It's all relative...
Alan DuBoff
>Marv,
Marv said:
----------
(I agree. However, I see nothing wrong with making changes, modifications, improvements to "non-vintage" things. The question is, who or want determines vintage when it's on the cusp? I've heard that anything over 20 years old is vintage. Is that always true? I have no problem modifying a saw made in the 1940,s. Most are quite junky, IMO.
----------
Oh, I don't have any problem with the saws from the 40s or 50s to be honest, and believe some of them deserve to have the knife taken to them, to make usable. Here is one for example that I took a rasp to, but it was one of those boxy, 40s-50s Disston saws that nobody likes. Now it's a usable tool that the owner (who traded some other vintage tools for the saw, seems to love).
http://softorchestra.com/images/disston_8_right.jpg
In this case I just did the best I could with what I had.
Marv said:
----------
The point I was trying to make was, some saws sell for less while another saw that's the same will sell for much more only because the high rollers aren't looking at the auction
----------
But the folks that buy from you buy because you have a nice auction with nice pics, for a saw they feel will be decent. I'm more of a bottom feeder, looking for saws that can be fixed up, rather than one that has been fixed already. I enjoy that part of the hunt myself. I like to find a 3D vise for $15 because the seller didn't know what it is, or that the seller doesn't take paypal, I have patience for some stuff. I've gotten them for that, 2 of them.;-) People who don't know how to use ebay efficiently will tend to lean towards auctions such as yours where they feel safe, and I on the other hand enjoy the thrill of victory, and the agony of defeat (apologies to Wide World of Sports). I never bid until the auction is closing, when I buy, and I notice that you will more than likely bid on the auctions you watch early, and even bid them up against the other buyers, it's a difference of how both of us use ebay.
The other thing about me is that I don't buy Disston saws, hardly ever. Typically only at local flea markets when I find them, but most all of the Disston backsaws I have will be for sale at some point, with an exception of a few that are very old (i.e., split-nuts), or unusual. Disston dovetail saws (68/69/70/71) are an exception, I think I have 3 No 70s, one has not been used very much. I don't have a 69, that's one of the Disston DT saws I don't have, but that is for metal.
While most people go ga-ga over Disston saws, I ignore them for the most part, and go after English and/or saws I consider to be worth more in the future. Hard to argue that a 200 year old English saw in solid condition wouldn't be worth more in the future. I don't have a lot of them, but have several that are that old or close to it.
Again, I don't have a problem with what you do, if others like and prefer to buy saws from you. Horses for courses as they say, and to be honest, I get more excited about making my own saws these days, if I am going to do that much work. The pic below shows how I can carve up handles and bother nobody but my own self. I like and prefer old tools in many cases, but for saws I will end up with a full set of my own built saws.
I will only take an edge tool to the handle in the case where I consider them to be utterly useless, like the boxy handles from the 40s and 50s. I even left the owner's name stamp'd on the one pictured above, and some of the paint on the handle...;-)
As you have said, and I agree, different strokes for different folks. There is no harm in the work you do that makes you feel good, and certainly no harm in providing working tools to people. For folks that don't like wheat carvings they can just keep looking at other auctions, as I do. And I know that you don't take the knife to all of the saws you sell, I don't want it to sound if so, but when I see a vintage and/or collectible saw you did take a knife to it does bring a virtual tear to my eye, that's all.
Regards,
Alan (I hope I don't offend anyone with the pic, these handles are not vintage;-)
PS - Marv, you have the skills to build new saws and you should, you would be an excellent saw maker, IMO, and the industry needs more people making quality saws.
