Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Adjusting my expectation of perfection

Posts

Adjusting my expectation of perfection

#1

Adjusting my expectation of perfection

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown, PA

>I was the Designer Craftsman show a few weeks ago in Philly a few weeks ago. This was my first time a what I call a "high end" craft show, and the work there was truly fantastic. Dutch Highboy's and Tiger Maple must have been all the rage this year, though.

As an aspiring professional woodworker, I was interested in just how good the pieces were. Looking at things with the critical eye of a woodworker, I was actually a little surprised at what I saw, but as I thought about it, things started to make sense. My eye could pick out a gap in some mitered molding, some tearout on the face of a door, a drawer that stuck a little. And this was on furniture costing several thousand dollars.

What I thought, was that maybe my own ideas of perfection are simply way too tight, and this is what these craftsmen have figured out. Sure, another woodworker might see minor flaws, but most clients would never notice. And, sometimes the minor flaws are what sets a piece apart. And when I stepped back, I realized that it was the whole piece that was important, and here you could see they were good. The finishing was even, smooth, near perfect. The design and balance of the pieces was great. And all the craftsmen (and women) there were great to talk to.

So, now I've gotten a taste of what to aspire to and maybe an idea to see the forest a bit, instead of focusing on the trees. Plus I should watch out for clients that can and will notice every little detail.

Oh, and I got to meet Adam a last. Nice work on the secretary Adam, and it was good to finally meet you. I gotta get some real mortising chisels to try that technique you showed.

Re: Adjusting my expectation of perfection

#2

Yes

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA, rainin' again

>I think a confluence of factors - the apparent perfection offered by power tools and the increasing levels of income in the U.S. and Europe being my two top candidates - have led us to thinking that wood can accept endless improvement in finish.

I go to the local furniture show at least partly to look at pieces and think about how I'd have made them if I had the time and whether I'd have made some of the same decisions. My wife made the decision not to go with me a few years back partly because I'd spend 15 minutes on each piece, and then go back to some for reconsideration. I always find some things I'd have spent more time on - but then, unlike most of those presenting at the show, I'm not likely ever to need to live on the results of my handwork.

As I have before, I point to David Pye's brilliant distinction between the workmanship of certainty and the workmanship of risk. One of the conclusions that he reaches in his argument is that human beings require texture in the visible world, and that evidence of human workmanship is a major source of that texture. Needless to say, he would not have been fond of the chrome-and-glass school of furniture. NOTE: the preceding statements are from a nearly-60-year-old-guy's memory, and thus subject to a workmanship of risk of their own. But I don't think I'm slaughtering his ideas much.

Re: Adjusting my expectation of perfection

#3

Re: Adjusting my expectation of perfection

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>As an aspiring professional woodworker, I was interested in just how good the pieces were. Looking at things with the critical eye of a woodworker, I was actually a little surprised at what I saw

I had the exact same feeling when I attended the show at the Rosewood Conference two years ago, and their "show and sale" (furniture made by Rosewood alumni and current students) last year.

Especially last year, I couldn't help but notice a number of flaws in some of the pieces, some of them with asking prices in the $3000 vicinity. One such piece had a small drawer, that upon opening I noticed gaps in the dovetails on one side. Long story short, I went out for lunch and when I came back to the show I had the opportunity to see the other side of the drawer. Man oh man, I could have inserted flat toothpicks in the dovetail gaps! I don't know about you, but in my book if I'm to fork out $3k for a small table, I expect that kind of details to be flawless... Maybe customers don't pay attention to the small details and only look at the overall look of the piece?

I guess that over time, as I've become more proficient I've become more and more critical of other's work, and of mine at the same time...

DC

Norman's work was flawless BTW :-)

Re: Adjusting my expectation of perfection

#4

Re: Adjusting my expectation of perfection

Greg Forster

>I have a good friend, who has been building and selling 18thc style furniture for many years. Every once in a while a client, used to our modern plastic world, will call attention to a "flaw". Joe has the perfect response; he, quite enthusiactically, examines the piece, thanks the client for pointing this out and informs the client that he charges $100 extra for these marks of handwork. Oh, yes, and by the way does the client see any other "flaws" so the additional cost can be added to the final bill.

Re: Adjusting my expectation of perfection

#5

Re: Adjusting my expectation of perfection

Tony - Memphis

>I've had similar experiences. I have taken some classes from some of woodworking's "notables" and have noticed similar "markings" on some of their work. One thought I have had is that they aren't as much mistakes as much as they are just true markings of hand made furniture. Some of those things aren't a question of workmanship as much as they are just stuff that happens. It has made me feel a little better about my work to see that "they" are human too. Don't get me wrong, I am still in awe (and very inspired by) of some of the stuff I see folks producing out there. And to watch someone like Rob or Frank or whoever cut a dovetail blindfolded is really something (not really, but you know what I mean).

I am an engineer by day and I used to be in the race car parts biz. I designed camshaft profiles for many of the NASCAR teams. Our tolerances were in the thousandths of inches and we used CNC machines, etc. So, that was my mindset. You set the machine, run the part and it comes out perfect (within a few thou anyway). Well, it took me a while, but I finally learned that ain't the way it works. Especially with the tools I can afford. Now I appreciate my hand tools to really bring home the joinery. Its funny, I still think a lot of folks make the assumption I did before I learned anything about woodworking - that the pros use expensive machine tools and wouldn't waste their time with hand tools! Ha!

I look at the antiques we own (the local antique store antiques, not the expensive stuff) and if you examine them, you'll find all sorts of issues from age and design, yet we still think they are beautiful. It usually takes about six months after I finish something to get over seeing every single mistake or accident. A friend of ours still teases me because the first time he came over and I showed him something I made, I spent most of the time pointing out my errors (true ERRORS, believe me).

Anyway, enough babble. Its all relative and subjective I guess.

Tony

Re: Adjusting my expectation of perfection

#6

I can relate....

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>Not a single piece of furniture has gone out of my shop without at least one flaw and usually a few. Granted, they must be minor or I would not let the piece leave the shop. However, being my own toughest critic I beat myself up about it every time. And when I am doing a gallery show opening I do find myself dreading the thought of patrons scrutinizing every detail, finding a tiny flaw and changing their mind about buying it.

But as far as I can tell, most patrons (not all) seem to overlook or simply not care about small flaws. When a design and overall appearance of a piece pleases them then that's what matters. And in some cases patrons do see flaws and appreciate them as indications of hand crafted work.

None the less...yes I dream of the day I create a flawless "diamond" ;-)

Tom

Re: Adjusting my expectation of perfection

#7

hb

Re: Adjusting my expectation of perfection

HB

>I too was at the designer craftsman show, and I think that what has been said is true to some extent, but I also believe that, to some extent, people are gullible and foolish.

That may sound harsh, but as amazed as I was at some of the craftsmanship, I was also shocked at some of the poor craftsmanship. What springs to mind is some of the tiger maple furniture that was displayed there. I was surprised to see how many tabletops and carcase sides were composed of glued up panels made of boards as little as 4 inches in width. They just ripped the most figured part off each board and slapped it together to make a piece of furniture that was overly figured. The grain matching was not great. Drawers were sloppy in their fit - and I'm not critical because they weren't a piston fit to the case, I'm talking about 1/2 or more of slop covered by lipped edges.

Dovetails, a subject that is second only to "which tablesaw should I get" on woodworking forums - were sloppy. And a lot of them are machine made. How do you make a sloppy machine made dovetail joint with a jig?

I also got to see people like Adam that show off their mistakes, mis-measurements and cutting errors and call it part of the character of the piece - which I believe to be true when the furniture is truly made by traditional methods. Even a marriage of methods where stock prepartation and drudgery tasks are done by machine leaves behind that sort of thing.

I think that in a production environment, where everything is done with patterns and is repetetive work, a lot more sloppy work goes out the door than we belive possible when measured by the tolerances that we set for ourselves.

The difference between us and them is that although our dovetails may be better, they can push a heck of a lot more work out the door, even if we were to let our tolerances slide.

When a piece is a one of a kind, like something that Adam makes, the flaws ARE part of the character. When you're running a production shop and things are sloppy, they're just sloppy and should detract from the value of the finished work. But people are sheeple and because it;s packaged right they believe it's worth the premium price.

I would bet that if you looked at the furniture a production type woodworker kept for themselves, it would be of better than average quality compared to what they send out the door.

HB - who was happy to see that his freehanded mitre cuts were better than at least half of what he saw at this show.

Re: Adjusting my expectation of perfection

#8

hb

caveat

HB

>Not all shops send out sloppy work, but there seems to be a proliferation of people making reproduction furniture with just average skill, but still charging a premium price. Dumb people everywhere are going for that.

Re: Adjusting my expectation of perfection

#9

Re: Adjusting my expectation of perfection

Paul Kierstead

>The flipside is that I have seen a very good number of pieces with impeccable craftsmanship but aesthetics that made my cry, and not in a good way. Often along the lines of "Why, oh why, couldn't' he have made that thinner?" or the like. A lot of it is what I call "Furniture only a woodworker could love."

God is in the details, but if it doesn't look good, no amount of details will rescue it. But if it looks great, maybe we'll let some details pass.

There is impeccable furniture out there that also looks fantastic, but I think, for the most part (but not always), people who totally obsess over the smallest details tend to lose sight of the general feel. Can't see to forest for the trees, as it were. This is no excuse for shoddy work, of course, but if you're going to spend extra time on a project, make sure it is well spent. Now, I just have to remind myself of that more often :)

Re: Adjusting my expectation of perfection

#10

"sheeple"

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA, rainin' again

>Today's vocabulary word for me. I LIKE it.

Re: Adjusting my expectation of perfection

#11

Thoreau on the subject

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>I just read this passage yesterday and thought it could apply to woodworking just as easy as not. Kinda' comical that this subject has come up and I can respond to it with some Thoreau.

Thoreau said: "The workers in stone polish only their chimney ornaments, but their pyramids are roughly done. There is a soberness in a rough aspect, as of unhewn granite, which addresses a depth in us, but a polished surface hits only the ball of the eye".

Now, don't get me wrong, I can appreciate a nice polished wooden surface just as much as the next person, but you know, that isn't required, nor to me, desired in every surface.

Given my druthers tho, I much perfer the look of a hand hewn beam over the looks of a sawn one.

Not related to this particular subject, but still a bit to woodworking is this line from Thoreau: "The forms of beauty fall naturally around the path of him who is in the performance of his proper work; as the curled shavings drop the plane, and borings cluster round the augur."

Re: Adjusting my expectation of perfection

#12

Re: "sheeple"

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>I believe it was Michael Savage that coined this word. Can't say for sure, and can't say when, but I do seem to remember quite a major uproar over it. I like it too Bill, but I'd better leave it at that to avoid an uproar in the House of Ellis. ;~)

T.O.

Re: Adjusting my expectation of perfection

#13

Re: Adjusting my expectation of perfection

Mike Schwing from Maryland

>I, too can relate, but from a different direction. My father and I have built several award winning boats. One of them is also a "user", and as such it has received its share of usage marks, so I'm not so critical about it now.

But when it was freshly done, there was a single blemish in the paint on the deck, and don't ya know, that is the one thing that people would put their finger on. Forget the brightwork, the custom fiberglass, the polished engine and impeccable bilge, that little paint mark got more notice than the rest of the boat. The judges didn't seem to mind, however.

But with my woodworking, I cannot bear to let anything go out the door - for money - that has any visible flaws. I'd rather burn it, and in many cases have done just that, or give it away for free. I don't do this for a living though, or I'd have a different perspective. Especially in the turning world - once you get a reputation for doing good work, you'll be crucified for turning out something that has something wrong with it.

Re: Adjusting my expectation of perfection

#14

Re: Adjusting my expectation of perfection

James Watriss

>"God is in the details, but if it doesn't look good, no amount of details will rescue it."

Boy, howdy.

It's an interesting conversation. The true fact is that the details we see are evidence of the attention to detail. But a dovetail is just a dovetail. It's a fancier way to do something you could use a lock miter or other joinery to do.. namely, join two boards together. It's a joint, not an entire piece, and really, it's not even a design element. That's not to say they shouldn't be executed well, but they're not he be all and end all of design. And the truth about so many details is that if they're well executed, noone will notice them. Like a regular harmony, or the hum of a refrigerator compressor... it's all white noise. But add an off-note, or a rattle into the compressors hum, and all of a sudden... something's wrong, and you'll hear it. If you do the details well, no one will notice them. And that's the goal.

I made a stacking dresser years ago, out of cheap pine from a Borg. Simple 4-board carcases DT'd together, with Dt'd drawers. I think I used tongue and groove for the back, set into rabbets. Each unit was identically shaped, using golden ratio. Individually, they looked great. Stacked up, the whole thing suddenly looked very squat and bulky. Bad proportions are bad proportions. Pretty dovetails won't change that, as much as you might wish they would.

Re: Adjusting my expectation of perfection

#15

Re: Adjusting my expectation of perfection

Peter Hyde

>On the Antique Road Show they took the Keno twins to an up market cabinet/furniture shop to extol the wonders of such beautifully made furniture. The builder proudly showed off his attention to details and there were a set of dovetails that had more gaps than wood. I'm sorry but there is absolutely no excuse for this kind of shabby workmanship at any price. So maybe good fitting joints will not rescue a poorly proportioned piece but at least it has the dignity of being well made! If you want this to be the standard for everyone then it doesn't take very many high priced sales to convince everyone that quality doesn't matter.

Poor joinery should not be tolerated at any price. Poor design is entirely in the eye of the beholder and as such is still of better value than poorly made.

My$.02

Re: Adjusting my expectation of perfection

#16

Re: Adjusting my expectation of perfection

Dick Coers

>Just a lurker on this side of Woodcentral, but I have to comment on this subject. Errors like a gap in a miter, tear out showing on the face, ill fitting drawers, etc......., should never be written off as "the customer will never notice". That could only be the mantra of someone that does not respect themselves as an artisan. We are making something that will last for generations. The small amount of time we spend making the piece pales to the amount of time this will be appreciated and used. I fear the idea of sending out bad work is in part, due to our impatient society. How long do you think it would have taken to make the miter fit? 30 minutes? If I had to spend an extra day to make those details correct, then I should. Ask Ford or GM how the "the customer won't notice" is working for them? Would you mind if the door had a 1/2" gap in the back and a 1/8" gap in the front? How about a few little dents in the steel on the hood? The quality of our work is like a book. It speaks stories about us and what we think of ourselves and our customers. If the artisan doesn't think he can make any money making good work, maybe look at their career choice. I have been a professional woodworker for 19 of the 35 years in the work force, the first 16 as an engineer. Eight were running my own custom woodworking shop, 3 for a woodworking magazine, and now 8 as a modelmaker. I do make mistakes, more I'm afraid as I get older and my eyesight is dulling, but they are corrected before it goes out the door. I hope you all don't see this as a rant, but I feel we should promote our craft with quality. There is plenty of junk in the furniture store from overseas. If hand made furniture has those same problems, why spend 3-10 times the price for us to make it?

Re: Adjusting my expectation of perfection

#17

Re: Adjusting my expectation of perfection

paul womack

>Depends on scale - a small case for a watch, for example, is held in the hand, and needs a high degree of perfection.

As you say, a smilar degree of perfection in a wardrobe is simply not needed.

Admirable if present, but not needed. It depends on your motivation.

BugBear

Re: Adjusting my expectation of perfection

#18

Re: Adjusting my expectation of perfection

Charles

>Sssshhhssshhh, you'll make David Charlesworth completely apoplectic.

Re: Adjusting my expectation of perfection

#19

Re: Adjusting my expectation of perfection

Mike Fitterling

>In the end, anything we make is well-made if it does its job; that is, Do the dovetails, or any other joinery hold together securely? Are the sizes of each part sufficient for the load put upon them? Are the proprotions right for the utility of the object (for instance; Is the height and seat depth correct for comfortable seating in a chair?). Anything more than that is "ornamentation" and subject to individual taste and historical stylistic preferences.

While I think there are some commonalities in design (golden ratio, etc.) that lend themselves to "beauty," what one finds beautiful is also and largely subject to the viewers' preferences. Some like tight fitting joinery, others like rustic surfaces, others like glass smooth finishes, others like the simplicity of oil and wax, and it goes on forever.

Is the "object" the object or the perfection of technique the object? It all depends on the outlook of the observer.

Just rambling and thinking out loud here. An interesting discussion, especially after just having read Pyes Nature and Aesthetics of Design.

Re: Adjusting my expectation of perfection

#20

best advice on this subject

Tom Sontag - St. Louis

>The best advice along these lines I ever received is that people first (and often only) notice two things about a piece: the design and the finish. If you get these two things right, you will be way ahead of the average hobbiest. Craftsmanship is important IMO, but will always be a distant third place to overall design and finish.

Since my craftsmanship seems to be destined to remain average, I find myself focussing more and more on design and finish. And on using awesome pieces of wood.

Re: Adjusting my expectation of perfection

#21

Re: Adjusting down my expectation of perfection

ThomD

>Just because it is in a show doesn't mean it is good. If you look at better antiques, while they sometimes have time saving stuff like split out drawer bottoms. The stuff that shows is more perfect than what you seem to be reporting as new.

Go to a musicalinstrument show and see how many gaping perflings or shody finishes there are, etc...

There are also a lot of people out there coming out of schools with high standards, but some of these folks are a year and 2 pieces past being a beginer. In fact walking through an art school woodworking department you will see tons of abandoned dreck. The process of getting this stuff to a show may look like lacing a corset onto a fat person.

There are also the folks brought up mainly as designers. The days of seven years before you loose your stuff directly on the public are long past.

Always keep in mind that it is often/generally faster to do a perfect job than to do a bad one. The extra contours of bad joints may well represent extra work, if not time and suffering just to get it as "good" as it is.

Ever play a bad hole of golf? Doesn't take less hits than par, it takes a lot more. Plus stuff you don't see on the score card like hunting for lost balls, repairs to turf, endless practice swings, gleeful time spent fishing out balls lost by yourself and others.

Sure some people are happy to leave a trail of incompetance all over their furniture, intentionally or otherwise. That's how it was done (by hacks) in the past. Hand work is inaccurate, while machine work is accurate... after the machine was hand scraped!

Re: Adjusting my expectation of perfection

#22

Heights and Perfection...

Todd Hughes

>......are two things that scare me.

This whole idea of perfection is an outgrowth of thinking like a machine. To strive for perfection in a hand made item is to try to make it look like a machine made item and not have it look like what it is...somthing made by a person by hand. Doesn't make sense to me.

...I think alot of time with stuff like furniture the problem comes in that most pieces you see at shows like this and such are not really made by hand but are made using machines mostly. Any flaws like the sloppy hand cut dovetails are out of place with the rest of the piece. If the entire piece was hand made like an antique was it wouldn't look bad or stand out so much......Todd

Re: Adjusting my expectation of perfection

#23

Re: Adjusting my expectation of perfection

Marv

>Perfection.....what does it mean? According to Webster..."the state of being without a flaw or defect"

Can you think of anything you have ever built that was without a flaw or defect?

No matter how good we might be at our craft we will never achieve perfection. Perfection is a myth.

The most useful revelation I have experienced during my 70 years was to realize that to pursue perfection is a waste of my valuable time. To expect it from others is unrealistic.

To me, excellence should be our goal. That, I know I can achieve. Set the bar high, but not too high. Raise the bar as your skills improve. Maintain a level of quality that you will not compromise.

Critique but don't criticize. The person you are criticizing might not have achieved the skill level that you have. They need encouragement, not criticism.

Most importantly.....employ all your skills while fixing your inevitable screw-ups. Making mistakes is part of the process. After all, making mistakes is how we learn. It's impossible to learn anything from something we already know.

Marv

Re: Adjusting my expectation of perfection

#24

Re: Adjusting my expectation of perfection

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>The customer may not know the difference, but we should. In the past what was important to the customer and what was important to the craftsman was the same thing to purchase and produce a quality product. Now there was junk built in the past most of it has gone to the fire, although we do have examples. What was important is what showed.

�The Money Side�. That is what mattered then and it is or should be what matters now. The money side is that which shows, that which sells the piece. Of course design is important and following fashion trends and design books of the period, most pieces are usually of good proportion and thoughtful design. There are pieces that look like they have eaten another piece of furniture or are about to give birth to another piece of furniture. Some designs are ugly.

We as workers in the trade tend to go to details that the average person does not. We see open miter joints, badly matched moldings, poor choice of wood grain, etc, etc, etc. These details largely go un-noticed today but I think in the past people expected more as the investment and expense of furniture was a major financial consideration. Not the disposable society we live in today.

Most pieces of old furniture look great on the outside and if you examine drawers you may find saw kerfs on the inside backs of the drawer fronts to facilitate half blind dovetails. You will find evidence of riving on the �underside� of chair rungs or other turnings. Scrub marks on the backs, these are the marks left by the originating craftsmen on the parts of the furniture that doesn�t show. This does not mean that they are bad craftsmen; this meant they were smart craftsmen.

It is afterall the furniture not the joinery. Today, Customers see furniture, craftsmen see joinery, in the past both saw the same thing.

Stephen

Re: Adjusting my expectation of perfection

#25

Wonderful and fascinating responses

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown, PA

>There were so many great responses, I just wanted to make sure I thanked everyone. Most of seem to working along the same lines in that we can strive to limit flaws in a piece but they will always be there. That doesn't mean we can get off easy though, we should always work remove as many flaws as we can. Also, the design of the piece is often as important as the construction of the piece. Designing with both the customer and the purpose of the piece mind makes for something long lasting.

What I have realized is that I have to stop thinking "I'm not ready yet". Just because I have not made a Highboy or learned to carve ornamental details is not a bad thing. It's simply one more thing to strive for. Maybe I'll never build a Highboy (personally, I don't really like them anyway). If I can make a piece that the clients likes, fulfills their needs and was constructed well, then I've done my job.