WE MOVED...
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Shellac/Wax Finishing Question

Posts

Shellac/Wax Finishing Question

#1

Shellac/Wax Finishing Question

Dave (Arlington, VA)

>Hi -

I am finishing a small box with a 1# cut of dewaxed garnet shellac (fresh - from flakes) by brush. I am on my 9th coat and will probably put on another one or two before turning to a final wax application. After every third (or so) coat I have been smoothing the shellac with 600 grit sandpaper and 0000 steel wool. I am trying to follow what I understand to be Jeff Jewitt's recommendation from homesteadfinishing.com.

So, here's my question: as I move from my last coat of shellac and before I apply the wax should I smooth the shellac with the sandpaper and/or steel wool, or just apply the wax over the last coat of shellac?

Some may want to encourage me to forgo the wax, however, I expect the inside of the box to get damp from time to time and wanted and additional layer of protection against moisture. In addition (and perhaps more importantly) I would like the final surface to have more of a satin finish than the gloss that is resulting from the shellac.

Thanks!

Dave

Re: Shellac/Wax Finishing Question

#2

Re: Shellac/Wax Finishing Question

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>I wouldn't finish the box interior at all, take a look at old furniture, very seldom if ever finished; however, if you insist, perhaps a light coat or two of shellac.

Pam

Re: Shellac/Wax Finishing Question

#3

Re: Shellac/Wax Finishing Question

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>If you want the final finish to be satin, then you should do that to the shellac and not rely on the wax to dull the sheen.

The wax, which is only a surface treatment will eventually mechanically wear off the shine of the shellac will show through.

So bring the shellac down to where you want they apply wax with wreckless abandon.

Stephen

Re: Shellac/Wax Finishing Question

#4

Re: Shellac/Wax Finishing Question

Dave (Arlington, VA)

>Thanks, Pam. I see now that I should have supplied some additional details though my principle interest was in my original shellac/wax question (and I was trying to avoid too long of a post). This is not technically a box...or rather it is a box with no top...kinda. One of my sons has a loft bed and he complains that after reading in bed at night before turning in, he has no convenient place to put his glasses so that he pick them up and put them back on first thing in the morning. This has lead him to forget to take them to school on occasion (a bad thing!). So I've made him a small plaque-like wall-hanging, the bottom third of which is a small open-ended box into which he can place his glasses and other (very) small objects for overnight storage...and hopefully this means he won't forget his glasses when he goes to school (or so he assures me).

So, my thinking is I want the inside of this box to have at least as much finish as the outside.

I appreciate your feedback.

Dave

Re: Shellac/Wax Finishing Question

#5

Re: Shellac/Wax Finishing Question

Dave (Arlington, VA)

>Thanks, Stephen.

I haven't used shellac before so this is a learning experience for me. I haven't really liked the way the 0000 steel wool has brought down the shine and wouldn't want to leave the piece looking that way. Any other suggestions? This is a very small open-top box...designed simply to hold the eyeglasses or for one of my sons.

Also I have used walnut...which has some really beautiful grain...but is open pored (as you know) and so doesn't look that nice (to my eye) when it has a high gloss. I thought about filling the pores back when that would have been much easier (i.e. before assemblying the box) but decided not for a number of reasons not the least of which is this project has already taken too long.

So, any other suggestions would be welcome on how to - easily - knock down that shine, that is some other method other than the 0000 steel wool?

Dave

Re: Shellac/Wax Finishing Question

#6

Re: Shellac/Wax Finishing Question

Roger Myers

>I apply the wax ising 0000 steel wool, which I find does a nice job of putting the wax on as well as bringing the gloss down, all in the one step. Since you mention the wood is walnut, I'd also suggest you use a dark wax, not natural, since with the unfilled pores of the walnut you may find the natural wax fills the pores with light colors... You can tint the wax yourself or buy wax in various shades...

Roger

Re: Shellac/Wax Finishing Question

#7

Re: Shellac/Wax Finishing Question

Dave (Arlington, VA)

>Thanks, Roger. The tinting suggestion intrigues me. How would you go about doing that? Could I "tint" the wax by adding some of the "dust" from sanding another piece of walnut? Other suggestions?

Dave

Re: Shellac/Wax Finishing Question

#8

Tinted Wax  *LINK*

Greg B�tit, Vergennes VT

>


Woodcraft Supply sells tinted Briwax

Re: Shellac/Wax Finishing Question

#9

Tinted Wax will rub off on clothing

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>

Re: Shellac/Wax Finishing Question

#10

Re: Shellac/Wax Finishing Question

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Sure, I see, we're going for behavior modification here. :) Speaking as someone who has worn glasses since 3rd grade (OK, I was stubborn, paid no attention to those who said don't read by flashlight in bed when you've got the measles), I'd say get him an additional pair and leave one or the other in his school backpack/brief case. If he's far sighted, he has no need to put on glasses first thing. If he's near sighted, he knows he can't see when he gets up.

As to your hanging container, make sure the interior is sanded smooth and shellaced, then apply a little renaissance wax. I wouldn't worry about pours on the interior, you don't see them, the glasses don't care, and probably your son won't feel them.

Pam

Re: Shellac/Wax Finishing Question

#12

Re: Shellac/Wax Finishing Question

Patrick Gibbons, Houston, TX

>I don't understand why you used dewaxed shellac unless it was already on hand. The shellac in its more natural state, with wax that is, supplies more protection than in a dewaxed state. Nine coats seems too much to me. Also, if the finish had been rubbed on then the need for sanding is obviated. It is best to let the shellac cure for a week to a month before applying the wax. The wax is more for the shellac, that is to protect the finish, than to protect the piece. A very thin coat of wax is all that is necessary. Shellac is a shiny finish, period. Oil would have been more appropriate for a satiny finish. But either way, the shellac is the finish, not the wax. It will be what it is and nothing else. Wax will tone it down a bit, but it is a temporary application that will need to be renewed from time to time. Sorry if this post sounds too curt but I hope the information is helpful.

Re: Shellac/Wax Finishing Question

#13

Nine coats of shellac should have filled the pores

Patrick Gibbons, Houston, TX

>Also the use of pumice and rottenstone would invisibly fill the pores and is what is used to sand between the coats if that is what is desired. The grains stay in the pores and the refractive index of the shellac makes them disappear.

Re: Shellac/Wax Finishing Question

#14

to dull the finish

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>rub out last coat with 4/0 wool lubed with wax . And you don't need to wait a month to do it. If you want glass smoothness sand flat and then rub out with wool and wax.

Re: Shellac/Wax Finishing Question

#15

OT contrary response

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I have looked at old furniture and that is why I always finish the inside of drawers and the like. Old wood has a dead luster and it looks dirty and probably is. A thin coat of shellac leaves the interiors bright and clean looking and they feel good if shellaced and lightly sanded.

Re: Shellac/Wax Finishing Question

#16

Re: OT contrary response

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Yeah, but it's lasted a good long time, without smelling up clothes/linens. I think sanding is a good idea, or smooth planing. But I often read woodworkers saying they "finish the interior just like the exterior," this is virtuous. I don't think it is, so I emailed the Keno at Sotheby's and asked whether antique furniture had finished interiors. He said no, none that he recalled.

However, as Dave said, this doesn't apply to his open box.

Pam

Re: Shellac/Wax Finishing Question

#17

Re: Shellac/Wax Finishing Question

ThomD

>There is shellac and wax, and then there is shellac...

There is the English method, or whatever it's origin where the shellac is hardly more than a base coat, and the sheen and protection come from the wax. It's pointless to 600 grit it, and that sounds dodgy anyway, where are all the other cuts. Then there is french polish, which could be waxed, may take multiple coats and doesn't require cutting back with sandpaper, though some people who loose control do (we have all been there).

Anyway, since your inside is really the outside, you might as well do both the same.

Re: Shellac/Wax Finishing Question

#18

Re: to dull the finish

Patrick Gibbons, Houston, TX

>Bill, I have to confess to not waiting either when I've been in a hurry but it is better for the finish if one can wait to let it cure first. But I agree that it is not a deal breaker.