Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Anvil Anxiety

Posts

Re: Anvil Anxiety

#26

Re: Anvil Pics 2 of 2

Alan DuBoff

>Todd,

Was looking at the pics of this anvil again, and I notice the two pritchel holes, I don't know I've seen that. But many of the farrier anvils I've seen, the opposite side of the cutting table is fatter than a normal london pattern shape. This doesn't look like that, but hard to tell. Looks like a fairly normal horn, other than the table. I have used an anvil like that before, and it just makes it harder to use the horn, at least for me. Farriers seem to just tap the shoe around shape it for the hoof, so they don't usually need too much of the tip of the horn.

I know you have a Fisher, and they have a really short, and blunt horn.

I know a couple people that have the big 275# Peddinghaus, and they love it...$1500 is not cheap though...I think you would laugh at spending that much on an anvil, and rightfully so...but it sure is a nice anvil...I'm getting one if I hit the lotto ever...but I rarely play the lotto, so the odds are really low...:-/

Re: Anvil Anxiety

#27

Mike's Blacksmith Shop in Kansas *LINK*

Alan DuBoff

>I mentioned Mike's Blacksmith Shop in Kansas, as the gent I bought my anvil from...he told me he got from 'ol Milt down south...in a drawl of course...Mike's a good guy though. He deals in a lot of anvils, and I feel he has pretty good prices. My anvil was used for a good number of years, but is in good shape, 'ol Milt took good care of it.

I live in Northern California, and there's an arrogant person up in Santa Rosa, who I won't mention by name, but he is very rude in his ads and responsed to people, and asks outrageous prices for anvils. I see him mostly on craigslist, but he frequents ebay also. He wanted me to drive 3 hours, but wouldn't let me light a forge to for a piece of steel, so I could select the anvil I preferred. He called me names and all types of stuff...well, that didn't go over big with me...:-/

If you find yourself in an area where people are charging a lot of $$$s for anvils, check out Mike's Blacksmith shop.

http://stores.ebay.com/Mikes-Blacksmith-Shop

As an example, I'll link to a 170# Trenton which is Buy-It-Now for $400. He lists that in fair condition.

However, keep in mind that Mike rates his anvils for the condition they are for forging, and you don't see any rusted up anvils for sale on his site typically.

This is not a farrier's anvil, and in pretty good shape. If you're interested in a decent anvil, look around Mike's store, he's got a bunch of anvils listed on there, there's a nice 300# Trenton. I know that I'm glad I found him, was just googlin' for Hay Buddens, he's always got several. Real clean 100# Fisher for $275, a bit small, but very clean and Todd will tell you how nice those "don't ring", and it's true...a lot of smiths like the low ring of the Fisher.

I hope I didn't cause an anxiety attack...:-(

BTW, UPS will ship anvils with no packing, up to 150#. Mike will put them on a pallet for you and drop it at the freight pickup by him, if you see a larger anvil you like.


img

Trenton 170# Anvil

Re: Anvil Anxiety

#28

Nice 100# Fisher *LINK*

Alan DuBoff

>Good travel size, or small home smithy. If any of you talk to Mike, tell 'em I said Hi!


img

100# Fisher Anvil

Re: Anvil Anxiety

#29

or that I don't spell for beans...

Alan DuBoff

>

Re: Anvil Anxiety

#30

David, just clean yours and use it! *LINK*

Alan DuBoff

>David,

Don't get discouraged by the pics I linked to, your anvil will be fine, just clean it up with a scotch pad and use it.

While those anvils at Mike's are cleaner, you will find that your anvil will clean up nicely. Your top looks flat, and that is important also.

I will link to an anvil I bought for $150 and it was really rusty, I put it in an electrolysis tank. The pics of the anvil after it came out of the electrolysis tank are at the link. Came out looking pretty good, but you could really see the sway...I did use it a bit, but it bug'd me, and my instructor convinced me that I probably did deserve a better anvil, but we were going to try and forge it back into shape, he's a little wacko like me...anyway, that didn't happen, and I just took a belt sander to it and got the front section flat, and the heel flat, but both are not level. I don't have any pics of it after I sanded it. I could get a pic tomorrow if you want to see how it came out, it works ok the way it is. It is smaller than your Trenton, it's a 134# PW.

I sprayed it with T-9 before I took the pics, so it looks clean, but it looked like yours before I put it in the electrolysis tank. I also didn't turn it around, and it had green paint just like your Trenton, you can see the paint line at the horn, that was the section sticking out of the water in the electrolysis tank.

The front edge doesn't look as bad, only because I sanded it, but I didn't fill it with welding rod, so it is still not good. It is a fine anvil to do most work though, and not nearly as nice as yours will be. This is really a well used anvil, worth the $150 I paid for it, but I would had been better to get a better anvil first. You can see better pics at the link, showing how bad the top is, although contour can be to your advantage, depending on what you forge...


img

Well used and tired 134# Peter Wright

Re: Anvil Anxiety

#31

Re: Anvil Anxiety

Tony Zaffuto

>About some twenty five years ago, had a hair dryer flung at me while I was taking a shower. Shattered the plastic shower door and fortunately it cam unplugged as it made its trip to me. Later I got hit in the face with a sneaker while I was asleep.

Probably deserved it for one thing or another. She's gotten over the temper part as this August we will have been married some 29 years.

T.Z.

Re: Anvil Anxiety

#32

That's a sweetie! *LINK*

David Barnett - SW Florida

>Got me hot and bothered. Nice polite little 'indoor' tool-maker's anvil. I've been coveting a smaller anvil in that range but with a double bick. The Nimba 'Titan' cast steel anvil has been at the top of my list for awhile. Problem is, I really don't need another anvil and am now old enough and disciplined enough to resist. And that's just sad.


Some very nice new anvils

Re: Anvil Anxiety

#33

Oh Yeah

David Miller from Iowa

>No worries, I'm a rust collector from way back. I have a smaller Hay Budden, around 120#, I'll probably put on ebay to help pay the new one off.

Re: Anvil Anxiety

#34

Re: Oh Yeah

Alan DuBoff

>David,

I'll tell you a story about my Peter Wright 134#, worked out the worst for me, but it is the way I am...

When I had started to learn how to forge, I realized how bad my anvil is, I mean that PW was really tired, it looked like someone was working cold steel with a sledge on it...so I posted some pics of it, in fact these same pics of it, and a long time smith who is fairly respected told me to use it and not worry about fixing it.

Scott Thomas, by then a friend and instructor, suggested that we actually forge the anvil back into shape, that we could create a pit forge in the ground, run a pipe into it and use a set of bellows or a hand crank to forge it, with a special set of tongs, similar to ice tongs that would hold the anvil upside down, and we could have 4 guys at least so that we would have 2 lifters and 2 strikers. The idea was that we could heat up the top, and you would have to do that until it was red and ready to forge, lay it on top of Scott's anvil with a thick steel plate on top to protect it, and the strikers would hit the side of the anvil, and try to push the top back up...so, this idea would actually be a kind of experiment, since we never did find anyone that actually had done this before, every smith in the land was willing to say we couldn't do it. More reason for a guy like me, I love to do the undo able. Scott was also game for it.

Well, most all smiths online were telling us that it couldn't be done safely in an average smithy, that we would need to wear thermal clothes, that working that large a piece of steel would throw off heat for at least 2 feet from the anvil once heated, but Scott felt wrong.

Funny thing is that even in Postman's book he shows pics of guys forging anvils, and they might have thermal clothes on, but their sleeves are rolled up. The fact is that most heat rises, so we felt we could forge it with sledges.

Ended up getting me ban'd from one of the most popular blacksmith sites on the web, and the bubba admin blocks my IP, so that in theory I can't use his site. He was in a huff when I removed most of my posts, and said you can't do that on his site...that I needed to listen to people who have 40 years of experience, blah-blah...well, why did he let me edit my posts and delete them? In haste, he made it so that nobody could edit, and then many people were complaining, it was similar to here on WC, once it is posted there is no editing, even for spelling. He finally changed it back so others can edit.

What is funny is that I have another login, and I have a machine sitting on the monitor next to the IP I can't use, which goes through VPN to the company I work for. He once had their IP blocked also, but found out that there are about 35,000 people he was blocking from viewing his site by having that IP in there. So, he took it out eventually... If he knew the name of my login, he'd probably ban me, but I rarely use it.

I do not need to use their site, I do not need help from them, and truth be told I am more interested in woodworking. I do like to forge a lot, though, and love to talk about it. Not many people doing it anymore...I think that's one thing I like about it.

Out of this whole deal, I became pretty good friends with a guy named Ron Reil...a real genuine smith. Ron, although a very public figure in the smithy world, doesn't use any online forums or mailing lists, because of the exact same reason I describe above. He has become a true friend and email partner and we exchange email several times a week. I have better access to smithy knowledge through his advice, than a forum full of bible totin' bubbas who don't understand the freedom on the inet. As I said, Ron is genuine.

In the end I did do what the bubbas said I should, take a belt sander to it and be done with it, or use it like it was. It worked ok as it was, just was annoying to try and work flat stock at the front section of the anvil, where smith uses most. I found the Hay Budden at Mike's Blacksmith Shop before I did that though. Once I had another anvil, I didn't care as much about the PW. But the PW turned out to be a half decent anvil...after I cleaned it up. Your Trenton is not nearly as bad, IMO, although it's probably in similar exterior condition, rusty.

Ok, it's time to make some sawdust...;-)

Re: Anvil Anxiety

#35

Whoa...those look nice...

Alan DuBoff

>They certainly look like nice anvils, I haven't seen those before, and they're in the same price as the Peddinghaus, even a bit more.

I see the Nimbas are cast. the Peddinghaus is forged tool steel.

Many smiths prefer a cast anvil as you may know, and the Fisher was cast with a tool steel plate on top. Those are interesting, thanks for the linky, I'm sticking it in my bookmarks.

Re: Anvil Anxiety

#36

Another fine anvil at Mike's Blacksmith Shop! *LINK*

Alan DuBoff

>David,

I saw this and contemplated pulling the trigger on it myself. It is in better shape than mine, although it is only 128#, what a beautiful Hay Budden this is. If I didn't have 2 anvils already...and I might try to sell my Peter Wright to get this...:-/

I am not sure why Mike doesn't auction off some of his anvils, cause Steve at Matchless Antiques would sell these anvils on ebay for $500-$600 with minor cleaning.

Mike only seems to sell them through his ebay store as Buy-It-Now.

That Fisher is a nice anvil for $275, and if someone was wanting to learn to forge, it's a fine one.

This Hay Budden for $395 is a great deal, considering this would probably go for about $600 on ebay at auction, if it was cleaned up.

Kinda good to find guys like Mike, although the prices on his swages, blowers, bellows, and some other stuff is not great, IMO, but the anvils are good prices!*wink*


img

One nice looking 128# Hay Budden

Re: Anvil Anxiety

#37

I just paid $10/lb for this anvil...

Alan DuBoff

>David,

There's been some talk of how much anvils go for per pound, and I just paid $10/lb. for this little guy. Some things I see and just gotta have.

I've seen larger ones before, and a lot more $$$s. There was a ~100# similar round, but larger anvil sold on ebay when I was watching for anvils a couple years ago. Went for about $300...that was too rich for my blood...

This little guy weighs about 5 lbs, so it's small. I'm going to use it on a bench where I work on handsaws.

Darn, I shouldn't be looking around Mike's site, very tempted to sell my PW and get that Fisher, I've not had enough time on a Fisher to say how I like them, but one of my friends has one and loves it. I've used a Vulcan a bit, they're kinda similar. I do like the tone of the Hay Budden, but don't mind the PWs either. I like the play my anvil with relief taps, like a pair of tap shoes...;-)


img

Re: Anvil Anxiety

#38

Sweet little anvils!

Scott Burr in somewhat warn Ben Lomond, CA

>Did you polish them? If so how?

Re: Anvil Anxiety

#39

Polished? You bet. *LINK*

David Barnett - SW Florida

>To the appropriate degree, that is.

Anything used for planishing; hammers, stakes, small anvils, repousse planishing punches, and so on, get high polishes on either a polishing motor with a tapered arbor, various buffs, and compounds, or 1" x 42" polishing belts (try Lee Valley and catalogs for golf club makers). I remove the platen on the belt sander and use it slack belt style which conforms nicely to whatever shape I'm polishing.

I also make heavy use of the sander to reshape and refine hammers, stakes, other small tools with coarser belts. I can't imagine how toolmakers get by without one of these cheap and versatile tools, but one can also use sanding and polishing sticks charged with abrasive compounds (green crayon for a final polish). I did for years. For hard to get at areas you can always strum: use compound on a string or cord -- great for details.

Tools used for moving metal before planishing (repousse punches, hammers, etc.) get a scratchier, grippier finish that may even be left as a final matte texture. Some engraving and chasing hammers I leave with a less-polished finish, as well.

There are, and I have, far too many buffs, belts and compounds to talk about here, but if you have any specific questions I'll be glad to narrow things down.

BTW, if you have an old motor lying about, you can attach one of these tapered mandrel/arbors to the motor shaft and quick-change all those cool jeweler's 3" to 8" buffs, wheels, cones. All jeweler supply houses have them: Rio Grande, Gesswein, Otto Frei, Contenti, FDJ, et al. You can also use that motor to power the belt sander that Lee Valley sells.

And while you're finding things to use that motor with, order one of those exceptional little Taig lathes from LV, too, in both the metalworking and woodworking configurations (They're interchangable. I use both). Blithely make saw nuts and get rich quick!


Various arbors

Re: Anvil Anxiety

#40

Errata

David Barnett - SW Florida

>I meant to type 'thrum' instead of 'strum'. The technique is known as 'thrumming'.

Also, I apologize for not providing a warning, such as "Beware! Seduction by electrons may follow!" or at least a "Fun with Motors" subtitle.

Re: Anvil Anxiety

#41

No worries here David...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>Thanks for all the great info. My wife makes jewelry (wire work for the most part) and is getting into more advanced items. I've been on the hunt for small anvils like yours for her and a big one for me!

Thanks again!

Re: Anvil Anxiety

#43

Check these out these small anvils, Scott *LINK*

David Barnett - SW Florida

>The 6 1/2 lb anvil is 10USD/lb, and the 11 lb is about 8USD/lb.


Small Austrian anvils

Re: Anvil Anxiety

#44

I suppose one 'these' would've sufficed

David Barnett - SW Florida

>