Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

A new low in tool making.

Posts

A new low in tool making.

#1

A new low in tool making.

Paul Kierstead

>I bought a new set of these irons from Lie-Nielsen. I am very disappointed. Not only did then not arrive sharp, but once sharpened they lost their edge almost immediately! I am very disappointed.

Re: A new low in tool making.

#2

Jim in Burlington Ont.

They are annealed

Jim in Burlington On

>You still need to be hardened then sharpened. The reason they are soft is because you still need to tweak the final shape before hardening.

Re: A new low in tool making.

#3

Re: They are annealed

Dean J in MN

>Sarcasm just doesn't translate well on a message board does it? :-)

Re: A new low in tool making.

#4

Here's how to harden them

Peter Berglund

>It's not too difficult:

Hardening O-1 Tool Steel

-Peter

Re: A new low in tool making.

#5

My Apologies ...

Paul Kierstead

>It was meant as a joke, and to highlight what appears to be a great new product. As Dean says, the sarcasm doesn't translate well.

I am pretty stoked about these coming to market; I really love to see this encouragement of making tools, instead of buy buy buy. I'll be lined up to buy these. OK I know that sounds wrong ... but getting tapered irons otherwise could be more then a little difficult and I really want to make a couple of planes.

Re: A new low in tool making.

#6

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: A new low in tool making.

Jack Guzman from Maine

>I had no idea they offered those.That's going to make it alot easier for me to get started on my set of hollows and rounds. Thank's for bringing it to our attention.---Jack

P.S. those are made from special,easy to sharpen steel,it's a new technology

Re: A new low in tool making.

#7

For that price...

Todd Hughes

>you could very easly buy a complete original antique molding plane in excellent condition with a good blade already hardened and tempered and ready to work.

Even on the ebay I don't think many good hollow or rounds go for much more then what just these unfinished irons are being sold for [Looks like $15-$26 each]

Again why would sombody want to pay the same for a blade which they then have to shape, harden and temper and then make an entire plane for befor using then just buy an excellent condition ready to use plane for about the same price?...Whats next,.. tooth pick kits where they sell you a 2X4 eh?

I guess if you have a good plane with a good profile that has lost it's iron somthing like this might have a purpose but how many are getting sold for that I wonder? ...Todd

Re: A new low in tool making.

#8

Jack Guzman from Maine

My reason

Jack Guzman from Maine

>I can't say for anyone else Todd,but the reason I will jump at that deal is this. I enjoy making tools.I decided the best way to get decent hollows and rounds is to make my own. I'm not a metal worker. I work with wood. As fun as it looks to make my own irons,I'm not set up for it.Instead of purchasing iron from a source I'm not familiar with,hacksawing to width,shape;all I need do is puchase LN's irons grind hone and anneal.(not particularly in that order)This resource makes it more likely that I will actually get this project off the round toit list and make it happen.

I've been purchasing cheap used hollows and rounds for 3 or more years now and still don't have much to work with. The ideal solution, purchase a decent new set from a reputable maker,is financially impossible.So my solution is to make my own and Lie Lielsen just made it easier.---Jack

Re: A new low in tool making.

#9

Re: For that price...

Dan Donaldson

>I would guess that in many cases, the cost is not really a factor. Many just enjoy making the tools and economics really doesn't matter. A lot of the things that I make, I could probably buy cheaper, especially considering the cost of the tools that I bought to make them.

Re: A new low in tool making.

#10

Re: My reason

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>First, I applaud LN for these blades and the new dvds by Larry and Don. However, look at the small amount of work/tool cost you're saving. The only tasks you avoid are hack sawing and knowing something about the correct sizes. Granted, these blades will get you started with less grunt work.

Pam

Re: A new low in tool making.

#11

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: My reason-also...

Jack Guzman from Maine

>I don't know if you realize this but,the ease of finding used planes you speak of doesn't exist for me.My ebay experience is limited,as is my flea market hunting.I spend only a few minutes checking ebay per session.If I happen upon a flea market in passing I will stop by if I have time. Some of the planes I have bought turned out to be less than ideal.I have two blades from a wide hollow set that I'm still working on grinding to get past the edge pitting.I just don't wish to invest my time in this manner.---Jack

Re: A new low in tool making.

#12

Re: For that price...

Paul Kierstead

>Give the capital costs, woodworking is a pretty hopeless endeavor for the home woodworker (me), financially speaking. You would have to make some pretty outstanding stuff to offset the costs in most cases, let alone the labour. In most cases we would be better of buying the finished product anyway.

I enjoy making stuff. One would have to be pretty dim to think that making a woody is cheaper then buying one used.

If life was just an exercise in base economics, where the goal was to gain as much stuff as possible for the least possible price, I'd have to consider giving up on it; that would be a very miserable life for me.

As an extra little push for me is that I don't see all these high quality H&R's from trustworthy dealers out there. I'm not so good at finding bargains on eBay and the better dealers do not let them go for a song.

Re: A new low in tool making.

#13

Tapering.

Paul Kierstead

>

Re: A new low in tool making.

#14

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: My reason

Jack Guzman from Maine

>Pam,I think the major advantage is in actually getting started.I balk at hacksawing a piece of iron in a vice.I have never enjoyed that particular operation.The thought of that alone will stop me from finding the beech to get the plane making project started.It's about motivation.There are many other things that need doing. I just move on and it never gets done.---Jack

Re: A new low in tool making.

#15

Re: Tapering.

Raney

>Yup - this is the big advantage. I made a pair of H&R's from Larry W's DVD last month, and the hacksawing of O1 is certainly no big deterrent... the tapering of the blades, however, IS. Larry W makes a compelling argument that this is critical to ease of setting and use of these planes, and with my gaged (non-tapered) blades I see exactly what he means.

I spoke to a machinist friend of mine about tapering a sheet of O1 for me to cut blanks out of and he said that it would cost much much more to taper these on a surface grinder than the cost of the blades from LN. He was a bit surprised they could do them this cheaply. (he does machining for a vast number of companies, Boeing included, so he's not an inexperienced source).

As I understand it, C&W intend to start using these blanks for their planes as well, which I think speaks pretty highly of them.

Raney

Re: A new low in tool making.

#16

Angle grinding? How 'bout a large file?

David Barnett - SW Florida

>Really. Discounting blacksmithing (not everyone has a forge) and eschewing angle grinders and vertical belt sanders, a file does the job nicely on annealed O1. You can saw to an appoximate taper, too.

Filing can even be enjoyable. Sanding sticks can be helpful, as well.

Re: A new low in tool making.

#17

What ever happened to....

Todd Hughes

>to not wanting to spend time and effert getting tools ready to work? Seems I am always being treated to hearing that one of the big advantage LN tools have over original planes and why they are bought is that they are ready to use out of the box instead of taking time and effert having to "tune" that vintage Stanley. Never mind that most original Stanleys could be cleaned up and put back to work in less then half hour seems many wood workers don't want to take the time or feel they can do this simple work.

... Now you have to finish these blades they sell, harden and temper it THEN make the body and wedge etc. for it....and I hear that people really like to spend time and effert after all getting thier planes ready to use....even if you have to make the entire plane!....Just kind of funny to me I guess......Todd

Re: A new low in tool making.

#18

Re: For that price... *LINK*

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>Too much for my blood.

I'd say make your own if you don't put a dollar value on your free time, which I don't.

T.O.


Recent e-bay offerings

Re: A new low in tool making.

#19

Re: What ever happened to....

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>When I first started using hand planes I first tried the old Stanley route. I wasn't able to get them to work. It was important that I bought the LN LA jack, taught me a lot about planing; and when I got into Japanese planes I was more confident in using them and, ultimately, making them. I refuse to apologize for this, moving from absolute failure for months to absolute success in a week. I still hate Stanley bench planes and will probably never buy another one.

Pam

Re: A new low in tool making.

#20

Re: What ever happened to....

Paul Kierstead

>Seems I am always being treated to hearing that one of the big advantage LN tools have over original planes and why they are bought is that they are ready to use out of the box instead of taking time and effert having to "tune" that vintage Stanley.

What on earth does some users preference for LN (or LV, or any other for that matter) planes have to do with some users enjoyment of building tools? You do realize there are more then one or two people here, right? And that each and every one of them are individuals with individual interests?

Re: A new low in tool making.

#21

Not to mention I friggin hate metalwork,

Paul Kierstead

>But actually I do have a soft spot for old Stanleys.

Metal work and wood work are different.

Building and fixing are different.

Re: A new low in tool making.

#22

Re: Angle grinding? How 'bout a large file?

Raney

>Maybe I'm missing something here - are you talking about skewing a blade? Cause thickness-tapering a 1/8-inch blank doesn't seem like anything I'd ever want to do by hand.

I'm not sure that I could get my hacksaw to do anything like an approximation of tapering a 1/8-inch thick blank to a 1/16-1/8 taper over a 7-inch length. If you can use a hacksaw to resaw a 1/8-inch blank in this way, my hat is off to you.

As for a file - you are talking about filing away fully 1/2 of the material in the original blank, and it needs to be done with some precision if you want the blade to bed at all well, and continue to do so as the blade is shortened with repeated sharpening. I imagine the price of files you would need to frequently replace alone would almost offset the cost of the LN blanks, and the 2 hours or so it would take at a minimum for a pair of blades is nowhere near worth it to me.

I considered any number of ways to do this when I was making my H&R's, and finally decided it was definitely a job for someone with a surface grinder. Every machinist I've seen weigh in on the subject agreed - and they also all agreed the LN price was fair to say the least.

Re: A new low in tool making.

#23

Re: For that price...

Todd Hughes

>If you bought the un finished LN blade blanks to make that set of 25 vintage complete planes that sold for $750 and which look awful nice it would cost you around $500 just for these blades. Imagine the wood must cost something too...lets just say you can get all the correct sawn and dried beech for only $50. So yeah you do save some money making these planes....But you have to make the 25 plane bodies and wedges etc. to save that $200....and will your planes be as nice as these vintage ones when you are done?...Todd

Re: A new low in tool making.

#24

The problem with DaBay is

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>Most wooden planes I see on it are POS's, and if there not they go for $20.00 and up.

How long would it take to assemble a 1/2 yet alone a full set of matched H&R's from ebay?

I'd probably be worm food before that happened.

Re: A new low in tool making.

#25

I'm glad to have read this post...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>Before replying to your first post reguaring these blades. I was all ready to flame your dumb arse good ;^).