Re: It certainly is a matter of perspective...
Alan DuBoff
>Paul,
Missed this, wasn't trying to avoid your question, this interface here at WC is not very similar to any other foras I've used, kinda reminds me of Anvilfire in that it is one of a kind...
Anyway, I had quite a few saws under my belt before I took that one apart, but that was not always the case. While not the first saw, one of the first saws I ever sharpened was an 8" crown gent's saw, I think I paid about $20 +shipping for it.
I tried to make a cut in a piece of oak, and saw how bad it was. Then I cut the handle off, made a new one out of maple burl, attached it to the blade, and sharpened it until it cut well. I spend either 3 or 4 times re-sharpening it before I could get it to cut well in soft and hard woods, but the hardwoods are more difficult, IMO.
I didn't ruin the saw, I made it cut better than it was. So I packed it up and sent it to a fellow galoot for Galootaclaus back in 2005.
Truth be told, I had only filed a few times before that, never really got comfortable with it, but spending the time on that one saw helped me out so much, I somehow started to learn how the file acted, how I could eliminate at least some of the screeching which often left kids running down the neighborhood, and that even if you don't do a perfect job, it will most likely be better than when it was dull.
Once I realized that I couldn't take that much metal off with a file, things started improving. Then I started filing more of my saws, and tried some of the little gizmo blocks with angles on them which folks use, and realized that the angle of the rake is only one aspect, sometimes I won't want 8 degrees, or 4 degrees, or 0 degrees...Nowdays I look at the wood I'm using, the teeth, and just decide if it looks ok, or if it actually cuts ok. If not, I file it, and I almost always file my saw before I use it for a project, just like I would my chisels or plane irons. I don't need to sharpen them every time, but it will always give the saw that extra edge. Sure, I could have just decided to send my saw out to someone else to sharpen, but that didn't seem a very wise thing to do, in regards to learning the skill myself.
I hate those little blocks with angle-lines on them which people use, and so many folks recommend them. To me it's an annoyance also, and seems to always pop off my file or turn on me when I'm filing anyway...I have no clue what the infatuation is over those things...
I just use a protractor to mark 90, 82, 75, and 65 degrees on a piece of paper. These are only guides to go by, it's not rocket science. You want a more aggressive rip saw steepen the rake a tad, but you don't need to measure it, just turn the angle of the file up when you file them. Even if all the teeth are not exactly the same angle, it doesn't matter. With those 4 lines, you have what you need.
This is how I use it.
8 degrees is a common rake for rip files saws, it's just a reference though, nothing says you must do it like that. 90 degrees is filing the rip teeth with 0 fleam, and 82 shows 8 degrees off of that which is the rake angle. Those are my two references for rip filing. I change this per wood I'm using, and/or direction of the grain, because sometimes you need to make a decision if you'll use rip or xcut when looking at the grain.
15 degrees is the common rake for xcut, and 25 degrees of fleam is kinda ballpark, and that is the 75 and 65 marks (75 is 15 off the 90 mark, and 65 is 25 off the 90 mark).
It's kinda backwards in regards to how the angles are marked on the paper, so it might not make sense to others, but works for me. I'm adding a pic here, you can see it's very high tech, a piece of paper on the wall with a piece of tape. It is ONLY a reference I use. I only use it to set the file when I'm starting, because I watch the teeth I'm filing and the file at the tooth, rather than watching some dumb block on the end of my file. I want to watch where the file is actually cutting the metal. Once the file is set, you only need to push it straight across the tooth at close to proximity angles, and can concentrate on the actual filing AT the tooth, not at the end of your file, not at the wall, not on the floor.
You seem to imply that I might not have done that if I had never sharpened a saw, and maybe so, but I wouldn't let that stop me from grabbing a beater saw to practice on, because I know now that after only a few times through a set of teeth, most people would scoff at the idea of sending their saws out.
I'll tell you a secret, but don't tell anyone...(shhhh!) Sometimes I file a tooth off. I don't tell the wood, as I figure it doesn't need to know. Sometimes a saw will have set more at one end of the saw, I don't measure it and just use a small stone to it lightly...as an engineer it's easy to pontificate over these small things in woodworking, I see people using machining tools to measure wood with...the very reason I do it by hand is that I don't want it to be accurate to a nat's hair...
More importantly, everyone needs to get over the fear and to feel comfortable with a file, and I was no different. For the OP of this thread, I know how giddy a sharp saw can make one feel, and to me I get that much giddier when I've done it myself, after using it dull. Try filing an old saw, or buy a cheap gent saw to start on. You will most likely feel comfortable enough very soon to sharpen the same saw that you sent out to be sharpened.
Take any saw in your tools, even a Wenzloff, LN, Adria, etc...file it 10 times, start to finish on both sides. If you have made it inferior, then send it out to someone to sharpen for you. Chances are you will have learned to feel much more comfortable with a file, and will feel that much better about your saws. Give it a try. If you feel you have ruined your saw, send it to me, and I'll fix it up and use it myself...*gd&r*
Do you sharpen your own saws or send them out to be sharpened, Paul?
