Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Concensus request:

Posts

Concensus request:

#1

Concensus request:

Marv

>As a hobby I recondition old handsaws, tenon and dovetail saws. I collect some and sell some.

What are your feelings about buying a new, present day tool, versus buying an old tool in it's as-found condition versus buying one that has been reconditioned for the purpose of allowing it to return to useful service? My question has to do with tools to be used not collected. When responding, price should not be a major factor.

With some saws that I recondition that were made after 1928, I will reshape handles for better comfort and usability and with some saws I will add wheat carving to make them more attractive. Most all serious collectors hate these kind of changes, but my main purpose is to recondition them so they are once again useable. How do you feel about changes of these kind?

Below is a picture of a common Disston D-8 made after 1928 when Disston drastically changed the shape of their handles.

TIA

Marv


img

Re: Concensus request:

#2

All of the above

David Miller from Iowa

>Some new tools are fine, but only the premium grade. I buy any functional hand tool if the price is right. with some exceptions, for collector grade stuff, I think is is great to modify old tools to enhance their functionality (I am less excited about removing original finishes on nicely patinated tools - refurbishing rusty tools its fine).

David

Re: Concensus request:

#3

Re: Concensus request:

"RJ" Whelan

>Marv ... with just a few exceptions (tools inherited from my grandfather) I don't collect tools based on their rarity or intrinsic value.

I would much rather buy a tool that has been reconditioned and improved for better utility than have to live with rust, pitting or uncomfortable ergonomics.

As far as I'm concerned, your approach is right on the money for my needs ... rj

Re: Concensus request:

#4

Re: Concensus request:

Todd Hughes

>I would rather buy clean original tools that have not been monkeyed with.

...First by reshaping and carving the handles you are not "reconditioning" them you are modifying them to somthing that meets your needs [real or imagined] and your desires.Not anything really wrong with this esp. if done to common tools that are for you but I think if you plan on selling them to most buyers it doesn't make them all that much more desirable and may of course affect it negativly depending on what you did and what you have.

...I have sold truck loads of "user" tools to users and in my experance they are just as picky , or even more so,as a pure collector as to what the tool looks like and that it is original and not been messed with.A user will buy a no. 5 with 75% of it's original dull jappaning everytime over the same plane with a 100% shiny new spray painted finish if priced the same.

...When ever you modify somthing to suit you it is important to remember not everybody has the same tasts as you do...To me the saw you carved up while I can appreciate the time and effert it took to do just looks kind of strange.If the carving was old I would buy it as a curiosity but if I knew it was new I would pass on it....Sure don't see how it makes the saw any more "usable" either......Todd

Re: Concensus request:

#5

Re: Concensus request:

Jeff S.

>Marv,

The main reason that I buy used saws is that they are significantly less expensive than modern quality saw (ie LN, Adria, Wenzloff, etc). When I purchase a used saw for the purpose of actually using it, I have no qualms about reshaping, refinishing, or re-handling it to suit my functional and aesthetic preferences. I would not even hesitate for a second to taking a longish miter box saw and shortening it to 19� for a large tenon saw. Of course, none of these saws are of interest to collectors, as they would be priced well out of my budget if that were the case.

Generally speaking, I am not a fan of wheat carving on handles as I think they are more beautiful and more comfortable without the carving but your version is much cleaner and more pleasing than anything I have seen come out the former Disston factories. Further, your easing of the corners and the very smooth, satin finish are definite improvements over the original. I can�t tell from the picture, but the saw nuts often benefit aesthetically by removing the machining grooves left by the factory.

And remember, �patina� is a just a nice word for a mixture of decomposing finish, wax, dirt, and sweat. (Ducking) ;-)

Jeff

Re: Concensus request:

#6

You Pick

ron in Kokomo

>They are your saws. They are users. They are NOT part of a dwindling historical resource.

Do what you want with them. This is not a flip response. I know that this will cause some hearts to skip a beat. But if a guy finds a Stanley 4 and he wants to drill a hole in it to hang it up behind his bench. Who has he harmed?.

Obviously this would be different with a rare tool.

But most of us are pretty unlikely to face that problem.

Re: Concensus request:

#7

Re: Concensus request:

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Myself, I'm a rust hunter, so I buy the saws at garage sales, just as you do; and, fortunately, you're a good hour away from me, so we're not fighting over the saw table.

If I had a little more money, I'd be interested in reconditioned saws, saving me the work of learning how and doing the reconditioning. Not sure I'd be willing to pay more for the wheat carving; I agree with others that it doesn't add to user value and that the handles older than the wheat-carving era are so graceful that it's an unnecessary addition, like putting a 3" chrome exhaust tip extension on a Jag XK120.

The thread further down on marking and cutting dovetails wanders off into a discussion of saws - logically enough - and there are several expressions of the opinion that the quality of a saw is largely determined by the skill of the saw filer. Like selecting a barber, you can't tell for sure until you buy, but you can place some reliance on the consensus of other customers; so how you place yourself in the market will largely be determined by how much good feedback you'll have, and perhaps how well you can honestly display that until people refer to you in the same breath with, say, Tom Law or Pete Taran.

If I had a LOT more money, I'd probably be trying to decide among the various high-grade small-maker saws out there. The likelihood of this is right up there with my getting hired as a body double for Brad Pitt, so I don't spend much time thinking about it.

Re: Concensus request:

#8

Jack Guzman from Maine

Pretty saw

Jack Guzman from Maine

>I like that handle. I have seen handsaws in the thousands with 1 or 2 dollar price tags on them destined for the scrap heap. For all the saws out there there aren't enough people who want them.Noone ever picks them up at flea markets unless they're rare and/or collectible.I stopped collecting them after I had over two dozen. Now I just glance them over looking for rarities.I think it's a great service you're performing in renewing and embellishing these unwanted old saws. Unless you're grabbing someone else's saws and altering them you're not hurting anyone. Keep up the good work. Where do you sell them? Anything interesting in stock?---Jack

Re: Concensus request:

#9

Re: All of the above

Marv

>Hi David,

Thank you for your response...

I have sort of experimented with the degree of reconditioning from just cleaning and sharpening the blade and a little steelwooling of the handle to what you see in the picture. I will remove loose flaking original finishes completely while only lightly steelwooling and waxing a handle that still has most of it's finish. It's surprising at times how beautiful the wood can be underneath the original finish.

Marv

Re: Concensus request:

#10

Re: Concensus request:

Marv

>Hi RJ,

Thank you for that,

I have a number of beautiful old saws that I have chosen to basically do nothing or very little to. I have an old Disston #7 with split nuts that still has the sanding marks, all in the same direction. Obvious that the nuts have never been moved or tightened. I can see nothing that I could do to make it better.

On a reconditioned saw, rust is intolerable but a certain amount of pitting to some degree will not effect the function of the saw. Most badly rusted saws will have some pitting and can be sharpened to cut perfectly. It would be a shame to discard an otherwise good working saw due to some pitting. However, some people will not consider a saw that is pitted. The blade needs to be conditioned to the extent that nothing rubs off on the wood.

Marv

Re: Concensus request:

#11

Re: Concensus request:

Wiley Horne

>Hi Marv,

I'm from a different saw religion, so you can take what I say with many grains of salt.

I do like vintage tools, though. Certain kinds of braces, and right now, plough planes. And old moulding planes.

Thinking about the wood on the molding planes and ploughs.....Main thing is, I can't bear it if the plane has just been skinned and redone. On the other hand, some dealers will absolutely not touch the wood on an old plane, especially one with a collectible name, and make a point of selling it to you 'dry'--this makes sense to me. But what do I do, when I get it? They're all users to me--even if I own a Jo. Fuller, it won't be a 3-dot or even an 'in Providence' model. If it were, I'd put it away. But getting down to cases, if the tool is late 18th century, like a usual Jo. Fuller, or Lindenberger, or Gabriel, I sharpen the blade and that's it. Don't touch the wood. If it's a little later, say a 19th century plough, I get out the clear Briwax and 3-ought steel wool and brighten the wood, so the boxwood looks really nice, and the beech has a little life in it and is clean of grunge--but is not skinned and new-looking. If the dealer has already done that, it's fine. The brass I clean with the Briwax and 3-0 wool, and leave it with a low but clean finish; the steel skate will be clean w/dark gray patina on it. If the dealer has overdone the metal parts, it's not a deal-breaker though, as long as the wood isn't skinned.

As far as modifications like carvings etc, the highest value to me is the way it came from the factory. I value what the factory did, over what anyone since has done. From this viewpoint, saws should look old, but clean and patinated. Briwax or equal is fine. The etch should be brought out if it's there. Beyond that, the highest value to me is if it looks 'factory'. If it's a D-8, I'd rather it not have wheat carving, no matter how good a job. But the toothing is different--I'm inconsistent there. As Bill Houghton said, the evenness of rake, set, fleam, and sharpness (Japanese 'metate') is pretty much the ball game, and for me at least, well worth paying for.

I like what Mike W. does with custom toothing--progressive rake, a little fleam on a rip saw, etc. To my way of thinking, that's where you want to be--a premier saw filer, and I understand that's what you are.

All the above is just my own personal preference, and not a value judgment on anyone else. As Ron said, and I agree, it's your saw.....

Wiley

Re: Concensus request:

#12

Rookie opinion . . .

steve mackay

>99 % of my hand saws are brass bolt Disstons. 99 % have been modified in one way or the other to do tasks odd to the work I do. That said, from what I've seen very few old saws left in origanal condition could pay off my mortgage. So why not do what makes you or anyone else happy and get use from them ?

Re: Concensus request:

#13

Re: Concensus request:

Marv

>Hi Todd,

I have many buyers who come back time after time to buy a saw like the one in the picture. I have one buyer who buys not only from me but from others and ships those to me to be reconditioned to resemble like the one in the picture. He wants everything I do for him to be wheat carved. Sometimes he will send me a saw that I consider rare but he wants what he wants, so I do as he asks. He only collects them for display. I have several customers who do this. On the other hand I have people who are like those you have described. All they want is a functional old saw, just sharpen it and make it work.

Lots of people buying saws and other old tools. In my experience, each is an individual with similar but different wants and needs. I like em all.

Thank you for your response,

Marv

Re: Concensus request:

#14

Re: Concensus request:

Marv

>Hi Jeff,

Your response is much appreciated,

Thank you for the compliment on the carving. I'm not impressed with most factory wheat carving. Simonds did the best job. Most Disston saws with carving is quite sloppy in my opinion. I've always felt that if one is going to wheat carve, lets make it at least resemble a stalk of wheat. Most of the wheat carving I've done on late model saws such as the D-8 in the picture was an experiment to see if they would sell better on eBay. Some did and some didn't, but that's just eBay. Ya never know who is going to be looking at your auction at any given time.

As for "patina", I pretty much agree with you when it comes to a saw handle. But if it's truely a rare saw, I tend to leave it alone, but with so many variables, I won't make a flat statement about it.

Marv

Re: Concensus request:

#15

Rather see that than......

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>....painting a gawdy picture on the blade! ;-)

Tom

Re: Concensus request:

#16

PS : That ones good look'n !

steve mackay

>

Re: Concensus request:

#17

Re: You Pick

Marv

>Hello Ron,

Sometimes there's a fine line between a tool that is rare and one that is just short of being rare. I don't consider myself qualified to always know where that line is. For example, I just finished reconditioning a Richardson Bros. 12" carcass saw. It might be a rare saw but it isn't a Disston that more people are attracted to. I have wheat carved the handle. I'm hoping that when I put it on the auction block there will be at least two buyers out there in eBay land who will both want it equally and that the carving will make up for it not being a Disston. Just a theory, but sometimes we do things like that hoping to make the difference.

Thank you for your thoughts and opinions,

Marv

Re: Concensus request:

#18

Re: Concensus request:

Marv

>Hi Bill,

uhhh....1-3/4 hours via HWY 101.

I guess I wheat carve for the same reason Disston and others did it. I try to step it up a notch though. Being retired and doing it as a hobby, I can do that because I'm not trying to meet some kind of production quota. It's quite tedious and time comsuming actually. It rarely pays off with the sale of a saw, however I do get alot of emails during an auction wanting to know how I do it.

As for being mentioned in the same breath with Tom Law and Pete Taran, I'm sure I don't have enough remaining hours to acquire their fame. However, send me a saw that isn't working for you and you will get it back working as good or better than it did when it was new. So far I haven't received any complaints and mostly repeats.

Brad Pitt? That ugly dude? He'll never make anything of himself.

I appreciate your thoughts,

Marv

Re: Concensus request:

#19

Re: Pretty saw

Marv

>Hello Jack,

Thank you for the koodoes.

You'd think that a rare saw belongs to the public and by gawd no one should be messing with it, at least in the opinion of some.

Where do I sell them? I sell on eBay and directly. Selling on eBay works as a marketing tool to some degree. I often get questions about other saws I might have. I usually don't do anything to a saw until I'm ready to sell it. At present I have about 150 saws, all of which will require some repair or upgrade of some kind if only sharpening them. I get all kinds of requests from just a sharpened saw up to a complete reconditioning. Rather than try to explain my pile of saws, let me know what you want or need and I'll get back with you as to how close I can come. We will first discuss your specific needs.

Thank you for your comments and thoughts.

Marv

Re: Concensus request:

#20

Re: Concensus request:

Marv

>Hi Wiley,

You are probably much more of a collector than I am. I do have quite a collection of old eggbeater and breast drills along with some planes, hammers, wrenches, hand grinders, hatchets. I'm with you to a large degree. No way would I buy a Millers Falls #97 breast drill if it has been wire buffed with most of the original paint buffed off.

When selling on eBay, I'm depending on hundreds of people seeing a saw I have up for auction. I'm hoping that someone or several will like what they see. Sometimes I'm very disappointed at the end of the auction due to not getting as much as I think it's worth. Problem is, they don't know how many hours I put into the reconditioning. Most people don't care. However, on the very next auction for basically the same kind of saw, it will sell for way more than I expected or what I think it is worth. So it kind of averages out over the long term.

I too like how Mike does his saws and how he does business. One of his greatest selling points is to custom file a saw to meet your needs. I do that too when I sell direct. But when selling on eBay I will file a saw for general purposes but assuming that the saw will be used for hardwoods. Dovetail and tenon saws are always filed for hardwoods. Hardwoods versus softwoods is mainly about the set.

Thank you for your response.

Marv

Re: Concensus request:

#21

Re: Rookie opinion . . .

Marv

>Hi Steve,

I'm with you on what you say, but I have to say, I sure like some of the saws that I know are rare, Disston and others that are not modified or reconditioned.

Thanks for the compliment.

Marv

Re: Concensus request:

#22

Re: Concensus request:

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Marv,

Well, I don't think you got a concensus. I do agree with all that was said, especially Todd's post.

I have a slightly different approach. I only buy straight back (no skews) saws with nibs. Even if the nibs are missing, I can easily replace them. I always replace the handles. These saws have no collectors value.

I replace the handles with old style handles with fewer bolts and larger holes for my hand. I started with cherry and have continued to use that wood exclusively. I also mark my handles to insure that no one thinks they are old. But my stamp is old style, so it may cause those in the future some consideration and this of course is a concern.

Stephen

Re: Concensus request:

#23

Marv, I say

Stuart Hough

>what you're doing is great! If you get enjoyment from doing it, and make some money at it, then wonderful. Those that don't want it won't buy it, and those that do, will. I understand the line of thought that you should preserve history, but in this case we must remember that these are tools, and as such, were meant to be used. If they were supposed to be put on a shelf and revered, they'd be called art. Keep up the good work! I might even be in a position one day to enjoy using one of your pieces!

Re: Concensus request:

#24

Re: Concensus request:

Marv

>Hey Stephen,

I'm glad to see you so agreeable, today. That is a rarity. Of course I mean that in a nice way.

Expecting or hoping for a consensus was probably just wishful thinking on my part. It is always good to get honest opinions and learn what others think whether negative or positive. It is all helpful to some extent and in some cases to a great extent.

It is interesting that you replace the handle on all of your saws. I think I have seen one of them....I'll include a picture of one that I saw on eBay awhile back....The extra large grip is definitely a good feature. When looking at the picture I do have a question though. What do you use as a stamp so people in the future won't think they are old? *grin*

Thank you for your input,

Marv

Re: Concensus request:

#25

Second try on the picture: 

Marv

>


img