Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Daryl Weir

Posts

Daryl Weir

#1

Daryl Weir

John Hoffman

>Just got back a carcass saw I sent to Daryl to be fixed. Didn't know if it was the saw or me. It stuck in the first part of the blade near the toe.

Tested it out and it is like a new tool! Absolutely perfect and sometimes it really is the tool.

Great job Daryl and I recommend him to anyone needing a fix.

John H

Re: Daryl Weir

#2

Couldn't hurt to try sharpening yourself, either!

Alan DuBoff

>

Re: Daryl Weir

#4

Re: Who is Daryl Weir?

Marv

>Hi Scott,

Daryl Weir is a friend of mine and is well known in other woodworking forums and has a reputation for his excellent handsaw sharpening skills. He is also very skilled in woodworking as well as metal working. I got acquainted with him on eBay. He often sells reconditioned handsaws, though he doesn't have any up for auction at the moment. Probably waiting until after the Super bowl. His work on handsaws is second to none....well, maybe mine, but I'm sure that's debatable. I sent him this forum address this morning. Maybe he'll come in and say hi.

Marv

Re: Daryl Weir

#5

Re: Who is Daryl Weir?

John Hoffman

>Should have included contact information in case anyone needs a saw fixed.

Daryl Weir [weir@gallatinriver.net]

Regards,

JH

Re: Daryl Weir

#6

Re: Who is Daryl Weir?

Marv

>Hi John,

You were wise to send your expensive saw to a professional filer and not attempt it yourself. If you are inclined to do it yourself, an old beat up saw would be the best to practice on.

I have fixed many a saw for people who thought it was easy and were not properly equipped.

I like the statement I read on another forum awhile back...the guy said he sends his saws out to be sharpened for the same reason he doesn't make his own plywood. A bit of an exaggeration but his point was well made.

Marv

Re: Daryl Weir

#7

OTOH, maybe that's not so wise afterall...

Alan DuBoff

>Marv said:

---------

"You were wise to send your expensive saw to a professional filer and not attempt it yourself. If you are inclined to do it yourself, an old beat up saw would be the best to practice on."

---------

I don't see that advice as being very wise, and more so encourage all people to learn how to sharpen their handsaws just like they would their chisels and hand plane irons.

This is not rocket science, and it's time that people get over the fear of sharpening their own saw, period. I'm not saying pick your best saw to practice on, go buy a cheap saw for $5 if that makes you feel good, they're all around the fleas for that price. Or buy a cheap $20 crown gent saw to practice on, that will serve fine for the purpose of learning how to sharpen. If you're in fear to sharpen your saw, use Japanese saws that are disposable, and buy a new blade when it dulls. Otherwise pony up and bite the bullet, learn how to do one of the basic skills needed for hand tool work, sharpening a hand saw.

It won't take very long to get comfortable with it, you can sharpen your expensive saw before the session is over most likely. You will not remove that much metal, do not fear that you will ruin your saw! And certainly don't listen to anyone telling you that your fear is substantiated.

This is a skill that no craftsman doing hand work should be without, do not be dependent on having a another person do it for you. You will need to resharpen that same saw after you cut some wood, how will you handle that? Will you send it back to the filer after you do a project? Will you just keep using the saw in fear that you can't sharpen it properly and eventually send it back, but use it as a dull tool until then? I will typically file a saw before I use it, just as I will a chisel or plane iron. A sharp saw is a pleasure to use, and a dull saw is a miserable experience for me.

I am certainly no expert on woodworking, but being at someone else's mercy to sharpen your saw because, quite frankly, you're too fearful to learn how to do this simple task yourself is dumbfounded and not the way a craftsman should operate. The teeth don't need to be perfect to cut better, you don't need to have a lot of equipment to sharpen, buy a $5 file and be happy to start sharpening it yourself.

That's my non-professional, honest advice. I might not be a "professional" filer, but the teeth cut the wood I work just fine.

Re: Daryl Weir

#8

Re: Daryl Weir

Daryl Weir

>Hey John,

Thanks for the kudos!

I usually post on another forum but thought I'd poke my head in for a second since Marv e-mailed me. Don't want to get in the middle of an argument whether or not you should sharpen your own saws. I don't know if there is a right or a wrong answer. It's kind of what they say about opinions........well you know.

I'll just leave that up to the individual to decide how they want to spend their time.

Thanks again &

Take care,

Daryl

Re: Daryl Weir

#9

All should be encouraged to sharpen their own saws

Alan DuBoff

>Daryl,

Hi, not an argument, but I think every galoot should be able to sharpen their own saws. Certainly nothing wrong with sending them out to be sharpened to folks as yourself, Cooke's, or Marv.

Horses for courses, but speaking for myself and what I advise others, get a $5 file and learn how to sharpen your own saws. Most worst cases are better than a dull saw, which I consider a potential dangerous tool.

I hope as a handsaw advocate, you would encourage people to learn to sharpen their own saws, but then maybe I'm off base there. Wouldn't you sharpen a saw before you started to work on a project? In the middle if you felt the teeth could use a touch up? I know I do, maybe it's in my head but to me it's just like sharpening my chisels or plane irons, a dull edge tool is dangerous, period.

Re: Daryl Weir

#10

Re: All should be encouraged to sharpen their own

paul womack

>Horses for courses, but speaking for myself and what I advise others, get a $5 file and learn how to sharpen your own saws.

Weeeel, you do need a saw vise (bought or made), a mill file for jointing, and a saw-set, as well as the file...

And the skill does take a little time to acquire. If someone is truly woodwork-project centric, sending your saws out is a sensible option.

BugBear

Re: Daryl Weir

#11

Some perspective

Marv

>Hi Paul,

Just wanted to exchange some thoughts on a subject that I feel we both understand and to reflect on some of what has been posted in this thread.

The difficulty factor regarding sharpening handsaws comes up quite often on these forums. Like anything we build, we do in fact need the proper tools, so I agree with you about needing a good vise and saw set and the right files. And for most of us old farts, we need good lighting and magnification. And we need a good understanding of what makes a saw cut wood and follow a pencil line or scribed line and do it accurately and with ease.

Sharpening a handsaw can not be compared to touching up the edge of a chisel. Far from it. To suggest that fixing a LN dovetail saw that is binding in the kerf is as simple as honing a chisel is pure hogwash.

It's true that anyone can grab a file and file a saw. A monkey could do that. Filing a saw and proberly sharpening a saw is entirely two different things as I'm sure you and anyone knows who sharpens saws for pay or as a hobby.

It is no doubt to a woodworkers advantage to know how to sharpen their own tools, including saws, but, not every woodworker wants to invest in all the tools and time to practice doing it so their saws cut as well as when a professional does it. I will encourage anyone to do it, however, I will not overly simplify the process nor will I intentionally insult someone by making them feel it is too complicated.

If a person who has never sharpened a saw is lead to believe that it is as simple as grabbing a file, they could easily become discouraged when they learn that there is more to it. The first saw I ever filed, that's exactly what I thought and did. It was in horrible shape before I filed it and even worse shape after I filed it. It was then that I started reading and learning what all was involved.

Some people have a natural knack for this kind of thing and some don't. Some people have a natural knack for accounting work, but not everybody and so it is with most anything that involves some study and practice. Accomplished wooodworkers know exactly what I'm talking about here. It's also a matter of how one prefers to spend their time and money. No one should be made to feel less of a person just because they send their saws out to be sharpened.

I'll say it again, John was wise to send his expensive LN saw to a professional such as Daryl Weir rather than grab a file and whack away at it. A saw does not need to be resharpened everytime it is used. A properly sharpened saw will last a long time with proper use before it needs to be resharpened. To infer that it does is not useful to those who might not know better. I'm sure there are a number of beginners who read these forums. It is those people we should keep in mind as we exchange ideas and thoughts and chat back and forth about our knowledge and skills.

Paul, I have read a number of your posts both here and on other forums and that is exactly what you do. Always useful information....thank you.

Marv

Re: Daryl Weir

#12

Re: Some perspective

Brad in Ottawa

>Marv,

Don't deny that it isn't easy but it isn't as hard as a lot of people make it out to be. I also think that saw sharpening is more forgiving than most people think. With so many teeth involved in the cutting action there is some leeway for minor variances.

I'm not advocating people learn to sharpen a saw using a premium DT saw with small teeth. (In fact, I would highly recommend sending those saws out if you are still learning.)

That still leaves a lot of other saws to learn with! We aren't talking about tons of money to learn either. Some files, a vise and maybe scraps of wood to make a jig. Heck, you can even buy an older saw for pretty cheap in my corner of tool purgatory for $10!

Brad

Re: Daryl Weir

#13

Brad, I totally agrain....

Marv

>Hi Brad,

The degree of difficulty is a subjective issue. It's a matter of definition and will vary from person to person as is the case with anything that requires a learning process and practice to elevate the skill level.

Marv

Re: Daryl Weir

#14

I thought you might!

Brad in Ottawa

>

Re: Daryl Weir

#15

It certainly is a matter of perspective...

Alan DuBoff

>And I'm certainly glad I don't have to worry silly that I would destroy a $100 saw with a $5 file...the decisions in life...oh my...the next thing people will be sending their shoes out to be tied for them...

I wonder what people would think knowing I completely dis-assembled one of my Mike Wenzloff saws...have refiled all of them, and continue to do so as I use them.

Fortunate for me, nobody told me I could ruin those saws, and I just filed them like I do any other saw that costs $5 at a flea.

You need a saw vise...grab a couple pieces of wood, toss them in a vise and clamp a saw between them. You can build a nicer one later, or find an old cast iron one for a few bucks...You need a file handle, easily solved with a small chunk of wood, you can even shape it to fit your hand if you are so inclined.

I can't see how the cost of a saw being $100 would/should prevent me from using it and sharpening it as the tool should be, on a regular basis.

To treat this as if one needs to be a cautious, and to substantiate their fear by suggesting it is wise to send your saw out, well...horses for courses. I hope at least some folks will see this thread and be encouraged to try sharpening. Start slow, take some light passes. Get a feel for it. Don't touch the set, don't do anything, except a couple light strokes of the file on every other tooth, then flip it around and do the alternates you skipped the first time. Now, just to give yourself some comfort, cut some wood with the saw so you can see that you didn't destroy it!

I find it odd that anyone would discourage and even imply they could damage or destroy a saw. I wonder how many folks send their saws off to be sharpened and don't even use them? I bet there is more than one anal retentive arm-chair worker that has to have all the fanciest tools, yet never uses them to cut wood at all, just keep them all shiny and sharp hanging on their tool wall. I bet at least some of them send 4 or 5 saws to someone to be sharpened for them, so all of their saws will be sharp, even if they don't use them.

I use my saws for working wood, so I prefer to have them sharp. Relying on someone else to sharpen them is no more acceptable for me than it would be to wear shoes and not know how to tie the laces.

Learn to do this simple task yourself, it is a skill that all woodworkers using handsaws should possess.

Re: Daryl Weir

#18

I like a corn cob for a file handle

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>

Re: Daryl Weir

#19

Xlnt idea, I have butter fingers already...;-)

Alan DuBoff

>

Re: Daryl Weir

#20

Re: It certainly is a matter of perspective...

paul womack

>I wonder what people would think knowing I completely dis-assembled one of my Mike Wenzloff saws...have refiled all of them, and continue to do so as I use them.


How many saws-worth of filing experience did you have when you did this?

BugBear

Re: Daryl Weir

#21

Re: Hi Daryl...

Daryl Weir

>Hey Scott,

Glad to stop in for a little while.

Take care,

Daryl

Re: Daryl Weir

#22

Re: wot no answer?

paul womack

>

Re: Daryl Weir

#23

Re: It certainly is a matter of perspective...

Alan DuBoff

>Paul,

Missed this, wasn't trying to avoid your question, this interface here at WC is not very similar to any other foras I've used, kinda reminds me of Anvilfire in that it is one of a kind...

Anyway, I had quite a few saws under my belt before I took that one apart, but that was not always the case. While not the first saw, one of the first saws I ever sharpened was an 8" crown gent's saw, I think I paid about $20 +shipping for it.

I tried to make a cut in a piece of oak, and saw how bad it was. Then I cut the handle off, made a new one out of maple burl, attached it to the blade, and sharpened it until it cut well. I spend either 3 or 4 times re-sharpening it before I could get it to cut well in soft and hard woods, but the hardwoods are more difficult, IMO.

I didn't ruin the saw, I made it cut better than it was. So I packed it up and sent it to a fellow galoot for Galootaclaus back in 2005.

Truth be told, I had only filed a few times before that, never really got comfortable with it, but spending the time on that one saw helped me out so much, I somehow started to learn how the file acted, how I could eliminate at least some of the screeching which often left kids running down the neighborhood, and that even if you don't do a perfect job, it will most likely be better than when it was dull.

Once I realized that I couldn't take that much metal off with a file, things started improving. Then I started filing more of my saws, and tried some of the little gizmo blocks with angles on them which folks use, and realized that the angle of the rake is only one aspect, sometimes I won't want 8 degrees, or 4 degrees, or 0 degrees...Nowdays I look at the wood I'm using, the teeth, and just decide if it looks ok, or if it actually cuts ok. If not, I file it, and I almost always file my saw before I use it for a project, just like I would my chisels or plane irons. I don't need to sharpen them every time, but it will always give the saw that extra edge. Sure, I could have just decided to send my saw out to someone else to sharpen, but that didn't seem a very wise thing to do, in regards to learning the skill myself.

I hate those little blocks with angle-lines on them which people use, and so many folks recommend them. To me it's an annoyance also, and seems to always pop off my file or turn on me when I'm filing anyway...I have no clue what the infatuation is over those things...

I just use a protractor to mark 90, 82, 75, and 65 degrees on a piece of paper. These are only guides to go by, it's not rocket science. You want a more aggressive rip saw steepen the rake a tad, but you don't need to measure it, just turn the angle of the file up when you file them. Even if all the teeth are not exactly the same angle, it doesn't matter. With those 4 lines, you have what you need.

This is how I use it.

8 degrees is a common rake for rip files saws, it's just a reference though, nothing says you must do it like that. 90 degrees is filing the rip teeth with 0 fleam, and 82 shows 8 degrees off of that which is the rake angle. Those are my two references for rip filing. I change this per wood I'm using, and/or direction of the grain, because sometimes you need to make a decision if you'll use rip or xcut when looking at the grain.

15 degrees is the common rake for xcut, and 25 degrees of fleam is kinda ballpark, and that is the 75 and 65 marks (75 is 15 off the 90 mark, and 65 is 25 off the 90 mark).

It's kinda backwards in regards to how the angles are marked on the paper, so it might not make sense to others, but works for me. I'm adding a pic here, you can see it's very high tech, a piece of paper on the wall with a piece of tape. It is ONLY a reference I use. I only use it to set the file when I'm starting, because I watch the teeth I'm filing and the file at the tooth, rather than watching some dumb block on the end of my file. I want to watch where the file is actually cutting the metal. Once the file is set, you only need to push it straight across the tooth at close to proximity angles, and can concentrate on the actual filing AT the tooth, not at the end of your file, not at the wall, not on the floor.

You seem to imply that I might not have done that if I had never sharpened a saw, and maybe so, but I wouldn't let that stop me from grabbing a beater saw to practice on, because I know now that after only a few times through a set of teeth, most people would scoff at the idea of sending their saws out.

I'll tell you a secret, but don't tell anyone...(shhhh!) Sometimes I file a tooth off. I don't tell the wood, as I figure it doesn't need to know. Sometimes a saw will have set more at one end of the saw, I don't measure it and just use a small stone to it lightly...as an engineer it's easy to pontificate over these small things in woodworking, I see people using machining tools to measure wood with...the very reason I do it by hand is that I don't want it to be accurate to a nat's hair...

More importantly, everyone needs to get over the fear and to feel comfortable with a file, and I was no different. For the OP of this thread, I know how giddy a sharp saw can make one feel, and to me I get that much giddier when I've done it myself, after using it dull. Try filing an old saw, or buy a cheap gent saw to start on. You will most likely feel comfortable enough very soon to sharpen the same saw that you sent out to be sharpened.

Take any saw in your tools, even a Wenzloff, LN, Adria, etc...file it 10 times, start to finish on both sides. If you have made it inferior, then send it out to someone to sharpen for you. Chances are you will have learned to feel much more comfortable with a file, and will feel that much better about your saws. Give it a try. If you feel you have ruined your saw, send it to me, and I'll fix it up and use it myself...*gd&r*

Do you sharpen your own saws or send them out to be sharpened, Paul?


img

Re: Daryl Weir

#24

Re: It certainly is a matter of perspective...

paul womack

>I find rake quite critical - the range from "pure" rip, to "lazy" cross cut is only 15 degress. As such, I find assistanbce in controlling rake helpful. Like you, I don't muich like the block-of-wood idea, so I do this:

rake control

It doesn't control the file, but it help ME control the file.

On fleam, which is less critical, I just use a piece of paper on the bench, with lines at the angle I want.

Good to hear you didn't try your first filing experiments on a top-end saw :-)

BugBear

Re: Daryl Weir

#25

Re: It certainly is a matter of perspective...

Tony Zaffuto

>Alan,

Loved seeing your response. One point you made is that which describes many woodworkers working towards metal precision. I couldn't agree more! I find it humorous on how many guys purchase blade calipers or micrometers to measure thickness of plane shavings and brag about getting one or two thou. sahvings, but don't realize these tools need calibrated to a known standard plus a certain finese to use properly.

In my manufacturing business (powder metal parts manufacturer for primary automotive), we need precision to a tenth or two of a thousandth IN SOME CASES. How many times in woodworking do we come across that needs that extreme? Our forefathers would laugh at some of our antics (and probably some of our obsession with some tools).

I've sharpened a few saws and I don't know if it was a result I was looking for, but they feel better than they did before sharpening! would I try sharpening my Adria or LN yet? Probably not, but I do have a few to experiment on. Anyhow, thanks for posting your interesting perspective as it is one that many of us agree with.

T.Z.