Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

bench flatness--Cris how do you do it?

Posts

bench flatness--Cris how do you do it?

#1

bench flatness--Cris how do you do it?

McKay Sleight

>Christopher Schwarz said;

"I find that once the top goes out of flat by .006" or so, then my work tends to spring on the top unacceptably. "

Other than my table saw table, explain how anyone can get a piece of wood that flat? I want to have a flat workbench, but this seems beyond me. Card stock is .004. Cris, are you speaking about the entire top? Front to back? Side to side? (maybe I should just give up and purchase a machinist layout top.)

Re: bench flatness--Cris how do you do it?

#2

Re: bench flatness--Cris how do you do it?

Alan Schwabacher

>There is a chapter in his book, reprinted in the current Pop Woodworking, that describes his process in some detail. I can't speak to the precision, but the basic ideas are to look at it carefully and take off the high spots, use a long plane going various directions, check frequently for local straightness and with winding sticks for lack of twist.

I suspect the .006" is not over the length of the bench, but the size of a workpiece. It's probably the gap under the workpiece.

Flattening your workbench by hand makes sense because any deviation from flat that is smaller than you can produce with a handplane will not matter to your work. And if your skill improves to the point that it does matter, you can reflatten the bench.

Re: bench flatness--Cris how do you do it?

#3

Re: bench flatness--Cris how do you do it?

Paul Kierstead

>I can't speak for Chris, but my split-top workbench is a royal PITA to flatten. And I am lazy. So I just keep a portion of the bench really really flat for planing. One of these days I am gonna make me a planing board to help make it easier.

Re: bench flatness--Cris how do you do it?

#4

Just read the article

McKay

>I just read the article and it is very good. I am not sure that I will ever get to the point that I am that accurate.

Re: bench flatness--Cris how do you do it?

#5

Re: Just read the article

Christopher Schwarz

>Really, the only part of the bench that is really critical is the part that you use -- what is right at the front edge and about 48" long.

Getting that area of the bench that flat requires no special skills. If it did, my bench would not be flat.

Chris

Re: bench flatness--Cris how do you do it?

#6

What is the link

Wayne

>what is the link

Re: bench flatness--Cris how do you do it?

#7

Re: Just read the article

David Charlesworth

>Flatness is important for some operations, like planing thin drawer sides.

My planing DVD demonstrates exactly how to plane a component to plus or minus a few thou. This cannot be done in thin stuff on a bumpy surface.

With a 3 foot straight edge and winding sticks it should be possible to create a very good surface with errors of no more than 4 to 6 thou, overall.

The methods Chris describes are very effective if you are reasonably good with hand planes, and sharpening.

best wishes,

David Charlesworth

Re: bench flatness--Cris how do you do it?

#8

Re: bench flatness--Cris how do you do it?

paul womack

>Whilst high skill and a long plane will get you there quickly, a long straight edge, winding sticks, and a fine set plane (of almost any length) will get you there.

Proceed slowly, measure often, plane off the high spots, repeat.

BugBear

Re: bench flatness--Cris how do you do it?

#9

After a heated debate on the Chat last night..

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>during which I was called 'pedantic' (which may be true) it was over:

Christopher Schwarz said;

"I find that once the top goes out of flat by .006" or so, then my work tends to spring on the top unacceptably. "

Being that I don't have any tools to measure .006", my benches are fairly flat, marbles don't roll off when dumped in the middle.

Some discussion on winter and summer tolerances, if there are changes depending on shop conditions.

There was talk that the work had to be perfectly flat on a perfectly flat bench in order to be planed perfectly flat. I just don't think that is the case. A rough board from the sawmill, will not lay flat on the bench, then what?

And if your perfectly flat bench top has a speck of sawdust or very small wood chip on top then the whole .006" is meaningless.

We discussed shooting moldings, but the molding plane follows the board, so it helps if the stuff is flat but it is not critical.

I am also of the opinion (my personal opinion) that this kind of advice to beginners can put them off from trying to build a workbench because of those tolerances.

It was a great chat, lots of folks, thanks everyone.

Stephen

Re: bench flatness--Cris how do you do it?

#10

Re: After a heated debate on the Chat last night..

paul womack

>There was talk that the work had to be perfectly flat on a perfectly flat bench in order to be planed perfectly flat. I just don't think that is the case. A rough board from the sawmill, will not lay flat on the bench, then what?

If the workpiece is thick enough to be rigid (within your desired tolerances) the workbench doesn't matter.

The following only (therefore) applies to thinner stock.

If the stock is rough, and high accuracy is your goal, you must flatten both side simultaneously (alternately is more practical ;-), otherwise the rough LOWER surface prevent the stock conforming to (anbd hence benefiting from) the flat workbench.

If VERY high accuracy is your goal, yes, shavings and crud become an issue, but only at the last stage of the process.

As usual, one makes a stepwise progress from rough to ready.

BugBear

Re: bench flatness--Cris how do you do it?

#11

AH HA!

Bob Hackett

>So there IS hope for poor slobs such as me!

Here I was jumping back and forth between the need to pull out the old micrometers again and the theory(mostly put forth by folks like Adam and his camp)that acceptable work can be done by folks like grandpa who started with an ax and a froe and ended with a card scraper made from an old saw blade.

Every old bench that I`ve ever seen was flat to within .250 MAYBE,at best.

What I hear most times involving thousands of anything just doesn`t jive with the old equipment I`ve laid eyes on.

MB

Re: bench flatness--Cris how do you do it?

#12

An attempt at clarity

Christopher Schwarz

>Sorry I missed the chat.

Perhaps I need to clarify. If my work springs on the bench then the planes won't make it flat.

Thick stock won't "spring," but it will rock and teeter. So you shim it to stabilize and then plane it.

But I don't work with thick stock exclusively. I like 3/4" for case sides and 1/2" for drawer sides and the like. This stuff springs under a jointer plane or smoothing plane when I have a hollow in my bench of about .006".

I measured it once in response to a reader's question long ago. I don't ever measure it myself. When my work won't get flat, I flatten the bench. And I don't think that it's an unreasonable level of flatness to achieve in the working area of your bench.

In fact, it's easy to achieve without special tools or machinist's measuring devices. Flatten your bench like you would a board or a panel and you are golden.

Hope this helps.

Chris

Re: bench flatness--Cris how do you do it?

#13

a cranky note

ron in Kokomo

>Some incredible hand work has been produced on benches that I suspect were not flat to 4 thousandths ???. Some third world woodworkers make incredible stuff on their laps and a log.

Are benches not made from a material that moves?

Very few of us have the hand skills that will really make a difference as long as our bench is pretty doggone flat.

Yes accuracy is important, and I know that if you can ask " is this close enough" then it isn't.... but there are limits to the need to seek absolute precision when we work with a medium of unpredictable stability.

just my $.02 on a cold Indiana morning

Re: bench flatness--Cris how do you do it?

#14

Dang! And I missed it...

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Not my style normally, but once in a while I like heated debates :-)

DC

Who has no clue as to how flat his POC bench is

Re: bench flatness--Cris how do you do it?

#15

a question

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Am I to understand that you worry if a drawer side is not uniform to 0.006" resulting from a bench not flat to 0.006"?

Re: bench flatness--Cris how do you do it?

#16

I would say a "right on note"!

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I would hope that no novices are reading this exchange or they will surely be dissuaded from continuing the hobby, as Stephen has already proposed.

Someone brought a stunning desk/table to our last meeting. It rocked on the floor. The floor was out of flatness by something more than 0.006, as many are. It may have also rocked perceptibly when set on a granite reference plate too, but we didn't check.

My bench arches in the winter. I know it and just work around the problem. The time I would spend fixing or fretting I could make one more piece of furniture.

Re: bench flatness--Cris how do you do it?

#17

Re: a question

Christopher Schwarz

>I know that people think I'm being fussy here. And it is upsetting because I am not a wood machinist.

I don't work to any number. I work until it fits and looks good.

When your work springs on your bench you take too heavy a cut at the ends of a board and the plane stops cutting in the middle of the board because the middle bends into the hollow. Over and over and over and over. Then you've made a nice wooden banana.

Chris

Re: bench flatness--Cris how do you do it?

#18

Dimensions, Tolerances & Allowances

Marv

>With anything we build, whether we are working with metal or wood, we are usually concerned about dimensions. With any dimension, there will be tolerances, plus or minus on both sides of the dimension. When working with metal, I'm often working to much tighter tolerances than when I'm working with wood. Of course it depends alot on what we are building. There is also a question of "allowances". For example, a drawer would have an allowance to make it smaller than what it slides into but the width of the drawer would be made to a certain dimension plus or minus some amount so it will end up sliding within the allowed space that it slides in and out of. Now we have a tolerance for the width of the drawer and the width of the opening that it slides into. All of the tolerances involved must be such that the drawer will slide and not bind. Does flatness play a part in all of this? Yes, it does. Flatness can cause a a drawer to not fall within the allowed space for which it must fit. What we do to prevent this from being a problem is, we allow more space for the drawer to slide in. With more allowance, we can be less concerned about holding a tight tolerance and we can be less concerned about flatness as well. Whether we want to work to a close tolerance such as .006 or .003 or whatever, is a choice we make. The beginner should understand the meaning of tolerances and allowances and how to relate to them when building anything to a certain dimension. A beginner should be thinking in terms of working with fractions of an inch, not thousands of an inch. As the beginner gets better at working with their tools and techniques they can work with tolerances less than 1/64". When you go below 1/64" you are working with thousands. Most woodworking tools do not measure in thousands.

Alot more could be added to this explanation, but it's already starting to bore even me.

Marv

Re: bench flatness--Cris how do you do it?

#19

Re: a question

MikeW

>I think the thread has developed into a rather silly one--not that the OP wasn't serious nor that it wasn't an excellent question.

For me the issue of bench top flatness isn't something to measure and strive for and I don't see Chris' statements in that vein.

Flattening/flatness of a bench top is simply the result of using a reasonably flat plane in response to flattening the top, whether at the time of building or periodic maintanance.

By "periodic maintanance" I mean that if something I am working on down the road will not lie flat enough on my bench for me to work on *and* I find the top is no longer flat enough to do so without hassle, the result of reflattening it does bring it to whatever tolerance the plane and I am capable of.

In all likelihood, the flatness achieved would be within earshot of what Chris is talking about. Until it changes again. That is, if I can actually use a plane at all.

What I found is that after building a bench and it remaining in a given environment for a length of time, that it remains flat enough after a few flattenings so that I don't need to attack it with a plane again.

Take care, Mike

Re: bench flatness--Cris how do you do it?

#20

Re: a question

paul womack

>When your work springs on your bench you take too heavy a cut at the ends of a board and the plane stops cutting in the middle of the board because the middle bends into the hollow. Over and over and over and over. Then you've made a nice wooden banana.

I think this addresses an important point. One of the measures of a benchtop being "not flat enough" is when the error in the bench is greater than the error in my plane sole (normally not much) PLUS the blade projection.

If the curve in the bench *is* greater than this, the plane stops cutting, which is a real, "practical" problem.

BugBear

Re: bench flatness--Cris how do you do it?

#21

Judgment

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I think what is required here is judgment. This kind of thing is easier to learn when someone with experience is looking over your shoulder.

When is the bench not flat enough? When it makes it hard to plane a flat board. The same for the plane sole. When is the board not flat enough? Only when the sloppiness interferes with joinery or fitting. The end result is what dictates the necessary tolerances, which need not be quantified.

Yes, it is helpful to have these surfaces reasonably flat. But an obsession with "perfectly" flat stones or benches or plane soles or chisel backs or prepared stock can be an impediment to a worker, especially a beginner.

Re: bench flatness--Cris how do you do it?

#23

Controversy? or Facts

David Charlesworth

>Tolerances matter. Just different amounts to different trades.

The lack of old flat benches is purely a reflection of the scarcity of fine cabinetmakers, and probable abuse after the original craftsman died.

Chris and BB are correct as usual, if you want to plane thin stuff "true" you need a flat surface, and it requires considerable skill and attention.

Similarly a hollow plane sole (length) will not plane a straight edge with a fine shaving.

It mystifies me why people continually argue about these simple and self evident facts? Though I totally understand that not all makers choose to work to the highest standards, and a very small percentage of work demands them.

best wishes,

David

Re: bench flatness--Cris how do you do it?

#24

Re: Controversy? or Facts

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Almost thirty years ago I moved into my present neighborhood and my landlord asked a woodworker friend about me. He reported that the guy said "Warren works wood like a machinist works steel". I'm not sure if that was entirely complimentary.

Sometimes it seems that a fellow gets his first plane or builds his first bench and people are right away pushing these high standards on him when he doesn't have the skill to accomplish them or to take advantage of them. Other times it seems people have little feel for when more precision is helpful and when it is not.

Frankly, great precision is not the only thing that makes a great cabinetmaker. Things like style and warmth, design and construction, color and finish, and efficient execution are really more important.

Re: bench flatness--Cris how do you do it?

#25

Re: Controversy? or Facts

David Charlesworth

>Warren,

Totally agree, and I have no wish to discourage anyone.

Design, colour, function, beauty, ergonomics and satisfaction are the goal, and any creative endeavour has tremendous rewards, but facts are facts, and I can prove them in any workshop in the world in ten minutes.

Very best wishes,

David