Different strokes *LINK*
David Barnett - SW Florida
>"Maybe I'm missing something here..."
Tapering, not skewing, but that's not so hard, either.
"I'm not sure that I could get my hacksaw to do anything like an approximation of tapering a 1/8-inch thick blank to a 1/16-1/8 taper over a 7-inch length. If you can use a hacksaw to resaw a 1/8-inch blank in this way, my hat is off to you."
I'm guessing you've never tried this. Of course, I'd never even consider starting with 1/8" thick stock to do this, nor would I likely use precision ground tool steel. By the way, you'd be surprised how quickly you can saw O1 with a hacksaw or jeweler's sawframe and the right blade, but I'd likely use a bandsaw for multiples. I was pretty much limiting my discussion to hand tools that one might already own, but as I mentioned, an angle grinder or 1" x 42" belt sander would also do nicely for the tapering. Forging would, of course, be a direct and economical way to make irons from scratch.
"As for a file - you are talking about filing away fully 1/2 of the material in the original blank, and it needs to be done with some precision if you want the blade to bed at all well, and continue to do so as the blade is shortened with repeated sharpening."
Files are perfect for this. Why do think this is hard? Do you have experience with hand filing? I've filed stone carving tools from heavy stock with files. It takes awhile, sure, but it's not terribly slow nor physically demanding.
"I imagine the price of files you would need to frequently replace alone would almost offset the cost of the LN blanks..."
A factory sharp 12" file will do a set of H&R irons in the 2 through 8 sizes. Send it to Boggs for sharpening and you can finish the big pairs and do a another set of small and mediums. I've got files -- lots of files -- that I've had for years and there's still life in 'em.
"...and the 2 hours or so it would take at a minimum for a pair of blades is nowhere near worth it to me."
That's entirely understandable. I'm not saying the L-N blanks aren't worthwhile. I'm just making the point that they're doable for not a lot of money in a home shop equipped with simple tooling, can be fun and satisfying to make (remember, many here are touting that very reason for making moulders), and for a personal set of H&Rs, it's an appropriate approach.
For convenience the L-N irons are obviously unbeatable for making new moulders. For replacements, maybe not so convenient, but a place to start. And some folks just don't enjoy metalwork, and that's fine. I'm just suggesting alternatives. Options are empowering and offer other learnings.
"I considered any number of ways to do this when I was making my H&R's, and finally decided it was definitely a job for someone with a surface grinder."
A surface grinder is overkill, IMHO -- at least for a few irons.
Filing is a useful skill* and it doesn't always have to be freehand. Jigs, filing forms and creative fixturing can make the work easier and highly accurate. With even simple filing, though, you can make nice knives and hand tools with nothing more than a jeweler's saw, a couple files and some sandpaper. A drill is helpful, too, as is a vise.
"Every machinist I've seen weigh in on the subject agreed - and they also all agreed the LN price was fair to say the least."
Ah... I think that explains a lot.
*Lindsay used to offer a book or two on vise work with hand tools; filing, scraping, lapping. Get their catalog as the website only lists some of their titles.
Lindsay's Technical Books