Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Are you tired of busting your nuts? *LINK*

Posts

Are you tired of busting your nuts? *LINK*

#1

Are you tired of busting your nuts? *LINK*

Alan DuBoff

>Well, I'm talking about saw-nuts.

The traditional way was to use split-nuts, which continue on for tradition sake, if for nothing else, and they look way kewl...

Well, I have been pondering for some time on coming up with a saw nut that would allow more purchase, and allow one to get a better grip on the nut itself. What we find is that most all vendors used different sized split-nuts, and this is true to this day even. The Wenzloff saw-nuts are different than the LN, than the Adria, than the Grammercy, etc...and sometimes it requires one files a special nut driver.

I'll put a link to McMaster-Carr for the spanner screwdriver bits, I like the idea of incorporating the notched spanner screwdriver into the split-slots. A friend is working on a proof of concept.

So, I have been pondering over this, and am working with a friend to add some small pin holes or elongated slots in the bottom of the splits. My friend thinks this is worthy to patent, but I honestly do not see enough of these being used/sold to warrant such a patent, and think it would be better to just share these ideas with other makers, rather than fighting over patents as has plagued us for a century and a half...

The idea was that if it was possible to get the same look of the split-nut, but allow the use of a special spanner type bit, it would allow for much better purchase and/or abiltity to loosen/tighten in the future, since this is actually where most nuts become damaged.

For most all vintage saws, I would prefer to have an old vintage nut, should they become destroyed, but for new saws an improved split-nut would be a welcome addition to my toolmaking, speaking for myself.

I've thought about either hex or allen head as well, and another thought that had crossed my mind would be to keep the center bolt end down inside and create a hex inset around the bolt, so that you could use a hex/allen driver and not be interfered by the center bolt. That would have a different look though, and keeping the traditional look would be one of the intentions, if possible.

In this regard, either pins or slots in the bottom of the split slots seems like it may work. I have been pondering on making a thicker nut so work that idea with.

Any other comments? Traditional split-nuts best????

Remember, the saw-nuts you save from being busted could be your very own!;-)


Spanner screwdrivers at McMaster-Carr

Re: Are you tired of busting your nuts? *LINK*

#2

Nothing wrong with old nuts

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Split nuts are just too easy to make, some brass, a drill, tap, hacksaw and file and you can make your own.

Also I have repaired old split nuts with cammed out slots and stripped threads. Some damaged slots can be peened back to servicable, the loose threads peened around the holes and running the bolt back through to fresh the threads. They do this in old clocks to tighten up worn bushings.

Properly fitting spanner bits are absolutely important for removing and replacing split nuts. It should be of the correct side and thickness for the split nut.

Stephen

Re: Are you tired of busting your nuts? *LINK*

#3

Split nuts, worst nut ever made...

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>The split nut was the worst design of any saw nut ever used on a saw. The only way to improve on it is to eliminate it by replacing it.

It boggles my mind that present day saw makers chose to use a fastener that requires a special screwdriver to tighten or remove it. There are so many better designs for clamping wood to metal, why not use one of the better methods?

Drilling holes in the bottom of the splits is not an improvement. It only further complicates matters. Another special screwdriver? At least now we can easily make a screwdriver blade with a notch that stradddles the screw. Who's going to make a screwdriver with pins or try to find one they can buy?

The early saw makers after way too many years of using a flimsy, easily stripable nut finally came to their senses and came up with a nut that would accept a bladed screwdriver. Most of the early nuts were only about 1/16" thick with less than one coarse thread and part of that thread was cut away when the split was machine in.

It's amazing that after so much thought went into making a handsaw in the first place that they didn't spend more than about ten minutes designing the screws.

Tradition? When making a new saw, forget about tradition and come up with a nut that completely replaces the old thin nuts and will do a better job of clampling the wood to the blade. Do it right and the handle won't be coming loose everytime you use the saw.

I have reconditioned many saws with flush saw nuts. I shudder everytime I do it and think how easy it would have been to have made them functional and much more practical.

Marv

Re: Are you tired of busting your nuts? *LINK*

#4

Actually, there were several wrongs with them

Alan DuBoff

>Stephen,

There were actually several problems with the old split-nuts, and the exodus away from their use around 1880 is apparent of that, at least to me. Stripped and busted nuts are the results.

I would like to add that even after the slotted screw came along it didn't prevent people from horking their nuts, and we still see a great deal of of saws which have problems with the handles and/or nuts.

Some of the things I have noticed are:

(these are only off the top of my head)

1) stripped split-nuts in general, the most obvious.

2) toolmakers who filed the nuts flush with no slot, although a nut is there, it becomes as 2 flush surfaces. Nowadays we can use epoxy to afix a nut to, so we can get it off. But hide glue wouldn't work very well for that...so that is a peculiar problem I've seen more than a few...

3) many of the nuts (both sides, head and nut, but both flush surfaces) are very thin and prone to damage in normal shop use. Either getting dropped, having tools fall on them, inadvertently being hammered on/with (yes, galoots will use a saw to hammer, or use a nut to peen on;-)

4) small diameter bolts break easily

5) many spin on the opposite flush side of the split, so requires more ingenuity/time to solve.

6) brass is soft in general, and why it is used. nowadays we could use a more durable material. It was easier for toolmakers to work with in the past, pre-Industrial Revolution, or what I refer to as traditional, before powered tools to work metal/wood.

In some ways, Marv is correct in that trying to adhere to tradition may prevent the best solution. I have pondered that as well. This goes for function as well as material. There is room to create a better saw nut.

My problem is that I admire tradition, because it represents the epitome of hand crafted. I have a hard time letting go of that tradition, because it is in itself what attracts me to all things vintaged and/or antique.

The point of the spanner screwdriver bits is that they CAN be bought more readily available.

I feel that in general the toolmakers should provide a working driver for the saws they sell, unless it was so common, and slotted fits that bill for the most part. It just doesn't solve the problem of being stripped and/or damaged either, and history has already shown this.

Maybe there is a clever way to create a better locking type bolt/nut, even out of brass, even though it would require a special driver.

I really think a more durable material would be better also, like bearing bronze. I've been looking into using 932 bronze for backs and nuts, but the cost of material is much higher than brass, which is not cheap to begin with! 932 mills good though, and milling is the only realistic way I could do something like that, I would just spend too much time doing it by hand, not that I won't waste time milling around in the shop...LOL!

Re: Are you tired of busting your nuts? *LINK*

#5

Re: Split nuts, worst nut ever made...

Alan DuBoff

>Marv wrote:

----------

"At least now we can easily make a screwdriver blade with a notch that stradddles the screw"

----------

And you still could if there was holes/slots in the bottom of the slot, the exact same way. I'm not sure I understand your point.

The point of putting the pins in the bottom of the slot is so that you could use a standard split-nut driver as you would today, which is different on most of the toolmaker's saws.

Certainly a better solution can be done. A deeper and thicker slot could even be one way, but it needs to provide good solid clamping ability.

I would guess that most modern makers must damage a brand new split-nut on occasion as well, tradition is a funny thing, heh? Doesn't always work that way, the saw back is another discussion in itself, as most use modern milled backs.

No matter if it's tradition or best solution, it is ambition that drives people to create. If one doesn't have ambition, it doesn't matter how many great ideas they would come up with. Results are the proof I guess. The very reason I posted this thread is that I haven't quite came up with the right idea or had enough ambition to try to really solve it. Although my current plan is to use splits-nuts which I have, I want to see what my friend comes up with, if anything, because it seems he might have the ambition.

Re: Are you tired of busting your nuts? *LINK*

#6

I am not defending the split nut...

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>that is not my job. What I am saying on old saws with split nuts you have to deal with them. And if you are making or buying and using reproductions you have to deal with them.

As you so well pointed out the nuts were abused and damaged and altered in many ways, I have seen holes drilled in for pin spanners. The problem is the screwdriver/nut driver.

Many of these have very fine slots and require a dedicated bit. I have three different sized spanner nut bits for my brace, which is as far as I am concerned the ideal tool for removing and installing split nuts. It has incredible control and almost completely eliminates the possibility of cam out.

The brace and spanner bit give you a better feel for how tight the nut is because of the leverage advantage. The bit in the brace, allows proper downward pressure reducing the possibility of camming out of the delicate often shallow slots. Much more positive way to remove and replace spanner nuts and any other slotted screw.

It is also easy to alter a reproduction screwdriver with a flattened shank (for a wrench, which is important) by cutting a notch in the center and sharpening it properly to engage the split nut. This approach with the wrench is very similar to the brace and bit and greatly improves its ability to remove and replace split nuts.

Stephen

Re: Are you tired of busting your nuts? *LINK*

#7

Re: Are you tired of busting your nuts?

Joel

>Most of the complaints you have seem to be on old dinged up saws in mostly poor condition. When the old saws were new, before they were "fixed", "reconditioned" or otherwise restored the nuts were perfectly adjustable by a split nut driver that in the 18th and 19th century was a common toolbox accessory. I have a lot of old saws, I've disassembled them all in the name of research, and in general a proper split nut driver made it cake.

in the mid 19th century when slotted screws replaced the split nut - the slotted screws weren't flush with the wood and IMHO, not as nice looking or not as ergonomic. And those sometimes come dinged too after a century of poor maintenance.

Now you have wanted a replacement for modern saws - and for new saws I think none of this is an issue. Both LN and Gramercy sell split nut drivers for their saws, which can be trivally modified for other makes. You won't need them often but if you do they are available. And the saws come with nice clean slots that are easy to engage. You can also easily make your own slotted screwdriver if a few minutes.

Re: Are you tired of busting your nuts? *LINK*

#8

Re: Split nuts, worst nut ever made...

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Alan wrote:

........

And you still could if there was holes/slots in the bottom of the slot, the exact same way. I'm not sure I understand your point.

........

My point is, drilling holes in the existing slots doesn't solve the problem with the slots that get buggered up. The holes could get buggered also and filled with crap. Holes would require an exact tool to fit them. Slots don't. I don't understand what you mean by pins in the slots. I haven't run across a split nut that I couldn't remove. However, if I had a screwdriver with small pins I might try drilling holes in a split nut in order to get the nut off, that is if I had no other way to remove it. But for general purposes I don't see any advantage. Perhaps I'm not understanding what you are suggesting here. When I checked the McMasters link, I saw a screwdriver with pins. That means that holes would have to be in the split nut to match up with the pins on the screwdriver. I doubt if there are very many people who could drill two small holes that would match up with pins on a screwdriver.

What I would like to see is a screw set with a screw driver slot on both the screw head as well as the nut. Making the head and the nut flush with the wood looks nice but is not practical. Also a larger screw head and nut would allow more surface for the fastener to bare against when clamping the wood. Most screw sets we see on backsaws are too small, especially older saws, even on some regular handsaws for that matter.

As for type of metal, brass is fine and easy to machine and is a bit cheaper than bronze. And doesn't need to be plated compared to using say steel fasteners.

If I were to manufacture saws, one of the first things I would do would be to reinvent the screws. They have been a pain in the arse throughout the history of saw making.

Re: Are you tired of busting your nuts? *LINK*

#9

Re: Are you tired of busting your nuts?

MikeW

>I should stay out of this I suppose.

Nuts that use pinhole spanners are available. Not a new thing. Application to a saw probably is, more or less.

I think comparing, or juxtaposing, new saws that use split nuts to vintage saws that have had the nuts continually filed down over what, more than 100 years, a bit overkill to make your point, Alan.

I have a couple saws from the late 1700s and a few from the very early 1800s with split nuts that are just fine. Many of the saws I have show evidence of retightening and filing. I suspect the users didn't want to bother with replacing the split nuts before they filed the slots out. Simple fix is for a purchaser of new(er) saws that use split nuts is not to do that. If a nut ever sits proud of the cheek, simply drill the hole a skosh deeper and tighten the nut then lightly file the protruding bolt down.

I think the main thing "back when" and now for makers is the cost effectiveness of split nuts. Come up with an effective "improved-improved" saw nut and bolt that is as cost effective and uses a slotted screwdriver and I'll gladly take a look.

In the meantime, grab yourself a couple 1/2" and 7/16" hex-drive spade bits and grind one in the 5 minutes it takes. File or grind the end down to fit various width split nuts on each one, file the notch, harden them with a propane or MAPP torch and throw them in a drawer until needed.

As long as the driver fits the slots reasonably well (speaking new split nuts here), there is no reason that they will not last for a 150 years. Not bad service from such a simple nut.

Take care, Mike

Re: Are you tired of busting your nuts? *LINK*

#10

Re: Are you tired of busting your nuts?

Alan DuBoff

>Mike,

Good to see you around.

I have to believe that there is a better nut to use, or we wouldn't see so many various types of failure. Sure, there are saws that are 150 years old and the nuts are fine, and how can we tell how many failed? Alas, we can't. But we can tell that a fair number of old saws have loose handles, whether it be from continued wood acclimation and moisture content over time, or stress from being used, or just weather and time, I'm sure a lot of reasons will contribute to the failures.

I hope that your saws are the first to last 150 years and be absolutely perfect, I won't be around to know. But knowing that saws do last that long concerns me. Hopefully there will still be wood to work in 150 years...at the rate our population is destroying the atmosphere, maybe it won't even matter...:-/

Many modern makers use harder woods for the handles, the wood could contribute to preserving handles better than yesteryear. I'm not convinced that the split-nuts are the best solution today, I'm sure they were in their time.

Re: Are you tired of busting your nuts? *LINK*

#11

Re: Are you tired of busting your nuts?

Alan DuBoff

>Joel,

Yes, split-nut drivers were available when these split-nuts were widely used, but today there are not split-nut drivers. You don't need to wait 150 years to loose a driver, most people are capable in loosing it within a year.

Sure, you can file a spade bit as Mike suggests, been there, done that. But how is the guys who is about to hork up the split-nut to know that, most likely they will be trying to use some other tools and hork it up good.

If drivers were widely available you wouldn't have need to create one for your saws. Also, when I read Chris Schwarz's blog not long ago about your driver bit, he seemed pretty happy that it would first 2 of the 3 nuts he owns. Would have been nicer if one bit fit all...but one could always file their own for each saw, that is what most have been doing...

The LN driver doesn't work very well on Mike's saws, and one that fits Mike's saws probably won't fit the Grammercy saws you sell, but I don't have one of yours to know. LN doesn't fit Mike's very well. Per Chris, your driver works on the LN.

Re: Are you tired of busting your nuts? *LINK*

#12

Re: Are you tired of busting your nuts?

MikeW

>You really ought to read thoroughly, Alan [g]...

It's not that there probably isn't a "better," more universal fastener already in existance (you mention a couple) and certainly someone could design the heck out of one.

If someone doesn't have a driver today, they are free to make one, (at present) buy a LN or one from Joel and slightly file the tip to fit ours or Adria's saws--or "dork" them up using whatever. We will have a driver soon that fits Eddie's or our saws--and hence many non-screwed up vintage saws and even LN/Gramercy saw nuts. One point above is, if someone needs a driver they are readily available. Joel's solution is the most cost effective presently and might take a few strokes with a file to fit ours (don't know).

I must admit that your "concern" that saws last so long and might/will need the split nuts tightened seems a bit overly dramatic. In the same breath you mention the lack of drivers--but there are some available. Don't you think people modified tools to fit their purpose/needs "back in the day"? What's the big deal to do so now?

We presently use both vintage drivers I had to file down as they were for larger split nuts than one would find on a saw, as well as ground hex-drive spade bits.

My main point--the last one I'll reiterate--is the simplicity, the utility and the low cost of the present split nut that has hung on for a couple hundred years simply is hard to beat.

Whatever you design, get a quote on having a few thousand of them made or if already a stock item, for buying in bulk. Oh...make sure someone doesn't need to purchase a new driver, even if it is a common pin spanner.

Take care, Mike

Re: Are you tired of busting your nuts? *LINK*

#13

An end to busting your nutz.

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Mike,

As we both know, saw screws and nuts lend themselves to being manufactured on a screw machine. You stick raw stock in one end and the finished part shoots out the other end.

Allow me to offer a few basic ideas for a practical screw set. You can adjust the dimensions to suit your particular requirements.

This design is simple with a minimum of machining steps.

First, reverse how the two parts screw together. The female thread should be in the part that is on the front or left side of the handle. It actually becomes the nut, not the screw. The part of this nut that extends through to the other side should be sized to fit the holes in older saws, approx. .200 dia. or the the size of a No.4 drill. (.209) This dia. will be just right for an internal 8-32 thread. The female threaded shaft should extend through the holes in the blade and about 1/8" out the other side. The blade would be used as a template for drilling matching holes in the handle.

Picture a single sized hole through the handle with a counterbore on each side for a flush fit.

For regular saws the head should be 9/16" dia and can be counterbored for a flush fit, or not. For backsaws the head can be smaller.

For the backside of the handle all you need is an 8-32 male thread with a slotted head that can be also counterbored for a flush fit. The head should be at least .125 thick. The screwdriver slot should be such that a standard screwdriver could be used.

This design allows for a long screw with lots of threads. I doubt if it would be necessary, but a star washer could be used under the head of the shafted nut to prevent it from turning as you tighten the two parts.

This screw set can easily be made in a screw machine but when you use this method, you usually produce large quantities. A semi-production lathe would do it in smaller quantities but would cost more per item.

Having the shaft extend through the blade gives added stability between the handle and the blade to lessen the chance of the handle becoming loose.

Invoice will follow....*g*

Marv

Re: Are you tired of busting your nuts? *LINK*

#14

OT - losing screwdrivers

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA, gloriously sunny

>When I had teenage boys, the life expectancy of a Phillips screwdriver was about the same as that of an unlocked Corvette with the keys in the ignition downtown in any major city. For some reason, flat drivers didn't get lost nearly as often (I still have one of the original set I bought 38 years ago), but Phillips were endangered. I finally took to keeping them in a drawer under the bed, on my side, so I could defend them if needed.

Re: Are you tired of busting your nuts? *LINK*

#15

Re: OT - losing screwdrivers

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Bill,

I had a similar problem with my kids.....Then I started chopping their fingers off....no more missing tools....

Do you think this was a bit harsh? Hey, I like my tools!!

Marv

Re: Are you tired of busting your nuts? *LINK*

#16

Re: An end to busting your nutz.

MikeW

>Still more expensive to make. Don't believe me? Draw it up and get a quote.

fwiw, our bolts are 8-36. I wanted a few extra threads. Our threads go nearly all the way down the bolt. No one will ever bottom out the nuts on the bolts. We use 7/16", 1/2" and 9/16" bolt heads/nuts. Depends on the saw.

You know, if ya all have these saws with bunged up nuts and bolts, why not just replace the suckers and they'll be good for another 100 years?

Take care, Mike

Re: Are you tired of busting your nuts? *LINK*

#17

Re: An end to busting your nutz.

Alan DuBoff

>MikeW wrote:

-----------

"Still more expensive to make. Don't believe me? Draw it up and get a quote."

-----------

How do I get a quote on my time? I can waste it how I see fit after all, so I don't see it as being a problem.

No law saying one can't mill them up themselves.*g*

Marv's suggestion is not bad, but sounds as if there is not much range on the thread, I need to read it again, but it sounded like it would only have 1/8" of thread...that must not be, and you suggested I read better, so I'll go do that...

Cheers, stay away from the 'bolo...(heard it was giving you and the boys fits). it's so beautiful that when people start using it they can't stop, and most seem to get an allergic reaction at some point.

Re: Are you tired of busting your nuts? *LINK*

#18

Re: An end to busting your nutz.

MikeW

>Yep, you can make them yourself. So can Marv. Anyone believing there's a better moustrap out there can--or copy the old style. No laws being suggested or broken.

You did ask for comments re "Any other comments? Traditional split-nuts best????"

"I feel that in general the toolmakers should provide a working driver for the saws they sell,"

And Marv wrote..."It boggles my mind that present day saw makers chose to use a fastener that requires a special screwdriver to tighten or remove it. There are so many better designs for clamping wood to metal, why not use one of the better methods?" And "If I were to manufacture saws, one of the first things I would do would be to reinvent the screws."

Point being is that part of this thread was about commercial entities making a new fangled bolt and nut, and or simply a discussion about them. Of course, I could have misread that.

I listed my main reason for continuing using a proven moustrap. It's different from yours or Marv's. The issue about drivers for split nuts is moot. Drivers are both available and easy to make or alter.

I suspect the first thing a craftsman did 150 years ago when his handle came loose and he thought, dang, I shoulda ordered a split nut driver was to make one without further thought.

I won't bore anyone further on this subject.

Take care, Mike

Re: Are you tired of busting your nuts? *LINK*

#19

I think my approach makes for better stories

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA, gloriously sunny

>

Re: Are you tired of busting your nuts? *LINK*

#20

A better design

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Mike,

Same number of steps in machining my design as your design, so I don't see any difference in cost. And lets not forget the amount of waste when the parts are machined from round stock. It's about the same with both designs.

Some pluses with my design..

Standard screwdriver slot

Could have at least a half inch of thread.

8-32 screw thread, less chance of stripping or crossthreading. Coarser threads are better in soft metals.

Can easily be made to not be flush to the wood, hence, eliminating the counterbores.

A larger shaft through the blade for better stability.

Not having the split nut makes for a much cleaner appearance on that side of the handle and no need for hand fitting when the screw protrudes through the nut too far.

I was hoping for more of an exchange of ideas instead of an immediate rejection of a better idea. Although, I agree, it is a boring subject.

I was just kidding about the invoice....LOL

Marv

Re: Are you tired of busting your nuts? *LINK*

#21

Re: A better design

MikeW

>Get a quote, Marv...unless like Alan you'll be making your own.

I cannot fully visualize what you are talking about, but I probably wouldn't request a quote if I did. Not because of rejecting your idea, but because I think I can visualize it well enough to guess that it would be more costly for a *possible* minor difference.

Feel free to prove me wrong.

I'm as open to the idea as I am for plastic handles. Now, before you go off thinking I'm against them from the exchange with Adam, I'm more or less making some.

Back to a nut using a standard screwdriver. I don't see how it is an improvement in cost and utility over the so-called improved saw nuts of yesteryear. With those, if the wood shrinks enough to bottom out the bolt one only has to grind a skosh off the bolt. Not a big deal.

Take care, Mike

Re: Are you tired of busting your nuts? *LINK*

#22

Re: A better design

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Mike,

I have no desire or ambition to make these things in any quantity. Maybe a few for my own uses. Just wanted to share a few thoughts in case they might be useful. I spent most of my working life designing such things. This is no biggie.

To draw them up and get quotes requires more time than I can justify.

Maybe I'll make a few for replacements on some of my saws to be reconditioned. If I do, I'll send you one so you can visualize. I surely don't expect you to change your entire operation there to incorporate a different screw set. Having been in manufacturing most of my working life I know what it's like to make such changes.

I realize the design is not a major breakthrough in fact it isn't totally original. There are lots of existing fasteners that are very similar but probably not dimensioned to do the job thats required for a handsaw.

As for plastic handles.....I suggest you take a look at the Disston D-95. It is made to not come loose from the blade. When I look at it I see alot of clever design that went into it even though the overall shape is not all that pleasing to the eye. But there are some great mounting ideas to consider. And lots of improvements could be made to a better shape that would make it more consistant with the shapes we like to see and use. With the advanced technology in present day plastics thinner cross-sections are quite possible. It doesn't have to look cheap. There's an opportunity to think outside the box and be totally creative. There are injection molded plastics available today that are virtually indistructable. Just think of walking into Sears some day and seeing a saw with a plastic handle that looks like a Disston #12 ca 1900 hanging next to the junk that we see there now with the name Wenzloff & Sons on the blade.

Marv

Re: Are you tired of busting your nuts? *LINK*

#23

The Question is the Answer!

Alan DuBoff

>Mike Wenzloff said:

------------------

I suspect the first thing a craftsman did 150 years ago when his handle came loose and he thought, dang, I shoulda ordered a split nut driver was to make one without further thought.

------------------

At the expense of embarrassing myself (not that I care;-), I will tell you story...it hinges on an article that Chris Schwarz wrote in the Autumn 2005 issue of Woodworking Magazine, the one with the Roubo on the cover. It has an article in the back which has the title of this post.

I don't know why, I think about that article from time to time, especially when it rings true...*sigh*

It was a casual day in the shop, thought I would do a little messin' around, and one thing I had been wanting to do is take one of the handles from the pair of joinery saws you made for me, the small 8" ones. Those have a higher hang, which I had to damn near convince you to do for me, which oddly now it seems you've like a lot with the hang a bit higher, and I see them listed on your site as such.

Anyway, I pondered, and then asked myself, "Self, this nut driver looks a little big, but it seems to be catching ok, should I use it or should I file a new one?". I think you can see by now where this is going and quite honestly, this is an honest mistake with a less than optimal solution, the traditional split-nuts.

So, this story wouldn't be any good unless the title rings true, which it did, and I knew the answer when I asked myself the question, yes in fact I should have filed a new split-nut driver, as the 2 I had didn't work, 1 wouldn't fit in the slots, and the other was close, looked not to bad from my tired eyes...this is not totally my fault, but one of my kids opened the door and asked a question, just as I was doing this, and as I looked up, it was enough to hork the nut.

After I got over the err, I reminded myself of that article...yes, I knew the answer...but I didn't do it even though I knew it, I tried to take the quick way out and use the driver I had, as I was focused on something else, not about those split-nuts.

This is an honest mistake, and one of my Wenzloff saws has a scar on it, but it still does cut fine, and I tell myself, "Self, now it looks like some of my other great vintage saws that have scars on them as well, and they still cut fine...".

I know you will most likely scoff this off with, "You didn't need to take the handle off", "it was your fault", "you should have listened to yourself to begin with and you wouldn't have done that", etc...and you would be right to any of those if you're saying them, but it just didn't work out that way in my shop that day.

The good thing is that it's only a tool, it's a piece of steel and some brass with a wood handle, something I can make myself. If anything I'm sure glad that I use my tools rather than not...

I did file a nut-driver for my Wenzloff saws after that, so that is a moot point I 'spose, but I don't feel that everyone should need to. Since you provide a less than common split-nut, and you don't provide a driver, in the course of time this is what will happen, I assure you I will not be the only galoot to hork up a split-nut on the hundreds, if not more than a thousand saws that you've made to date. You see Mike, I'm not picking on the toolmakers per se, I'm just pointing out that it is those very toolmakers using uncommon split-nuts who don't provide a driver to their customers who add fuel to this fire.

I'm not saying your evil for it, just that there *could* be a better solution to this long standing problem. You don't see traditional split-nuts as being a problem, so this is not an issue for you, and point taken. But saying that customers should file their own driver will mean that someone else down the road will be asking the very question I did, and I suspect I won't be alone with the results.

It has nothing to do with 5 minutes to file one, I could have done that and I did in fact do it even after I horked the split-nut. But I didn't take the time, fault me if you will, it was my fault.

There is nothing wrong with tradition, and the traditional split-nuts are in fact fine for their purpose, but they're not without faults either, just like me, I have quite a few of those myself...

Re: Are you tired of busting your nuts? *LINK*

#24

If it is boring, why do you keep replying?

Alan DuBoff

>

Re: Are you tired of busting your nuts? *LINK*

#25

Re: The Question is the Answer!

MikeW

>No worries Alan. I don't care if you decided to take the saw apart. Why would I?

Yep, a split nut driver has been in the works a while. I am remiss in that. It's about the same size of slot as Eddie's saws. Same as on my Moulson and a few larger vintage saws I own. Seemed common enough, just not what Tom used. The thought never crossed my mind to check Tom's. Joel's came after.

We will be producing two drivers. One for the kits we can simply include if I can keep the cost down enough, and people can purchase for any saw out there (may have to file it ). The other will be priced competitively but be a "real" driver.

Now, some of what follows isn't directed at you.

Whether someone purchases a solution or makes a driver (like in our kit instructions I think) is no big deal. I personally think people should just make them. How many screwdrivers does the avergage woodworker have in their shop? For the people who want to purchase one of the then three available ones, we'll gladly do it.

If someone bungs up the nuts, it also isn't really a big deal. Lesson learned. If the scared nut is ugly in the eye of the beholder, we have nuts and bolts they can purchase. Else...live with it. It's a tool. It's not a piece of art. Tools get scars if used. It's part of the life of the tool.

Your saw. We've made either 3 or 4 of that pattern of saw is all. It's been embellished a little in the looks department, but the hang is the same. The saws you see on the web site aren't like yours. They are the Moulson pattern we've always made.

"You see Mike, I'm not picking on the toolmakers per se, I'm just pointing out that it is those very toolmakers using uncommon split-nuts who don't provide a driver to their customers who add fuel to this fire"

Uh, what fire? Only person I know as of yet fanning flames is...

I hear you Alan, even if I'm poking back at you. I started at 4 am this morning. Had three or four breaks until dinner time. There hasn't been a lot of time to work on a split nut driver. I know it isn't rocket science. But it does take time sourcing vendors, refining a desing that is cost effective to make and the communication that goes along with it--and trying to get saws out the door. Call me lazy, but it wasn't a real high priority.

Take care, Mike