Re: True-Value?
Marv
>Wilbur,
I think I understand your analogies, but still, lets get that unreasonable high price on those five saws down to a lower unreasonable high price.
Marv
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Re: True-Value?
Marv
>Wilbur,
I think I understand your analogies, but still, lets get that unreasonable high price on those five saws down to a lower unreasonable high price.
Marv
Re: True-Relative-Value?
Marv
>Mike,
First thing I did was to do the math. I remember a number of months back I sold a beautiful Disston D8 thumbhole saw on eBay for $301.00 that I had reconditioned. Someone in here posted a question, wondering why it was worth $301.00. I sensed that they were flabbergasted. I think it was you who replied.."because it wasn't worth $302.00." That was worth a good chuckle. I remember there being alot of discussion about it. I've reconditioned alot of saws before and after that one. That was one of a small number that I actually made a fair wage. Usually I'm lucky to make 5 dollars an hour.
I can easily relate to what you are talking about when you refer to a special saw that you made. Lots of time and effort and skill. Your reward is mainly satisfaction with a job well done.
A plumber or a mechanic or an electrician will charge, what?....$65.00 per hour?..maybe more? Is their labor any more skilled than yours? I think not. However if you charged that much for your time, could you sell a saw for $185.00, including shipping?
The $1600.00 Japanese saws are being offered with a starting bid of that amount with a "Or Best Offer" option. The guy who actually did the work probably made only a small fraction of that. The seller is no doubt tossing a huge number out there just to see if someone will bite. Perhaps we should wait to see if someone does before we say much more about it. Who knows, maybe someone will offer 30% of that and the seller will accept it.
You said....
Even if I could ever approach being as good on a Japanese saw, just what do you think I would charge?
$559.95??....I'll take a dozen of um. *smirk*
Marv
Well, I gotta say...
Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.
>...that the hammers, I would have a problem justifying these to myself, although I know next to nothing about fine hammers. So I won't pass judgment, although these seem overpriced compared to the saws...
Happy new year!
DC
Just for the record, Marv...
Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.
>I asked on the japanesetools.com forum about the saws being a good deal, and someone in the know said that "it is better than a good deal if you have the cash for the quoted Tetsunosuke saws"...
Someone recently paid GBP 150,000 at a Sotheby's auction for a Nakashima table, was it worth the money?
"Value" is a subjective thing. But in this case, these saws can be expected to perform like no other, only Tetsunosuke's son Yataiki is reputed to be as good.
DC
Re: might as well splurge on the camellia oil
Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI
>I guess if your spending $8K on the saws then you might as well splurge for the $15 camellia oil ;)
Will they ever be used???
David Cockey
>I wonder if these saws and the other very high end Japanese tools the seller is offering will ever be used assuming they find a buyer. Presumably to use them would significantly reduce their value. For many collectors owning is more important than using.
Somewhat like high end cars which are only produced in very limited numbers. Typically a high percentage of such cars go directly from the dealer to climate controlled storage and are never driven on the street. Then their are those who like the idea of spending a very large amount of money on an item and then using it to demonstrate to themselves and possibly others that they are in a position to do so.
I suspect the same is true for very high end guns with many being purchased but not used.
Works of art originally produced as art are a somewhat different matter since the art was never intended to be used.
Re: Making handles
Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away
>Well Bill, that leave me out then. ;~)
Does Marv usually froth at the mouth or is he choking?
I have to wonder what the conversation over at the Japanese wooding forum is going like? Here we are lusting hard for these saws and the Americans are saying "what's so special about these saws"?
T.O.
Hey Marv!
Brad in Ottawa
>You should meet my wife... you would get along great with her. She can't understand it when I think $100 for a Bedrock smoother is a steal!
Brad
How do you use art?
Bill Houghton, chillyish Sebastopol, CA
>Seems like art, kind of by definition, is there to be appreciated. Perhaps that's what we've got here in the saws.
Re: How do you use art?
Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away
>not knowing, nor really caring very much either I must confess about "art" as in paintings I do believe that there are many "Masters" that are socked away in climate controlled vaults where no eyes will be cast upon them until they get resold. It's all about the greenbacks baby, all about the greenbacks. Coarse, I can well imagine that what is considered to be a "Master" today was considered as pure garbage in their day, as I myself see alot of them to still be.
I can hear it now, "Hey, did you see that ugly vase of flowers that nutter Van Gogh painted?" "Yeah, I was going to buy it, he wanted $100 for it, but the frame was only worth $10"
T.O.
Re: Hey Marv!
Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away
>Ahhhhhhhhhh well then Brad, that certainly puts it all into perspective quite well eh? Good point and well made.
Somebody help Marv get that dagger out of his heart.
T.O.
Who'd like a $100 Bedrock 4.5 please.
Re: Hey Marv!
Marv
>Brad,
What's her name?.....Phone number?
Thank you,
Marv
Re: True-Value?
Warren in Lancaster, PA
>I have a neighbor who farms with horses and has no health insurance. When his son broke his leg last month the anethesiologist charged him $1350.00 for two hours (not sure what he did all that time}. This makes the saws seem cheap. I don't think anybody would argue that making such a saw does not require more talent, more experience, and more effort than putting someone to sleep. But if we want these things we have to pay the price. I think many of us would give two hours of labor to have such a saw.
Trying to follow your double negatives....
wilbur
>Warren,
Are you saying that it takes more talent to make a high end Japanese saw, than to be an anesthesiologist?
Re: Trying to follow your double negatives....
Warren in Lancaster, PA
>It certainly takes more talent, more dedication and more skill to be a sawmaker with this kind of respect than to be a run-of-the-mill anesthesiologist.
I have no problem spelling "Sawmaker"
Marv
>
Re: How do you use art?
James Watriss
>But are the saws appreciated as an artifact, or as tools?
If the maker in question is reputed to be such a wonderful maker of saws, can you really appreciate his workmanship without cutting wood?
If he's dedicated his life to making tools for the express purpose of cutting wood, is it really appreciative of his time and effort and accomplishment to say "thanks for the saws, they'll look beautiful hanging on the wall."
Re: How do you use art?
Marv
>Some people collect bottle caps, some collect other useless junk. Would someone who collects famous paintings also collect bottle caps? Probably not....
Why do people collect things? No doubt an endless list of reasons.
I collect old tools, but I'm a cheap collector. I can't afford to buy a Panther Saw for example or a No.1 Stanley smoother plane, etc. It's not that I don't want them, it's only because I don't have enough disposable revenue.
I'll guess that what people collect is determined largely by how much money they have laying around. Like Todd said, it's all about the greenbacks and marbles.
I'm going to take back what I said about someone losing their marbles if they paid $1600.00 for a saw. I only hope that, that person will bid on a saw that I might have listed on eBay sometime in the future.
Marv
Re: Trying to follow your double negatives....
Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX
>Wilbur, I don't think anyone was saying it took more talent exactly; but it sure is a much rarer talent; and very little of the cost goes to insurance and/or the hospital, although more of the cost involves materials.
Pam