Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Anvil Anxiety

Posts

Anvil Anxiety

#1

Anvil Anxiety

David Miller from Iowa

>I just dropped $400 on a 165# Trenton anvil I found in the back of a junk shop. It has that protrusion on the side someone told me was a farriers thing. Plus 8 hardy tools.

Did I overpay? How does the farriers feature work?

Thanks, David

Re: Anvil Anxiety

#2

Alleviating Anvil Anxiety

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>I just talked to Brian Westover the Blacksmith where I work and he said you got a screaming deal. Anvils go for 3 to 5 dollars a pound and the hardies are 30 to 50 dollars each.

As for as the protrudence, if it is flat on top, it is an upsetting block and if it is two stubs it is a bending fork, there were variations.

Stephen

Re: Anvil Anxiety

#3

Whew

David Miller from Iowa

>Thanks Stephen -

The protrusion is flat so I guess it is an upsetting block. What the heck is that and how does it work?

And what is the spelling consensus - hardy or hardie?

Re: Anvil Anxiety

#4

Re: Anvil Anxiety *LINK*

Jim

>I believe its called a clip horn used for forging toe clips on shoes. Email me, I'll give you info on blacksmith demos in the next couple of months in IA.


Upper Midwest Blacksmith Association

Re: Anvil Anxiety

#5

Re: Alleviating Anvil Anxiety

Dean Lapinel

>$3-$5 is way over the top. But this price was acceptable.

Re: Anvil Anxiety

#6

Re: Anvil Anxiety

Alan DuBoff

>David,

The price for that size anvil is not a bad price, but it sounds like you got a farrier's anvil, and the horn is quite different than a london pattern anvil, the more common style amongst non-farrier smiths.

There is no reason that a farrier's anvil can't be used to forge just about any iron, but the horn is often fatter and for me much harder to work scrolls and such off one.

Considering I've seen guys forging on old railroad tracks and producing nicer work than I do on a Hay Budden, I wouldn't worry about it too much. Everyone likes the anvils they like, and many folks prefer Fishers because they don't ring, Todd Hughes uses one for that reason. I like Hay Buddens, they have a good amount of tool steel in them, and the most recent style has about 1/3rd the top of the anvil as tool steel. They do ring quite a bit, but I muffle mine with either a chain or magnets. Peter Wrights ring very loud...I got a 134# that was pretty swayed, but took a belt sander to it and it's a pretty decent anvil now, just don't like it nearly as much as my Hay Budden 160#. I paid $365 for my Hay Budden from a blacksmith shop in Kansas, nice guy who has an ebay store, it's called Mike's Blacksmith Shop. He sells a lot of anvils at fair prices. Where I live some of the people with anvils must be smokin' crack, and if they're not, the people buying them are.:-/ The PW I paid only $150 for on ebay, but it was pretty swayed. Not a bad anvil for $150 though.

One other thing to note about anvils, is that when the size changes, the anvils start becoming more desirable, in proportions. If you look at the profile of a 160# anvil and compare it to a 120# anvil of the same maker, you will see exactly what I'm talking about. Look at a 250# anvil of the same maker, and a 400# of the same maker. The working surface on the top face gets quite a bit larger, but in order to do that it requires much more mass, so the more they weigh, the less size they gain as the mass as a whole gets larger. You also pay a premium for any anvils 200# and above, IMO, and they are the most desirable. I've not met many smiths that wouldn't take a larger anvil, given the same quality and characteristics.

I would characterize myself as an amateur smith, but will be curious to see what someone like Todd says if he responds to this thread.

If you could post pictures of the anvil, that would be helpful.

Re: Anvil Anxiety

#7

Re: Anvil Anxiety

Todd Hughes

>Sounds like very high retail to me alot depends on condition and your 8 anvil tools you got. If somthing special the anvil tools could be worth and sold for a good bit...if just some hand made horse shoeing stuff not worth much.

...In my experance amoung Blacksmiths trenton anvils while good anvils do not bring a premium like a hay budden or peter wright.

Prices on Anvils are a funny thing because it can be all over the place. I have been at auctions and seen them go very high and at others for the cheap.Lots of people still go by the old $1 a lb. rule but realistical probably out dated...though I still buy some for that or even less.

...Even in the old tool hell i live in I still see a good many anvils and still buy a few. Nowdays i usually only buy them if they are in good condition and cheap or are different.Kind of hard to explain have to be in an anvil buying mood too I pass on alot of them. Guess the last one was about a 200 lb 18th century anvil I bought back in the fall for $120....couldn't pass on that

...Funny story about a Trenton Horse shoe anvil....I had a wife once that worked with this woman that had bought a house with this anvil in the garage. Woman and her kids drag it to the curb for the trash men to take but they wouldn't take it so she drug it back up the driveway. Her and my wife got talking and Nitro said why her husband was a blacksmith and was sure he would come get it for her...she was right! Drove up and there setting in the driveway a very nice 150 lb Trenton shoeing anvil put it in the truck and drove home. Wife told me I should have charged her $20 to haul it away. Unusual thing about this anvil was that it had a groove in the horn probably someones idea for a better design...dom't know. I took it to a show and sold it for $150 and figured I did OK ......Todd

Re: Anvil Anxiety

#8

Re: way over the top

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>I guess the $60 I paid for a 9 pound anvil, errr, let me see here, that would be $6.67 per pound, would be just plain ridiculous then ;)

Re: Anvil Anxiety

#9

Re: Anvil Anxiety

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>Next time you get a call like that to haul away a free anvil and are not in the anvil mood I'll be glad to take care of it for you.

Re: Anvil Anxiety

#10

Re: Anvil Anxiety

Tony Zaffuto

>I'm more interested in the nickname "Nitro" than anything! Care to elaborate Todd?

T.Z.

Re: Anvil Anxiety

#11

Anvil Pics 1 of 2

David Miller from Iowa

>Thanks for everyone's input. 29" long and marked 165#. The seller had outlined the Trenton diamond because it was hard to see.

There are 8 hardies - 4 hot chisels and 4 concave swages. The other 3 swages are still in the trunk and the wife went to work, but they are sized about like the chisels. The largest swage would fit something abot 3" in diameter.

Is the green paint original? Should I wire brush this?

Thanks


img

Re: Anvil Anxiety

#12

Anvil Pics 2 of 2 

David Miller from Iowa

>


img

Re: Anvil Anxiety

#13

Looks like it tried to mate with a John Deere trac

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>

Re: Anvil Anxiety

#14

Great deal on a Trenton! I sure like mine.

David Barnett - SW Florida

>If your anvil's in good shape you got one helluva deal in today's market. I got mine over ten years ago for $200 delivered to my shop (when I still lived in Mass.), so I can't complain, as that comes to exactly $1 per pound.

I've refurbished (careful grinding and polishing) the top and upper horn since the photo and it's now smooth enough to use for jewelry work; mostly beating gold ingots into bars that'll pass through my rolling mill. I hot forge on it too, of course, making cutters, gouges, and punches. It's sits next to my jeweler's bench in what used to be my dining room.


img

Re: Anvil Anxiety

#15

Nice Anvil Stump

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>

Re: Anvil Anxiety

#16

Re: Anvil Anxiety

Todd Hughes

>Didn't take much to make her Blow Up.....Have a big scar on top of my head where she hit me with a shovel knocking me out of my chair. When I asked her why she did that told me she couldn't find the ammo for her gun.....Todd

Re: Anvil Anxiety

#17

Re: Anvil Pics 1 of 2

Todd Hughes

>Good bit rougher then I would expect for a top dollar anvil, face looks rough with a good bit of chipping along the edges. Green is not it's original color. Personaly if I was going to use it I would try to do somthing with the edges and try to polish the table up some maybe with a belt sander. I'd paint it black....Table looks pretty flat but hard to tell from here

After seeing what this anvil sold for think I will be draging those ones out in my drive way down into my barn !.....Todd

Re: Anvil Anxiety

#18

I'd try mineral spirits first...

David Barnett - SW Florida

>...with medium to fine 3M pads to remove the paint before adopting more aggressive measures. All I did on mine was remove loose rust and then oil with linseed. I love the patina. The top I ground with various c-thru flex discs on my angle grinder, followed by polishing and buffing. The top plate is so hard that files skate (typical of Trentons), but the horn you can file, then sand.

Also, don't expect or try to grind the top plate flat. It just isn't necessary. I ground the edges to the radii I prefer, removing or smoothing almost all nicks, and took out any nicks in the top, although I should say I started out with a fairly pristine anvil. If you have a rougher surface with cuts and divits, it might be wise to have a welder who understands refurbishing restore it.

Re: Anvil Anxiety

#19

No, what you bought was a specialty anvil

Alan DuBoff

>Those small anvils are more specialty than for heavy forging, a different beast. Those that are that small are typically used for jewelery work.

Many smiths like to keep a small avnil in the forge, off to the side, so they can use them to forge weld. I've seen 40-50 pound anvils for that purpose also, and those go for more per pound than larger ones.

It's all supply and demand.

Re: Anvil Anxiety

#20

Re: Anvil Pics 2 of 2

Alan DuBoff

>Looks ok, nothing to write home about, and actually if you look at the edges that are used most, they are not sharp/clean.

This second pic is pictured the wrong way for a right handed smith, who will typically forge with the horn on the left side. It is the far side of the top edge that you use most often, and the front edge as well, but those edges are important for a good anvil, IMO.

As noted by Todd, the resale on Trenton anvils is not as good as others, although they are not bad anvils, IMO, and are made from wrought with tool steel plate on top, similar to Peter Wrights, as I recall. I am more familiar with Peter Wrights and Hay Buddens. Peter Wrights have more problems with sway than others, but in pure numbers there are probably more PW anvils than any others.

You paid top $$$ for that anvil, but you can use it and be happy with it, and produce some excellent work with it. I'm confused by the horn, the shape of the anvil looks like a London Pattern, but that fubar section on the horn for shoeing, I'm not sure if that was added or what. Could be useful for upsetting, but I prefer to use the side of the anvil for that myself, sometimes the top. Better pics of the horn would help determine if it is a shoein' anvil or not, not that it matters, that anvil can serve you fine.

Either way, you spent $400, use it and be happy. Clean it up, mineral spirits and a scotch pad would work well, along with some elbow grease. If you put the scotch pad on a hand held ROS you will find that it will clean the steel up nicely. You are mainly concerned with the edges around the top plate, and the top itself.

If you really wanted to, you could weld some proper welding rod and clean the edges up around the top section, it all depends on how much time you want to invest in cleaning it up, or if you want to do actual forging quicker or not. I would use it first, fix it later, if it was me. I would focus on getting a forge setup if you don't have one, so you can use it. You'll need to have a stump/stand to put it on. You want the height to be so you can stand beside it with your hammer in your hand and the face of the hammer will be flat on the anvil, a good test is to measure your closed fist while standing next to the anvil, the knuckles should rest on the top of the anvil. That is the ideal height.

Re: Anvil Anxiety

#21

Re: way over the top *LINK*

David Barnett - SW Florida

>Alan's right. Some smaller anvils sell for a much higher price per pound. I have several light anvils up to 35 lbs and a few forming blocks and stakes that easily exceed large anvil per lb prices. Here's a couple:


img

Check out this tiny anvil's $/lb (the math's easy)

Re: Anvil Anxiety

#22

Re: Anvil Pics 2 of 2

Todd Hughes

>The projection on the cutting table is for making toe clips on horse shoes, this is the little tab on the front of the shoe that goes up over the hoof to protect it. You can make them on the corner edge of the anvil but this makes it easier...Think Hay Budden was making this feature first in the 1880s.

Also notice how it has two pritchel holes this is somthing you only see in a farriers anvil

I always had my anvil so that the horn faced toward my my right as I faced it...I know not correct but just seemed more natural to me. I think I read how 'smiths in Europe do it, don't know.....Todd

Re: Anvil Anxiety

#23

OMG, didn't know peddinhaus made anvils that small

Alan DuBoff

>

Re: Anvil Anxiety

#24

Re: I'd try mineral spirits first...

ThomD

>The problem with all these antique tools is there is always someone who got for free what you paid a fair price for. I probably wouldn't have paid that much, thoug I got my anvil for free, a rare score for me, so I will never know. Around here they are charging 3 dollars for proven anvils, so the prices can be high. There is a guy making some of the best blade-making anvils, and he only charges 300 bucks for them the are about 180 pounds. But shipping can cost as much.

I think the hardies are worth a bit, but most smiths can make their own, most these days are welded onto square stock, and there are some improved and somewhat fancy version for doing various things like drawing out.

I probably wouldn't grind down an anvil or weld onto it. You can scab on material to fill the divots, but the heat will draw the temper of any surrounding original material, unless you have a means to re-harden it which would be rare.

Re: Anvil Anxiety

#25

Re: Anvil Pics 2 of 2

Alan DuBoff

>Todd wrote:

"I always had my anvil so that the horn faced toward my my right as I faced it...I know not correct but just seemed more natural to me. I think I read how 'smiths in Europe do it, don't know....."

Ok, I will admit to you that I had been using my anvil with the horn on the right, before I met Scott Thomas, the smith at Ardenwood Historical Farm. One of the things that Scott taught me was to never use gloves in the smithy, unless one is stamping/cutting over a large piece of hot steel, in that case it's nice to have some protection on my left hand. Some smiths use gloves while they forge, that might make a difference. I hate it.

In regards to not wearing a glove, this means that you will typically need a full slack tub, so that you can easily cool the metal, often dunking one's entire arm into the tub, and keeping the hot iron out of the water, so one can cool the iron they hold, but leave the iron being worked hot. I'm explaining that for others, I know you know that Todd...in that setup, since I hammer with my right hand, it makes sense to have the slack tub on the left side of the anvil, so it is between the forge and anvil. Really depends on the setup also, Scott places his anvil opposite the forge, with the slack tub on the right of the forge, but it is similar to how I described in regards to the slack tub on the left side of the anvil, being that he also forges with his right arm.

The other annoying thing I find about the horn on the right side is that I like to feed iron up from the bottom side of the horn, so that as you're scrolling, you are hammering on the top and feeding it, using the top portion of the horn to leverage/control the scroll as you create it. This could be me, but I don't care for doing that with my left arm between me and the anvil, I seem to have a lot more flexibility when that arm is on the outside of my body, not pinched in between my body and the anvil.

These are the primary reason I like to have the horn on the left side, but before I started scrolling like that, it didn't bother me as much.

I like the front edge of the anvil, near the horn to have a sharp, crisp corner, and along the front as well, since I will work corners that are 90 degrees there, and draw metal out. But I like the back edge just so slightly rounded as I will taper and other stuff on the back near the horn. I have been taught to draw everything out square, even if it will be round, and I have a smithy friend that doesn't subscribe to that theory, but I think it helps keep things uniform, speaking for myself.

Maybe some of this will be useful to others, I don't know...