We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>Having just got a LN paring chisel for Xmas and finally got round to flattening and polishing the back, I'm interested to know if anyone has a recommendation on honing angles for working in Ash, Oak etc? I was slightly surprised to find the bevel ground at 30� so I reground it at 23� and then honed at 27�. The edge broke down v quickly. Is this A2 steel needing higher bevel angles for hand paring?
>L-N changed the delivered bevel angle from 25 to 30 degrees early in the production due to the problem you are experiencing. Some have found that the edges are fine after a few sharpenings at the shallow angles, but a final bevel of 30 should have you in fine shape. Apparently this alloy does not tolerate the thin edges well. There are threads here and at Woodnet about this topic. Your chisels are fine. You'll like them.
>There's a lot of white ash around here. I've not used paring chisels on it often, but for work that is not fine, I use heavy chisel at about 30 degrees. I have to hone often.
>I sent mine back thinking there was something wrong with the metal since they were early. LN just reground them to 30� and sent them back. They work ok, but I do't feel like they are worth anything near what they cost. Mine were a gift, so I am kinda stuck with them. I must say though, at the 30�, they hold up longer, but still not very great. They are pretty and they feel good.
>My experiences have been more or less the following:
-One old tradition I heard about chisels, even high-end japanese chisels, is that the best steel shows up after using and honing the chisel regularly for a few years. I've had some chisels that seemed a lot softer when I got them, and got better with use, so this seems to bear up.
-25 degrees is great for Pine. 28 is ok for woods like mahogany and walnut. I usually use 30 for things like maple and cherry. Particularly when I'm chopping or paring end grain.
-Ash, and particularly Oak, are really brutal on tools. There's just no way around it. My advice would be to experiment with different angles. If 28 doesn't work, try 29. If that doesn't work, try 30. I know some people who have separate chisels dedicated to oak and ash, that they grind at around 32 or 33 degrees, more for chopping. They maintain this separate set because they have to grind them so differently, it's just easier to keep a separate set than to keep regrinding.
I had one project where I was dovetailing white oak. I was using japanese chisels for a while, and I was stropping every 2 or 3 strokes. I'm sure I dubbed the edge a bit, so the effective angle was probably in the mid 30's. And after a while I got impatient, and tiny nicks began to appear in the edge of the chisel. Word to the wise when chopping oak: when the edge starts to break down, hone your G*d D*mned tools. Tiny nicks turned into bigger nicks, and now there's a chip that goes back probably 1/16" into the edge of one of those chisels. Moral of the story, white oak is ugly. I haven't had the heart to deal with restoring that chisel, though I'll have to get to it sometime soon.
I will say that frequent stropping did seem to help. After a while, I think the soft strop made something akin to a microscopic back-bevel on the back of the chisels, and after a while, the chisels were holding up a little bit better... until that huge chunk chipped out. The back bevel is not normally desirable, but it was small enough that it would disappear with a honing or two anyway. Chisels need to be maintained sometimes, and that's all there is to it. The best you can do is find a way to make them work the way you need them to work when you're trying to get a project to turn out well.
As for my experiences with lie-Nielsen, I think different steels react differently to different stones and sharpening methods. I did try Shaptons on the A2, and diamond paste. I recently read that Tools For Working Wood reported that their D2 plane irons did better with Nortons and paste than it did with Shaptons, and the moral of the story is that different steels really do seem to like different sharpening media. I picked up a decent natural finishing waterstone at Lee Valley in their discount section, and had pretty decent luck with that. I've also had good luck with fine Arkansas stones for final honing.
My 1/4" L-N chisel I honed with a knife-grind bevel, meaning it's actually convex, nd I use it pretty exclusively for chopping. It seems to hold up very well, and it's honed to around 30 degrees. I've beaten holy snot out of that chisel, using the Lee Valley brass journeyman's mallet, dovetailing in Maple, Cherry, and other hardwoods, and it's always done right by me. I have NOT shoved it into oak yet. I try to avoid that sort of experience now. But I'm sure, someday, it will come to that.