Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Daryl Weir

Posts

Re: Daryl Weir

#26

Re: It certainly is a matter of perspective...

paul womack

>Anyway, I had quite a few saws under my belt before I took that one apart

Hmm. Your site shows some lovely saws!!

some saw pictures

BugBear

Re: Daryl Weir

#27

Re: It certainly is a matter of perspective...

Alan DuBoff

>TZ wrote:

--------

Loved seeing your response. One point you made is that which describes many woodworkers working towards metal precision. I couldn't agree more! I find it humorous on how many guys purchase blade calipers or micrometers to measure thickness of plane shavings and brag about getting one or two thou. sahvings, but don't realize these tools need calibrated to a known standard plus a certain finese to use properly.

--------

Yeah, it is kinda funny, but it's easy to get caught up in that if you're not careful, happens to the best of us.

I think this is really true in regards to how some people look at saw sharpening, it doesn't need to be complicated, and there really is a very high chance of ruining the saw. It's only a tool after all.

TZ wrote:

--------

I've sharpened a few saws and I don't know if it was a result I was looking for, but they feel better than they did before sharpening! would I try sharpening my Adria or LN yet? Probably not, but I do have a few to experiment on. Anyhow, thanks for posting your interesting perspective as it is one that many of us agree with.

--------

I wouldn't let yourself shy away from those saws, and if so, give another saw a few filings. The very reason to buy a quality tool is to have a decent tool to use. Sharpening is actually a part of the maintenance in using one. Anyway, it's good that you started to file your saws, and I'm sure if you keep with it you will most certainly end up sharpening those saws you speak of.

Paul,

That aerodynamic tower is an interesting chatchka! That would be cool with cross hairs and and a red lazer pointer...I think it's good to go through the motions of doing those things, in the sense that you will typically learn some things about filing in doing so. I probably wouldn't use it over the long term, but I don't imagine you do either.

Or do you use that most of the time?

You have nice saw pages, I've often referred people to them in the past. Leif Hansen's pages are good also, as-is Brendler's pages are as well. Pete Taran's stuff is always good, and if others find the block on the end of the file good, that's all good for them, IMO.

Those saws are old pics, most taken when I first started to buy/compare saws. The best of them are in the attached pic.


img

Re: Daryl Weir

#28

Re: It certainly is a matter of perspective...

Dan Donaldson

>I think that the measuring is just a way to do an impartial measurement of performance. In the end, does it matter if you can take a 1 thou or 2 thou shaving? Not really, if what you get works for you in the context of the job that you are doing. On the other hand, it gives you a way to make changes and see if you made it better or worse than it was before. You can then do the things that work and ignore the ones that do not long term.

On still another hand (didn't know I had three hands did you?;-)), in any endeavor, someone is going to figure out a way to make it into a competition. They race lawnmowers and belt sanders, why not make a contest of thinnest shaving. All in fun.

Re: Daryl Weir

#29

Re: It certainly is a matter of perspective...

Alan DuBoff

>Dan Donaldson wrote:

-------------------

In the end, does it matter if you can take a 1 thou or 2 thou shaving? Not really,

-------------------

Actually it does matter to me that a hand plane can take off 1 thou, because that is a job that it does well...even the best tailed apprentice has a hard time taking off 1 thou...even if it is accurate to 1 thou. In that case it's nice to sneek up on your work 1 thou at a time with a hand plane. Can do the same cleaning a shoulder up with a chisel, take a very thin shaving off...However, it is not important to me to be able to take off exactly 1 thou, I'm ok with 2 thou or even 2.5 thou...it doesn't bother me if it's not exactly 1 thou per a set of micrometers/calipers, which I don't bother to check.

For saws, there are so many factors, the plate thickness, the amount of set, rake, fleam, etc...but it is so flexible that you can use even a panel saw and get it done.

And therein lies the catch...because there is such a wide variety of spec that will work on a handsaw, even that much more proof that this is not rocket science.

Re: Daryl Weir

#30

Re: It certainly is a matter of perspective...

paul womack

>That aerodynamic tower is an interesting chatchka! That would be cool with cross hairs and and a red lazer pointer...I think it's good to go through the motions of doing those things, in the sense that you will typically learn some things about filing in doing so. I probably wouldn't use it over the long term, but I don't imagine you do either.

Or do you use that most of the time?


The thing I like about the rake control pointer is that it doesn't constrain the file in any way; it merely increases the visual feedback.

I find "aiming" a triangular file very difficult, since the cutting faces are ALWAYS obscured by the upper face.

So, yes, I use the gadget (almost) all the time, and especially when altering rake angle, or reworking a badly damaged set of teeth.

If I had access to a lathe and more metal working equipment, I'd probably make a fancy handle with built in pointer.

Sandor

I think I'd want some kind of collet to hold the file itself, possibly via a sacrifical dowel.

BugBear