Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Workbench tops

Posts

Workbench tops

#1

Workbench tops

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>What is the fascination with a hard bench top? I have made 7 workbenches and the only one with a hardwood top was one I built from poplar for Conner Prairie Pioneer Settlement. All of the others were made of pine. I also no longer make benches with tool trays, which I consider a waste of valuable bench top space as well as a place that collects crap (technical use of the term crap).

The reason I use pine is that it will not damage any furniture I might be making or antiques I might be restoring. I don�t want the bench to damage my work. That is why it is made from soft wood. Now they still have plenty of weight and work just fine. As to wear on the top it is negligible even on the bench that is over 30 years old. And if I ever need to resurface the top it is easy.

If a sharp tool comes in contact with a hardwood bench top, there is a chance of breaking or dulling the tool, that just doesn't happen with a soft bench top.

Consider a big thick piece of pine for your next bench top.

Stephen

Re: Workbench tops

#2

Re: Workbench tops

Marv

>I used 2 inch thick partical board with 1/4" tempered masonite on top. It measures 30 inches by 8 feet. I probably would have used pine or fir but I got the partical board for free. If I need a new surface, off comes the old masonite and replaced with a new sheet. I've been using this bench for 35 years. Good gawd, that's half my life.

Marv

Re: Workbench tops

#3

I'd use pine any day...

John in New Mexico

>But I've had a couple of douglas fir benches, and I'd never use another. They're ok for a few years and then turn into a splinter factory. The hard rings in doug fir make nasty splinters, especially when you're picking something up off the bench and you get one under the fingernail -shudder.

Re: Workbench tops

#4

Re: Workbench tops

Roy Anderson

>Mine is SYP from the Blue Borg. It works just fine. No valuable hardwoods were harmed and I don't care if I ding it. Reflattening is a breeze, and when I decide I want a better or just different one, I'll just cut it up for fire wood.

A workbench IMHO is not a work of art but a clamping surface to hold stuff in place while you work on it.

Re: Workbench tops

#5

Re: Workbench tops

Ray Binnicker

>I was walking through one the Borgs one day and passing the SYP shelves I noticed some 2x12's that were virtually knot free. I dug through the stack and came away with about two dozen 2x12x10's that didn't have 3 knots in the total stack. I let them sit in the shop for a couple months and ripped 3" strips off the edges, leaving the center 4-5" of the boards for lesser projects. If you look at the end of a 2x12 the edges are almost always quartersawn. I glued these quartersawn strips together to make my 33"x8' workbench top. I really like it. I don't think I would ever spring for one the "hard" tops.

Ray Binnicker

Re: Workbench tops

#6

Re: Workbench tops

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Also, the softer woods hold the work piece better, no slipping about on slick, hard surfaces.

Pam

Re: Workbench tops

#7

Re: Workbench tops

ThomD

>I've got both so I am open to suggestions but I think hardwood is more appropriate to the average bench with vises and such, since it is stronger and takes the necesarry joinery and fixtures better. I'm certainly not going to stop the next person from making a wooden screw out of pine...

The Japanese tradition uses pine beams, it's not clear to me that the reason for that is that pine is superior to hardwoods as much as it isn't portable or part of the timber frame they are working on. Some of the early names who popularized Japanese woodworking over here were from the frame and "window" traditions. If you checked those trade's benches in the west, you wouldn't end up with a Cabinetmaker's bench, necesarilly, either. However, Denis Young who apprenticed in a chair factory over there, used a Zelkova bench. Japanese woodworking essentially jumped over the screw and straight into power tools.

On the tool well, I don't know what to tell you. Only some benches had them. Maybe those guys were better organized than the mess complainers, or maybe they didn't like sweeping the mess and their tools onto the floor all the time. I'm not sure they are all that big a mess where shavings and chopings are concerned, they are nasty where router stuff is concerned but that tool is mostly banished around my place.

The tool well is an efficient way to take about as big a chunk of wood as you might wish to handle, possibly wet, and then frame it out in a functioning system. My experiements with the ugly bench show that wood can be harvested, hewn and used in a bench without drying, so maybe that was what they were up to vs gluing together some machined pieces into a butcher block.

Re: Workbench tops

#8

Where To Buy A Workbench Top

Tom Colligan

>I'd just like to replace the top to a decent frame I made 15 years ago. But I only know of Grizzly offering tops and in maple only. Would anyone know of another seller? I'm partial toward beech. TIA, Tom.

Re: Workbench tops

#9

Re: Where To Buy A Workbench Top

Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia

>Google Bally Block. It is in Pa. and they sometimes have seconds (appearance deficits) for sale. Do a search here at Woodcentral archives for more information. A poster went and bought a pickup truck load and dropped them off on the way home and ended up getting his top for next to free. Nice tops.JR

Re: Workbench tops

#10

Good home center

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>The one remaining locally-owned home center in our area sells wooden kitchen counter tops at reasonable prices. Granted, they're only 1-1/2" thick; but they've got some display blocks that are a lot thicker, which implies they can special order (I haven't asked).

You might ask around at cabinet shops, too; time was, there would be local businesses doing "butcher block" tops. You might be lucky and find there's still one in business in your area.

Re: Workbench tops

#11

check these guys out

Robin Corell in Atascadero Ca

>

Re: Workbench tops

#12

Ikea (furniture hell)

John K in Hastings, MN

>They sell beech countertop sections at a reasonable price.

Re: Workbench tops

#13

Re: Ikea (furniture hell)

dave brown

>That's what I used to build my bench top -- I used three of their oak counter tops sandwiched together.

Re: Workbench tops

#14

Re: second try  *LINK*

Robin Corell in Atascadero Ca

>


perfect plank

Re: Workbench tops

#15

a small correction...

Warren, Earlysville VA

>Joe,

I was the guy. (I recall you were kind enough to treat me to a sub at a local sandwich shop you knew about.)

My objective was to spread transportation costs (gas, oil, wear-n-tear) over the 12 or so participants. Each person, including me, paid Bally's price for his top, plus a $20 contribution for the transportation. I think that was about right for running a full size pickup up to Bally and back. Worked out pretty well except for the rain!

The shop forman's name is Russell. He's the guy to contact, provided he's still there.

Warren