Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Axes, hatchets, etc.

Posts

Axes, hatchets, etc.

#1

Axes, hatchets, etc.

Rob Hix - King George, VA

>Hey all,

Me again. Following up on my previous post about the green wood, I went out on the web and looked at axes at the woodworking tool dealers. These guys are out of their minds on the prices.

So, for my application of riving out these logs, I am just as well off with a good name brand axe and hatchet from the borg, or do I really need to spend the bucks on these swedish jobs from the woodworking dealers?

I know you get what you pay for, but for goodness sakes, it is a piece of sharpened metal on the end of a handle.

Once again, thanks for the help and opinions,

Rob Hix

Re: Axes, hatchets, etc.

#2

Re: Axes, hatchets, etc.

ThomD

>The riving process gets pretty intence and you can actually do some damage to a nice axe like a Gransford. The only thing is that you need the right shape of head, one with enough taper. Some of the swedish pattern felling axes, a very comon pattern up her in big boxes, are two thin in the blade entry to rive well. Antique axe heads might be the ticket.

For the hewing I think the Gransfords are worth the penny. I mostly use the hatchets they sell.

Re: Axes, hatchets, etc.

#3

Re: Axes, hatchets, etc.

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>For some riving I have a large froe, a small froe, which I use more often and a basketmaker's froe, which I seldom use.

That said most of the splitting I do with an ax. I have what I can best describe as a polled battle ax with a straight double bevel blade and a short handle. Evil looking thing which I have sitting around the shop for intimidation purposes, I seldom use it.

The ax I use most all the time is a tomahawk. The one I have is new made but out of wrought iron and cast steel, forge welded. Round drifted eye with a tapered hickory handle. The thing works great for splitting as well as light hewing.

These are available at any Rendezvous or re-enactment in your area, get a laid steel blade if you can. These are not terrible costly and it seemed to work well for folks for hundreds of years.

I now also understand why most old examples you see have distorted eyes by pounding on the back, the tomahawk generally does not have a poll. I pound the tomahawk on the back of the eye with a froe maul, never metal, and I am sure over the years it will become distorted, but well worth the cost. I can also have the blacksmith drift out the eye if needed.

Stephen

Re: Axes, hatchets, etc.

#4

Re: Axes, hatchets, etc. *LINK*

Randy Johnson Connersville, IN

>Rendezvous are more common in some areas than others.

In case there are none close the provided link is the next best thing.

I used to buy these things for less than twenty bucks apiece.


http://www.hbforge.com/products/tomahawks.php

Re: Axes, hatchets, etc.

#5

Once knew a gal

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>who was a regional champ tomahawk and knife thrower (at rendezvous events), and the VP for academic affairs at a university (her day job). I told her the best way to keep the faculty in line was to demonstrate her skill...

Bruce

Re: Axes, hatchets, etc.

#6

For reasonable quality . . .

steve mackay

>yes, spend a couple bucks. No, not the fancy Swedish stuff, but a decent Eastwing is worth the price. Safer too.

Re: Axes, hatchets, etc.

#7

Re: Once knew a gal

Randy Johnson Connersville, IN

>I probably either know her or we have mutual acquaintances. Before my guns walked out the door and I dropped out of the game I was very active in the primitive game. I shot in seven different states and I never went anywhere that I didn�t already know some of the people there. Of course, the fact that the big national shoots are 55 miles away helped me know some of the ones from farther away.

Re: Axes, hatchets, etc.

#8

Re: Once knew a gal

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>Fargo, ND Know her?

Re: Axes, hatchets, etc.

#9

Re: Once knew a gal

Todd Hughes

>Don't know if the Miss Jazz can throw an Axe but I have seen her throw more then a few fits pretty well ......Todd


img

Re: Axes, hatchets, etc.

#10

Re: Axes, hatchets, etc.

Todd Hughes

>Take a $20 bill and go to your local flea market and buy an old axe or hatchet, with change left over buy some more tools and pick up lunch on the way home.

Lots of good high quality old axes and Hatchets out there....I actually have a Gransfors [think it's thier hunter model] axe and it is a very nice axe. The only reason I bought it was that a guy had it at the flea market priced at $25 and I couldn't turn it down at that price esp. since it was mint with sheath. Nice axe but aint no better then my old Plumb half axe that I paid $5 for and not as well finished.....Buy a new axe? Why would anybody do that?....Todd

Re: Axes, hatchets, etc.

#11

Re: Axes, hatchets, etc.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>I think the most important thing about old axes (as well as any cutting tools) is whether there's still enough steel to sharpen. How do you choose an old axe?

Pam

Re: Axes, hatchets, etc.

#12

Excellent question!

Chuck Nickerson

>Telling the unknowing to "go buy a good used axe for $10" is not very directed. It more likely will lead to us buying and using 20 used axes to figure out what is good.

Re: Axes, hatchets, etc.

#13

Whoa...that weather is just like Cali today!;-)

Alan DuBoff

>

Re: Axes, hatchets, etc.

#14

Re: Choosing

ThomD

>Pam, I have it easy, sorta, in that our "farm" where we spend summers at times, was owned by a great great uncle who gave it up to a lumber guy during the depression. By the time I was in the picture there were all these axes around, and I never really knew the reason. A few years back we had high water and we had to build up our shore back from undercutting. We were bringing in large sandstone blocks, and there was a marvelous deposit of river washed gravel such as one doesn't generally see on our beach. So I proceeded to dig that out before the boulders arrived. Anyway. I found several more bits, just like the ones in use around the place. I mentioned this to a friend who thought maybe folks were throwing the broken shafted axes into fires and the heads were percolating out onto the beach where the woodsmen might have collected, though it isn't really a summer occupation around here. Also that trick with the shafts would be real hard on the temper of the axes which seems real good. It is possible they simply washed up off the shore from boats, which means there are still hundreds out there maybe even on our shore...

Anyway, as to the sharpen ability of the bit. I have noticed two things in tool markets. The steel normally lasts a good bit longer than the geometry. If I find bits I like the look of, there is steel in there, and it has always been good. The other thing is that with axes, I see a lot of axes that are good quality and that I remember from catalogs in the 70s, there is old stuff to be sure, but people always need axes so sometimes one can find very decent stuff and good prices, that is basically new. Often I don't want these axe shapes, but quality wise they are fine.

A lot of axes I see with the exception of the basic woodsman models do not show a lot of use. When I find really old ones if there is something wrong with them it is often that they were used as wedges, which destroys these old heads made out of welded iron.

Re: Axes, hatchets, etc.

#15

Re: Axes, hatchets, etc.

Todd Hughes

>Probably most axes and hatchets you will find will be solid steel, the exception may be hewing axes which because they tend to be older will have a laid on steel bit. On a hewing axe with a iron body and a steel cutting you should be able to see the piece of steel on the back of the blade. Harder to see on a regular axe.

But in any case stay away from axes that have been sharpened up so that they are short even if they are solid steel. With very common tools like this no reason to buy any with problems.

...As to what to buy...you can of course look for quality names like Collins, Plumb, Kelly, True Temper, Man or others but in my experance just about any older axe will likely be a good axe esp. if well made. Look for an axe with good grind lines and a well formed head. Pass by any with damaged eyes or polls or that just look "cheap".Again this is a tool where condition matters

...I'm not quite sure what type of axe the original poster was looking for...not sure if he is either!. I think probably a good small hewing axe, a small double bevel carpenter hatchet and maybe a nice half size axe would cover most jobs that the avarage wood worker might have. I like axes like this that have thinner edges rather then thicker.

Might as well pick up a full size axe too and a double bit one too while you are at it because...well just because...Todd

Re: Axes, hatchets, etc.

#16

Well....

Todd Hughes

>its always Warm and Sunny around the Jazz......Actually in the 60s and sunny here on the shores of the Chesapeake Bay today....Todd

Re: Axes, hatchets, etc.

#17

60 degrees is a typical winter out here!

Alan DuBoff

>That is typical for winter out here, but today I guess it is slightly nicer at about 75-80 degrees...was startin' to miss the sunshine a few weeks ago...I suspect this will be a hot summer this year...

A friend always reminds me, global warming doesn't mean you'll alway be warm...case in point this winter.

I bet Ms. Jazz can swing that if she had to...at least you probably don't want her mad when she's got that axe in her hands...;-)

Re: Axes, hatchets, etc.

#18

Re: Once knew a gal

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>Todd, tell us more about that giant ax. Think it was some type of advertisement piece? Paul Bunyuns ax?

Todd

Re: Axes, hatchets, etc.

#19

Re: Once knew a gal

Todd Hughes

>Is made out of aluminum, not sure but I believe most probably a Parade axe which were axes carried in parades and events by old Fraternal groups. I sort of collect these things though I prefer the smaller home made ones some of which can be very fancy and made all out of wood.

...When I saw this one at an auction I just liked it and hung around most of the day to get it. So did sombody else but went home with me....Todd

Re: Axes, hatchets, etc.

#20

Re: Choosing

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Thanks, Thom, it would be fun to walk out the front door and pick up axe heads; although the digging part of that may be a little tedious. :) I've got a few adzes and axes; but I chickened out and bought them new. I bought one old Japanese hatchet which is very cool looking, but haven't sharpened it and have no idea...

Pam

Re: Axes, hatchets, etc.

#21

Re: Axes, hatchets, etc.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Thanks, Todd, as usual a very informative post. I still feel uncomfortable with long handled axes, one of those things I know can do a lot of personal damage, will have to wait until I get Medicare. :) At the moment I have the western heads I need for trimming rived pieces, but whenever I get the itch for something a little different I end up chickening out on ebay.

Pam

Re: Axes, hatchets, etc.

#22

OK, what don't you collect? :)

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>

Re: Axes, hatchets, etc.

#23

Re: Axes, hatchets, etc.

Dean Lapinel

>Hmm

I'm a little shocked that you need to find another axe to grind.

:)

Re: Axes, hatchets, etc.

#24

Very cute, Dean.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>

Re: Axes, hatchets, etc.

#25

Or, more to the point, perhaps you'd...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>have a few axes to grind, too, if you'd grown up a smart ambitious female in the '60's, thwarted almost every way she turned. An example very close to your home is when I attended the Yataiki 3-day seminar in Sausalito. After spending $450 for the seminar and about $1000 more for travel expenses (I stayed with a friend, or it would have been more), the first thing I was told when getting there was that Yataiki had made a major exception, that he didn't educate women in Japan. Boy, didn't that make me feel good; and this was only about 4 years ago.

Then when I tried to buy a Yataiki dozuki, he refused to sell it to me. Now I did manage to get a couple of his saws, but not the one I really wanted, and not from him.

So I say "Stuff it."

Pam