We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>What I know about planes in general could be described on one page. I promise that I won't do it here....
My question has to do with planing a board so it ends up square.
Is there a plane made with a leveling bulb attached crossways? For a beginner, does it make any sense to have a plane that the user could use as reference until he/she developes the natural feel of level or plumb? For it to work, the work surface would have to be level.
If this tool "aid" was available for a beginner, he/she could enjoy earlier success and not have to practise for years to get it right. Or it would be handy for the person who might want to occasionally use a plane for the purpose of squaring a piece of wood.
Marv
PS...Ok, Stephen, go ahead, say it....."balderdash"! *smirk*
>Hold a plane vertically in your hand. If you pay attention to the way it feels as you tilt it you will be able to hold it consistently square after a few minutes of practice
>If the piece is slightly off angle along the length, there are about 8 techniques for correcting it. One of the simplest, that helps build feel, is to simply ensure that you have the plane centered over the high edge, or even outside of it if need be. That way it will be neutral ballance in your hand, rather than conforming to the slople. Another thing you can do is center the plane over the edge and let it conform to the slope. This involves nothing much more than a slight opening of the hand. This will give you a sense of how off level it is.
When you are learning, I would recomend spending a little time with a square and marking the high spots. Over time you can pretty much learn to use the plane sole as a reference for the changes you will need to make through planing, but it can help to identify them a little more slowly when you are starting out.
The problem with stuff like levels is that they encourage you to hold tightly to their movements, a lot of stearing and correction. You want to be able to slump into it. Sorta like the difference between the competant driver not even aware they are sighting down the road, and the cautious beginer trying to line some part of the hood up with the lines of their lane. You don't learn to walk a slack line by carrying a level.
Anyone who can walk has mastered a far greater skill than planing a flat surface.
>I can't say that Marv, I just don't think it would work. A bubble level requires that the bubble is standing fairly still, so movement would bounce the bubble around.
Planes are made square with parallel opposing surfaces for a reason. That is to get a good visual on what is going on as you are planing. Some planes have spring lines to give you a visual orientation.
The feel thing is quite important as others have said. One problem is that most people tend to bevel toward the side they are planing from, a natural tendancy especially with handled planes as the hand holding the handle tends to twist towards the thumb.
This can be compensated for by adding additional pressure with the forward hand on the off side of the front of the plane.
>One other thing that helped me was to edge plane with my eyes closed. That way, the only thing you have to judge how level the plane is is feel and balance. It's surprising how effective this is.
-A level would only help if you knew, without a doubt, that the board was plumb in the vise. Bad vise mounting job, or a bench that isn't level, will prevent you from being able to use such a device.
-Larry Williams makes a good point... there was link in a reply to a thread regarding height of bench planes somewhere south of this post... that the human body is a pretty good judge of plumb and level, if you are familiar with your tools, and can hold them in such a way that will allow you to use your own ability to tell which way is up.
Basically, practice makes perfect. Making sure the vise is plumb will go a long way towards this, but the other thing is practice, and a combination square. Cut your boards a little wide at first, anticipating the need to plane the edges. You might need to take a few passes before you know about what square is.
Or plan a project that incorporates a lot of spring joints. That way you can practice planing square, but not really need a square edge. but planing the boards side by side will mean that it's not really critical that the joint be planed square. So you can practice without as much risk, the project will turn out fine if you can't quite figure out the whole square edge thing. Keep a combination square handy to let you know when you're on, and when you're not, and try to relax enough to absorb what your body tells you is happening, so you can start to feel when you're on, and when you're not.
A third thing to try out, is to plane edges with your fingers hanging off of the edges of the planes, brushing the faces of the board as you move the plane down its length. Use your fingers to get feedback abotu how the plane is behaving. You shoudl be able to be able to tell if you're tipping the plane as you move it along the edge of the board. That'll help you be able to better judge when you're keeping a steady angle. Once you can keep a steady angle, you'll be closer to being able to reliably plane a continuously square edge.
After a while, you'll pick it up, and be able to plane a straight and square edge without thinking too hard about it. In the meantime, practice, practice, practice...
I hate to be the guy to end his post this way, but it's the truth. Sometimes you just have to work to acquire the skill. I do think spring joints are a great tool for practice, just because you'll have to become familiar with your planes, and working on edges, to make a good spring joint.
I know, from listening to your other posts, that you're worried about using your time to the best effect. Once in a while, I think it's ok to just work. Sometimes the outcome works out the way you planned. Sometimes, it doesn't, and you have to work with what you get, and really, that's ok. But most of the time, the real joy of the hand tool work is in learning, at any age, and at any time, to commune with your body, and your muscles, and to gain confidence in your mind's ability to affect and effect your world, through your hands. I'm only 33, and I'm sure that I'll see things differently as I age. But I don't think that anyone is too old to rediscover the joy of learning. try to let go of the pressure from worrying about the project, and relax enough to allow the skill set to sink in. It's ok to be a little selfish, and to spend half of the effort on the project, and half of the effort on learning the new skill.
Relax. Feel what the plane is doing. Any hand tool will give you some sort of feedback, but you do need to learn to receive it, and put that feedback to use. Once you're able to do that, you'll be able to plane whatever sort of edge you need. Keep working, keep trying. The skills will come in time.
>There's nothing keeping anyone from gluing/double taping a small level, perhaps one of those round ones, to a plane. Photographers do this all the time with their view cameras. However, I doubt it's the panacea you're seeking since many times it's necessary to hold the plane out of level to gain a straight result on the piece.
> For a beginner, does it make any sense to have a plane that the user could use as reference until he/she developes the natural feel of level or plumb?
No. Not as a matter of principle, but I don't see how one could utilise such an indicator during such a dynamic movement as a plane stroke. Further, I don't think a bubble would stabilise quickly enough during a plane stroke. Further, a plane actually has NO CHOICE about how it sits on a work surface. You achieve flatness in the workpiece by choosing WHERE each stroke is made, and how long it is, not by levelling the tool w.r.t to some absolute reference.
Yes, "edge" planing. Like after hand ripping a 1 x 10 for example. Clamp it on edge and square up the top edge. Or a 2 x 2 and square both directions so it ends up being exactly 2 inches by 2 inches and square, not a paralelagram.
Isn't the "hotdog" handle that some people add to their plane for the purpose of squaring the edge of a board?
Regarding the level bubble, I was thinking of it mainly as a reference to establish what level feels like. It wouldn't be meant for the user to stare at while planing. If the work surface is level you could then depend on the level bubble to be dependable. You could see right off approx. how much out of square the work piece is.
Just seems to be a practical means of accomplishing something that should be relatively simple to do with less trial and error. Sort of takes some of the guess work out of the process.
You are right about the bubble not settling quickly, especially on a cheap line level that is sold at Ace hardware stores. That's one reason I say to use it mainly for reference before even taking the first stroke of the plane. Lets you know how much to tilt the plane on the very first stroke and which way to tilt it. If the edge is way out of square, that's real easy to tell by feel but if it's out like 1/64", that might not be felt by a beginner.
Whenever I'm faced with something that is new to me, my mind starts thinking outside the box and thoughts about level bubbles or some other odd ball thing might come to mind. I'm a bid on the lazy side and am always trying to come up with an easier way to do most everything.
If people didn't think in these terms, we would still be smoothing wood with rocks and sand instead of a nice tool like a plane that took years to become what it is now, along with it's many variations.
This forum is great in that it allows people with similar interests to brain storm new ideas. Often times a seemingly silly idea will spark a great idea from someone else.
It's much appreciated and enjoyable to receive the kind of responses I have experienced here. It's mostly all good positive stuff, some of what keeps the internet in balance with all the negative things that are going on.
Thanks to everybody who has offered their expertise in your reponses to my post.
>Thank you James for your generous sharing of your thoughts and expertise.
I attach a line level to my angle block when filing handsaws to control my rake angles. It works very well for maintaining consistant rake angles and eliminates the guess work. I thought it would also aid in a similar manner when edge planing.
I understand what the point you are making. I wasn't thinking of it as a panacea, rather as an aid to know from the git go how far out of square the edge of the board might be. If it's out of square alot, the level probably wouldn't be needed, one would easily feel the out of squareness, but if it's only off a small amount, the level would instantly give you an idea how much to remove on that first stroke instead of maybe planing off too much and then be out of square the other way. Sort of removes some of the guess work.
One problem in all of this level talk is the work holding. Whether it is making sure the bench top is perfectly level in all directions or how the work is held in a vise--I've never really trusted a board to come up out of a vise to be plumb to the world. Doesn't matter as using a level just seems to be complicating skill-building that shouldn't be complicated.
Aside from the leveling of work holding devices, once one face is flattened, the easiest "crutch" is to simply use a fence on a plane. I use to own a Stanley fence and it worked great. The Veritas magnetic fence seems like a relatively inexpensive thing for a beginner to use as a guide for squaring an edge.
The hot dog is designed for using a plane on its side in conjunction with a shooting board.
As MikeW states a jointer fence would be your best bet as a crutch. You can always make one from a stright board and some your favorite magnets, and paint the whole thing John Deere green of course.
I had totally forgotten about John Deere green and maggots eerrr, I mean magnets.
I like the idea of using most anything involving a hotdog, especially one stuck to a plane. With that in mind, one could stand on their head and square a 2 x 2. And Mike's idea to use a plane with a fence. But that's kind of cheating yourself out months and months of practise doing it on the balls of your feet and judging what square is by just the feel of it.
Now that you reminded me of magnets, might be a good idea to epoxy a level bubble to a magnet to hold it on the plane. Paint the magnet John Deere green.
Can't tell ya how many times I have reinvented the wheel and then discovered in pure astonishment that, oh my gawd!...someone already thought of that.
>I can relate, it's nice to have a sort of preliminary indicator.
Provided your boards are plumb when they're clamped up, there are some combination squares (like starrett) that do incorporate a level into the head... that might be a quick and dirty way of accomplishing something similar to what you're talking about, but I think checking for square is better, since you're really trying to plane a square edge, and not a level one.
You can always shim the vise to get it level. :)
I guess my main objection to the idea of a level on the plane is that you'd spend more energy concentrating on looking at the level, instead of feeling what the plane is doing. Plane a shaving off of the edge, check the board in various places for square.
The level can give you a good preliminary indication, but it's important to realize that there are times when you're learning that the stroke can start out level, and lean as you move down the board. It's incremental at first, and worsens with more planing. (forgive me if I sound patronizing... it took me half a week of planing edge joints to really tune into what was going on. You'd have to have an eye on the level throughout the stroke if you were doing it that way. Doing it the other way would allow you to plane without having to focus on the level, and then check the board to see where your stroke is going awry.
The basic process is plane, and get a feel for what the plane is doing, and then reconcile that with what the actual result is on the board. Plane again, trying to feel what's going on, and reconcile again with what you read on the board. After a while, you'll start to feel when you're tipping away from square. And you'll learn to keep the plane square, even when the edge isn't, so you can get the edge properly trued.
>Sometimes re-inventing the wheel is the best way to learn. If I told someone the best way to do something, as I understood it, it would deprive them of the experience that teaches WHY it's better to do something I certain way. I still have a dovetailed box where the sides were blown out, because I was trying to chop out the waste from some half-blind dovetails, with the board clamped vertically in the vise. I learned very quickly why it's such a good idea to chop them out with the board flat on the bench.
It's amazing how something that seems so genius can become common sense after a while. But there's always something new to learn in the skills dept, so genius today can still be common sense tomorrow.
Keep inventing (and re-inventing) Marv. May your joy of learning never fade, and your sense of wonder remain unclouded.
I saw that technique using a pointer of some kind sticking up from the file ferrule long time ago, but the one with the fleam pointer and lucite rake angle gauge I haven't seen before.
I thought about making the pointer type but then the line level on the angle block seemed to be a simpler way to go. I didn't like the idea of having something sticking up in my face. I file while standing and I have my vise up quite high.
The main thing about using the level is, the vise has to be level too, but that's no biggie. Any method I've seen so far, including mine, still leaves room for error based on how attentive you are as you make your file strokes. The method I'm using allows me to file nearly as consistantly as a machine filer, in some aspects, maybe better. Tom Law in his video didn't use anything and didn't go into much detail for the beginner regarding how to consistantly and accurately maintain the rake angle and fleam angles. He did it the old fashion way, by feel. Not everybody can do that. It's similar to knowing when your plane is squaring the edge of a board.
I have recently acquired a 28" Acme vise, like the one Steve Cooke has and have it set up so I can rotate the entire vise so I can leave the saw in the vise when I turn the saw to file from left to right. I turn both the saw and the vise at the same time. This keeps the saw level both right and left.
I've been toying with the idea of making an adjustable angle block so I can merely rotate the file to different angles and to make it easy and fast when I turn the saw to file from left to right. I will make it to accept both large and small files. With this kind of angle block, I would only need one or two instead of a different block for each angle. The design is still floating around in my mind. I expect that soon it will become a reality. The hang up at the moment is devising a means of clamping all sizes of files. A small three jaw chuck with angled jaws keeps poking at my brain. If I end up using this idea, I'll probably end up with two sizes, a small one and a larger one.
I bookmarked your link and will be revisiting it some more. Thank you for that.
>The method I'm using allows me to file nearly as consistantly as a machine filer, in some aspects, maybe better.
There is a school of thought that would suggest the inconsistency of hand filing is a benefit over the precise machine filed saw. Bringing a bit of pragmatism to woodworking and sharpening usually pays dividends for me.
Yes, I have read quite a bit about how hand filing can be better than machine filing due to inconsistant tooth angles and length, etc.
From first hand experience, I find that I prefer a saw that has every tooth doing the same amount of work whether machine filed or hand filed. That can only happen when each tooth is the same length, all with the same rake and fleam and the set is equal in all aspects. Having said that, I won't claim to always precisely accomplish that goal, but that is my mission with each saw that I file.
Sharpening a saw by machine isn't the primary problem regarding how well it will cut. It usually will have more to do with the set of the teeth and what that particular saw is sawing, soft wood versus hardwood and the number of teeth per inch. Lots of variables involved including how much rake and fleam angle is used. Another significant variable can be the basic design of the saw.
I bought a brand new Disston saw years ago. I never used it because it would bind no matter what kind of wood I tried to cut with it. Then I learned to sharpen saws. The problem? The set was wrong. It had been machined filed. I fixed the set and now it cuts great.
I can't say much about machine filing because I've never used a machine. I would guess that it can do an exceptional job with a freshly retoothed blade or one that has good teeth to start with, but I'd hate to see what it would do with a blade with horribly filed uneven teeth like so many of the old saws that I encounter.
So, I have to disagree with those who will argue in favor of hand sharpening over machine sharpening only because the saw was sharpened by hand. Lots of considerations that determine how well a saw will cut no matter how it's done.
I'm going to put my head on the block here and say....those who originally claimed that their hand filed saw cut better than a machined sharpened one, were reluctant to do one more jointing and do one more pass to fine tune the teeth or they hadn't figured out how to get all the teeth the same. I say this with all due respect for those who will take file in hand and at least attempt it.
I like what one guy posted on another forum..."I let others file my saws for the same reason I don't make my own plywood".
"Can't tell ya how many times I have reinvented the wheel and then discovered in pure astonishment that, oh my gawd!...someone already thought of that."
Every time I try to reinvent it it gets squarer and squarer!
>I think Dean's post was intended to note that often controlled imprecision results in smoother cuts than machine precision. For another example, check out hand cut files.
>From first hand experience, I find that I prefer a saw that has every tooth doing the same amount of work whether machine filed or hand filed. That can only happen when each tooth is the same length, all with the same rake and fleam and the set is equal in all aspects.
Happily the claimed benefit of handfiling comes from minor variations in pitch ...