Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Turning Saws

Posts

Turning Saws

#1

Turning Saws

Paul in NJ

>Do any of you use turning saws to saw out thick wood? I am asking about full size frame saws with blades maybe 24� long. I would like to make one to saw out cabriolet legs in 2-4� thick walnut. The only blades I have found are 9 tpi and I�m not sure how they are filed. Looking at coping saw blades, they filed rip with zero rake and I can�t tell if they have any fleam. I know some have used band saw blades. I think I would have to re-file these since they have a fair amount of positive rake. I am thinking about 6 tpi, 0 degrees of rake, and a couple degrees of fleam. Do any of you have suggestions for filing and blade size or wish to share your experience? How did the period furniture makers rough out items like these?

Thanks,

Paul Dzioba

Re: Turning Saws

#2

Re: Turning Saws

Dean J in MN

>Paul --

Mack Headly in his video "The Art and Mystery of the Cabinetmaker Crafting a Card Table" uses a panel saw to rough out the cab legs and finishes with a drawknife and spokeshave. I did the same for a recent set of legs for a tea table. It works quite well.

-Dean

Re: Turning Saws

#3

Re: Turning Saws

Adam Cherubini

>Paul,

I have a large turning saw you can borrow. I'm not crazy about it. I think its 27" long and has a coarse-ish blade. I think with material that thick a turning saw can be difficult to control. And I don't think its the blade or the saw. Its the curve. When you saw curves you really can't lay the saw down to correct a miscut. Thick work sort of exaggerates the problem and the mistakes.

I'll try to bring it with me to the D-C show. If I forget that will be a good excuse to get together and build something.

Adam

Re: Turning Saws

#4

Indirect response

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA, drying out a bit

>I don't know how the period makers did it, but more than one of us (I count myself in the group) cheats using the kerf-and-chisel method. The really bad drawing below may be self-explanatory; if not, the notion is that you cut cross-grain to near the curve, knock out the intervening bits of wood with a chisel, and drawknife and smooth from there. Sounds awkward, but it's pretty fast once you get in the rhythm, and, for major wasting of stock, often faster than a drawknife.


img

Re: Turning Saws

#5

Re: Turning Saws

Marv

>Hi Paul,

Generally speaking....

As for blade size, you want as wide a blade as possible but narrow enough to make the smaller turns. The wider the blade the more control you will have through the thickness of the wood.

You will want more set in the teeth than normal so you can steer the cut. And more set will allow you to use a wider blade.

A crosscut saw can also rip, but a rip saw does a lousy job of crosscutting. I would file the teeth as if I were filing a crosscut. I would use a 15 degree rake and between 20 and 25 degrees of fleam. 9 points per inch sounds about right for a 4" cut.

You will want maximum tension on the blade. It's easy to follow a pencil line on the side you are looking at but the other side is the problem. Maximum tension will assist in cutting straight across.

Marv

Re: Turning Saws

#6

Re: Turning Saws

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Years ago my supplier discontinued the blades I was using and I started using bandsaw blades. I like them better than what I had used and they are cheaper also. I get 3/16 blades in the 5 to 10 point range. Only the points are hardened, so it is easy to cut them to length and to make holes at the ends. I use them until they break and do not sharpen them. I don't think you want blades much wider than 3/16 for cabriole legs.

Re: Turning Saws

#7

Re: Turning Saws

Dale Warder

>I occasionally use an old Millers Fall Turning saw with an 18 inch blade 1/4 inch width,to cut curves in stock up to 2 inches thick. I obtained this saw from my father many years ago. When I received the saw it was filed rip, and worked very well. At some point, I decided it should be filed crosscut, and modified the blade. The saw became almost impossible to contrtol. After much experimentation, and following a recommendation by Tage Frid, I made a new blade, filed rip. This restored control to the saw.

I think the crosscut filing caused the saw to attempt to follow the grain of the stock. A sharp rip saw will cut either direction, but will leave a poorer cut surface when cutting crossgrain.

I suggest that you examine the teeth of commercial coping saws or fret saws as examples of tooth shape.

All said, it takes some practice to saw to the line in thicker material.

Good luck

Dale

Re: Turning Saws

#8

Re: Turning Saws

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>I have several bow or frame saws and two are set up with turning blades. Both blades are 1/4" wide, one is just a length of bandsaw blade, which works fine. The other has a regular blade which I resharpen. I just replace the bandsaw blade when it is dull. Easy to break to length and easy to punch a hole.

When properly set up and sharp they work very fast, especially cross grain. The tension needs to be proper and you can't force the work, the weight of the saw is all that is needed with little pressure and a lot of guidance.

I do have a cranked dovetail blade made from a bandsaw which I do resharpen, but I took the temper out when I bent the crank and never bothered to reharden the blade. Seems to work fine, only have to sharpen about twice a year.

It is easier to sharpen the blades when they are in the frame under tension.

Good Luck, give the turning saw a chance.

Stephen

Re: Turning Saws

#9

Re: Indirect response

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>This is how I do it, too, Bill, much faster and less drudgery than a saw-only solution.

Pam

Re: Turning Saws

#10

Re: Turning Saws

Paul in NJ

>You guys are great! I ask a few questions and shortly get a whole bunch of answers to ponder. Dean mentioned a panel saw, drawknife, and spokeshave method used by Mack Headly at Williamsburg. I have thought of using this method too. Looking at the tool inventory of the Benjamin Seaton chest there is only a small 13 � turning saw. This saw seems too small to get out cabriolet legs, but perhaps they had already gone out of style and a larger saw was not required. I also thought it odd that a drawknife and hatchet were not in the chest or mentioned in the inventory. I have used a similar technique to Bill�s, cutting perpendicular to the line and paring with gouges for scrollwork on a skirt.

I am going to try the turning saw and when I get around to actually doing it, I will report. Thanks a bunch everyone.

Paul Dzioba

Re: Turning Saws

#11

Re: Turning Saws

Warren in Lancaster, Pa

>Paul, there would not be any problem cutting the legs (three inch stuff) with a 13 inch saw. Five inches or so would start to give trouble, six would be no fun at all. Since I rarely use a drawknife, I would not miss it in a tool kit. If you have a lathe and a bench with vises and holdfasts, there is little need for a shaving horse. I would miss my block knife long before I would miss a hatchet or drawknife.

In excavations around the Hay shop in Williamsburg, was found a mahogany leg that was partly done. It was pictured in FW about 15 or 20 years ago. It was clear that the long rather straight cuts on the leg were done with a ripsaw, the rest with a turning saw. In both the case of the mahogany leg and the Seaton Chest, we have an example of only one, so it is hard to get too worked up over "this is the way it was done". If we looked in our various shops today, we would find many different methods of work and very different tool kits.

Re: Turning Saws

#12

Re: Turning Saws

Joel

>There is also a turning saw in the Phyfe chest.

Re: Turning Saws

#13

Re: Turning Saws - use your leg...

John Aniano - in central NJ...

>Hi Paul,

Sorry to add my two cents so late - but here goes...

I found with my ~22" turning saw I liked a coarse bandsaw blade, maybe 6 TPI, just as many here suggested. For the broad curves of a cabriolet leg maybe a wider blade would be good as well.

Also, I last year when cutting out the walnut sides for a bench for my antique reed (pump) organ, I discovered a neat method to control the turning saw. First, hold the workpiece to the bench firmly - I used two wooden clamps and held the work at the corner of the bench. After getting the cut started, take as long a stroke as possible - but here is the neat thing I found - let the bottom portion of the saw frame slide up against your leg - yes your leg. It dampened the saw vibrations and by moving your leg as the cut progressed, you could better guide the saw AND keep the cut perpendicular to the workpiece. It really stabilized the cutting process and allowed me to use a more more TPI blade than the ~3/4" thick stock would comfortably allow due to the mismatch between TPI and stock thickness. Has anyone else heard of or tried this method?

Over and out,

John

Re: Turning Saws

#14

Re: Turning Saws

Tom Colligan

>Paul, Williamsburg has a store from which I bought a video of Mack making a Cabriole leg. As Warren mentioned, in the video he shows this partially completed cabriole leg found in the ground as if it were tossed out. I've been getting their catalogs for two years now after having bought just that one video for $20. Tom

Re: Turning Saws

#15

Makes sense

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA, drying out a bit

>Most of us probably hold a regular saw by the blade with one hand sometimes while doing particularly tricky cuts, especially in tight spots or when the saw is, in fact, a bit large for the cut - or am I weird that way? So using your leg as an adjunct is another version.

I'll have to try to remember this if I ever get a round tuit with a turning saw stamped on it...

Re: Turning Saws

#16

Re: Turning Saws

Don McConnell

>Paul et al,

Sorry to be coming in on this thread so late, but I've been tied up with other things and haven't been able to find one reference I'd like to quote (still haven't found it, but decided to go ahead without it).

I think Paul's question regarding the traditional methods cabinetmakers used to shape cabriole legs is a very interesting one - and, possibly, worth a little more discussion.

I think the discovery of the unfinished cabriole leg in the silt near the Hay shop at Colonial Williamsburg has garnered a lot of attention largely because it seems to contradict the accepted understanding as to how this type of work was done. But, I think we need to place it in some context.

In the first place, I'm not sure how much weight we should place on an artifact which was, apparently, discarded as unsatisfactory. Possibly someone in the shop, faced with making some cabriole legs, didn't have anything but a rip saw at hand (maybe his turning saw web had broken and hadn't been replaced) and tried to make the best of it - without success.

Secondly, even if that single artifact indicates that the use of the rip saw was standard for the bulk of sawing out cabriole legs in that particular shop at a particular point in time, this doesn't necessarily mean it was the standard method in every shop throughout the eighteenth and early nineteenth century.

Finally, it seems to be a somewhat indirect and inefficient way of arriving at the basic form of cabriole legs. One of the interesting things about cabriole legs is that the final form is the combination of exactly the same "profile" in both orientations (front view and side view). And, in keeping with this, we know that, traditionally, cabinetmakers used templates/patterns to lay these out before any sawing commenced. Minimally, on both the front and side of each leg blank.

Then, the sawing commences in one of the orientations. The layout lines to guide the sawing of the second orientation can only be available if the waste is not quite cut entirely loose or by temporarily reattaching it in its original position.

At the end of the saw cuts, all the sawn away waste is removed, which also removes the vast majority of the layout lines in both orientations. If the sawing is done mostly with a rip or panel saw, it will not have been able to follow the layout lines closely, leaving more removal of unwanted material using more inefficient means and without the guidance of the layout lines. On the other hand, if a turning saw has been used to carefully follow (and just leave) the layout lines, a minimum of clean-up to remove the saw marks and fair out any irregularities will have to take place in the absence of the layout lines.

The latter seems, to me, to be a much more efficient and effective approach in the final analysis. More to the point, I find it difficult to believe that the bulk of "period" cabinetmakers went to the bother of making up templates then proceeded in a manner which minimized their utility.

As a side note, the kerfing in at right angles to the layout lines then removal with chisels would only work in this application if the cuts were made in both orientations before the removal of any waste. I've done a fair amount of this in other applications (mainly handrail fittingss), and always chose it as a last resort if there was no efficient way to make the cuts with a turning saw.

As to recommendations, I think I would tend to agree with much of what Marv wrote. This is a case where a little more set would likely be useful, allowing for a slightly wider (not thicker) blade than otherwise. Just as long as it will follow the "quickest" curves.

If one has trouble keeping the cuts perpendicular, it can be quite helpful to draw layout lines on all the faces, so you can monitor the cut at both extremes of the kerf. And, in keeping with accepted technique while ripping out thicker stuff, it is also possible to turn the leg blank over, if necessary, to help correct and control the cut. By definition, turning saws are "steerable," so making "corrections" are not difficult if you don't let things get very far out of hand.

As to the teeth, I would have thought 9 ppi, as Marv suggested, might be a little too fine. But, in checking Holtzapffel's chart of saws, the coarsest teeth he lists for turning saws is 10 ppi. I don't know, though, I think I would still be tempted to go with something closer to 7 or 8 ppi.

As to the shape of the teeth, I'm not sure I entirely agree with Marv, though _Spon's Mechanics' Own Book_, makes a similar suggestion. It also shows a tooth profile which illustrates about a 10 degree rake/pitch (i.e., the face of the tooth leans handle-ward about 10 degrees) and a considerable fleam angle. However, Spon's also acknowledges this results in a slightly slower cutting saw.

In this particular application, where most of the cutting is closer to rip than cross-cut, I think I would stay a little closer to a rip tooth profile. Possibly, 7 - 8 degree rake/pitch and 5 to 10 degree fleam/bevel angle. This is where I would like to have mentioned Charles Johnson's (_Saw Dictionary_) recommendations for "long miter" cuts, but can't seem to find my copy. In any event, experimentation will be the best guide. In the final analysis, very sharp and consistently shaped teeth may be the single most important factor in satisfactory sawing of cabriole legs. :-)

Don McConnell

Eureka Springs, AR

Re: Turning Saws

#17

Re: Turning Saws

Paul in NJ

>Don,

Thank you for your thoughtful response. I think modern woodworkers who started with power tools and try to work only with hand tools will have to re-think some of their processes towards hand tools. Things like whether every board needs to be four squared and smoothed, etc. Woodworkers using a jointer/planer/table saw/band saw, wanting to make cabriole legs, would 4-square their stock and mark their pattern on two sides as you suggested. They would not think twice about ripping each board separately from a plank once with the table saw and once to shape with the band saw. Would a professional, with their time constraints, either modern or period using hand tools do this extra ripping? It is possible to use your template on the shaped surface if you are careful. Questions like these are so fascinating to me. Thanks again for taking the time to post your response.

Paul Dzioba

Re: Turning Saws

#18

Re: Turning Saws

Wiley Horne

>Don,

I'm frantically searching for the copy of Charles Johnson you were kind enough to xerox and mail to me.

Wiley

Re: Turning Saws

#19

Re: Turning Saws

Don McConnell

>Paul, Wiley et al,

As to stock preparation for making cabriole legs, Paul, let's talk about this a little more. At a minimum, I think we can agree that the two "joinery" faces would benefit from being trued and squared up to each other. Beyond that, I think it can be argued that there is some benefit to bringing the other two faces to, at least, a relative state of being true and square to the others. For one thing, leaving any dimension significantly oversized will result in having to saw through more thickness than necessary during the process of shaping the cabriole leg. So, in the end, I'm not sure you'd be saving much by leaving them oversized at the outset. Secondly, if you're going to bring them roughly to dimension in any event, it will take little more time and effort to, at least, roughly true and smooth them up, to ease establishing layout lines, etc.

While methods and approaches do differ, somewhat, when working mostly by machine rather than with handtools, I believe that it is possible to make way too much of these differences.

In many instances, while working primarily by hand, it is actually more efficient, in the long run, to work reasonably accurately at one stage of the process in order to save time and headaches "fiddling" around with the results of sloppy/unplanned/unprepared work later. Those who want to advocate otherwise often overlook the lack of effficiency and directness of working which ensues, often fueled by an uncritical assumption that any striving for accuracy is completely informed by a machine tool mentality. I believe this is incorrect, incomplete and damagingly misleading. Many of the techniques and approaches used by those using mostly machinery were first developed by generations of trade woodworkers using hand tools. Yes, there are differences, but sweeping over-generalizations serve no helpful purpose.

Wiley, thanks for the thought about finding your copy Johnson's _Saw Dictionary_. It might be helpful, but I did want to add that my idea was to mention his "long miter" tooth profile mostly as food for thought. It may not be entirely suitable for this application.

Don McConnell

Eureka Springs, AR

Re: Turning Saws

#20

Re: Turning Saws

Jim Crammond in Monroe, Mi

>Wiley or Don,

I think this would be nice to have available on the web. I have a copy, but it always seems to disappear when I want to refer to it, too. Maybe Old Tool Shop or Toolerma Press would would host it.

Jim

Re: Turning Saws

#21

Don's powers of recall *LINK*

Wiley Horne

>are extremely good! I found my copy of Charles Johnson's 'Saw Dictionary', ca. 1907.

We're generally accustomed to the crosscut/rip dichotomy, but this was still in the era when handsaws were used to make a living. Johnson describes a continuum of rake and fleam angles, as one moves from pure crosscut, through short miter, to long miter, to rip. Don was suggesting that the 'long miter' recommendations were probably closest to the cabriole leg turning cuts.

Johnson's basic recommendation for long miters in dry hardwood is 5-7 degrees of rake, 5-10 degrees of fleam, and a 5-1/2, 6, or 7 point saw. Elsewhere, in discussing saws for cutting circles (i.e., use of a plate saw for a turning saw, as in ship work), he recommends a 7-, 8-, or 9-point saw with rake and fleam similar to the above figures.

Don McConnell's recommendations fall squarely within these ranges.

For those interested in further details of Johnson's rake and fleam and tooth count, and some discussion by Mike Wenzloff as well, see the link given below to a thread from April, 2007.

Wiley


More rake & fleam by McConnell and Wenzloff

Re: Turning Saws

#22

Chris Scholz

Re: Turning Saws

Chris Scholz

>Talking about cabriole legs, in China they have been around hundreds of years before they became popular in the Occident.

How did they do it? They certainly had frame/bow/turning saws (typically without the turned handles we prefer in the West) and spokeshaves (in fact the Chinese planes are just large spokeshaves). The also had a distinct preference for notoriously hard to work wood species.

Unfortunately there is very little written about the means and ways of traditional Chinese woodworking (maybe 100 pages during the last 3,000 years, mostly written by Western scholars during the 19th century. Ironically the old Chinese were obsessed with writing everything else down, just nothing about woodworking tools).

Chris

---

Chris Scholz

Atlanta, GA

Galoot-Tools

Re: Turning Saws

#23

Re: Turning Saws

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Don, Phil Lowe demonstrates making legs with the bandsaw for the initial cuts. What he does is cut one face and then with double sided tape sticks the cut piece back on for the second cut. I don't see any reason why this couldn't be done with a handsaw.

I'd like to review the Mack Headley video on making cab legs, but my vcr is broken. IIRC, he doesn't do the above.

Pam

Re: Turning Saws

#24

Re: Turning Saws

Don McConnell

>Pam et al,

Yes, the waste could be re-attached (taped back on) after the cuts have been made in the first orientation with a rip saw. In fact, that was the scenario, for both approaches, which I was envisioning when comparing the use of a rip saw with that of a turning saw in my first post.

In both cases, when all the saw cuts are made, nearly all of the layout lines are gone. In the case of the rip saw, a good deal of material still needs to be removed by means not as efficient as sawing and without the guidance of layout lines. In my opinion, this renders the use of a template/pattern much less beneficial.

In the case of the turning saw, if carefully done, the initial sawing might take a little longer, but there will be a minimum of material removal and cleaning up in the absence of layout lines. To me, this approach stands to benefit much more directly from the use of a template and layout lines. In other words, it's both a more direct and accurate way of working.

Don McConnell

Eureka Springs, AR