Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

LN chisel handles fall off...a DOH moment

Posts

LN chisel handles fall off...a DOH moment

#1

Jack Guzman from Maine

LN chisel handles fall off...a DOH moment

Jack Guzman from Maine

>I really like these chisels,but ever since I got them I've been plagued with the handles falling off.The first time it happened I posted here and I was told that this is not unusual with changes in humidity and to beat them back in with a mallet blow, with the blade in some hardwood end grain.No problem,back to work. A couple years later and this still happens EVERY TIME I pick them up after not using them for awhile.This is getting a little old.I'm thinking maybe I'll just glue them in.So a couple days ago,I examined one of these handles after it fell out again and had a Homer Simpson DOH moment. When they put the finish on the handle,the tenon got finished also.I cleaned it up with a little 220 paper and magic!!!!no more falling off. Oh well, back to work. One more problem solved.---Jack

Re: LN chisel handles fall off...a DOH moment

#2

Re: LN chisel handles fall off...a DOH moment

James Watriss

>I did a few things, on the advice of a friend, and mine have never fallen out.

-Fit the handle to the socket. Basically, rub the inside of the socket with a pencil, and insert the handle.

There seems to be one particular orientation where the handle fits, and I find it helps to make some sort of pencil mark to keep the orientation, so you don't smudge the pencil marks too much.

Shove the handle in, and the pencil marks will transfer to wherever the handle is contacting the inside of the socket. The rest is pretty much like paring dovetails... you're fitting the handle to the socket. Pencil, insert handle, and LIGHTLY scrape down the pencil marks. Repeat until you're getting a pretty even transfer of lead to your handle. I say lightly scrape, because you don't want to scrape down too much. You'll make the handle tenon too thin, and have to cut it back in length. I you're uncomfortable scraping, then use a fine file, or emory board. I assume no responsibility for ham-handed people messing up their handles. Light scraping.

Next step, give a light coating of mineral oil on the handle, and jam the now fitted handle into the socket. Put the bit on a piece of scrap wood, and give a good thump with a mallet. The mineral oil will help seal the hole, and provide just enough vacuum to keep the handle in there, even if they shrink a little bit due to seasonal changes in ambient moisture. That way the handle is still removable if you want... or if you decide at some point to replace it... but the handles have yet to fall out on me.

Of course, you could also use linseed oil. Not quite as strong as glue, but wold still form enough of a bond to hold the handles in. Handles would be removable, but it would be a lot harder, and you'd want to clean out the sockets before fitting a new handle.

Re: LN chisel handles fall off...a DOH moment

#3

Re: LN chisel handles fall off...a DOH moment

Michael Brady

>I have made a lot of socket chisel handles and I also own ten L-N chisels. I don't ver recall one of my handles coming off, but it is a frequent occurance on the L-N's. Do I make better handles than they do?...I don't think so! I do think that their sockets and chisel handle tapers are almost too clean and smooth, however. If there were irregularities on their product like the vintage tools had, then they wouldn't tend to slip out. To prove my theory, I'm going to turn a hickory handle for one of my L-N's and test it. I will let you know what I find out. I won't glue a handle in, that's for sure.

Re: LN chisel handles fall off...a DOH moment

#4

What ever happend to...

Scott Burr in somewhat warn Ben Lomond, CA

>Droping them by the handle on to a hard surface to set the blade on to the handle? This works for all my socketed chislels.

Re: LN chisel handles fall off...a DOH moment

#5

Use epoxy and don't worry about it...

Alan DuBoff

>I use epoxy on my vintage Stanley chisels. Works fine, haven't had one drop out since...:-/ You can heat it and remove the handle if you need to. Doesn't take much heat, in fact very little.

Re: LN chisel handles fall off...a DOH moment

#6

Jack Guzman from Maine

I agree

Jack Guzman from Maine

>I think the issue is that they're too perfect and smooth.None of my other socket chisels have this problem.In my case it was extreme because of the finish(I'm guessing some kind of varnish).I have a stanley 750 1" chisel that is a perfect match for the LNs so I fitted it with a homemade handle(rosewood)and keep it with the LNs to fill out the set. It has never fallen off.---Jack

Re: LN chisel handles fall off...a DOH moment

#7

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: What ever happend to...

Jack Guzman from Maine

>Works for me too,but would you want to do it every time you go to use your chisels? One time I picked up the pouch and three handles fell out onto the floor. The chisels were still tucked neatly into the pouch.That can get a bit annoying.---Jack

Re: LN chisel handles fall off...a DOH moment

#8

That is just bad advice

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>I hope no one uses epoxy on old chisels, there are going to be those now and in the future that will not appreciate it.

Use rubber cement that can easily be reverse.

Stephen

Re: LN chisel handles fall off...a DOH moment

#9

Re: What ever happend to...

Tony - Memphis

>I've gotten into the habbit of doing that with my LN's every time I grab one. Now, if I could just keep them from curling and chipping every time I chop out a dovetail socket....

Tony

Re: LN chisel handles fall off...a DOH moment

#10

Another possibility

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>I own a grand total of one LN chisel. I like it quite a bit, apart from that nagging problem. I don't like the thought of picking the chisel by the handle only to see the chisel fall off, maybe on my feet...

I used to re-seat the handle at every use, because from one session to the other the handle got loose again. Then I noticed that the tip of handle had a "bruise mark on it. Then it dawned on me that the handle tenon was butting against the end of the socket. I sawed 1/8" off the end of the tenon, and viola, problem solved, or so it seems.

Still, with the 25% RH I'm experiencing in the shop during the winter, the problem might crop up again. So I think I'll try Stephen's trick. Wonder if rubber cement sticks to cocobolo?

DC

Re: LN chisel handles fall off...a DOH moment

#11

Wow...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>That usually all it takes for me. That "wood" be annoying to have it keep happening.

Re: LN chisel handles fall off...a DOH moment

#12

Re: Another possibility & Whatever...

ThomD

>I'm not necesarilly saying you shouldn't pick them up by the handle, but on some socketed chisels the socket is the holdy pit, they are almost like those spliting bits with the inserted wood bit to hit.

I have almost the opposite problem with my Barrs, one of the sockets split, and the handle still hasn't come off. I;m guessin he slug the wood well before pounding it home.

When it comes to "whatever happen to" mounting techniques, I just hold the handle and wail on it, and the chisel rides right up, putting it on a block is for the cheap seats.

Re: LN chisel handles fall off...a DOH moment

#13

They seem to be holding fine...

Alan DuBoff

>I'm not sure I like the idea of having rubber cement in there, even the Barge can be pulled apart...epoxy is simple, available, and I haven't had a handle fall out that I've used it on. They seem to function better for me. I know it's not traditional to fix the handles, but it is simple. Just requires a touch of heat to reverse it, what's wrong with that?

Re: LN chisel handles fall off...a DOH moment

#14

Re: They seem to be holding fine...

Stephen Wilson (Shropshire, England)

>I bought one of the first sets of 5 x LN chisels, and these have beautiful rosewood handles. They never fall out. By the time LN had produced the intermediate sizes, they were using a different rosewood, and these tend to fall out. Later still they converted to cocobolo and these (and the hornbeam handles) also fall out.

I find that if you can twist the handle off at the start of a session, then just wet the taper with your own saliva and twist it back and forth into the socket with hand pressure until it locks up. It'll last the day.