Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Hide Glue in a bottle?

Posts

Hide Glue in a bottle?

#1

Hide Glue in a bottle?

Marv

>Ok, I confess.....I have never used Hide Glue. You know, the stuff that's made from cow's hide? It's what jello is made of except the jello kind comes from pigs.

Stehpen has made me curious about the stuff. Went to TFWW and saw some hide glue in a bottle called Patrick Edward's Old Brown Glue.

I also did some Googling and read some instructions as to how to mix hide glue and how to use it. Seems that it needs to be used hot and temperature controlled and that there are different granule sizes that effects the set and cure time. And you have to make sure the viscosity is just right when it's applied.

After reading about all that is involved with preparing the stuff for use, it would be much faster and easier to buy Pat's Old Brown Glue in a bottle. It has a shelf life of about a year. What that probably means, is that it's good for about 6 months.

Those of you who are well practiced in using hide glues, other than differences in price, what is your recommendations regarding using the glue in a bottle versus mixing the granules? Keep in mind that I'm of an age that I need to be concerned about conserving my remaining hours.

Thanks,

Marv

Re: Hide Glue in a bottle?

#2

Re: Hide Glue in a bottle?

Dean J in MN

>While Old Brown Glue is good stufff, it isn't a "drop-in" replacement for the "real" hot stuff. It lacks some of the features I've come to love about hot hide glue -- for one, a quick grab.

Really, mixing up hot hide glue is trivial -- I'm not sure what you read, but if I can figure it out I'm sure anyone can. Water + dry glue, let it puff up for a while and heat it. That is all I do. If is seems to thick, add a little water, too thin, let it heat a bit with the lid off. Give the hot stuff a real chance, there is no need to be all that fussy, they sure didn't have computer controled temp back in the 18th C.

-Dean

Re: Hide Glue in a bottle?

#3

Re: Hide Glue in a bottle?

John Jesseph

>I have gone through a couple bottles of Old Brown Glue. I recommend buying some straight from Patrick at oldbrownglue.com. Call him if you have questions. I like hot hide glue a lot, but if you want to just get to work, buy some and try it.

Re: Hide Glue in a bottle?

#4

Re: Hide Glue in a bottle?

Marv

>I like the sound of that....Most all of the things I glue are small and I don't do it very often, maybe once a week. An example would be gluing a new horn to repair a saw handle. I understand that I can mix up a batch of hide glue and store it in cold storage. I'm used to grabbing a bottle of Titebond and getting the job done without making a mini-project out if. Or mixing a small dab of epoxy. Epoxy is not critical temperature-wise compared to mixing and using hide glue.

Is the glue joint significantly better using the bottled hide glue than say Titebond or epoxy? I know that if I try to rebreak an epoxied joint, I'm going to break the wood before the joint. I don't see how much better a glue joint can be. This causes me to wonder why hide glue is so highly recommended. Is part of the reason due to nostalgia?

Thanks for the tip about buying it directly from Patrick Edwards.

Marv

Re: Hide Glue in a bottle?

#5

Re: Hide Glue in a bottle?

Paul Kierstead

>Is the glue joint significantly better using the bottled hide glue than say Titebond or epoxy?

For better to make sense, it has to be within some parameters. Just a *very* short list of parameters with respect to glue:

- open time

- ability to undo/repair

- creep

- flexibility

- drying time

- toxicity

- ease of clean up

- strength in a gap

- susceptibility to water/solvents/etc.

- lifespan (of completed joint).

- ease of use

- storage time

Those are just the ones off the top of my head. Some of them are a little more "absolute" then others; there is no real reason to *desire* more toxicity. But open time? Totally dependent on the application and user; the desired open time may be long or short. Many of them may or may not be a factor.

Given that, no one can say a glue is, in general terms, "best" or even "better" I think. You can just evaluate the characteristics of the glue, hold them up against you specific requirements for a specific job, and see if they are a match. One of the endearing attributes of hide glue is that it is highly user-modifiable; kind of like woodies vrs. metal planes.

But I'd distrust anyone who declared any glue "the best".

Re: Hide Glue in a bottle?

#6

Re: Hide Glue in a bottle?

Dean J in MN

>Fixing a horn on a saw handle would be a great example of hot hide glue having very desirable qualities. How do you clamp such a odd shaped piece? PVA glue require bondline pressure to form a strong bond if I understand correctly. Hot hige glue -- apply glue, rub a little until it grabs, let go. You're done. No clamps. The glue "sucks" the joint together.

I do agree, there is no one "best" glue. For the way I work, hide glue serves nearly all my needs. I can not use (hot) hide glue on a long glueline, say glueing up two boards to make a large chest side, etc. I'm simply not fast enough -- anyone want to be my glue helper? :) Here I use pva or liquid (cold) hide glue.

-Dean

Re: Hide Glue in a bottle?

#7

My hot hide glue set up - real easy...

John in New Mexico

>A 1 1/2" copper pipe cap, tinned inside with solder (probably un-necessary). Put that on an electric coffee warmer, got mine at a Walgreens 10 years ago for under $10. Probably hoards of the things coming out of China. The cup warmer shouldn't get much above 140 degrees, but it still pays to keep an eye on it so it doesn't boil. Funny things happen to boiling temperatures when you make a solution of two materials. Pipe caps allow you to mix just the amount you need or a little more. If you leave a large amount mixed it will either dry out (in arid climates) or mold. Drying isn't such a problem, but it then takes a long time to absorb water compared to new granulated glue. Most vendors like Woodcraft and Lee Valley sell a general purpose granulated glue, start with that instead of trying to figure out which of the multitude of special hide glues is the one you need.

Re: Hide Glue in a bottle?

#8

My experience exactly! There are

Wiley Horne

>a lot of situations where the fast tack is your friend (and others where it ain't). One other thing comes to mind--the cleanup. When the hide glue gets to a gel consistency, and that doesn't take long, you can scrape it off cleanly and easily, and wipe down with a damp rag--and it leaves no trace. Absolutely does not affect the finish. So if PVA or epoxy are giving any trouble in regard to mottling the finish, hide glue fixes that. That's why I love hide glue for drawer making--easy to take care of that 'inside squeeze out'.

Wiley

Re: Hide Glue in a bottle?

#9

Re: Hide Glue in a bottle?

Paul Kierstead

>I just called 'em and bought some. I've done lots with the hot sort, but never used the bottled sort. This should be fun!

Re: Hide Glue in a bottle?

#10

Re: My experience exactly! There are

Dean Lapinel

>The problem Wiley is that "When the hide glue gets to a gel consistency" it is no longer useful. At least that's the issue in the joint- squeeze out gel....start over. Perhaps you meant a good joint with a glue of good consistancy then a clean up of glumpy, gelled glue grap. :)

Re: Hide Glue in a bottle?

#11

Re: My experience exactly! There are

Wiley Horne

>Dean,

Thank you for the comment. Because it means I wasn't clear the first time. What I mean to say is that when the _squeeze out_ cools to a gel, it's an easy cleanup. Thanks for pointing this out, as my original message was unclear. Incidentally, I should have said "small drawers", because these I can dip directly into the glue, and join. Larger ones with lots of pins and sockets take too long, and maybe I should get the Old Brown Glue for them!

Wiley

Re: Hide Glue in a bottle?

#12

Re: Fish Glue in a bottle?

John Aniano - in NJ...

>Marv,

You might want to try my favorite - liquid fish glue you get from Kremer Pigments (now Sinopia) in New York City or on the web. Fast tack and holds quite well, even for the different materials that I use in making musical instrument bows.

As for the stuff going bad, I guess it may, although I still have my original bottle of the fish glue I've had for years out of the sun on a shelf in my shop. I have used this bottle of glue for a long time with no noticeable poor performance.

Hope this helps,

John

Re: Hide Glue in a bottle?

#13

Re: Hide Glue in a bottle?

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>I got some Liquid Hide Glue from the Titebond folks a couple of years ago to try some hammer veneering. That was a chore, but it wasn't the glue's fault. That bottle sat there on the shelf, and got used for all sorts of quickie projects, and I rather got to liking it.

For the stuff you describe, the bottled stuff may not be perfect, but it's cheap, and easy, and does a really good job, in my limited experience. The cleanup is one of my favorite benefits.

Re: Hide Glue in a bottle?

#14

Re: Hide Glue in a bottle?

Marv

>Hi Dean,

I don't glue an odd shaped piece. I make a new horn from a squared off piece of new wood. After the glue is sufficiently dry I pencil out the shape of the horn, rough saw it and then shape with a rasp, etc. So clamping isn't a problem.

Marv

Re: Hide Glue in a bottle?

#15

Re: Fish Glue in a bottle? *LINK*

Stew Pharis

>I haven't tried it, but I note that Lee Valley sells fish glue in a bottle too.

Stew


Lee Valley Fish Glue

Re: Hide Glue in a bottle?

#16

Re: Use a Baby bottle warmer

Wayne Carson "TX"

>You can go to Wally World and pick up a baby bottle warmer to heat the glue. Mine I put water in it and put a thermo.. (you know the thingey with the numbers on it to tell how hot it is), need to learn to spell. After I found the sweet spot mark the dial with a felt tip pen and you are set. If you need to make it to have a long open time put some urea (fertilizer) in it and you can make Patric's glue. The first time I used it to any extent was putting veneer on MDF and the nice thing is if it started to gel I used my wife's iron to heat it up again and bingo it really worked good. Takes a little time to get it ready but worth it on small to medium size jobs. The net is loaded with info.

Re: Hide Glue in a bottle?

#17

Re: Franklin vs Old Brown

les winter

>I have used Franklin hide glue and it works pretty well. Has anyone used both Franklin and Old Brown? Any guidance?

Re: Hide Glue in a bottle?

#19

Re: My hot hide glue set up - real easy...

ron in Kokomo

>I use an electric potpourri warmer that I "borrowed from SWMBO

works great.

I use hot hide glue for lots of stuff. It is perfect for unsquare glue-ups that are hard to clamp. I judt hole em together for a minute and set them down to dry

Clean up is so easy and doesn't leave "invisible trouble that you only discover after the first coat of finish

Re: Hide Glue in a bottle?

#20

Re: Yeabutt, have you ever tried the...

Marv

>Hi Scott,

For most of my adult life, starting around the age of 11 I've heard about sending an old nag (horse) to the glue factory. Is anyone presently using Horse Glue? What part of the horse was used? I heard it was the hooves. It's beginning to appear from what has been posted here that glue can be made from most all living things, that are dead of course. With Fish Glue, there doesn't even have to be a hide.

So I'm wondering just what it is that makes one substance stick better than another. It's all about adhesion. What IS adhesion? I read that adhesion occurs when two elements are brought to within angstroms of each other. Angstroms is the next level of measurement after Microns as we all know. When using a glue, a third element is brought into play. Adhesion can take place without glue. Water can create adhesion but it will evaporate. But even without anything as a bonding agent adhesion can occur by merely putting together two smooth surfaces such as finely ground glass. For best adhesion when using glue, the glue must have a good wetting or wicking or capillary action as one of it's main features, hence, applying Hide Glue when it is hot and at it's optimum low viscosity. It immediately cools and begins to shrink while it grabs onto fibers of wood for example. At this point the glue joint includes a mecanical connection but this mechanical connection isn't adhesion. Adhesion occurs due to the wetting process. Adhesive tape does what it does in the same manner but not as well because it doesn't have the wetting abilities as does Hide Glue as well as other type liquid glues.

I think we can in fact differenciate between one glue and another to determine which is best. There has to be a "best". To make that determination we have to define the application and "stick" to the catagory. One particular glue will be best in one application but not in another. It has been stated that Hide Glue will bond glass for example, but is the bond as strong and as reliable as a different bonding agent?

Marv

Re: Hide Glue in a bottle?

#21

Re: Yeabutt, have you ever tried the...

Paul Kierstead

>There has to be a "best"

Why? Glue is an exercise in compromise, and one mans good compromise may not be another's. There may very well be plenty of unsuitable glues for a variety of applications, but that doesn't mean there is a best. I'd expect there might be a top 3 or 5 for a very specific application, though, that you could get most people to agree on.

Next thing you'll be going on about the "best" finish :)

Re: Hide Glue in a bottle?

#22

Re: Yeabutt, have you ever tried the...

Marv

>You are right as long as you are generalizing. But as I also mentioned, one most "stick" to a particular catagory or application in order to determine "best". To evaluate anything, one must compare to something that is considered proven to be better or something worse. If you have glued something that falls apart when you pick it up we could easily say that is the worst joint I've ever seen but if you have to hammer on it to break it, we say that's the best glue joint I've ever seen. Everything else falls somewhere between those two extremes. There can only be "one" best, not 3 or 5 bests.

So....what is it you want to know about finishes? I don't have a clue. I guess, just make it look good. Totally differnt subject than glue joints.

Marv

Re: Hide Glue in a bottle?

#23

Still depends

Dan Donaldson

>I may want a joint that is strong, but can be taken apart if necessary. It might be important to me that it doesn't mess up a finish if it gets on the surrounding surface. I might want a dark glue line, or maybe a transparent one. It might be important that it be waterproof, or not... I might care if it is brittle, or maybe it is more important to have no creep. I might need a very fast tack time, or maybe want a long open time. I may need one that is good to apply in cold and another in hot and on and on. The "best" glue for each application and set of requirements is going to be different. The only way that I could see referring to any glue as the "best" would be after a careful analysis of the specific characteristics of the job at hand and matching a glue to those as closely as possible. That would probably mean using a different glue for every job that you do. ;-)

Re: Hide Glue in a bottle?

#24

Trade-offs

David Cockey

>Best depends on the trade-offs between desirable and undesirable characteristics. And some characteristics can be difficult to objectively measure. Specific techniques can also enter in. So what is "best" for one person in one application at one time may not be best for someone else, or a different application, or at another time.

Re: Hide Glue in a bottle?

#25

Re: My hot hide glue set up - real easy...

tstock

>$12 Rival hot pot, Ball jelly jar, some brass rod stock, and a squeeze bottle where thicker glue is needed.


img