Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Thanks Chris S. Now I have to build another bench

Posts

Thanks Chris S. Now I have to build another bench

#1

Thanks Chris S. Now I have to build another bench

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown, PA

>I recieved your excellent book over the weekend and started reading it. Very well done. The extra CD with the drawings on it is a real nice addition too. Now I'm gonna have to build another bench, though. I like the Nicholson, but the loss of surface clamping is a bit of a problem as I'm a hand/power tool guy. I'm thinking of working over designs (after I read your whole chapter) and looking for ways to handle that detriment (t-track in the top, open space for f style clamps, telekinesis, something).

I'm glad to see a presentation of what I call "real" benches. Those made from construction lumber, designed to take a beating, get dinged up, stained, glued, gouged, routed, cut, etc. I certainly like some of the show benches out there, but I'd be afraid to work on them.

Oh, I also watched you video on card scrapers. Maybe I can finally get mine to work well. That was well done too.

Thanks for the good stuff Chris!

Re: Thanks Chris S. Now I have to build another bench

#2

Bob Lang has some ideas...

Christopher Schwarz

>Stephen,

Senior Editor Bob Lang is in the final design phase of his bench. It is an interesting Roubo/Nicholson design that does not stop you from clamping to the top. And it has a tool well that doesn't entirely get my goat.

Perhaps he'll share a sketch with us....

Chris

Re: Thanks Chris S. Now I have to build another bench

#3

When the boss says perhaps . . .

Bob Lang

>I tend to say why not, especially this time of year. Here's my bench so far, I'm still waffling on a few details, mostly the vises. The tool trays down the center will be removable so I can dump the Gerbil bedding. They can also go in the same spots upside down.

Bob Lang


img

Re: Thanks Chris S. Now I have to build another bench

#4

another point of view

Bob Lang

>Here's the view from the end.


img

Re: Thanks Chris S. Now I have to build another bench

#5

Re: Bob Lang has some ideas...

Kevin Adams

>Hey Chris--

Been meaning to let you know how much I have enjoyed the new book. I got the autograph (I presume it is really yours), but unfortunately didn't rate a smiley face. Maybe for the updated version or next book...

Anyway, I know you have always loved the Roubo-style, but having used the Holtzapffel for a while now, have you changed your mind? I guess it really comes down to the twin screw vs. leg vice. As an all-around bench for handwork (including making chairs), what's your opinion on vice set-up?

Thanks and hope to run into you at some point in '08.

Kevin Adams

Re: Thanks Chris S. Now I have to build another bench

#6

Re: Bob Lang has some ideas...

Michael Rogen

>Bob,

Nice bench. What are the dimensions of it and what about the vises has you waffling?

Thanks,

Michael

Re: Thanks Chris S. Now I have to build another bench

#7

WOW! What a concept!

Roy Anderson

>I love it. I like the reversible tool tray in the middle. Be sure and let us see the finished results. In fact, I might want to come over and see it in person, if you're building it there at the PWW workshop.

Re: Thanks Chris S. Now I have to build another bench

#8

Re: When the boss says perhaps . . .

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Don't know the size of your bench, but at Homestead Heritage they use very wide benches like yours, with the tool tray down the middle. This makes it very handy for two people to use a given bench. The tool tray is permanent, but they have inserts that fill in the trays when needed.

Pam

Re: Thanks Chris S. Now I have to build another bench

#9

Jack Guzman from Maine

clampers bench

Jack Guzman from Maine

>That's got to be the most accessible to clamps I've ever seen in a bench. Nice design. Too bad I already have one.I can't wait to see it in color in Pop Woodworking.It is going to be featured isn't it?---Jack

Re: Thanks Chris S. Now I have to build another bench

#10

Re: neat

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>A nice design. At first glance it appears that the dog holes are going to be in a little far from the front edge of the bench. I think perhaps the wagon vise on the right would be a better option, but you have obviously put some thought into the bench. The other thought is that a twin screw vice on the left would provide better clamping for working on the ends of boards. Most boards that I work on would fit between screws, but then I like my shoulder vice. But I will be building a bench this summer as well (I think). A full blown euro style because after using a shoulder vise I wouldn't do without. I have considered the tool trays down the middle and think it is a good option.

Re: Thanks Chris S. Now I have to build another bench

#11

Re: Bob Lang has some ideas...

Bob Lang

>As drawn, each of the two top sections is 12" wide, so they can be removed and run over our 12" jointer and through a benchtop planer (not that I'd really do that). It's 84" long, and I'm not sure about the height at this point. I like the height of Chris's benches, but he's a lot taller than me. His arms are also ridiculously long, so I think we end up at about the same comfortable working height. I'll likely go with 34" from the top to the floor and keep the saw handy for trimming the legs if I have to.

I like quick-release vises. I don't have the patience for a lot of handle spinning, but every time I read about (or see) the twin screw vise I'm impressed with it. I'm also keen on a wagon vise in the end of the bench, but somebody tries to talk me out of it every time I bring it up. I've also thought about an Emmert or a Tucker as I tend to work on some oddball things. Unlike Chris, I don't like my bench against the wall, so I could put a vise on each side and each end, but that, I think would be a bit much. One of the great things about Chris is the way he can get you thinking to find an answer that suits you, but might not be ideal for him.

This bench will appear in Popular Woodworking sometime this summer, if I can find a way to cut through the chains holding me to my desk and get out to the shop.

Bob Lang

Re: Thanks Chris S. Now I have to build another bench

#12

Very similar to the Charlesworth Bench.

GregB

>

Re: Thanks Chris S. Now I have to build another bench

#13

Re: Bob Lang has some ideas...

paul womack

>Some re-spacing of the dog holes for the tail vice would make (two of) the dog holes re-usable for the face vise...

BugBear

Re: Thanks Chris S. Now I have to build another bench

#14

Removable tool trays rock!

David Charlesworth

>Interesting design, so glad someone else is trying the removable tool tray. This does indeed make for almost infinite clamping opportunities. I can not imagine choosing to work on a bench that did not have this feature, which was conceived with my first student in about 1977/8.

I feel that a waggon vise has many good things going for it. And have never understood the logic of moving the face vice away from the left hand end.

Another suggestion is that it would be nice to have some planing stops/dogs which were further away from the vice, and this option would work well with a waggon vise, as well as getting the clamping and planing function closer to the front edge.

Anyway, all this bench building and research is thoroughly admirable, well done chaps.

David Charlesworth

Re: Thanks Chris S. Now I have to build another bench

#15

agree

Tom Sontag - St. Louis

>Bob's design is very thoughtful and would be my prime starting point if I needed a new bench. And I agree with Moses that the doghole distance from the front might be my first change. Face planing a 2" wide piece might require just a little too much leaning in for my 5'10" frame. But that sure is a working man's bench.

Re: Thanks Chris S. Now I have to build another bench

#16

Purpose of Planing Stop?

Jeff S.

>If you have a tailvise and dogs, I am wondering if you need the planing stop? Of course, it can' hurt but it is rare to find both on the same bench. Folks either gravitate to one approach or the other.

Re: Thanks Chris S. Now I have to build another bench

#17

Need the stop for thin stuff, as a minimum.

Wiley Horne

>

Re: Thanks Chris S. Now I have to build another bench

#18

Not actually needed

Jeff S.

>With traditional Continental benches, it is common practice to place thin pieces at either dog so as allow planing of thin stock.

Re: Thanks Chris S. Now I have to build another bench

#19

That's interesting

Wiley Horne

>and I wasn't aware of it. Can you describe a bit more what this continental stop looks like. I find I do like to have a stop as wide as the thin piece I'm planing.

Wiley

Re: Thanks Chris S. Now I have to build another bench

#20

Re: That's interesting

Jeff S.

>Wiley,

I think I must have mis-communicated what I was trying to describe.

When I say "Continental" bench I am referring to one ala Tage Frid or Frank Klausz.

In this style bench, there are no planing stops per se, at least not like on a Nicholson or Roubo bench.

For planing thin stock on a Continental bench, one places thin pieces of wood between the bench dogs and the workpiece, clamping them with the tailvise as one does the holding of any workpiece. This gives adequate clearance for the motion of the plane, so that there is never any danger of running into the bench dogs.

Jeff

Re: Thanks Chris S. Now I have to build another bench

#21

Re: agree

Bob Lang

>The picture is still a "work in progress" so the holes will be moving after I decide on vises-thankfully that's easy to do in SketchUp. There is also an image on the Popwood blog where I've moved the vise on the end closer too the edges, and moved the holes accordingly.

Bob Lang

Re: Thanks Chris S. Now I have to build another bench

#22

Re: That's interesting *LINK*

Bob Lang

>Chris has a cool stop that's just a thin piece of wood with a cleat. The cleat is clamped in the vise, and the other end is restrained by a dog. Link below shows it.

The stop in the drawing is lifted from the Compleat Woodworker. I like the gizmosity of it. I want to build it to see if it really is a workable idea with the cam for adjusting the height. My guess at this point is that it will be more effort than it is worth.

I'll also likely make a stop similar to the one Chris has.

Bob Lang


thin stop on "Woodworking" blog

Re: Thanks Chris S. Now I have to build another bench

#23

Re: Removable tool trays rock!

Bob Lang

>Thanks for the kind words David, and forgive me for not giving you credit for this idea. As I mentioned above, vises, holes etc. are still undecided and I'm open to any and all suggestions.

Bob Lang

Re: Thanks Chris S. Now I have to build another bench

#24

Ian Kirby

Jeff S.

>"Chris has a cool stop that's just a thin piece of wood with a cleat. The cleat is clamped in the vise, and the other end is restrained by a dog."

Ah...it is good to see Ian Kirby's ideas being recycled.

Re: Thanks Chris S. Now I have to build another bench

#25

Re: Ian Kirby--LOL

Wiley Horne

>Jeff,

Ya know, at work we used to try over coffee to figure out who first had a particular idea, like horizontal slow-speed centrifuges for thickening sludge, or whatever. And you could never get to the bottom of it--even on fairly recent ideas. Maybe there's nothing new under the sun, as Bugbear sometimes says (even the saying is recycled).

So Chris should be forgiven and even rewarded for bringing a good idea forward. That said, I would propose that Ian Kirby is one of the most quoted craftsmen in the world--with and without attribution. The guy is a genious of the small detail that makes everything come together.

Also, thanks for the explanation about just giving thin stock a boost--now I get it. For myself, I just reach down and pick up the first likely offcut that I see on the floor near the bench, and clamp that in the end vise at the right height, and that's my stop.

Except if it's a strip of veneer that actually needs to be thicknessed, and then the thing that works is a recycled idea from Harry Strasil--a thicknesser that uses your own jointer plane.

Wiley