Tetsunosuke saws on eBay - Chance of a lifetime? *LINK*
Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.
>A friend directed me to this link...
Believe it or not, the price is not bad! And shipping is free :-)
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Tetsunosuke saws on eBay - Chance of a lifetime? *LINK*
Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.
>A friend directed me to this link...
Believe it or not, the price is not bad! And shipping is free :-)
But will they follow a pencil line?
Marv
>
OUCH! Marv!
Stuart Hough
>
??????????
Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.
>I must say that this one flew right by me...
Care to enlighten me?
DC
Tools for use - or - Collectables
David Cockey
>What would happen if someone actually decided to mount handles and actually use these saws instead of purchasing them to possess unused?
Re: Tools for use - or - Collectables
Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away
>Hoooooooooooooo Boy David, there's a can o' worms a'waiting to spill all over the place! I will say that for $2000 a piece for these saws in my mind is totally ridiculous, but then again,first a foremost Iam totally uneducated in the world of Japanese tools, and certainly of the works of the "Old Masters" To some these may be quite the bargain depending upon just what they do with wood,but at my wealth level,skill level, mindset, etc, etc, they are of no interest to me.
Folks collect tools and other stuff for various reasons. Fun, future profit, preservation, etc, etc, etc and I suppose there are worse things that one can do with their money. I for one would give $1 for an item such as a baseball card, but there are folks that'll by $1000's of dollars for just one! What the blazes for?! is my thinking, it's a piece of card board that has a picture on it to me.
T.O.
Re: ??????????
Marv
>Please, I need some enlightenment....thank you.
The price isn't all that bad, you say? For whom??!!
THEY ARE SAWS!!
The least they could do is put handles on them.
Why would anyone pay that much money for saws that are too short with no handles? It would be about as rediculous as spending 8K for a bottle of wine.
As far as I can see in the auction, there is nothing to identify the saws as being authentic. No etch, no logo, to model number, nothing.
But even if they were indentified in some manner, I for one will find something much more useful to spend my money on.
Lets see now....what could I buy for $8000.00? Maybe I'll ask Suzy and see what she thinks. Yeah, that'll work.....
Lets put the auction on our watch list to see if the auction gets any bids. I'm willing to put my money where my mouth is and bet fifty cents that there won't be any bids at the starting price.
Marv
Re: ??????????
Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.
>Well, the price isn't that bad, considering that 1. Chances are remote that one will find another set that's been unused, 2. Tetsunosuke II was considered the best saw maker of his time, 3. His son, Yataiki (Tetsunosuke III), charges (or charged) $1500 for his top of the line saws. This is an issue of market price here, and collectible value also. Of course, authenticity must be there, and if I were in the market for saws like that I'd be leery of buying from someone I don't know.
Your comment about them being "SAWS!" reinforces my opinion that saws are the Rodney Dangerfields of hand tools... The amount of work required to make one of these saws, and the expertise required, naturally constrain the market to a small group of people. It's no different from cars, high end stereo equipment, etc. The problem with Japanese saws is that high-end ones often don't look that different from $50 ones.
Some people have paid in the vicinity of $20K for a Holtey jointer plane. You might think this is ridiculous, but these buyers wanted the "very best" (at least that's what it was considered at the time). It's their money...
To you it doesn't make sense to pay that much for a set of saws, and it's fine. I wouldn't also pay $8K for a bottle of wine (yet I'd like to taste it :-) It's all a matter of perceived value...
It will be interesting to see if the saws sell, but even if they don't sell now that's not necessarily a sign that the saws are overpriced. Like million dollar mansions, the potential buyer market is small, so it can take time to sell.
DC
Re: ??????????
MikeW
>Hi Denis,
I doubt I will ever be in a financial position to afford such saws. I would if I could, though.
I do believe if (and I have little info to cause doubt) they are truly Tetsunosuke II saws, they are a pinacle of saw making art. Much like me being able to purchase an expensive infill.
I would use them as well--just like I've drank rather expensive bottles of wine and brandy ans smoked rather expensive Cuban cigars (seems another lifetime since, but I digress).
Thanks for posting the link. Beautiful.
Take care, Mike
I gotta agree... Kinda...
Scott Burr in cold Ben Lomond, CA
>I sure wouldn't drop 8K on some saws even if I could afford them. I understand the ammount of work that goes into them, but I don't think I could tell the difference between these and a machine made one.
5K for hammer heads now that's another story Hmmmm, I like hammers...;^)
Tools vs. artifacts
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
>Marv,
At that price, I'm not sure that you can call them "saws" anymore. They no longer represent just tools. If you stumbled over a perfectly preserved highboy (is that the right term? Those dressers with the gooseneck molding, finials, etc.?) from one of the major 18th century makers that the family had kept in a climate-controlled attic room, you would no longer have a piece of furniture to put your socks and undies in, but an artifact of historical worth.
Those knowledgeable about Japanese sawmaking have informed us that this maker was the best of the best, so his saws are worthy of high prices; but the ultimate buyer will be buying the artifact - the association of the maker with the tool - not just a set of tools.
I have a strong bent in the "tools are useful for making things" direction. I wound up behind a pickup truck today with a metalflake paint job, and was, as I always do, shaking my head. Pickup trucks are TOOLS; they show that they've done hard work, and if that means they're dented and slightly rusty, so be it. I suspect the buyer of these saws would have a hard time understanding my thought processes, as I would his/hers, when gazing at the photo and the picture on eBay.
Bill, whose shop would be frighteningly crowded if I had $8,000 to put into tools.
Re: ??????????
James Watriss
>I'm pitching in to agree with everyone else. Jim Krenov used scrap wood and old block plane irons to make quick and dirty wooden planes to work with. But they're fetching way more than the original cost of materials, and probably even the cost of Krenov's time. So why would anyone want to pay what people have been paying on eBay?
For the same reason, I guess, that I spent $600 on a Calvin and Hobbes poster a few months ago. Watterson sent out 1000 of them, signed and numbered, to newspapers running his strip, the year he went on sabbatical. The posters are an artifact of his ability, but also a memento of his incorrigibility and integrity, re: his sabbatical, in this specific case, and his refusal to cave to merchandising deals in general.
To me, that's something worth commemorating, and worth honoring, and I'll hang a $600 poster of a comic strip character on my wall to remind myself that there are people out there who have the spine and stamina to do amazing work, without cmpromising their own principles.
Would I spend $8000 on 5 saws? I don't know enough, and I'm not skilled enough to be able to appreciate such things. I think that something that is truly well made, by someone who has been pursuing this sort of quality standard their whole life, has to be worth more than something made by someone who isn't able to do it as well. Experience and talent take things beyond the realm of the norm, into the realm of art.
Another example: Philippe Wurtz is a French clockmaker who has taken mechanical movement clocks to a new level. The Gramat is a case clock that's air-tight, and the density of the air is maintained with a vacuum pump to provide uniform resistance to the pendulum, which is temperature-compensated, and various other things. The movement runs for 4 months per winding, and is accurate to something like half a second, per year. Can you get a quartz movement that's equally precise? Absolutely, for 1/10,000 of the cost. (Wurtz Clocks go for 6 figures, I'm told, with the current exchange rate.) I wouldn't pay so much for just a clock, or just a watch. But if I had the money, I'd certainly reward such persistence, and dedication to precision and perfection. I'd pay the money to see, for myself, firsthand, that someone had the brains and the dedication to reach a pinnacle of measurable achievement. Is it worth that much just to know what time it is? No, not really. But it's worth it to know that human aspirations do not always come to nothing.
Re: Tools vs. artifacts
Marv
>Bill,
Thanks for the perspective....perspective is a healthy thing...ignorance can be costly. Speaking for myself here.
I guess when I first looked at that auction and saw the starting price, my ignorance caused me to react just like I do when I see a high priced abstract painting. My first thought is "what the hell"?
Sorry Denis but I'd still would want to know for sure that the saws can cut straight even if all I'd do is show them off to people who are in my immediate surroundings who would think as I did..."what the hell"? Having said that, from now on, I'll think of Japanese made saws in a different light. Maybe the needle on my ignorance meter has moved to the left a few thousands. I've said it before, life would sure be boring if I knew everything. Believe me, my life surely isn't boring....*grin*
Marv
Re: Tools vs. artifacts
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
>"When I was a boy of fourteen, my father was so ignorant I could hardly stand to have the old man around. But when I got to be twenty-one, I was astonished at how much the old man had learned in seven years." - possibly Mark Twain (I always thought it was him, but apparently there's some question).
If we project that far, to the age range that Marv and I share, there's a WHOLE lot to be learned.
OT.....Hammers? ???
Marv
>Scott,
I like hammers too....do you have a Tim Allen? On the side of the polished chrome head, in large caps is "RRR".
Marv
Ahhhhhhhh Yes, Artifact........
Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away
>Bill does make a excellent point, and one I certainly didn't I must confess. With that said, it seems that a whole new level as been put into old tools/rust hunting. Does this make the slope steeper or slipperier? Which is higher, Artifact or Relic? Oh me,oh my the new Light is so blinding. This will cause much late night contemplations I can forsee. ;~)
Marv, don't feel to badly, as my Ignorance Meter too a pretty hard hit as well. ;~)
Well, if I don't get to those pics my arse might take a pretty hard hit from Walt. :~O
T.O.
Blinded by the Light
Re: Tools vs. artifacts
Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX
>The reason these saws and those by Yataiki can command such a price is based on their superior performance. Without that, theyd be just some saws.
Pam
And if you can't afford those... *LINK*
Rob Lee
>... there are some hammers also up ...
Can't seem to find the $2000 set of matching handles though....
Cheers -
Rob
Hammers,,,
True-Value?
Marv
>Pam,
Besides cutting on the pull stroke, what specifically can they do that any properly sharpened western saw can't do, that justifies such a difference in value?
Other than sawing ability, the value will often be established by nothing other than someone with piles of money who is willing to pay any amount no matter what the asking price is. This drives the price out of reach for we common folk and might have little or nothing to do with actual superiority of the tool. It's mainly about who has the most marbles. IMO, anyone who pays 8K for five saws has pretty much lost their marbles, so to speak.
Marv
Rob, you'll be sending Marv around the bend
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
>Remember, Marv: ARTIFACTS. Their value has little to do with actual utility as hammers. These are art pieces, no longer tools.
It's thoughtful of this seller to throw in free shipping. If I had just paid enough to furnish my entire shop and have money left over for a year's supply of furniture wood, I'd be kinda resentful if I had to pay the additional $10 for shipping.... (teasing, teasing!)
Re: True-Value?
wilbur
>Marv,
Try substituting "chest of drawers made by Krenov with solid Claro walnut with birdseye maple inlay, hand cut dovetail joinery, and hand rubbed oil finish" for "Miyano Tetsunosuke II saws" and "Ikea furniture" for "western saws", and you'll get an idea as to why this set of saws may command such a price. Both pieces of furniture will hold clothes. One will be much more expensive than the other. Many people won't see why one should even consider buying the former, or think that anyone who would must be lacking some amount of sense.
As far as function, it is true that there are many ways to saw a straight line with japanese or western saws. I haven't had the experience of using such a high end saw as this Tetsunosuke saw set, but I have used a hand made Japanese saw. Think of the difference between a really smoothly opening drawer operating on ball bearings and a basic sliding mechanism. Both will open a drawer, one will be much more pleasant to use, and the other may open the drawer, but may bind up a bit. It's up to you as to whether that is worth the price of the tool. Again, there are people who think that one would be silly to spend more than Ikea prices on furniture.
One thing I always think of when I read discussions on the cost of tools (Japanese vs. western, Sawstop vs. Grizzly), is that I can't think of a woodworker that has a problem justifying the price of a hand made piece of furniture, yet there are some that will gripe about the cost of a hand made tool. Same idea, different object.
Re: And if you can't afford those...
wilbur
>Actually, for these sorts of saws and hammers, often the person buying such a tool will be wanting to make their own handle as well. Think of our turning colleagues who buy unhandled gouges.
Re: True-Relative-Value?
MikeW
>Looked at another way, the saws are $1600 each.
Now, I can see the sputtering already, Marv. And I understand it. I really do.
Early in 2007 I made a 28" rip saw for someone. Because of their disposition towards Japanese saws/tools, I thought I would honor them by making a sen and use it for the tapering. Probably even introduced a slight hollow, I don't know. It was, to say the least, a lot of work. But it was an incredible experience, one that I will repeat in the future.
When I look at those saws Denis posted, I have a small inkling of the work involved (to say nothing of the skill involved). If you looked at the teeth, you would be amazed at the filing job I suspect--aside from the geometry of the teeth.
Those things and more (like the hardening/tempering process, the finish on the blades following all the whacking with a hammer, etc.) are what I see when I look at those saws.
If I had charged a $15/hr wage for the 28" saw I mentioned, it would have been easily 50% greater cost. Now I can go faster with better results (with apologies to that owner) But the point is the same.
The skill and result is what I see. What would be wonderful is to experience how they saw. I have used some vintage refurbed Japanese saws. Top ones are just that.
Even if I could ever approach being as good on a Japanese saw, just what do you think I would charge?
Take care, Mike
Making handles
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
>Probably not from recycled broken shovel handles.
Grunt, grunt, grunt...
Scott Burr in cold Ben Lomond, CA
>As a matter of fact, I don't. I almost picked one up.