Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Thanks Chris S. Now I have to build another bench

Posts

Re: Thanks Chris S. Now I have to build another bench

#26

No Attribution Required

Jeff S.

>"So Chris should be forgiven and even rewarded for bringing a good idea forward."

Oh my...I certainly did not mean to say that Chris needed to give some sort of attribution.

I would also agree with you (and Bugbear), that Ian Kirby probably did not invent the idea. I think that he is probably responsible for popularizing it from articles published in those early years in FWW, his various demonstrations, teaching engagements, etc. I expect that there are untold woodworkers from that era who adopted that technique, who would find it kind of humorous to see it show up as something novel, but who would also be joyous at seeing it still admired and used.

Now...I am still waiting to see someone revive Don McKinley's innovative workbench. :-)

Jeff

Re: Thanks Chris S. Now I have to build another bench

#27

Some really good ideas.

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown, PA

>I like the modified front apron to allow clamping for edge planing but still allowing clamping room for the top. I do like the wagon vise that Chris put in, however I don't think that changes the overall design much at all. I think the leg vise would still work OK as well.

A thought on the removable tool wells - could you make them with a thick enough bottom that you could turn them over and have a solid surface bench. Or, just make extra blocks to drop in if you need a solid surface - say if you have to clamp right over it.

I think I'll have to look at these plans more closely (you know, when I'm not at the day job). And then go spend some time with Sketchup.

I know it goes against one of the rules, but I'd still like to have as much storage under the bench as possible. Working in a 1 car garage forces you to use every inch you can find.

Thanks for sharing Bob!

Re: Thanks Chris S. Now I have to build another bench

#28

New things under the sun

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Ya know, at work we used to try over coffee to figure out who first had a particular idea, like horizontal slow-speed centrifuges for thickening sludge, or whatever. And you could never get to the bottom of it--even on fairly recent ideas. Maybe there's nothing new under the sun, as Bugbear sometimes says (even the saying is recycled).

It's not that there's nothing new under the sun, but that we all build on the shoulders of those who go before; so it is hard, perhaps impossible, to find a source of an entire idea. However, usually the latest bit is new and/or original. Take a look at the latest Nova two parter on cold, for example, and the Bose/Einstein condensation. There was nothing there that was completely original, including the notion that such a condensation can even be allowed to exist; but some scientists got close enough to absolute zero and devised a way to allow them to be photographed. That was new.

Pam

Re: Thanks Chris S. Now I have to build another bench

#29

hb

Re: When the boss says perhaps . . .

HB

>Have you given any thought to the longevity of the removable tool trays considering that you'll have to knock down their depth once in a while as you flatten the benchtop?

HB

Re: Thanks Chris S. Now I have to build another bench

#30

Re: Bob Lang has some ideas... *LINK*

Alan DuBoff

>Bob Lang said:

--------------

I've also thought about an Emmert or a Tucker as I tend to work on some oddball things.

--------------

Yes, I contemplated over that also, as I really did like the Holtzapffel design, yet it was missing the pattern maker's vise that I wanted and had been planning in my previous bench. Not a big deal, I found a way to incorporate it, albeit possibly a tad different than others would find suitable for themselves.

I do not know how this will work out yet, but I feel confident that even though I didn't pop for the Tucker, I will manage without the quick release on the end. I would really prefer the Tucker, just hard to justify when I have $400 worth of vises as-is ($200 for the twin-screw and $200 for the Emmert clone).

I don't have the twin-screw mounted yet, but got the Emmert clone mounted last night, see pics at the link below. I showed this to Chris, and in fact he's seen the progress on this for the past couple months I've been putting it together. I think the non-QR got him thinking...(I'm not sure it will be a problem though). I think having the vise on the end makes sense. Maloof's bench for instance has the pattern maker's vise on the end in the same position. Seeing pics of him working, he is often standing in front or off slightly to the corner, working on chair arms and/or legs. Using it for a tail vise with bench dogs will be interesting, but the vise screw is very smooth for the most part, and I don't anticipate any problems, I shall see...I'm going to build the chop for the twin-screw this weekend, hopefully.

Regards,

Alan


img

Holtzapffel Style Bench