We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>I thought about making the pointer type but then the line level on the angle block seemed to be a simpler way to go.
Angle blocks (IMHO) inbcreasingly foul your filing stroke as fleam angle increases. They're certainly simple when filing rip, but when using a fine file, 5" long, and a 25 degree fleam, the block can be most intrusive.
I agree with you. If the block is too big, it does make it a bit combersome so I make smaller blocks for the smaller files. Cut the corners of the block at an angle. This allows the file to be drawn back toward the vise farther. Not having the block out there at the end of the file would be better though.
IMHO...I just don't understand the logic behind varying pitches making a saw cut better. If one tooth with say a 15 degree pitch cuts good, why wouldn't the next tooth with the same pitch cut good also and the third tooth and fourth and so on? The resonance "theory" doesn't make sense to me. I know for sure that I don't get them all precisely the same, but if I could I would.
If the theory is more than a theory, I'm wondering if we purposely filed some teeth at 12 degrees and some teeth at say 18 degrees and some at 15 degrees, and do it at random, how much better would the saw cut? Or instead of 3 degrees difference between one tooth and another, how about 1 degree difference? In other words, how much difference does it take to make the saw cut better or worse for that matter? And also do the same with the bevel angle. And lets mess with the set too.
Actually, come to think of it, alot of saws that I encounter are pretty much filed that way and don't cut worth a damn. When I get through with them, they do.
>Are you referring to hand cut files for metal? Or hand cut rasps for wood? I don't know Pam, from a logical standpoint I just can't go along with the theory. I guess I have to ask the question, is it just a theory or is it a proven fact? Is there a documented scientific study that has been done?
>IMHO...I just don't understand the logic behind varying pitches making a saw cut better. If one tooth with say a 15 degree pitch cuts good, why wouldn't the next tooth with the same pitch cut good also and the third tooth and fourth and so on?
I think we have a jargon problem.
You're talking about "rake" (or slope). I'm talking about pitch (or spacing, or TPI).
I will admit that some old book use pitch to mean slope, but I don't :-)
(other old books use pitch to mean spacing. Sigh)
The beneficial effects of non-equal spacing in avoiding chatter have been widely reported.
Yes, the jargon can be confusing. I usually don't use the word "pitch" when referring to the angle of the cutting side of the tooth. I only used the word "pitch" because you used it and was hoping to be on the same page, jaron-wise.
However, having varying pitch/rake won't change the number of teeth or points per inch. A change of "pitch" can only change from one saw compared to another if we use the word "pitch" in place of TPI or PPI.
YOU SAID.....The beneficial effects of non-equal spacing in avoiding chatter have been widely reported.
When there is non-equal spacing it is due to the rake being different from one tooth to the next. The main reason for chatter, IMO, is due to some teeth being longer than others. When I get chatter, I joint the teeth again and make another pass to get them all even. The chatter goes away. I find that chatter can also occur when sawing wood that has hard grain that is not spaced equally, like in some Douglas Fir for example. Hard grain and soft between the grain. I can use the same saw on soft pine or dense Mahogany, no chatter. The more consistant the teeth are, the smoother the saw will cut. How the saw is used can also cause chatter. Angle of saw when sawing, amount of pressure on the saw. So when someone says their saw chatters, it can be due to many things or a combination.
Am I understanding you correctly or am I still confused? I'm usually confused, so that's pretty much a given. :-))
Chatter occurs when some teeth are taller than others. This means that the teeth are not all at the same height.
It is entirely possible (and in my case extremely likely), that during the filing process some gullets are filed deeper than others. These can be at the exact same rake and fleam angles, but the effect of the gully being deeper than a neighbor can affect the spacing of the tips of the cutting edge. This variance in the spacing between the cutting edges is the beneficial variance that is being referred to here. It does not necessarily require variance in rake or fleam angles to implement this.
Big tooth-little tooth syndrome, as Tom Law refers to it in his video.
You are right. You can file all the teeth with the exact same rake angle and all the teeth are even at the points and still have some gullets deeper than others. The problem with this will cause a problem with the setting of the teeth.
Usually with "big tooth-little tooth syndrome, every other tooth will be shorter. When the teeth are bent, the short tooth will not be bent as much in respect to the side of the blade as the big teeth are.
But this is not what Paul W and I were discussing. We were referring to only varying the rake angle from tooth to tooth. This too can create "Big tooth-little tooth" but it would be more random than if the rake angles were all the same and having different gullet depths.
As for making the saw cut better or prevent chatter with all these variences, I still cannot get my mind around the theory. I guess I went to a different school.
I have no problem with those who feel their saw cuts better with each tooth filed differently. My experience is just the opposite. The closer they are to being the same, the smoother the saw will cut.
>I have no problem with those who feel their saw cuts better with each tooth filed differently. My experience is just the opposite.
Have you actually tried purposefully filing a saw this way? I understand you see lots of saws filed this way that saw badly, but that doesn't mean much; they were probably dull, not jointed, etc. But try out a *good* filing job (where everything else is done "right"); that might be interesting.
Well, no I haven't done it purposefully, however when I was first learning to sharpen handsaws I don't think I filed two teeth the same. Talk about rough sawing!
As time went on and I learned how to file more consistantly the roughness stopped and my saws started sawing smoothly and nearly followed a pencil line on their own.
I took this experience to mean that I should pursue filing all the teeth the same, at least as close as I possibly can. What I am saying here of course, I'm sure I'm not filing each tooth precisely the same. That means there's some variations. So perhaps based on that "fact" the slight variations that will be in every saw that I sharpen is what makes it cut smoothly and straight. Perhaps some conclusions can be drawn from this. But I will continue to be as consistant as I can. I'm pretty sure that anyone who sharpens saws does the same thing. The results will be a matter of degree based on how far from perfect can a sharpened saw be before it does not saw smoothly? What is our point of reference or standard? There are so many aspects to sharpening a saw properly, it is difficult at best to draw any definite conclusions whether or not a saw cuts better only because it's been sharpened by hand.
I don't remember how we got to this point in this discussion. Oh, yeah, I think it had something to do with using a level bubble to control rake angles and also for aiding in edge planing. *grin*