It is true, simple is good...
Alan DuBoff
>But I personally don't like to clamp and do any hammering on some of my woodworking vises, and especially don't like to clamp any type of peening device made out of round metal in any with a wooden jaw, or one that is lined with leather. Wrapping the pin in leather might help some, but I would still use a metal vise.
Peening is horses for courses, and simple certainly is best, which is why I would just peen on the top of a post vise. One of the smithys I frequent occasionally has 2 post vises at the forge I use, one up high for twisting/hot-filing and another down lower for stamping and/or hammering. I have peened on the top of the lower vise with no problem, doesn't even require any securing, go figure. For that matter, an anvil does work for peening also, for *me*. I have a couple post vises at home also, so no problem.
Given the options, I'll spare my woodworking vises with wood/leather jaws on them. I picture an old cabinet maker's bench in your shop that wouldn't matter what you put in the vise, probably couldn't do much damage to a pair of old beat up wooden jaws. I know peening doesn't take much force, I just don't care to do any work on my woodworking vises. Now, if the OP has a machinist vise, or better yet a post vise, that would work dandy and most have v-notches in the aluminum jaws to secure round objects.
Stay warm.