We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
Re: DT's - Cut to line, on line, next to... *LINK*
Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX
>I'm with you, Richard, mark the cut where you want it and cut to that line, no fiddling. I'd like to note that I follow Jeff Gorman's advice on using the marking knife bevel towards the wood; whereas it appears that your knife would make that almost impossible.
You could take the same saw and have two different saw filers sharpen it and you could easily end up with totally different cutting results. Not every saw coming from a single saw maker will cut the same, even when it sports the same model number.
The advantage of buying a saw from Mike is, he will question you as to what you want a particular saw to do. He then will basically custom file it for you. At least that is how I understand him to do business. You would have to confirm that directly with him though.
My guess is, you could have sent your LN saw to Mike, tell him what you needed it to do and he would have made it do exactly that. A saw of that kind is merely a piece of spring steel with teeth filed in it. It's all about the teeth. Number of teeth per inch, rake and fleam angles and set. And of course consistancy of all those aspects.
Sawing hardwoods versus softwoods is also an important consideration when determining how to file a saw. Woodworkers who extensively use regular handsaws for example might have a dozen different saws. Each one for a particular purpose.
When we pay alot of money for a saw we expect it to do alot of work for us. Unfortunetly though, no one saw is capable of performing all tasks equally. An LN saw is one of the more expensive saws available from a saw maker of today. For the money, you'd at least expect it to follow a scribed line and for sure not get hot. Even a cheap saw can be made to cut properly in the hands of an experienced saw filer. It's all about the teeth.....
>Link to a photograph of a Roman dovetailed box from the 2nd/3rd Century AD ('Limesmuseaum' is a typo in the original text, should read 'Limesmuseum; 'eels' is a mistake by the automatic translator, should read 'Aalen', i.e. a town in Southern Germany, formerly a large Roman military installation).
>No argument over what you said Marv, but paying premium $$$ for a saw that doesn't perform well is disappointing to say the least...
I did try once an inexpensive gent's saw that was sharpened by Tom Law, and it was impressive. In the world of hand-made Japanese saws I've read that any saw will gain by sending it first to Mark Grable. Except for Yataiki's...
>Regardless of which way round the knife, awl or pencil is held, it should be clear from Jeff Gormans excellent photos, in the link in Pam's post above, that (knife) lines have width.
The whole width of line will be outside the waste of the socket or dovetail. So we must saw adjacent to the line(or up against the waste side) for a snug fit.
Splitting this line will result in a sloppy fit unless some magical undercutting of the pin or dovetail was contrived at transfer. There are offset techniques designed to solve this dilemma, but they are mighty cumbersome.
Unless you plane a great deal off the exterior, I believe that we do rely on waterbased glue to reinflate the compressed fibres on the non waste side of the line in through and single lap dovetailing.
Jeff's use of the bevel of his knife against the work, may not work for very fine pins as there may not be enough space to lean the knife over.
I am currently playing with a fine toothed dovetail saw from Joel, Tools for Woodworking, which is very nice indeed for small work ~;-)#
"I did try once an inexpensive gent's saw that was sharpened by Tom Law, and it was impressive."
Thats a good example of what I was saying about when a cheap saw gets in the hands of someone with the ability to properly file a saw. Tom Law of course was/is one of those people. There's good reason for his name to pop up on all the popular woodworking forums.
I recently acquired a no-name gents saw with teeth you'd think was used to saw a rock. I kinda felt sorry for it, thinking what it had been through and decided to make it a challenge. After removing the teeth, what was left of them and starting with a blank edge I filed in all new rip teeth, gave them a little set, and now it's one of my favorite saws I use for small repairs on saw handles.
I like to look for beat up and neglected old tenon and dovetail saws on eBay, try to be the only bidder and then recondition them to perform as good or better than when they were new.
I'm presently working on a very old 12" Richardson Bros. tenon saw that had a huge S curve in the blade. The only way to fix this kind of problem is to remove the spine. Once the spine is removed, the blade pops back to straight as long as there aren't any kinks. Kinks must be hammered out.
Anyway, the point is, even an old rusted, bent, toothless saw can be made whole again. As far as performing, it will do as well or better than some of the saws you pay a huge price for.
>Well you know I have a great deal of respect for Stephen Shepherd. Even though I may not agree with everything he says or does and even poke fun at it occasionally I still pay attention. Lifting the saw on the back stroke was discussed a week or two back; I lose track of time. I wouldn't say that it makes a hill of beans difference whether you ease the weight of the saw upwards on the backstroke but it does give it a different feel and a different stroke. My first experiment with it made me feel like I was cutting more efficiently. Kind of like changing the oil in my car always makes it sound like it's running better; perhaps.
The crosscut saw teeth are filed in a diamond shape, and the set on the teeth makes it cut a slight V, higher in the center. Wood is a stringy material. My experience with not having a rip saw within two steps and being too lazy to go get it is that the stringy fibers are not aligned at 90� to the end of the board and they seem to make the crosscut saw want to follow the grain of the board while ripping it. I'm not publishing a newspaper here, just blabbing on about things as they appear to me. If someone wanted to set up an electron microscope and do the research I would gladly stand on the sidelines and cheer ;)
>Wow, that is fantastic. Two thousand years later, and we are still making them to look the same! Are were relatively sure about the timeline? That lock looks more "modern" (though what do I know)
>Sure would like to see the details of the lock. The lid is missing, slides in and is secured with the lock. A drawer lock, Half Mortice? Through hole under escutcheon? Is it a bolt lock or a cam lock?
>Automatic translators sure emphasize (inadvertently) how much difference there is, language to language, in sentence construction and idiom. It's a wonder that adults can ever learn another language than their birth language.
Do you know, Chris, whether those round things at the corner of the box face are dowels, nails, or something else? It looks like the builder might have driven something in at right angles to the weak direction of the dovetails. If so, it's a clever approach - dovetails to keep the front of the box from being torn off, pins/nails to keep the sides from being torn off. If not, of course, then it's something else entirely...
>Might have been the particular one I had, but a saw that's hard to start in the cut, whose blade gets uncomfortably hot, and tends to bind in the cut, doesn't cut the mustard in my book.
That's odd. I have no doubt LN would have fixed it for you, or replaced it, or given you a refund, but that ship has sailed.
LN DT saws famously require a little practice too start; thi is the cost of the comparatively coarse teeth, but that (of course) is what gives you high cutting speed, and straight cuts.
The binding and heating are(were) obvious indicators of insufficient set - a rare fault. The more normal complaint on DT saws (in general) is too much set.
I get heartily tired of people saying otherwise. A knife edge may have no width (if well sharpened) but unless the cut is of zero DEPTH, the cut has width, due to the bevel of the knife.
Re: Life's philosophy- camping, running and woodwo
Hank Knight
>Bill,
In case you were in doubt, my post was strictly tongue-in-cheek. While you are somewhat of an icon on this board, in my mind at least; we share the philosophy of reducing the tedium and drudgery of woodworking (and other pursuits) to a minimum. I have long since ceased to find a sense of accomplishment in "doing it the hard way" if there is a more comfortable avenue to my goal - within reason, of course. I like hand cut dovetails, for example, better than machine cut ones on many things, so I learned to cut them by hand even though my Leigh jig will give me more consistent results arguably quicker. But I share your philosophy that "hand cut" dovetails don't necessarily require that every scrap of waste be removed with a chisel. My post was a good natured jab at the purists among us at your expense, for which I apologize if it nicked you a bit.
>I have no idea. All I have seen is that image. I hope someone from across the pond who has seen this box, will chime in eventually.
Here is a link to the University T�bingen that seems maintain the Limes Museum. Chapter 12 has descriptions of various artifacts including keys, bolt locks, nails, spoon bits and such. Unfortunately it appears as if the corresponding photographs were missing. (Link to full online guide below)
Here's a link to a free online book on Roman Tools (free for us that is, the German people have to pay 19% sales tax to get this kind of stuff, what a deal!).
What's more, I like to sharpen my marking knife at about 35 degrees, and cut at least 0.5mm deep, so my lines have lots of width.
Easier to see and a nice positive depression in which to locate a chisel edge with some security.
If subsequent paring cuts are required, the cut side or polished track as I like to call it, provides a ledge to work from. Very little danger of cutting below/or inside the line.