there's a pic of a guy *letting* his wife be a striker, for instance...LOL!

Most of the knife makers grind material away, and the Japanese typically forge it, so the two are quite different. Both labor intensive though, many of those nice knifes in America take hours and hours to create. Many of the smiths spend more time on pattern welding than they do on the knife itself.