Re: how flat is flat enough
RobRing
>Indeed.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Re: how flat is flat enough
RobRing
>Indeed.
OK (long)
Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.
>Just to define terms a little further, I am talking about lapping on either granite (preferred) or thick, supported glass. As Bugbear points out elsewhere in this thread, unsupported plane iron will flex.
I also highly recommend PSA microfinishing film, rather than sandpaper, because it is very thin and hard and won't radius (dub) the edges of what is being lapped upon it.
The first pass on the abrasive is diagnostic: You want to read the initial scratch pattern and learn whether the sole is overall convex (bellied out) or concave, and furthermore, where the local high and low spots are on the sole, high spots being those that project toward the work, low spots being hollows.
The strategy to be followed depends entirely on this first diagnostic pass. If the sole is overall convex, then it can only be flattened by first making it concave. Let me say that again: If the sole is convex, or if it appears to be 'flat', lapping will make it more convex. It will have to be scraped or abraded hollow to get it to the concave condition to make it flat. This is the same principle as edge-jointing a convex edge--you plane from the inside out, first making it a little hollow, then it flattens on the finishing pass or two. The Japanese make both their plane soles and chisel/plane iron backs hollow for this very reason. But I digress...
If the sole is overall concave, then it can be lapped flat (more detail below in answer to your question). There can also be localized issues--if any part of the front of mouth is low, that won't do. It needs to be flush on the work. If there are high spots behind the mouth or in front of the mouth, that will lead to all kinds of erratic misery. These localized high spots can be scraped down efficiently by hand, as Joel pointed out. With the local high spots scraped, you can now lap the concave sole.
The question regarding lapping was: why wouldn't differential abrasion between leading and trailing edges lead to convexity? The short answer is that we are not going to have leading and trailing edges. Not consistent leading and trailing edges. If we did, that would be like putting the plane sole to a continuous belt sander, in which case it would go immediately convex, just as you said. Instead, we will randomize the scratch pattern so that (1) the sole is always moving toward fresher abrasive, and (2) there is about equal pressure front and rear. The approach is similar to when we move a plane or chisel blade on a stone, always moving toward less-used places to keep the stone flat. The minute a consistent pattern is established--repetitive orientation of the plane, or digging a worn channel on the abrasive--there will be problems.
The sole is lapped with equal pressure front and rear, and moving the plane always in the direction of the freshest abrasive. Marv suggested a figure 8 to do this. The desired end point is when the front of mouth, toe, heel, and periphery are coplanar. Stop short of having the entire sole showing the same scratches--if that happens, it is either convex, or soon will be.
In summary, lapping can work on concave surfaces, if the user applies the same intelligence as when sharpening a plane blade or edge-jointing a board. A jointer plane simply run down a board repetitively will not produce a flat square edge--some elementary diagnostics and technique are required. A sharpening stone will quickly hollow out if the blade is run in a track down the middle over and over. We learn not to do these things; the same lessons can be applied to lapping.
Wiley
;-)
Dan Donaldson
>
Re: how flat is flat enough
ThomD
>Main thing is where it is dished. If it is hollow right in front of the mouth, or high just behind, and they often are, then you have a problem. Other than that I think the try it advice is pretty good. Getting it closer over a full length is not a job for shop methods. As a general issue getting it much flater is a job for a surface grinder. You can even out "texture", ups and downs, but really nailing it all the way takes an SG. Most woodshops don't even have the gear to measure that accurately. Most plane will distort 5 thou in use form hand pressure. Still the flater the better, but you may try it and find it does everything you need it to.
In general, I don't totally feel woodworking and metalworking are all that different in tolerances, but where they apply those stanadards is different. You want to bore a hole that is a press fit for a bearing it has to be just so, When woodworkes make parts like that they are normally oversize. But woodworking joinery, or the steps in which woodworker's reduce a surface for joints or finish are right in the way of the same tolerances metal workers use, so there is more in comon than many allow.
Re: how flat is flat enough
paul womack
>Oh come on, Mr Scholtz, you can't get away with just that.
How much more of that kind of thing do you have secreted away?
Is the fellows here don't want theory, trust me, I know some people that do.
BugBear
Very interesting...
Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.
>So, if I read you correctly, we can flex a long plane to some extent.
However if the sole is concave we can't get a flat surface out of that plane because by the time we can press down to flatten it the plane has already taken a thicker shaving at the beginning of the board. And the board that is worked on may very well flex a bit too, further affecting the result (which way, I'm not sure).
This suggests that a flat, or very slightly convex sole, is preferable, because even with a flat sole it is possible/probable to take a thicker shaving at the beginning of the stroke just out of the pressure to hold the (at that point) unbalanced plane on the board. And that there is enough flex in the whole plane/board setup to make absolute sole flatness somewhat irrelevant.
Bottom line, as long as the sole is not concave, the user's technique in handling the plane is the main factor in getting a flat surface.
Or, put another way, there's no substitute for experience :-)
Sounds about right?
DC
Re: Very interesting...
Sgian Dubh
> So, if I read you correctly, we can flex a long plane to some extent.
Yes Denis, I've been doing just that on purpose for years, even decades. Start an edge with simple forward movement. Bend the sole as you progress towards the middle of the board and take a thicker shaving. Let the sole straighten out again as you get towards the end.
I can't remember where I learnt to do it. I was probably shown the trick by some horny handed old cabinetmaker during my training. Maybe I worked it out for myself. No matter; I do it anyway.
Or, put another way, there's no substitute for experience :-)
Sounds about right?
Yes. Slainte.
Re: Very interesting...
Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.
>Yes Denis, I've been doing just that on purpose for years, even decades. Start an edge with simple forward movement. Bend the sole as you progress towards the middle of the board and take a thicker shaving. Let the sole straighten out again as you get towards the end.
I think one could get the same result with a slightly convex sole, without having to put extra pressure in the middle of the board...
Makes sense?
DC
Re: Very interesting...
Sgian Dubh
>It does make sense Denis.
That's another wrinkle on the plane sole debate I have to deal with when demonstrating plane use to beginners. Not all planes and plane soles are equal, especially those planes brought in by beginners that can't work out why they can't plane wood. So long as the sole is flat where it matters, or slightly convex, and the iron is sharp I can work with just about anything from a nice new Clifton to a sad rusty looking thing with a loose handle and wonky front knob.
You just have to do a bit of planing, get a feel for how the thing performs and adjust how you use the thing according to how it is.
However, if the sole is significantly concave, then no amount of buggering about on my part as I'm planing produces satisfactory results.
Plane soles like this need a bit of flattening. I just use a sheet of glass, or other flat surface; a long strip of 40 or 60 grit abrasive spray mounted down; retract the iron; then 'plane' the sole. 10-20 minutes later, 30 minutes at the most and the job's done.
There's no need at all to go any smoother than 40 or 60 grit for a fully serviceable plane. If you're fussy and like a more attractive sole then 80 or 120 grit makes it look a bit sharper.
If you enjoy tuning up plane soles for fun you can spend hours at the job all the way up to 20,000 grit or whatever and silver jewellery polish. None of that does anything useful for performance that I've ever noticed; but the sole certainly does shine nicely, until you score it up all over actually using it, ha, ha. Slainte.
Re: Very interesting...
David Charlesworth
>Richard,
I find that a smoother sole has less friction and requires less candle wax etc.
Finishing with blunt 240 grit, followed by a good hard scrub with 0000wire/steel wool and metal/chrome polish, cuts friction a lot. Pushing the plane is almost effortless, especially after a coat of paste wax.
Wire wool and metal polish is also good for routine maintainance, removing the first traces of rust or tarnish.
David
Re: Very interesting...
Sgian Dubh
>I take your points David. However, I do wonder if the steps of polishing, waxing, etc, makes up for the friction a smooth plane sole experiences.
Compare a flat and very smooth (highly polished even) sole to one that's also flat, dull looking and shows 40 or 60 grit striations. I wonder which one puts the most metal on the wood?
Surely more metal contact equals more friction? By that logic the sole with coarse striations might even encounter significantly less friction than a highly polished sole. And a bit of candle wax slathered on the 'furrowed' sole also has somewhere to lodge, unlike on a very smooth plane sole-- a bit like pigment stain on maple or sycamore compared to ash or oak.
Certainly I use recently flattened planes with coarse striations in the sole without any problem. Maybe one day I'll take one of my planes with an already more refined sole, eg, one of my Clifton planes, and work through the grits a bit more. Then I could try that chrome polishing malarkey to see if it makes any significant difference.
I've just never seen the need to go that far and spend the time required to do the job to that level. I mean I've seen people spend close to a whole day working on the sole of a jack plane. When they're done it's shiny enough to shave in, but that's six or eight hours furniture making time wasted, and I'm not much interested in looking in to the sole of a plane to shave, ha, ha. Slainte.
Re: Very interesting...
David Charlesworth
>Richard,
Not sure you are right about friction and contact area?
The wire wool and metal polish, followed by wax, takes no more than 15 minutes max. The wire wool smoothes the tops of the scratchy mountains, no need to remove scratches, which are costantly created by some abrasive exotic timbers anyway.
The reduction of friction is very noticeable.
David