Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Hide Glue in a bottle?

Posts

Re: Hide Glue in a bottle?

#26

Neat!

John in New Mexico

>I like the dual viscosity feature too.

Re: Hide Glue in a bottle?

#27

I love it

Jeff S.

>What a great example of More for Less! Thanks for taking the time to post the picture.

Jeff

Re: Hide Glue in a bottle?

#28

Re: Franklin vs Old Brown

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Les,

I have used both and they work just fine. Patrick's glue is a lighter color than Franklin. Below 70 degrees Old Brown Glue will not come out of the bottle without warming. Franklin at 60 degrees does the same. A slight warming and they both work just fine.

OBG has a more aggressive tack and is stronger than Franklin/Titebond. Franklin is plenty strong but Patrick's is measurably stronger. I use more Franklin than OBG because a friend orders the stuff 5 gallons at a time, so I get a gallon or two a year when he orders.

I like Old Brown Glue over Franklin for reasons I am not sure I can explain, other than I like Patrick. It has better texture and it does have better gap filling than Franklin. It behaves more like hot hide glue except it is liquid at room temperature (given a warm enough room).

I also use hot hide glue which is great but when my shop starts out at the outside temperature and is heated with a wood stove, it is too cold for the glue pot and less than ideal conditions for hide glue. No hot glue room in my shop. So I use a fair amount of liquid hide glue a year.

Besides isinglass glue, rabbit skin glue and fish glue I use hot hide glue and liquid hide glue exclusively. With these choices who needs modern glues.

Stephen

Re: Hide Glue in a bottle?

#29

Re: Franklin vs Old Brown

les winter

>Great info. I'll give it a try.

thanks

Les

Re: Hide Glue in a bottle?

#30

Re: Franklin vs Old Brown

Marv

>Stephen,

A definitive answer to my initial question.

Sounds like (cow) Hide Glue is seasonal for some people.

Thank you,

Marv

Re: Hide Glue in a bottle?

#31

Re: I love it

tstock

>The candy thermometer costs a few bucks, but setting the temp to 152 degree water temp gives me 145 degree glue.

Re: Hide Glue in a bottle?

#32

Re: Use a Baby bottle warmer

Peter Evans in Sydney

>I found baby bottle warmers do not get hot enough for hide glue. The wax warmers used by beauty salons are great, even the domestic versions - they can reach a higher temperature and also hold the desired temp better. Not a problem in Sydney, but they would work better in low ambient temps as well. Also you can remove the hair on your legs if so inclined.

Re: Hide Glue in a bottle?

#34

My experiences

James Watriss

>My experiences have been much more limited than some of those here, but might be helpful anyway.

-------------Alastair's advice--------

I knew a guy, my first semester in school, named Alastair, who did some amazing work, and he was totally sold on hide glue, saying it had actually saved him a lot of time in the long run, because of the reversibility characteristics. He had made a few small drawers, and something had gone awry, but he was able to heat up the joints and separate them, and re-assemble the joint. He was working on a repro Seymour piece.

(See picture, bottom of the post)

It was a beautiful piece, and at the end of my first semester, it was a beautiful introduction to the school. I can't say enough about Al, crazy aussie that he was... he was a damned fine woodworker. But the detail you probably can't see is that the quilted blister maple veneer is one piece from bottom drawer to top drawer, and book matched cross them all.

Because of the expense, in time and money, of working with bookmatched veneer with a pattern that spread across all of the drawers, having one drawer go wrong would be pretty ugly, so being able to take the joints apart and rebuild really saved him some headaches. And after actually using it on the whole project, he said he was absolutely sold.

--------------My first time-------------(get your mind out of the gutter)------

My first project with hide glue was a hammer veneer job, and one of my instructors encouraged me to at least try the hide glue stuff out. Well, an old friend had donated a glue pot and some hide glue granules, so I figured why not, I'll see how this stuff is.

Well, the first thing I noticed was that something smelled like it had gone horribly wrong, and I got a lot of bad looks from the folks in my immediate area. Well, as luck would have it, turned out that Behlen hide glue crystals (which was what I'd been given) are reputed to also have some bone content too, and it really smelled godawful. I was assured that hide glue will smell like an old foot to a point, but that it really shouldn't smell like THAT. And it wasn't really holding very well. More on that later, but in this case, turned out that it was probably the brand of glue, but that my mixing hadn't really helped.

Eventually the hammer veneering job was finished, and not too soon after that, I left school, and moved into the top floor of my current building, which is very well heated, and more relevantly, bone dry, in the wintertime. I had the table in question wrapped up for a while, and didn't really lay eyes on it until I was really moved in, and ready to lay some shellac on it.

The hammer veneered part was just the pedestal, and I'd used yellow glue for the rest of the veneered surfaces, which I threw in the vacuum press. (I've since been informed that yellow glue in a vacuum bag isn't the optimal choice, but this is about hide glue, not yellow glue.)

Well, turns out that hammer veneered hide glue is more flexible than vacuum bagged yellow glue, and the huge shift in temperature and humidity basically crazed the surface of the pedestal, and it took me a while to regain my composure and get everything back to good enough for finish again.

All things considered, though, I thought (crazing aside) that the hide glue experience (once I'd switched to better glue granules) was pretty good. Just don't move hide glue veneered surfaces to massively different climates if you can help it.

-----------------The Boggs Class-----------------------

Later that year, I took a chair making class with Brian Boggs. Excellent class, and the guy is a real genius. I'm still in awe after half a year that he was able to do what he did with us in 10 days.

M. Boggs told us that he really prefers hide glue, because he says it holds better than most glues, despite bad reviews in print (and my own experiences) He says part of the problem is mixture, and part of it lies in not properly sizing the pieces being glued. He told us that sizing (coating the surfaces with glue, and letting it set up before making the joint) gave the glue "roots" in the wood, which helped hold the joint together very well. He apparently did a test where he did a plain butt joint, end grain to face grain, with hide glue, and when he broke it apart, he got face grain tear out, because of the deeper mechanical hold. I don't know what species he was using, and I can only imagine that such a trick would surely work better in a porous wood like Oak, but what do I know.

Anyway, he had us use old brown glue, heated in a glue pot full of water.

I personally liked the idea of pre-made hide glue, simply because I'd had issues with the wrong glue brand, and the wrong viscosity before. So using something like that took the grunt work out of experimenting for me. If you're worrying about saving what hours you do have, it seems like a great way to go if you're gun-shy about the learning curve. But in terms of saved time and money if a glue-up goes wrong, I think it's definately worth your time to look into.

Re: Hide Glue in a bottle?

#35

Re: My experiences... forgot the picture. :)

James Watriss

>Here's a shot of Alastair's finished seymour piece at school...


img

Re: Hide Glue in a bottle?

#36

...and I just noticed...

James Watriss

>... if you look in the background, to the left, on the floor, by the leg of the chair, is the glue pot. (the little black thing)

Re: Hide Glue in a bottle?

#37

Re: My experiences... forgot the picture. :)

Wiley Horne

>Thanks, James.

That piece is the one on the cover photo of the Seymour book by Mussey, right? It has that fabulous 'arrow' banding on both the mirror and the lower rail under the main drawer section; there is a detailed article in one of the SAPFM journals which shows how Phil Lowe makes that arrow banding--a valuable article if anyone wants to make this piece.

Thanks for sharing!

By the way, I have had none of that smell issue (that I read about sometimes) with Joel's hide glue. He carries 4 different strengths, last time I looked.

Wiley

Re: Hide Glue in a bottle?

#38

Re: My experiences

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>James, after Brian sizes the matching pieces, does he apply more glue before mating them? Or does he mate/clamp them with just the glue used for sizing?

Thanks,

Pam

Re: Hide Glue in a bottle?

#39

Re: My experiences

James Watriss

>He sizes, and then applies more glue to (his words) reactivate the glue used for sizing.

And I forgot to mention (thanks wiley) that the old brown glue, while it certainly smells a bit more than titebond, certainly does NOT smell anywhere near as offensive as the Behlen stuff. (ugh)

Re: Hide Glue in a bottle?

#40

Re: My experiences... forgot the picture. :)

James Watriss

>Yup. And Alastair went all the way, with all of the details. He collaborated with various people to make sure he got the pattern right, carved the models for the finials, which were cast with lost wax, etc...

Alastair Boell... woodworker down under.

I think he's currently teaching and giving lectures and such.

Re: Hide Glue in a bottle?

#41

Thanks, James.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>

Re: Hide Glue in a bottle?

#42

Re: My experiences

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Bone (hide) glue (derived from ossein) does have more of an odor than Hide glue made from hides.

Stephen