After a heated debate on the Chat last night..
Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret
>during which I was called 'pedantic' (which may be true) it was over:
Christopher Schwarz said;
"I find that once the top goes out of flat by .006" or so, then my work tends to spring on the top unacceptably. "
Being that I don't have any tools to measure .006", my benches are fairly flat, marbles don't roll off when dumped in the middle.
Some discussion on winter and summer tolerances, if there are changes depending on shop conditions.
There was talk that the work had to be perfectly flat on a perfectly flat bench in order to be planed perfectly flat. I just don't think that is the case. A rough board from the sawmill, will not lay flat on the bench, then what?
And if your perfectly flat bench top has a speck of sawdust or very small wood chip on top then the whole .006" is meaningless.
We discussed shooting moldings, but the molding plane follows the board, so it helps if the stuff is flat but it is not critical.
I am also of the opinion (my personal opinion) that this kind of advice to beginners can put them off from trying to build a workbench because of those tolerances.
It was a great chat, lots of folks, thanks everyone.
Stephen