Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Concensus request:

Posts

Re: Concensus request:

#26

To Stuart.....

Marv

>Thanks Stuart,

I'll keep up the "good work" as you have referred to it. Based on some of the input here, I will redirect my focus just a bit regarding which saws I do the wheat carving on. It's probably one of those things that people either love or hate with a few in between with mixed feelings or don't care one way or the other. As I mentioned earlier, it is a bit tedious and certainly time consuming. I don't do it with it in mind that it will make the saw perform better. That would be stupid. It seems to attract more attention with the pictures on eBay. Lots of people are selling saws on any given day of the week. Sometimes it's helpful to do something to make it stand out among all the others as potential bidders scroll through all the saw listings.

Marv

Re: Concensus request:

#27

Re: Concensus request:

Alan DuBoff

>Marv,

Seems to me you've missed the point. I have bought my fair share of saws on ebay, and I have always stayed away from any of the ones that you have carved with wheat patterns. They do look nice, I just don't want saws with modified handles on them, or I'll make/modify them myself. You also sell mostly larger handsaws and I typically buy mostly backsaws. I have seen a couple backsaws you took the knife to, and I've passed on those intentional.

I used to sell vintage guitars, and a modified guitar is very much the same as a modified saw.

You mention that you are sometimes disappointed in the price which a saw is sold for at auction, and that people might not realize how much time you have put into the saw...but the bottom line is that people pay what they think it's worth and I've seen many of your saws go for prices that I would never pay. Even though your work looks superb, it does bring a tear to my eye when I see a modified tool, when it could have been kept original. I also have my own Foley gear, I can stamp teeth and clean saws up myself, which I do. I haven't sold many of them yet, but have traded a few refurb'd ones away to friends.

As you have stated, there are people that prefer the carving and have saws sent to you to do the same, and that is all good. Doesn't mean it's the right thing to do, but I'm sure that folks do prefer that, just like all things in life.

OTOH, getting a saw with wheat carvings is probably not half as bad as getting a saw with a horn knocked off the handle and the split-nuts strip'd as if Helen Keller had tried to tighten/loosen them.

You got a pretty penny for that nice 3D vise with the filing guide, not long ago, hopefully stuff like that makes up for your disappointments.

Regards,

Alan

Re: Concensus request:

#28

Sort of....

Todd Hughes

>reminds me of this Amish woman I know that paints scenes on saws and sometimes bids against me at auctions for them. Tells me she has quite the bussiness with people wanting her work with some buying more then one to display. No figuring with peoples tasts and desires I guess when it comes to Art.

Of course with your saws you can still use them as a user though guess the same could be said after all for a painted saw too. I have bought painted saws befor and stripped the paint off and you could never tell it was ever painted....won't be able to do that with one that had a modified handle through .......Todd

Re: Concensus request:

#29

Re: Sort of....

Jeff S.

>Todd,

Hopefully, you are not equating Marv's work on that saw to Amish painted saws.

Re: Concensus request:

#30

Alan

Marv

>(((((Hi Alan))))))

Marv,

Seems to me you've missed the point. ((((((I thought I got them all, did I miss one?)))))) I have bought my fair share of saws on ebay, and I have always stayed away from any of the ones that you have carved with wheat patterns.(((((((Oh, so yer the one!...*grin*)))))) They do look nice, I just don't want saws with modified handles on them, or I'll make/modify them myself. You also sell mostly larger handsaws and I typically buy mostly backsaws. I have seen a couple backsaws you took the knife to, and I've passed on those intentional. ((((((Like the old saying goes...."different folks for different strokes"....or is it the other way around?))))))

I used to sell vintage guitars, and a modified guitar is very much the same as a modified saw. The operative word here is vintage. ((((I agree. However, I see nothing wrong with making changes, modifications, improvements to "non-vintage" things. The question is, who or want determines vintage when it's on the cusp? I've heard that anything over 20 years old is vintage. Is that always true? I have no problem modifying a saw made in the 1940,s. Most are quite junky, IMO.))))))

You mention that you are sometimes disappointed in the price which a saw is sold for at auction, and that people might not realize how much time you have put into the saw...but the bottom line is that people pay what they think it's worth and I've seen many of your saws go for prices that I would never pay. ((((((((The point I was trying to make was, some saws sell for less while another saw that's the same will sell for much more only because the high rollers aren't looking at the auction.)))))) Even though your work looks superb, it does bring a tear to my eye when I see a modified tool, when it could have been kept original. ((((((Some saws deserve to be modified. Those particular saws were so horribly designed and made, the originator doesn't deserve my respect.))))))) I also have my own Foley gear, I can stamp teeth and clean saws up myself, which I do. I haven't sold many of them yet, but have traded a few refurb'd ones away to friends. (((((((You should try selling on eBay...a whole new learning experience.)))))))

As you have stated, there are people that prefer the carving and have saws sent to you to do the same, and that is all good. Doesn't mean it's the right thing to do, (((((( I respect your opinion))))) but I'm sure that folks do prefer that, just like all things in life. ((((((Yes indeed. All kinds of people with different likes and dislikes. A rough estimate appears to be about, out every 5 people, 3 will like the overall look of the saw, even the wheat carving.))))))

OTOH, getting a saw with wheat carvings is probably not half as bad as getting a saw with a horn knocked off the handle and the split-nuts strip'd as if Helen Keller had tried to tighten/loosen them. ((((((I get alot of good saws with missing or damaged horns. I put new horns on them, mainly the good ones like a Disston #12 for example.))))))

You got a pretty penny for that nice 3D vise with the filing guide, not long ago, hopefully stuff like that makes up for your disappointments. ((((((Yes, it was a good price at $222.50, but did you see the one that "rockwood04" sold last year for just under $1100.00? Actually the one I sold wasn't my vise. It belonged to friend who bought it at an estate sale for less than $10.00. It had never been used. The one that "rockwood04" sold was very much used. With eBay, it's usually the luck of the draw.))))))

((((((Thanks for your welcome response......Marv))))))

Regards,

Alan

Re: Concensus request:

#31

A lot of this might be groupthink among us

wilbur

>Overall, if I am buying a vintage tool for my own use, I'll do what I think needs to be done to it to get it working the way I want it. If I was buying it for the purposes of restoration and selling it later, I'd probably try to keep it as close to original condition as possible. Luckily, I'm not intending to do this, so I don't have to think about it.

However, I also think that a lot of this school of thought is just consensus among hand tool aficionados, and not something that is set in stone for all vintage items. The other group of vintage tools that I have are old woodworking machines (I know, I know), and among the OWWM crowd, there's nothing wrong with taking an old machine, wirebrushing the patina off of the exposed cast iron, stripping the paint, and repainting it any color you want, even if it's a color scheme that's way out there (think purple bandsaw).

Re: Concensus request:

#32

Well now

ron in Kokomo

>The buyer will determine.

I would really question whether you will get paid for your time on the Wheat Carving.

If you are keeping it, it doesn't matter.

Re: Concensus request:

#33

The Concensus is:

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>Your ugly and your mother dresses you funny! Just kiddin Marv...

I guess I sit on the fence here. I like old tools and new ones.

I have old Stanley planes and new LN and LV ones.

There are old tools that are very useful that are not available today, think Stanley No. 113 and No. 20 and plow planes (until recently).

I don't know of anyone that makes eggbeaters anymore.

Sorry, but cost is a factor here, look at the prices for some old planes compared to new ones. I couldn't afford a Stanley 112 or 62 but I can get a LN for a lot less.

Re: Concensus request:

#34

Actually.....No

Todd Hughes

>"Sorry, but cost is a factor here, look at the prices for some old planes compared to new ones. I couldn't afford a Stanley 112.... but I can get a LN for a lot less "

A look on ebays completed auctions will show you that you can get a very nice original Stanley 112 plane for around $175 while I do believe a new LN repop goes for about $200 so it is the LN plane that costs more.......I bought mine near mint older Stanley 112 for $25 -$ 35 if I remember right ....Todd

Re: Concensus request:

#35

It's all relative...

Alan DuBoff

>Marv,

Marv said:

----------

(I agree. However, I see nothing wrong with making changes, modifications, improvements to "non-vintage" things. The question is, who or want determines vintage when it's on the cusp? I've heard that anything over 20 years old is vintage. Is that always true? I have no problem modifying a saw made in the 1940,s. Most are quite junky, IMO.

----------

Oh, I don't have any problem with the saws from the 40s or 50s to be honest, and believe some of them deserve to have the knife taken to them, to make usable. Here is one for example that I took a rasp to, but it was one of those boxy, 40s-50s Disston saws that nobody likes. Now it's a usable tool that the owner (who traded some other vintage tools for the saw, seems to love).

http://softorchestra.com/images/disston_8_right.jpg

In this case I just did the best I could with what I had.

Marv said:

----------

The point I was trying to make was, some saws sell for less while another saw that's the same will sell for much more only because the high rollers aren't looking at the auction

----------

But the folks that buy from you buy because you have a nice auction with nice pics, for a saw they feel will be decent. I'm more of a bottom feeder, looking for saws that can be fixed up, rather than one that has been fixed already. I enjoy that part of the hunt myself. I like to find a 3D vise for $15 because the seller didn't know what it is, or that the seller doesn't take paypal, I have patience for some stuff. I've gotten them for that, 2 of them.;-) People who don't know how to use ebay efficiently will tend to lean towards auctions such as yours where they feel safe, and I on the other hand enjoy the thrill of victory, and the agony of defeat (apologies to Wide World of Sports). I never bid until the auction is closing, when I buy, and I notice that you will more than likely bid on the auctions you watch early, and even bid them up against the other buyers, it's a difference of how both of us use ebay.

The other thing about me is that I don't buy Disston saws, hardly ever. Typically only at local flea markets when I find them, but most all of the Disston backsaws I have will be for sale at some point, with an exception of a few that are very old (i.e., split-nuts), or unusual. Disston dovetail saws (68/69/70/71) are an exception, I think I have 3 No 70s, one has not been used very much. I don't have a 69, that's one of the Disston DT saws I don't have, but that is for metal.

While most people go ga-ga over Disston saws, I ignore them for the most part, and go after English and/or saws I consider to be worth more in the future. Hard to argue that a 200 year old English saw in solid condition wouldn't be worth more in the future. I don't have a lot of them, but have several that are that old or close to it.

Again, I don't have a problem with what you do, if others like and prefer to buy saws from you. Horses for courses as they say, and to be honest, I get more excited about making my own saws these days, if I am going to do that much work. The pic below shows how I can carve up handles and bother nobody but my own self. I like and prefer old tools in many cases, but for saws I will end up with a full set of my own built saws.

I will only take an edge tool to the handle in the case where I consider them to be utterly useless, like the boxy handles from the 40s and 50s. I even left the owner's name stamp'd on the one pictured above, and some of the paint on the handle...;-)

As you have said, and I agree, different strokes for different folks. There is no harm in the work you do that makes you feel good, and certainly no harm in providing working tools to people. For folks that don't like wheat carvings they can just keep looking at other auctions, as I do. And I know that you don't take the knife to all of the saws you sell, I don't want it to sound if so, but when I see a vintage and/or collectible saw you did take a knife to it does bring a virtual tear to my eye, that's all.

Regards,

Alan (I hope I don't offend anyone with the pic, these handles are not vintage;-)

PS - Marv, you have the skills to build new saws and you should, you would be an excellent saw maker, IMO, and the industry needs more people making quality saws.


img

Re: Concensus request:

#36

Please don't mention my "relatives"

Marv

>Alan,

I'm pretty much a bottom feeder also when it comes to buying saws.

As for bidding on eBay, I will often times bid early because a number of my saw friends might want to bid on it also. It's to let them know that I want it and hope they'll back off. Sometimes they don't however. Most of the time I get out bid anyway because I'm so cheap. But if I really want it, I'll sometimes use one of those sniping services to bid for me.

I have to get a saw really cheap or I can't recondition it and come out on it when I sell it. That's why you don't see me bidding very high most of the time. When I do bid high, it's because I want it for myself.

I work mainly with Disston saws only because that's what more people are attracted to. Actually, I like Simonds and some of Atkins saws better, especially Simonds. They made some very nice saws. They had the good sense to get out of the saw making business in 1926 about the time other saw makers such as Disston started downgrading their saws in an effort to reduce the cost of manufacturing, hence, all those junky, clunky handles that we see so many of that were made after 1928.

I took a look at that little saw you reconditioned....nice job....but of course I would have put some wheat on it...*grin* Did you sharpen it?

If I was buying only for myself, I would only buy the really old Disstons that were made from around 1917 and earlier. I like Geo. Bishop saws, and Spear and Jackson and Richardson Bros plus a few more I'm not remembering the name of...oh and lets not forget the famous pather saw. Let me know if you find one of those laying around somewhere.

I don't go so far as to tear up when I see a rare tool defiled but it does bother me alot. I guess I'm just not as emotional about these kind of things.

I hope you don't tear up when you see my next auction this coming Sunday. It will be the wheat carved Richardson Bros. carcass saw. So get out your tissue and throw a bid on it.

In the picture you posted here, I'm especially drawn to your work area. I thought at first that you took a picture of my shop. Need some space to work? Just push a clear spot on the bench and get with it. That's the way I do it too. I've made a few saw handles for both tenon and regular saws. It's fun but I have to be in the mood. I use Forstner drills to drill the radiuses and then saw from one hole to the other, kinda like connecting the dots.

With so many junky old saws around there's enough to keep me busy for a long time. But thanks for the encouragement.

Marv

Re: Concensus request:

#38

Re: Please don't mention my "relatives"

Alan DuBoff

>Marv said:

"It's to let them know that I want it and hope they'll back off. Sometimes they don't however. Most of the time I get out bid anyway because I'm so cheap."

Don't expect me to back off for instance, and expect me to bid in the last 2 seconds. No, I don't use a sniping service, I do "manual sniping".;-) I don't buy much these days. I agree that you usually don't win because you're cheap, but bidding early only drives the price up. If I want something, I probably will not get outbid, but I am surprised on many occasion that I get outbid. I don't need any more saws to be honest, I am more interested in making my own at this point. I do believe that original vintage saws will be worth quite a bit of bucks someday, but they certainly aren't now. They are all not good either, but I know what I like...I probably have a couple dozen of what I will try to keep, and I have quite a few Disstons I will gladly sell on ebay.

Marv said:

"I took a look at that little saw you reconditioned....nice job....but of course I would have put some wheat on it...*grin* Did you sharpen it?"

Kinda dumb question, a saw is only as good as it's cutting ability. Of course I sharpened it, actually twice, I had to change the rake and add just a tad of fleam so that it would cut acceptably in both soft and hard woods. But I did test it for the guy. Those plates are a bit thick on the 40s/50s Disston backsaws, although the steel is very good quality, IMO, and they are very well built. Although most people prefer a thinner plate for joinery work (at least I do;-), these saws make excellent saws for a beginner with no saws, because they are stiff enough (i.e., thick plate) so that they can be used on larger timbers such as a double 8/4 laminate, yet can be used for dovetailing drawers also. For a single pair of good all around general purpose saw (is there such a thing?) a pair of these saws, and one could do most joinery. (rip/xcut, I'm of a faith you need both tooth patterns for most sizes and types of saws)

See the attached pic below, a pair of old blocky handle'd Disston saws from the 40s or 50s. The one in the rear (12") has been rasp'd so that it is at least acceptable, and it will be paired with the front 10" saw. This is for a guy that doesn't have any saws. I would never really want to keep these for myself, yet they will make a very nice pair of saws that can used until better and/or more specific sized saws are obtained by the person. I always want to have at least a dozen, if not more backsaws, for my own personal users, but a quiver would need about 2 dozen...horses for courses like always. *grin*

The reason I don't own any larger panel and other larger hand saws is that I do all of that type of work on power tools. Those larger saws are primarily for dimensioning timber, and I would prefer to spend my time on the joinery, assembly, and details by hand, and this is where I use my hand saws. I am actually separating my work areas and creating a separate hand tool area, and most of my hand saw work will be done there.

Lastly, sorry for the lengthly reply, I do like to talk saws which I haven't done for a while, I haven't used many online fora, and have become disappointed with many of them. They are so predictable...

My best scores have been sellers that do not take paypal and require personal check or m.o.

OTOH, I'm gotten myself into a headache with an old Nichols mill I bought cheap which was damaged in shipping, and I don't have it running yet, still waiting on another motor.

I don't bid on anything Disston, which is why you don't see me in much of your auctions. I can only imagine that, in his day Disston smelled a lot like Bill Gates. Money does smell...lol...

DISCLAIMER: Blocky Handled Disston 40s/50s backsaws to follow, anyone with disparaging thoughts about these, please don't look!!!! Marv, for you I used a $15 Disston 3D vise as a prop for the 10" saw! Yeah, it's a little dirty, but I didn't have to bid against you in the hundreds...;-)


img

Re: Concensus request:

#39

Re: Concensus request:

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>My own personal opinion is that while the wheat carving is nice it is just not my style. I know this because I think your saw in the picture is nice, but I think the picture of the saw Adam Cherubini put in the article on page 27 of February 08 issure of PWW, bottom left, is a Fantastic saw. Outstanding. Stupendous. The saw handle on the right I think is nice also but it appears to me that the horn curves too far back down and perhaps would make it uncomfortable for me to use.

I would guess that most of the people reading this board have more sense than money. There are a lot of people in the world where the opposite is true. I might pay $100 someday for a hand saw but I kind of doubt it, because that is still a chunk of change to me. I can buy a very nice saw for $15 at M-WTCA tool shows file it any way I want to and use it. Back saws cost more but I can occasionally find those at garage sales for less than $10. So right now I have a saw till full of saws and an old crate full of saws none of which cost me more than $20 and the average cost less than $5. I can put a new handle on them if I want and make it exactly the way I want for very little cost and it's fun. I like older saws better than new saws, although Mike's saws are where I would spend my $100 + to buy a new saw if I had some spare pocket change.

If I had the time to pursue saw filing I would concentrate on the filing and not so much on the restoration. I would clean them up and make them work great without putting a lot of time into the handle. The handle has to be comfortable but it does not need to look great to work well.

Re: Concensus request:

#40

Re: Concensus request:

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>It only takes five of those old saws (at the average $20) in your crate that you aren't using to constitute $100.

Pam

Re: Concensus request:

#41

Re: well yes, but...

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>That thought has occured to me. I just find it very difficult to turn down a nice saw at a flea market for $5. So I probably have spent enough money on saws that I could have a nice stable of brand new $150 saws for every need that arises. I don't think that would be quite as much fun. We go through stages I guess. After reading "Workbenches" and seeing (and thinking about) the sparsity of tools actually required I will be paring down my tools. Although some tools, even though I am not using them, are worth more to me than what anyone would be willing to pay for them. I wish there was some way to only have the tools I actually need, and have them all organized. On the other hand, I don't think that would be as much fun either. It is kind of fun to find tools you didn't know you owned.

Re: Concensus request:

#42

I suppose that somebody's got to keep buying. :)

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>

Re: Concensus request:

#43

Looks wonderful!

Alan DuBoff

>Marv,

Looks wonderful, and I have to say once again, your wheat leafs look wonderful. You could make some great handles, you have more talent than most.

You amaze me, as you have the milling experience and know-how to really make some quality saws. I hope we'll see some of your own in the future.

That handle looks wonderful, although a small tear rolls down from my eye in knowing that a vintage saw was modified.:-(

Re: Concensus request:

#44

Re: Concensus request:

ThomD

>I don't like wheat carving, and often those kinds of personalization are particularly jaring to people coming upon stuff furhter down the road. But if you or your clients like it for now, why not!

I'm completely pro user. Anything you do to recondition a saw and get it into use is fine by me. Also if the saw is minty and not used then it really isn't of historic importance in the same way that a military weapon that was never used has less interest than one personally used by Napoleon. So get to it and fulfill their intent, if that messes up the collectors' interest, well, let them bid higher next time.