Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Are you tired of busting your nuts? *LINK*

Posts

Re: Are you tired of busting your nuts? *LINK*

#26

Re: The Question is the Answer!

Alan DuBoff

>Mike,

Was only referring to the hang, that I notice you mention that the dovetail or small joinery saws have a slightly higher hang. No biggie, I wanted the hang higher based on some of the older saws I have. But it really would depend on the bench height that one uses, when cutting. My new bench is 32" rather than the 36" I've been using in the garage. This will make a higher hang for cutting joinery more desirable. Even so, that is questionable considering one needs to put the stock in the vise at the proper height.

For some reason I got the impression from you that I was trying to flame some vendors, and that certainly was not my intention, I was only trying to get other folks' ideas on if a better nut could be created. This is a controversial subject, but a friend of mine is milling some up for me soon, and I will learn how to cut them myself. Even if I was to make split-nuts like Leif outlines on his site, I would like to be able to say I made a saw from raw materials. Not that it matters to anyone, I'm sure that means more to me than anyone else.

One reason I wanted to copy the saw you made for me is that we designed it together, although you crafted it for me. You are making some of the, if not the, best handsaws on the current market, IMO. There are other good saws, don't get me wrong, but your saw seem to be very consistent with the widest variety of styles.

FWIW, I'm going to cut down the Peace saw you made for me, the one with the handle inset. It is without a doubt one of my favorite saws. I will take about an inch or an inch and a half off the blade, I'm sure you remember what we did on that...it's like 3 3/4" of blade depth...was more of an experiment. It really cuts well, just a tad off balance with the handle being so high for a 12" blade.

Lastly, thanks for all of your help. The fact you would help someone like me to build a similar tool as you sell, is something you should be commended for. You are a true mensch, sir!

Re: Are you tired of busting your nuts? *LINK*

#27

Re: A better design

Alan DuBoff

>Marv wrote:

-----------------

Standard screwdriver slot

Could have at least a half inch of thread.

8-32 screw thread, less chance of stripping or crossthreading. Coarser threads are better in soft metals.

Can easily be made to not be flush to the wood, hence, eliminating the counterbores.

A larger shaft through the blade for better stability.

-----------------

Marv,

Hope this thread hasn't put you to sleep yet, I think you have some good ideas.

I don't like slots at all though, and in some ways prefer a split-nut to a full slot. There must be a better way, even if it does require a special driver. Square could work, or hex, possibly but I don't have the mill to do that...although you do Marv...*wink* Sounds like yours wouldn't be flush, and that could be a deal breaker for me. I really like flush. And the brass looks nice, with wood. I'd like to try bearing bronze though.

The threads idea is spot on, IMO, in soft metal like brass. This might be something good to try, IMO. I am not sure what the thread is on the ones I have, I think they're 3/16" bolts with 1/2" heads.

Marv wrote:

-----------------

Not having the split nut makes for a much cleaner appearance on that side of the handle and no need for hand fitting when the screw protrudes through the nut too far.

-----------------

Your version doesn't seem to be flush, how would the head be?

I'm not sure I quite see it, I need to go read the other message again possibly.

Re: Are you tired of busting your nuts? *LINK*

#28

Will the Driver be a Traditional Design?

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>

Re: Are you tired of busting your nuts? *LINK*

#29

Re: Tightening

paul womack

>NEVER (and I mean on no occasion) try to tighten a saw handle onto a saw blade by applying force to the nuts. Even modern (brass) nut/bolts e.g. Spear and Jackson are too weak (3/8" BSW) for this to be effective.

ALWAYS close up the handle using external force (clamp or vise), then simply take up the slack on the nuts.

BugBear

Re: Are you tired of busting your nuts? *LINK*

#30

Re: A better design (rant)

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>........

Your version doesn't seem to be flush, how would the head be?

I'm not sure I quite see it, I need to go read the other message again possibly. YES, READ ALL THE WORDS.....

.........

The head of the screw and the nut is flat with straight sides. It can be flush or not flush. To make the heads flush, counterbore the holes on both sides of the handle.

The simplest way to slot the screw head is straight across. Any other way will complicate it, unless one is in the business of manufacturing screws of all kinds. Brass doesn't lend itself very well to allen or square indentations, too easily stripped. If a standard screwdriver slot is deep enough and wide enough, it will hold up quite well.

Paul says in his post that we should never use the screws to tighten the handle to the blade. Should use a clamp or vise to apply the pressure. He is absolutely right....but...in reality, 87% of people who has a saw with a loose handle will not think of that and will grab anything that slightly resembles a screwdriver and go at it. Are they going to take the time to make a notched screwdriver for the split nuts? From what I see on old saws, I have to say...NO. The designers of these type things need to realize how most people are and design accordingly.

Lets just say this about "hork'n" up a screw head, when I pay $285.00 for a handsaw, I don't want to be "hork'n" up anything on it and thinking it's just a piece of metal and some wood. That much money for me, leaves my wallet quite flat. Add some shipping cost plus the cost of a special screw driver and we are well over $300.00. It takes alot of aluminum cans to pay for that.

From purely a logical standpoint I just don't see how anyone can think that using a screw that requires a special screwdriver, whether available for a cost of ten dollars or more or having to make one is better than just making a screw with a simple slot. This is such a no-brainer, I don't understand why it warrants so much discussion. Well, to be honest, I do understand.

I have dealt with this kind of thing all my life. "It's not my idea, so I don't like it". I bet the guy who invented the wheel was scoffed at and rejected until someone else stole his idea and then took credit for it. Of course I wouldn't apply that to anyone here in this thread or direct it to any specific person, it's just the way we humans are, generally speaking.

Rant to be cont.

Marv

Re: Are you tired of busting your nuts? *LINK*

#31

Re: Tightening

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Paul/Bugbear,

Ya know? Talk about a no-brainer! I have always used the screws to tighten the handle to the blade. It makes perfect good sense to clamp the handle tight then snug the screws down. It's these simple things that even those of us who should know better won't think of. From this day forth I will be doing as you suggest.

However, we both know that most people won't think of it or do it even if they do think of it. We are all used to looking at a loose screw and a nut and automatically tightening it the easiest and quickest way. In view of that fact, we who design things, must design for dummies. Someone should write a book.....

Marv

Re: Are you tired of busting your nuts? *LINK*

#32

Re: If it is boring, why do you keep replying?

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>I'm going to guess it's because I'm drawn to this subject like flies to........

There is no doubt in the minds of those close to me that I need therapy. It's been suggested many times. I'm constantly in fear of some kind of intervention.

As we grow older, somehow we reach an age when we think we have a license to say what we think. To my detriment, I'm afraid I arrived at that age earlier than others.

Marv

Re: Are you tired of busting your nuts? *LINK*

#33

That is the intention...if possible

Alan DuBoff

>Stephen,

That is the intention, if possible, to be able to use a standard split-nut driver, but have additional slots and/or pins in the bottom of the slot for some type of spanner as well. This would allow the use of a traditional split-nut driver, but if you had the special driver you could get the extra purchase in tightening/loosening.

I don't know if that is possible.

The other idea is trying to design a completely new nut that didn't use a split-nut. I am leaning to the prior, since I admire tradition myself.*grin*

Re: Are you tired of busting your nuts? *LINK*

#34

No prob, I just get grumpy myself...*g*

Alan DuBoff

>

Re: Are you tired of busting your nuts? *LINK*

#35

Re: A better design (rant)

Alan DuBoff

>Marv wrote:

--

The head of the screw and the nut is flat with straight sides. It can be flush or not flush. To make the heads flush, counterbore the holes on both sides of the handle.

--

This would work for me Marv, if I could counterbore and make them flush, that piece wasn't absolutely clear in your posts to me.

Marv wrote:

--

Paul says in his post that we should never use the screws to tighten the handle to the blade.

--

I agree for the most part, but I don't always adhere to it, even myself.

I don't get bothered by the money as much myself, because it is just that...money...the reality is that people can make their own saws out of paint scrapers if they wanted to, so they don't need to buy expensive saws...and really, what is expensive? $200, $500, $1000? The reality is that most all saws are not expensive.

Most new saws are fine, it's when they start to acclimate, and the handle gets loose from use or climate that one needs to start tightening.

Re: Are you tired of busting your nuts? *LINK*

#37

Good poing that I don't always adhere to...:-/

Alan DuBoff

>Paul,

Good point that I don't always adhere to...yes, I should, but I don't.:-(

It is inviting with a screw head on it.

I cracked a handle not long ago by doing this. Some handles are more sensitive than others. For most of my vintage saws, even if the handles are cracked or the split-nuts are horked up, it doesn't bother me, in many cases I just wanted the handle to trace/observe.

Re: Are you tired of busting your nuts? *LINK*

#38

It's just money.......

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>I don't get bothered by the money as much myself, because it is just that...money...the reality is that people can make their own saws out of paint scrapers if they wanted to, so they don't need to buy expensive saws...and really, what is expensive? $200, $500, $1000? The reality is that most all saws are not expensive.

.........

If money is no concern, feel free to go bid on the giant miter saw I have up for auction this week. I'd love to see it bid up to $1000 or so. Hey, it's just money......I just got done paying $650 to fill my fuel tank. Oh well, it's just money. Never enough aluminum cans laying around.

Marv

Re: Are you tired of busting your nuts? *LINK*

#39

I didn't say it was of NO concern

Alan DuBoff

>Marv,

I didn't say money was of no concern, I said I don't get bothered with it, and I meant in regards to handsaws. They're only tools. Money itself is a concern, and I try not to do foolish things with mine, like sending it to some guy for a saw I'm not interested in...*g*

I don't like miter saws or any larger handsaws at all, I do most all of my dimensioning with power tools, and use a smaller xcut backsaw with my bench hook and/or smaller bench mounted miter box. Mostly what I use handsaws for is to perform the joinery, assembly, and detail work...you know, backsaws. *gd&r*

Good luck on that miter saw, maybe there's someone that it is of value to...but seeing that people don't bid much on them kinda shows that they are not very popular. There must be a reason for that, I am not sure, but still I wouldn't hold my breath on that auction going up too high, if it's a miter saw...*wink*

Although I have seen some of your auctions, you focus on the very saws that I don't like, notably Disstons. I hate Disstons, with the exception of the dovetail line, those I collect, No 68/69/70/71, those I would be interested in. Let me know if you put any of those on auction.

Re: Are you tired of busting your nuts? *LINK*

#40

It was implied.....

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>By saying that "it's just money", the implication was there.

I don't expect it to get bid up much. It came along for the ride with a pile of DISSTON saws I bought awhile back. Miter saws never sell for much, if at all, but it isn't doing me any good laying around here.

I sell mainly Disston saws because that's what a majority of buyers are looking for.

I have sold alot of tenon/dovetail saws but I doubt if you would pay the high price they usually sell for. Plus the fact I totally deface them with the added wheat carving. According to your posts, you only pay about 10 or 20 dollars for those you have. Is that really true? Does the San Jose Flea market still have old tools or has it become mainly off-shore junk? In the early 70,s I sold stuff there. Those were the days when alot of sellers spread their stuff out on the ground so you could see it all at a glance. I spent many a Sunday wondering around there, eating big juicy hamburgers.

Marv

Re: Are you tired of busting your nuts? *LINK*

#41

You might be surprised... *LINK*

Alan DuBoff

>Marv,

You're right I don't typically pay much for most of my tools, but certain ones I will pay a premium for, especially rarer ones like the turn of the century hand tools, like Goodell-Pratt, Miller Falls, etc...but I don't have many of them, I do cherish the ones I have.

I don't go to the San Jose flea market, but do occasionally go to DeAnza College flea, since I live 5 minutes away. Alameda is the better flea for me to find tools, I have even bought some Disston backsaws there, but a couple were 68s, and one was an older turn of the 19/20 century 12", although that is not old for a saw. I don't really even look for any saws, if I get bored I'll go surf through the listings on ebay, but I don't do it much anymore. I couldn't tell you what you have listed or not, I haven't looked at any saws in several weeks at least.

I will pay top dollar for any saw I really want, but that is still not a lot of money if you consider that even $100 is not that much. Most vintage saws are not worth that much, but some are. Most of the expensive saws I see are older large, full size hand saws. Those I'm not interested in.*g*

It wasn't until recently that that more people started to bid on some of the older English saws I prefer. So, even those are selling for more...but as I have told you, I am more interested in making my own saws, I want to have a full set of my own saws that I make for myself.

Most of my vintage saws will not be used, although I have plenty of users and do use mostly vintage saws today, aside from a few Wenzloffs, and a dozuki (great for softwoods). I have saws to do most work I need to do, I just want ones that I build myself for my users. More out of pride than anything else.

Imagine how odd that people wouldn't want this tool, or that most would know what it is. They only know that shipping is more than they want to pay for the tool. I'll buy those at that price whenever I can find them. There are still deals to be had, even on ebay.


Bottom Feeder type of auctions I bid on!

Re: Are you tired of busting your nuts? *LINK*

#42

Not much surprises me anymore...

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Disston 3D vise is, in my opinion, the better saw vise in many ways. I would never buy one that's been welded or brazed though unless I found it where I wouldn't have to pay shipping. They are heavy buggers and always on the other coast somewhere.

They have an inherent design flaw. The lever cam will wear an indentation into the jaw casting it bares on. Once that happens, the cam will not keep the jaws closed or will not clamp the blade tight enough.

I sold one on eBay about a month ago that I overhauled. I made it so it will last much longer without wearing out as fast. It worked better than a new one. I know because I have a new one, old but has never been used. The cam action on it was kind of rough, so I have overhauled that one too. It's in my shop wrapped in a plastic bag to keep it clean. I found it early in the morning on eBay with a Buy-It-Now option for only 25$. I have another one that I've used for several years, also overhauled.

The most important thing is to prevent filings from getting down into where the cam is. Filings will mix with any lubricant you put in there and will act as a grinding compound and will excelerate the damage.

Even in view of the inherent design problem, it's still the best vise around.

I checked the auction on the vise but cheap assed eBay isn't showing the pictures of it.

Marv