Re: Turning Saws
Don McConnell
>Paul et al,
Sorry to be coming in on this thread so late, but I've been tied up with other things and haven't been able to find one reference I'd like to quote (still haven't found it, but decided to go ahead without it).
I think Paul's question regarding the traditional methods cabinetmakers used to shape cabriole legs is a very interesting one - and, possibly, worth a little more discussion.
I think the discovery of the unfinished cabriole leg in the silt near the Hay shop at Colonial Williamsburg has garnered a lot of attention largely because it seems to contradict the accepted understanding as to how this type of work was done. But, I think we need to place it in some context.
In the first place, I'm not sure how much weight we should place on an artifact which was, apparently, discarded as unsatisfactory. Possibly someone in the shop, faced with making some cabriole legs, didn't have anything but a rip saw at hand (maybe his turning saw web had broken and hadn't been replaced) and tried to make the best of it - without success.
Secondly, even if that single artifact indicates that the use of the rip saw was standard for the bulk of sawing out cabriole legs in that particular shop at a particular point in time, this doesn't necessarily mean it was the standard method in every shop throughout the eighteenth and early nineteenth century.
Finally, it seems to be a somewhat indirect and inefficient way of arriving at the basic form of cabriole legs. One of the interesting things about cabriole legs is that the final form is the combination of exactly the same "profile" in both orientations (front view and side view). And, in keeping with this, we know that, traditionally, cabinetmakers used templates/patterns to lay these out before any sawing commenced. Minimally, on both the front and side of each leg blank.
Then, the sawing commences in one of the orientations. The layout lines to guide the sawing of the second orientation can only be available if the waste is not quite cut entirely loose or by temporarily reattaching it in its original position.
At the end of the saw cuts, all the sawn away waste is removed, which also removes the vast majority of the layout lines in both orientations. If the sawing is done mostly with a rip or panel saw, it will not have been able to follow the layout lines closely, leaving more removal of unwanted material using more inefficient means and without the guidance of the layout lines. On the other hand, if a turning saw has been used to carefully follow (and just leave) the layout lines, a minimum of clean-up to remove the saw marks and fair out any irregularities will have to take place in the absence of the layout lines.
The latter seems, to me, to be a much more efficient and effective approach in the final analysis. More to the point, I find it difficult to believe that the bulk of "period" cabinetmakers went to the bother of making up templates then proceeded in a manner which minimized their utility.
As a side note, the kerfing in at right angles to the layout lines then removal with chisels would only work in this application if the cuts were made in both orientations before the removal of any waste. I've done a fair amount of this in other applications (mainly handrail fittingss), and always chose it as a last resort if there was no efficient way to make the cuts with a turning saw.
As to recommendations, I think I would tend to agree with much of what Marv wrote. This is a case where a little more set would likely be useful, allowing for a slightly wider (not thicker) blade than otherwise. Just as long as it will follow the "quickest" curves.
If one has trouble keeping the cuts perpendicular, it can be quite helpful to draw layout lines on all the faces, so you can monitor the cut at both extremes of the kerf. And, in keeping with accepted technique while ripping out thicker stuff, it is also possible to turn the leg blank over, if necessary, to help correct and control the cut. By definition, turning saws are "steerable," so making "corrections" are not difficult if you don't let things get very far out of hand.
As to the teeth, I would have thought 9 ppi, as Marv suggested, might be a little too fine. But, in checking Holtzapffel's chart of saws, the coarsest teeth he lists for turning saws is 10 ppi. I don't know, though, I think I would still be tempted to go with something closer to 7 or 8 ppi.
As to the shape of the teeth, I'm not sure I entirely agree with Marv, though _Spon's Mechanics' Own Book_, makes a similar suggestion. It also shows a tooth profile which illustrates about a 10 degree rake/pitch (i.e., the face of the tooth leans handle-ward about 10 degrees) and a considerable fleam angle. However, Spon's also acknowledges this results in a slightly slower cutting saw.
In this particular application, where most of the cutting is closer to rip than cross-cut, I think I would stay a little closer to a rip tooth profile. Possibly, 7 - 8 degree rake/pitch and 5 to 10 degree fleam/bevel angle. This is where I would like to have mentioned Charles Johnson's (_Saw Dictionary_) recommendations for "long miter" cuts, but can't seem to find my copy. In any event, experimentation will be the best guide. In the final analysis, very sharp and consistently shaped teeth may be the single most important factor in satisfactory sawing of cabriole legs. :-)
Don McConnell
Eureka Springs, AR