WE MOVED...
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

bench flatness--Cris how do you do it?

Posts

Re: bench flatness--Cris how do you do it?

#26

Re: bench flatness--Cris how do you do it?

Sgian Dubh

>I've never understood the engineer like precision that some woodworkers seem to demand of themselves. My bench is okay; flattish, but not worth getting too excited about.

My plane soles are pretty good too, and there's another tool people agonise over needlessly. As long as they're flat where it matters, or perhaps very slightly convex, they'll work. It's easy enough to bend and twist planes as you use them so how important can perfect sole flatness be?

Thin bits of wood for drawer sides are handled pretty easily. Chuck a few shavings on the bench underneath about the mid-point of the length of wood being planed, whack it up tight between the dogs and plane away on the now convex face. Table tops hand planed after glue-up more often than not get a line of shavings spread along the centre of the bench and cramped down at either edge. Alternatively a line of shavings across the width of the bench and all cramped up tight using the dogs works well. Sometimes a general morass of shavings somewhere under the centre of a glued up panel works.

Stiff boards can be propped up at alternate corners, or in the middle, or at each end as needed so that the face side can be planed flat.

The point is that a lot of work done on a bench is deliberately jacked up in places, or pressed down in sections, or bowed in the length, and generally purposely distorted prior to working it. Worrying about perfect bench flatness isn't something that's going to occupy the mind much in this old hack I'm afraid. If I plane a piece of wood flat, go and have a break for an hour or two, or overnight, there's a very good chance the wood will have moved a bit in that time anyway. At that point it's time to pick up where you left off and carry on, or at least that's what I do. Slainte.

Re: bench flatness--Cris how do you do it?

#27

Re: Jim Kingshott

David Charlesworth

>Richard,

Shimming with shavings or whatever is a cunning and useful plan which works if the packing is exactly right.

I think the need for better than average flatness only becomes apparant when working very thin sections.

Accuracy and lack of wind are most helpful for small door frames, small drawers etc.

Some of the finest work I ever saw was Jim Kingshotts restoration of early wooden cameras.

Kingshott served his apprenticeship in the late 1940s and states clearly

"It is probably unnecessary to stress how important a truly flat benchtop is;"

David Charlesworth

Re: bench flatness--Cris how do you do it?

#28

Re: Jim Kingshott

Sgian Dubh

>David, it's occurred to me since your comments that I perhaps work more accurately than I at first realised. I'm not a hand tool only woodworker and I do most of the grunt work with machines, particularly squaring up wood and much of the joinery. Similarly I never use something like a combination plane for creating grooves, housings, rebates, etc, except to demonstrate the tools and techniques.

Still, a bench and all the hand tools are essential, but I suppose if I've got the wood mostly squared up using power saws and a power planer and thicknesser, then a perfectly flat bench doesn't matter too much. But there are still jobs like hand planing and squaring a limited number of small parts for small drawers and doors that you mentioned that I do.

As I said earlier, my bench is okay, but I know it's not perfect. It also moves around as the seasons change. My planes too are okay, but they too are less than perfect. Yet I find I can use those tools to get the wood good enough to do the job, and I can make drawers, doors, and other small items square and true. Slainte.

Re: bench flatness--Cris how do you do it?

#29

Re: Jim Kingshott

GregB

>David and Richard,

I'm an amatuer and so don't worry about time too much. The only time crunch is a coming birthday or my own suspicions that the work won't stay flat/true forever....

For a project which can be held in the hands, I want as much accuracy as possible. The hands can detect more than the eye. So a gift box gets much more attention to accuracy than a side table. I like drawers to be right just because I like drawers to be right. Nobody's paying me for anything, so I do as I please.

David put me on the path to accuracy, which started to hand tool set-up and sharpness. I couldn't get them to work before; now they do just as I ask of them.

By the way, I'll never forget something Kingshott wrote in A Woodworker's Guide to Joints. As soon as you say, "good enough", you've just admitted it isn't. [just kiddin' around!]

Thanks to you both,

Greg

Re: bench flatness--Cris how do you do it?

#30

Re: Jim Kingshott

paul womack

>I think the need for better than average flatness only becomes apparant when working very thin sections.

Yes; I think this is true for two reasons.

1) Thin stock has no inherent ridigity, and thus conforms to the supporting surface

2) A 1 mm error in a 30 mm stock is no big deal. In 2 mm stock it's a disaster!!

BugBear