Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

DT's - Cut to line, on line, next to...

Posts

DT's - Cut to line, on line, next to...

#1

DT's - Cut to line, on line, next to...

Joe in a Cleveland Suburb

>Hello.

When you use (hope I'm asking this right - I get confused on this) the tail board to mark the pins using a mechanical pencil for example, do you cut on the line, next to, waste side?

Just need a refresher...

Thanks.

Joe

Re: DT's - Cut to line, on line, next to...

#2

Re: DT's - Cut to line, on line, next to...

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Next to, waste side. If you cut on the line you'll leave gaps.

DC

Re: DT's - Cut to line, on line, next to...

#3

Re: DT's - Cut to line, on line, next to...

Wiley Horne

>Joe,

Denis is right.

The way to think about this: When you reach down through the tails board socket to mark the pins board, any wood you can reach should become part of the joint--if you can reach it, then it's needed to fill up the socket. That includes whatever mark you make, whether knife line or pencil. The mark is on live wood, not waste.

So when you go to saw, you want your saw to leave your marks. Leave the entire mark. If you split the mark, the joint will be loose, because 100% of the mark is on live wood.

Wiley

Re: DT's - Cut to line, on line, next to...

#4

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: DT's - Cut to line, on line, next to...

Jack Guzman from Maine

>Joe,

This is one reason why it's better to use a knife rather than a pencil to mark with.Unless your pencil leaves a very sharp consistent line,it's hard to tell where the actual edge is. Also,with a knife line,the cut is already started.Just keep the cut line as the very edge of your saw cut.---Jack

Re: DT's - Cut to line, on line, next to...

#5

Re: DT's - Cut to line, on line, next to...

Adam Cherubini

>It depends on how you chop the waste between the tails. You can't divorce your question from that. If you put your chisel in the scribe line and pound down, especially if that material is thick and soft, you may need to leave the line. I leave the scribe line or very nearly and saw the pencil lines out.

Adam

Re: DT's - Cut to line, on line, next to...

#6

Re: DT's - Cut to line, on line, next to...

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

>Thanks guys.

I just needed to reconfirm in my head before I start making firewood.

One other question regarding DT's. When did DT's start showing up in furniture?

Thank you.

Re: DT's - Cut to line, on line, next to...

#7

Re: DT's - Cut to line, on line, next to...

Kevin French, Antrim, NH

>Joe if you have trouble seeing a knife line and want to use a pencil, pick up some #4s they are extra hard, can be sharpened to a fine point, and the point will last thorough a whole DT setup.

Re: DT's - Cut to line, on line, next to...

#8

Re: DT's - Cut to line, on line, next to...

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>The word 'dovetail' was first used in 1573.

Stephen

Re: DT's - Cut to line, on line, next to...

#9

Ancient China and Egypt

wilbur

>Dovetail joints go back to ancient China and Egypt.

Re: DT's - Cut to line, on line, next to...

#10

further advice and information

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I recently did over 150 of these things for some boxes and trays, so the marking issue is fresh in my mind.

1. +/- 0.005" is the difference between a perfect joint and one that is too loose, or too tight to assemble.

2. maybe some can reliably mark and saw to this precision any time they choose, and on any wood combination, but not I.

3. hence, every time I am faced with dovetails I always do some practice joints on the wood I will actually be joining. The tolerance for joining two hard woods is noticeably smaller than for joining softer poplar or pine drawer sides to a hard wood front.

4. I don't see how anyone can make the transfer marks with a pencil to the precision required. I use a combination of marking knife and pen. The 0.5 and 0.3 mm gel pens made by some manufacturers (notably Pilot) don't wick on wood and they leave a reflective mark that is easy to see even on walnut. I find that for my technique I need to remove wood right to the knifed line if the woods are hard.

Re: DT's - Cut to line, on line, next to...

#11

Chris Scholz

Re: Ancient China and Egypt

Chris Scholz

>Classical Chinese furniture was fully developed by at least 900A.D. Dovetails were considered rather trivial joints used for crude boxes, rarely for fine furniture.

Chris

Chris Scholz

www.galoot-tools.com

Re: DT's - Cut to line, on line, next to...

#12

Re: further advice and information

Tony - Memphis

>So Bill, do you cut close to the line and then pare the sides? I'm asking because I am not good at sawing to a line. The saw seems to find where it wants to go no matter how careful I am. I am building a lowboy and would like to make the half blinds for the drawers by hand. I've only cut a few and haven't had real good results. Still trying. I doubt that I'll ever get that good with a saw. To be honest, I don't really want to spend the time it takes to get that good. My shop time is sparse and I'd rather be doing other things. I've also seen where some folks use a router to clean out a lot of the waste (FWW article and Lonnie Bird DVD).

Thanks,

Tony

Re: DT's - Cut to line, on line, next to...

#13

answers

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>First, I am no expert in dovetails so anything I do should be taken with some reservation. And let me define my dovetails. Flauntable dovetails are out there for all to see, an integral part of the piece, for example a tray, or blanket chest. I can't saw these directly reliably if both wood's tails and pins are in a hard wood. I saw as near the line as I can without going over and pare as needed. Non-flauntable are used to assemble drawers and the like. If the drawer side is poplar I can usually saw to the line and drive the joint together with little additional paring. They may not look like they grew together in every case but they don't look bad.

do you cut close to the line and then pare the sides? I cut to the line but don't cut into it. The result may require paring sometimes, more or less.

" The saw seems to find where it wants to go no matter how careful I am"............. I had this problem until I bought a LN saw. This saw saws where I point it and I can correct the direction if needed. The Japanese saws I have tried do not enable correction and the stick handle makes confident pointing more difficult in my hands. This saw moved me way up the learning curve. Never-the-less it will cut on the wrong side of the line if you let it. So I mark the waste areas so I know which side to be sawing on.

"To be honest, I don't really want to spend the time it takes to get that good. "...Me either. But you will get that good if you aren't afraid to use this joint when you have the opportunity. Soon your confidence will be such that you will not avoid this joint even if it needs to be flauntable. Its all a lot like sharpening free hand.

"I've also seen where some folks use a router to clean out a lot of the waste"........ I route out most of the waste on half blinds and band saw it out on tails and not half blinds.

Re: DT's - Cut to line, on line, next to...

#14

Aaaaarrrggggghhhhh!

Hank Knight

>"I route out most of the waste on half blinds and band saw it out on tails and not half blinds."

Another icon bites the dust! ;~)

Hank

Re: DT's - Cut to line, on line, next to...

#15

Re: DT's - Cut to line, on line, next to...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Some people use their dovetail saws to mark the pins from the tails (or the reverse). If you do this, it's probably best to saw to the line precisely, which is much easier if the saw has made the mark.

Pam

Re: DT's - Cut to line, on line, next to...

#16

Re: the saw

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>Cutting dovetails is a combination of skill and the right tools. I don't believe it is that hard to learn, although it can take a while to really get the fine points. Which is why I was reading this thread; every time I read a thread I "see" something new. I mark the tails with a pencil (.5 mm mechanical) and cut them. I have started removing most of the waste with a coping saw while the board is still in the vise. I cut off half of the line. (It really doesn't matter much on this because the pins are made to match the tails).

After getting threatened with a dope slap for starting a saw by pulling it backwards I paid some attention sunday afternoon when I was cutting a box. The saw needs to be a sharp rip saw, about 12 or 14 teeth per inch. (Using a cross cut saw to rip will cause it to wander off the line). I started a cut by putting my thumb down as a guide with the saw beside it, adjusting the end of my thumb so it would start where I wanted it to. I set the saw on the wood very lightly then pushed forward (hardly any weight of the saw on the board) and then pushed down gently with my wrist as the saw was in the first forward stroke. This started the cut very well. In the same thread about dopes and saws I read about lifting the saw on the back stroke. I found that if I paid atention this was a natural part of the back stroke motion if the wrist stays about the same position and the upper arm goes back the saw kind of lifts on its own. The forward motion is just a slight pressure down with the wrist and a sharp saw without much set in the teeth magically makes a pretty straight cut.

The pins are then marked with a marking knife; a sharp one that will take the end of your finger off if it comes too close. I used the pencil again to transfer the pin lines I had made on the ends of the boards straight down so I could easily see the 90� vertical reference; this line is not critical because it is used simply as reference to keep the cut perpendicular to the end of the board. You start the saw again with the end of your thumb as a guide, starting with very light pressure, aiming to cut right up to the knife line on the waste side. The forward motion with increasing wrist pressure as the saw is on the forward stroke seems to make it jump right into the knife line. Now that the saw is started you can look at your vertical pencil mark and see where the saw is cutting in reference to the line and simply follow the line down with hand/eye coordination. You don't turn the saw one way or the other, you just look at the line and cut down and your brain will make the saw follow the line. This technique works well for good serviceable dovetails cut efficiently. If I wanted to build a piece to enter in a show somewhere I would probably leave some waste on the pins and trim them with a chisel to fit the tails.

Re: DT's - Cut to line, on line, next to...

#17

Good one, Moses!

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>

Re: DT's - Cut to line, on line, next to...

#18

Re: DT's - Cut to line, on line, next to...

Miles

>I found a nice pencil trick recently, when marking pins/tails from each other. This was some 'garden' level work using 2" strips ripped from old iroko boards to make simple single-dovetailed frames to hold apples (on a mesh fixed to the underside of the frame) - the boards were grooved on one (the inner) surface, as they were recycled decking - and these occasionally intersected the edge I was trying to mark from... so I needed to make my line refer to the surface not just the edge. Usually a marking knife task, but a pencil is easier to see sometimes.

I did it by planing one side of my pencil at a similar angle to the usual point, to make a flat surface that intersected the point of the pencil, and holding that surface on the side of the pin to guide the mark on the end of the other board. Because I had planed the lead of the pencil with the same cut, I knew the edge of the pencil mark was what I had to saw to.

I made 16 of these joints in quick time, and they all fitted snugly without paring - the pencil trick was vital to getting it done easily.

Needs a simple sketch, really - but I hope it's clear. I am sure this is not new, but it was a nice find for me!

Miles

Re: DT's - Cut to line, on line, next to...

#19

marking and sawing- excellent description

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Your patience or typing skill is to be commended. Except I use a gel pen for better visibility, what you patiently typed for marking and sawing is what I do too, but was too lazy to describe in the detail you provided.

For those that have not perfected it, your description of starting a LN saw ( or equivalent) is right on.

Also I think the fuzzy and, hence deformable, cut the relatively coarse toothed LN saw leaves aids assembly.

Re: DT's - Cut to line, on line, next to...

#20

Re: the saw

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>A few statements here raised my eyebrows, and to quote Krenov (taken from a FWW interview), "this is where I become a very questioning person"...

"After getting threatened with a dope slap for starting a saw by pulling it backwards"

Is this the same principle as lifting a plane on the return stroke? One will pull the saw through the cut anyway, so that's only one extra pull stroke out of how many. Yes it will in theory dull the teeth a trifle faster, but is it worth the hassle of forcing oneself to start the cut on the push stroke? I wonder...

"Using a cross cut saw to rip will cause it to wander off the line"

I can't see why this makes a difference. Visualizing the mechanics of cutting, I can see that all other things equal, a crosscut saw will have a natural tendency to cut a wider kerf than a rip saw, through the wedging action of the teeth against the wood (the harder the wood the larger this effect should be). But wander off the line? Seems unlikely to me... If I'm missing something I'd like to know... This looks like a good subject for experimentation.

"In the same thread about dopes and saws I read about lifting the saw on the back stroke"

Looks like this is related to the first "question" above, i.e. minimize wear on the teeth. But this seems to me like an extra opportunity to distract the operator from concentrating on cutting to the line...

As I said at the beginning, I'm questioning here, not claiming I own the truth...

DC

Re: DT's - Cut to line, on line, next to...

#21

Jack Guzman from Maine

pencil lines

Jack Guzman from Maine

>If you need to use a pencil because you have difficulty seeing a knife line there is another option. Make your marks with a knife and then run the pencil along your knife line. It makes the line easier to see but you still have the cut line to follow.---Jack

Re: DT's - Cut to line, on line, next to...

#22

Life's philosophy- camping, running and woodwork

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>In my formative years I back packed with my older cousin at a time when suffering while back packing was fashionable. We were comfortable. He thought that once he demonstrated that he could survive in the woods under a pine branch for shelter, then he was free to camp any way he chose.

My wife says she will take up running when it looks like runners are having fun.

Combining these wisdoms, I used to tediously chop out dovetail waste. I never purred with satisfaction during the process. In my boredom I occasionally missed the base line. I find painting ceilings more satisfying than chiseling dovetail waste. Then I attended a lecture by Jeff Headly and learned some pointers on how to make more, nice stuff with less tedium.

While on that subject, Headley is teaching a bunch of classes this year- WWOTSV.com and you must not use Firefox to see the site. I will be in the August class. If I can learn proportionally what I learned from an hour lecture this will be a useful exercise.

Re: DT's - Cut to line, on line, next to...

#23

starting a LN saw...accurately

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I have pushed this thing through a lot of dovetails in the past year. In may hands it starts a cut most accurately when done exactly how Moses described it. So for me it is a question of starting accuracy, not saw wear.

Re: DT's - Cut to line, on line, next to...

#24

LN saw...

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Bought one. Did not like it at all, sold it.

The only positive thing I can say about this saw is that it keeps a good resale value :-)

Might have been the particular one I had, but a saw that's hard to start in the cut, whose blade gets uncomfortably hot, and tends to bind in the cut, doesn't cut the mustard in my book. I tried a Medallion saw and it was an improvement over the LN. I'd like to try Mike's saws, and the Gramercy one too.

DC

Re: DT's - Cut to line, on line, next to...

#25

Re: DT's - Cut to line, on line, next to...

Sgian Dubh

>I'm sure I've posted the image below somewhere on this forum before, but I transfer the rake of the tails (cut first usually) to the pin board with a home made knife I christened a "bird's beak" knife. I've no idea if that's a 'proper' name for a knife. A bit of hacksaw blade and a lump of wood does it. If the fine line is a bit hard to see, a black pencil or white pencil run in it helps according to the wood colour.

Then once the rakes are transferred I remove almost all the line for an off-the-saw fit. I so rarely pare either tails or pins to fit I can't recall when last I did so. Paring is aggravation, slow and tedious and adds too much time to the job. It also has a nasty habit of making the joints sloppy; at least every time I witness someone fiddling with chisels on either tails or pins that's the end result I usually see. Slainte.