Re: Romantic nonsense...
ThomD
>Stipulating that perfection is not possible, but big wacking cracks in mitre joints or tight mitre joints are... There is the romance that hand work is unique because it is flawed, and there is the romance that accuracy by hand is highly possible. Up until recently the only way to get accuracy was by hand. Machines, like photography, allow you to make multiples, but the underlying accuracy was always built by hand. There isn't a rightness or wrongness to it one way or the other. As long as it isn't an excuse:
It might make me feel better if football was played at a level I could keep up with. Nobody could rush faster than 100 yards in 20 seconds and so forth. And people like me would sit in the announcer's booth and dream up reasons why guys who could break 10 seconds weren't really playing the game. Some people may likewise be spinning their mangled projects. Saying that they are hand made, and necessarily rough, but only because they are crap. What is crap? Unintended stuff. I suppose it also would be random, incomprehensible, intentions.
As Pye described, there is workmanship of risk, and there is certainty. I think it belittles craft to suggest that workmanship of certainly, like planing a straight line with a plane should come out all squiggly. What kind of Beaver on LSD would it take to do that?
So if, as in the original example, the miters gapped, that isn't Michelangelo sculpting the David, it's normally an incompetent, careless, hack leaving a calling card.
I also think this whole contrast between machine and hand-made is somewhat artificial. A power tool can do things faster, it can jig reproducible results. But some machines, like disc grinders, are very open geometry, and have a high degree of skill in use to achieve consistent results. While other devices like hand planes have limited geometry, and can be used for highly repeatable jigged processes. Simple non-mechanical tools like chisels are highly jigged, that's why we need so many of them. The well equipped workshop is full of tools, precisely so that all the determined shapes can be linked together to create a determined whole.