Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

A new low in tool making.

Posts

Re: A new low in tool making.

#26

Re: The problem with DaBay is

joel -( tools for working wood)

>If you need a 1/2 set of hollows and rounds the best place to get them is in England. harlequin sets in good shape are common, matched sets in good shape are easy to get too, just cost more. Just call up any decent English dealer and ask them.

Re: A new low in tool making.

#27

Re: Not that I'm advocating it but. . .

Dave Mount

>If one was driven to do it, I don't think it is that unreasonable to think about filing a taper into a molding iron blank. Recall that the vast majority of the depth that must be removed is on the narrow tang, and not all of the flag needs to be tapered anyway, only to the tip of the wedge. A coarse file can cut pretty fast, and draw filing to a pretty flat surface is not that hard. For that matter, many of the vintage molding plane irons I've seen are not that incredibly flat anyway. Assuming one is starting with flat ground stock, you can have the machined face be the one against the bed, and the wood in the wedge can take up some uneveness. You would probably need to construct some kind of fixture to hold the iron while you filed it. Again, I'm not advocating it, but I don't think it would really be that hard to do.

Now the hacksawing approach, that I too have trouble envisioning. . .

Best,

Dave

Re: A new low in tool making.

#28

Re: For that price...

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>Well certainly there are advantages and disadvantages to buying a vintage set, or making your own. The biggest advantage I can see is that not all folks simply have that kind of money to spend all at once for a nice set, not to mention taking a gamble of them being not quite up to what the seller describes them to be, either thru purposeful misinformation or ignorance. In a case like this the reputation of the seller is of utmost concern no doubt.

I just posted the link to add fuel to the fire truth be told. ;~)

T.O.

Re: A new low in tool making.

#29

Even with the...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>Dollar so low in value compared to the Pound? Add in shipping and I have a feeling it would be pretty pricey, or am I wrong?

Re: A new low in tool making.

#30

Re: Even with the...

Joel

>A few months ago Ray Iles was selling matched 1/2 sets of hollows and rounds for about US$800 with the dollar so low it would be more like 950-$1000 an unmatched harlequin set would be about half.

If I didn't have a brand new set of MArples hollows and rounds from about 1900 I would be getting on the queue for a set from Clark and Williams. tool making can be fun but I would rather a set made by a professional planemaker than a set made by a beginning part-time toolmaker (me). There is a reason why planemaking was one of the first identifiable toolmaking professions that was primarily woodworking - it's easy to make an OK plane but to get them to professional performance isn't easy.

Re: A new low in tool making.

#31

I would agree

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>That people are funny. It is simply amazing what people will spend money on. I heard once of a guy who actually bought one of those tools to make a curved rabbet by hand. I can't imagine ever needing one of those ;)

Re: A new low in tool making.

#32

Different strokes *LINK*

David Barnett - SW Florida

>"Maybe I'm missing something here..."

Tapering, not skewing, but that's not so hard, either.

"I'm not sure that I could get my hacksaw to do anything like an approximation of tapering a 1/8-inch thick blank to a 1/16-1/8 taper over a 7-inch length. If you can use a hacksaw to resaw a 1/8-inch blank in this way, my hat is off to you."

I'm guessing you've never tried this. Of course, I'd never even consider starting with 1/8" thick stock to do this, nor would I likely use precision ground tool steel. By the way, you'd be surprised how quickly you can saw O1 with a hacksaw or jeweler's sawframe and the right blade, but I'd likely use a bandsaw for multiples. I was pretty much limiting my discussion to hand tools that one might already own, but as I mentioned, an angle grinder or 1" x 42" belt sander would also do nicely for the tapering. Forging would, of course, be a direct and economical way to make irons from scratch.

"As for a file - you are talking about filing away fully 1/2 of the material in the original blank, and it needs to be done with some precision if you want the blade to bed at all well, and continue to do so as the blade is shortened with repeated sharpening."

Files are perfect for this. Why do think this is hard? Do you have experience with hand filing? I've filed stone carving tools from heavy stock with files. It takes awhile, sure, but it's not terribly slow nor physically demanding.

"I imagine the price of files you would need to frequently replace alone would almost offset the cost of the LN blanks..."

A factory sharp 12" file will do a set of H&R irons in the 2 through 8 sizes. Send it to Boggs for sharpening and you can finish the big pairs and do a another set of small and mediums. I've got files -- lots of files -- that I've had for years and there's still life in 'em.

"...and the 2 hours or so it would take at a minimum for a pair of blades is nowhere near worth it to me."

That's entirely understandable. I'm not saying the L-N blanks aren't worthwhile. I'm just making the point that they're doable for not a lot of money in a home shop equipped with simple tooling, can be fun and satisfying to make (remember, many here are touting that very reason for making moulders), and for a personal set of H&Rs, it's an appropriate approach.

For convenience the L-N irons are obviously unbeatable for making new moulders. For replacements, maybe not so convenient, but a place to start. And some folks just don't enjoy metalwork, and that's fine. I'm just suggesting alternatives. Options are empowering and offer other learnings.

"I considered any number of ways to do this when I was making my H&R's, and finally decided it was definitely a job for someone with a surface grinder."

A surface grinder is overkill, IMHO -- at least for a few irons.

Filing is a useful skill* and it doesn't always have to be freehand. Jigs, filing forms and creative fixturing can make the work easier and highly accurate. With even simple filing, though, you can make nice knives and hand tools with nothing more than a jeweler's saw, a couple files and some sandpaper. A drill is helpful, too, as is a vise.

"Every machinist I've seen weigh in on the subject agreed - and they also all agreed the LN price was fair to say the least."

Ah... I think that explains a lot.

*Lindsay used to offer a book or two on vise work with hand tools; filing, scraping, lapping. Get their catalog as the website only lists some of their titles.


Lindsay's Technical Books

Re: A new low in tool making.

#33

Tony routinely sells harlequin sets for $450.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>

Re: A new low in tool making.

#34

Re: Tapering.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Larry W makes a compelling argument that this is critical to ease of setting and use of these planes, and with my gaged (non-tapered) blades I see exactly what he means.

I don't understand this. How does setting your untapered blades differ?

Pam

Re: A new low in tool making.

#35

Re: Tapering.

Raney

>Pam,

I was looking for a post from Larry that I believe I saw at one time that went into some detail on this, but my googling ability is not at its best today... I have been trying to write up my 'theory to explain the results' here, but to be honest I think I'm confusing myself more than adding any clarity. Plus, they are essentially the theories of a very inexperienced planemaker, and not particularly experienced wooden plane user. I think I'll humbly avoid muddying the waters any further with my inept explanations.

So I will state only the two things I am certain of here: Larry has stated pretty emphatically that tapered blades are much easier to set, especially for someone new to wedged plane use, owing in large part to the problems that most new users experience due to over-tightening the wedges. More importantly, I have quite clearly noticed that the only tapered blade woodie I own has always seemed much much easier to adjust with sensitivity than any of the other wooden planes I have - including a couple of excellent Knight planes.

With the H&R's I made, the problem seems even more pronounced. Increasing the depth-of-cut, for example, by tapping the tang has the rather annoying side-effect of tightening the wedge fit even more. This is even more annoying when trying to remove the blades completely... which I needed to do extensively during bedding and final fitting. I think the reasons why this would not be a problem with tapered blades is somewhat self-evident. Whether this is the only, or even most significant, reason for my observations is up for debate.

I apologize that I don't have a better reply to back up my prior statements, but I would rather admit that I'm at the end of my understanding and ability to explain than try to bolster my case by communicating through a more 'unseemly' orifice.

If I can locate Larry's posts on this, I will forward them on forthrightly.

Re: A new low in tool making.

#36

stepping in front of a train here

Larry Williams

>I know speaking out against "conventional wisdom" isn't likely to have much impact but I'm going to climb up on my soap-box and do it anyway.

As I have read the various woodworking forums on the Internet over the years, I've become increasingly aware of how little understanding of wooden planes there is out there. This is just as true for bench planes as molding plane but I'm talking about molding planes here. There are so many misconceptions about these tools and I certainly had most of them myself before I started really studying them.

People tend to think of wooden planes as primitive or crude. The reality is that the tools are as highly evolved and sophisticated as the furniture and woodwork they produced. You don't build the Hubble telescope or a Philadelphia highboy with a flint ax.

Another misconception is that all these planes are the same. Not true, there's as much difference between mid 18th Century molding planes and their later counterparts as there is between a Norris smooth plane and Shelton's version. The reality is that there was a steady decline in quality of molding planes after at least the very early 1800's. The falling quality over time is even more dramatic than the decline in Stanley planes after WWII. For the most part, American wooden planes never matched the quality of the British planes and American planes declined in quality a lot faster than did the British planes. Continental planes lacked the more sophisticated features developed in Great Britain in the very late 1600's and early 1700's. Spring, leaning wedges and boxing are examples of these early British refinements. 18th Century British planes are probably the best and most refined ever made.

If you examine 19th and 20th Century planes compared to 18th Century planes there are several compromises that become easily apparent. Every one of the compromises I see were developed to ease production. I can't find a single one that represents an improvement.

One of the first things plane makers did was to standardize wedge thickness and reduce the number of thicknesses used. For example an 18th Century half set of hollows and rounds will have nine different wedge thicknesses that range from about 1/8" to 1/2" and a mid 19th Century set will have three thicknesses from 1/4" to 3/8". The smaller sizes of planes have to be thicker to accommodate the thicker wedges and this makes the planes feel clumsy and awkward while also reducing the feedback one wants when doing the fine work these planes were intended to use. The bigger planes suffer from lower quality bedding by the limited size of the wedge. Compromising wedge thickness leads to all kinds of problems. The best analogy I can think of is hammers. The thicker wedge in the smaller sizes is like putting a framing hammer handle in a jeweler's hammer--it defeats the use of the jewelers hammer. Likewise putting a handle for a jewelers hammer in a framing hammer results in a hammer that just won't do the job and this is similar to what happens with a 3/8" thick wedge in a #18 plane. The mortises for the thinner wedges are the most difficult to make and the thicker wedges which can't flex at all are the most difficult to fit. Plane makers just eliminated these to ease production.

There are some out there today who suggest just using 1/4" thick wedges for all molding planes. I think this is nothing more than compounding the mistakes of 19th and 20th Century plane makers in an effort to allow using a modern mortising machine to make the wedge mortises.

Plane makers also shortened the upper grip area of the planes to speed making mortises. The grips don't have to be shortened much to make producing the mortises a lot easier. Removing 1/4" or so from the narrow end of these tapered mortises opens things up quite a bit. The down side is that this moves the effective wedge pressure point up the bed, away from the mouth. This reduces the quality of the bedding of the iron.

To overcome the weaknesses these compromises create in holding the iron plane makers moved to thicker irons. Thicker irons are good--Right? Well, no. The profile of a molding plane iron resides on, is created on, and must be maintained on the bevel. Because of the geometry, each little bit added to the thickness adds a lot more to the size of the bevel. This makes sharpening and maintaining these irons a lot more difficult. We use nine different grinders in our shops and have worked on making creating and sharpening profiled irons as quick and easy as possible. Even with our investment, when I look at one of those thick irons, I'm very happy I don't have to deal with them. I have little doubt the reason so many of those later planes have badly scarred escapements from clearing chokes is because those thick irons are so difficult to properly sharpen.

When we started making planes, I had visions of making improvements. The reality is that all these years later the one improvement we made was inadvertent and I didn't even realize the advantage for a long time. We decided to try to buy our way out of the learning curve of blacksmithing and machine our irons. In hindsight the learning curve was probably about the same either way and we probably took the more expensive path. The machined irons have a uniform predictable taper and hand forged irons are pretty irregular. This irregularity created problems for early plane makers and most early planes I've seen have irons which were bent in the middle of the bit. They were bent so that the back of the iron is concave and this forces the iron near the cutting edge into the bed. This reduces the effective life of the iron by at least half and probably more. Each sharpening changes the bedding quality of the iron slightly.

Almost every feature of an 18th Century molding plane is functional. If you look at later planes you'll find that nearly every one of those features were compromised for ease of production or to lower production costs. Years ago, when Bill and I were first trying to put together a good working set of British planes I was thrilled when we were able to buy an unused half set of early 20th Century Griffiths hollows and rounds and a near new condition set of 9 ca. 1900 Greenslade side beads. Because of their condition and collector value we never did tune these up and use them. I looked at them again yesterday afternoon and, with a lot more knowledge, the compromises those planes represent leave me feeling a little hollow. Yes, with deep pockets it may be possible to put together a really working good set of 18th Century planes; but I wonder if 200+ year-old artifacts should really be used.

There's a lot about the irons Lie-Nielsen is offering that isn't apparent at a glance. Each is properly proportioned to work with an 18th Century style plane needing a bit width of about 1/16" or 1/8" less than the width of any given iron. Nothing about the dimensions of the irons is arbitrary. I'm confident that the more people learn about traditional molding planes the more they'll appreciate LN's irons. It wasn't inexpensive for them to get these out and sure hope a lot of people recognize the opportunity to benefit from it.

We spent a lot of years reverse engineering these incredible tools and repeatedly pouring over sparse written records of how to make and use them. Thomas Lie-Nielsen has invested a significantly in helping us package that information and put into production the more difficult to make tools and irons. A lot of effort has gone into putting owning and using these within the reach of everyday woodworkers. I'll be interested to see what becomes of it all.

Re: A new low in tool making.

#37

Re: Different strokes

Raney

>David,

That was a very helpful post - thank you. I think I understand your points a little better now. I still think it's a job I personally wouldn't want to undertake, mainly because I don't much like working metal, but I did some thinking about how to jig a blank for the sort of filing you describe, and I see your points.

Also, the 'resaw' with a jeweler's blade akes my forehead hurt just thinking about it, but you are absolutely right that knowing the possibilities and options is always better...

Re: A new low in tool making.

#38

Re: Removing irons

Dave Mount

>Morning Raney--

This is a sidebar, but you mentioned tapping the tang down to remove an untapered molding plane iron. I don't remove mine that way, I do it by withdrawing the wedge. Hold the plane in one hand with that hand cradling the top of the plane and a finger against thefront of the wedge. Then tap the rear end of the plane sharply with a wood mallet. You'll feel immediately when the wedge friction breaks. Make sure you do something to keep the iron from falling out on the floor, either hold the plane so the iron is parallel to the floor or keep a finger on the tang (DAMHIKT).

Best,

Dave

Re: A new low in tool making.

#39

Re: stepping in front of a train here

Paul Kierstead

>Thank you very much for posting that. I would be deeply interested in seeing all that information you have captured written down this time, so it won't get lost so easily again. Plus it is pretty interesting stuff.

As a matter of interest, we can see how an increasing orientation towards production could have impacted their manufacture, but how does decreasing demand (and use) due to mechanized production play into it? Or even, for that matter, how does a move to less ornamental woodwork play into it? We need to convince some budding historian (anthropologist?) to spend their Ph.D. on this...

Re: A new low in tool making.

#42

Re: Tapering.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>I like tapered irons a lot, use a huge percentage of Japanese planes; but those irons are tapered from edge to top (thickest). Are the tangs of the molding plane blades tapered that way? Or the reverse? Or are they biggest below the tang and taper to a smaller thickness at the tang top?

Pam

Re: A new low in tool making.

#43

Funny

Todd Hughes

>but the boat builder that I outbid on that 196 plane was talking to me about it the other week, told me he was cutting a rabbet around a boat cabin and that plane would have been perfect for this job. Wanted to know if I still had it....Couldn't help myself and told him I sold it and what it brought.....I think he will find another tool to use.....Todd

Re: A new low in tool making.

#44

Wedge width

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Thanks for the information on hollows and rounds. This evening I found myself in the shop measuring my own motley collection which I have used for several decades. I have seven different wedge widths from 3/16 to 1/2. Perhaps this indicates that I have some older planes. I have to say that I never considered this an important feature. I can 't see how making the wedge 5/16 instead of 1/4 or 3/8 makes as big a difference as many other factors.

One feature that I like on my planes is the laminated iron. Because I often do production work with my planes (I have no moulder or shaper or router), I am keenly aware of sharpening time and I appreciate that laminated blades are easier to sharpen. I have noticed that latter day makers often use all steel irons. Is this a compromise to ease production and cut costs?

Re: A new low in tool making.

#45

Re: stepping in front of a train here

Gary Karner

>Thanks so much for the information, I have a question. I have a matching 1/2 set of York pitched skewed H & R's made by T Turner, Queen Street, Sheffield, Am I supposed to believe that they are inferior planes because the Wedges are only three sizes.

I have measured the Wedge on the #2's and yes they are a fully a 1/4 wide but I must say that they do still seem to be a delicate and very accurate instrument.

maybe I could buy a new set of H & R's from Clark and Williams, pay more than three times what I paid for my set, and wait up to a Year and half to get them, but would I really have a set of planes that would do that much better than the set that I have now.

Re: A new low in tool making.

#46

Thank You

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ontario

>Thank You Larry,

I have copied your post and saved it to my file on wood planes. I learnt a great deal from you here, I have been looking at a hollows and rounds and doing some reading but I just learnt more in your post than I had known.

Merry Christmas,

Jim

I sent you an email via your web site a few weeks ago, not sure if you recieved it.

Re: A new low in tool making.

#47

Re: Tony routinely sells harlequin sets for $450.

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ontario

>Hi Pam,

Tony Who?

:-)

Thank You,

Merry Christmas,

Jim

Re: A new low in tool making.

#48

Thank you Thomas and Larry

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Larry

Thank you for your detailed reply (above). It confirms that there is always more involved in situations such as these than meets the eye. The investment that lays behind the (what might be considerd a simple) DVD and set of irons is quite considerable.

First of all there are the years of experience and critical examination that determined the design of both the plane(s) and the iron(s). Your DVD is excellent and clear and sets a easy model to follow for amateur toolmakers like myself.

Secondly, there is the investment made by Thomas in making the irons available. There can't be a lot of money in this. The population is too small. I did exchange a few emails with Thomas before their release, and his pride in the achievement was very evident.

Building these planes is not about saving money. Building these planes is about pleasure and achievement.

I already have a half set of H&R planes. They probably date back to the first quarter of last century. Your DVD will help me restore them correctly (I have used some for several years, but now I know that they could be better).

I plan to make more complex molding planes as well as a couple of dado planes. The LN irons will be perfect for this task.

Thomas asked me for my opinion of the DVD(s) and I promised that I would publish something in the future. This will have to wait until after February (possible even March as we will be renovating at home in the New Year), but I am looking forward to creating historically correct planes. Can you help with designs of dado planes?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: A new low in tool making.

#49

Re: Tony routinely sells harlequin sets for $450. *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Tony Murland. BTW, I noticed a set for $395 on his site last night.

Pam


Tony Murland's old tools

Re: A new low in tool making.

#50

Re: stepping in front of a train here

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Very interesting, Larry, thanks. How do tapered blades fit into this scheme? How are the blades tapered (in which direction)?

Pam