Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Fret saw sources

Posts

Fret saw sources

#1

Fret saw sources

Michael Brady

>I am looking for a saw more robust than the typical coping saw for dovetail roughing out. I have seen fret saws mentioned for this purpose , but have yet to find a source for them. I assume that they take regular coping blades but have a stiffer frame. Anyone have any ideas?

Re: Fret saw sources

#2

Re: Fret saw sources

Dean J in MN

>Fret saw blades are much smaller than coping saw blades. No fret saw I'm aware of would accept a coping saw blade. Poke around on leevalley.com, they carry fret saws and blades.

-Dean

Re: Fret saw sources

#3

Re: Fret saw sources

Denny

>I was pretty impressed with a fret saw I saw Rob Cosman using in one of his dovetailing videos. I asked him about it, and he does have some available. I haven't tried one, the price seemed pretty high to me. Here is his reply, let us know if you find the ultimate saw.

Denny

...the saw you see me using is not the saw I use today. We had several requests after the video was released so we ordered in 100 of these saws, I had bought mine about 18 years ago and was surprised to find the company was still making them. When they arrived the quality was so bad we returned the order and set out to find a better one. We did find a saw that had a much better blade holding clamp, was lighter and though not a LN saw it does the job better than anything else we have since found. We sell them for $47.95 including 12 blades (12.5 tpi skip tooth) In USD that is about $40. If you cant find one locally you can get one from us, email or call the toll free at 1-877-967-5966 ... www.robcosman.com

Rob

Re: Fret saw sources

#4

Re: Fret saw sources

Tony Zaffuto

>May just want to try a better coping saw! Tools for Working wood has a very decent one--Olson, IIRC, very reasonable price and real good blades. I bought one especially for dovetail work and it does great.

No connection to TFWW.

Re: Fret saw sources

#5

Re: Fret saw sources

Christopher Schwarz

>The Olsen coping saw (and the ground blades) from Tools for Working Wood are indeed excellent.

As to fretsaws.... I bought an inexpensive German jeweler's saw off eBay several years ago (less than $10). And I use skip-tooth scrollsaw blades in it (you can use *anything* in these saws because of the simple pad clamps).

However, the pad clamps stink on most of these saws. The grooves in the pads need to be deeper to have a better grip. A few minutes with a file made grooves that grab and hold like nobody's business.

I really like using the fretsaw with scrollsaw blades. The set-up works great.

Chris

Re: Fret saw sources

#6

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Fret saw sources *LINK*

Jack Guzman from Maine

>Michael,

I don't like using a coping saw for dovetails. I find it too hard to turn with the blades I've been able to get.It's too clumsy a tool for the job.I use a jeweler's saw.They take finer blades. The right blade makes cutting small tails easy in hard woods.I get mine used. The used tool market is full of them cheap.I think Garrett Wade sells them. Any jewelers or clock tool supply will have them. I enclosed a link to a webpage that shows one kind.---Jack


Jewelers saw

Re: Fret saw sources

#7

Re: Fret saw sources

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>You can put coping saw blades (even broken pieces)in most fretsaws or you can buy equivalent fret saw blades. But like Tony I think your problem is your coping saw frame. You could try gently spreading the frame to get more tension on the blade. If it is a cheap frame the tension may last only long enough to give you an idea what a good saw is like or it may last indefinitely. Don't buy a frame at your local hardware- the price usually indicates quality.

I have two fretsaws but use a coping saw for the dovetails.

Re: Fret saw sources

#8

Re: Fret saw sources

Michael Brady

>Thanks, as usual to each and everyone of you for the great input. Looks like I have good options and I will look at all and go forward. My best to you all.

Re: Fret saw sources

#9

Re: Fret saw sources

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Michael,

I like the combination that Chris S. talks about--jeweler's saw and scroll saw blades. You get the saw frame from a jewelry supply, and the scroll saw blades from a woodworking supply.

The stoutest and best jeweler's saw frame that I have come across is one recommended by David Barnett a coupla years ago (BTW, I've learned to take about all of David's recommendations). Contenti sells them. Here is the link--click on one of the first two 'Best' frames:

http://www.contenti.com/products/saws/sawframes.html

I like the 'fixed' one without the slide adjustment, because that thing will take big tension and not deflect.

I use Olson 'Regular Skip Tooth Scroll Saw Blades', and get them from here, although there are many suppliers:

http://www.sloanswoodshop.com/scroll_saw_blades.htm

On the blades, there are two key variables--the tpi and the thickness. I use No. 2 blades because the thickness (0.012") will just snake down a dozuki kerf, and I'm stuck with a 20tpi saw. But if you're using a

a western backsaw with a wider kerf, you could use a thicker blade and fewer tpi, and saw faster.

On the same note, if you're using a western backsaw, I think I'd take a look at those Olson coping saw blades that Joel is selling--he's very high on them, and Joel is very honest in his assessments. You might call him up and talk over the whole thing.

Wiley

Re: Fret saw sources

#10

It may be how you use it...?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Michael

You have not said, and I'm sure other's have assumed, that you are using a coping saw/fretsaw correctly.

It seems so obvious, but ... which way round do you cut, on the push or on the pull? These saws should be set up to cut on the pull. That way the blades can take the tension off the frame.

The frame does not need to be very robust. Think of Japanese saws.

Regards from Perth

Derek (who uses a vintage Jeweller's saw that has stood the wear and tear of time).

Re: Fret saw sources

#11

Shocking

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>It was quite shocking to get up Monday morning, ready to finish up a load of drawers for another woodworker, and find that I have been cutting my dovetails incorrectly for the past thirty years. Coping saw blades are reversible- we sometimes use in push mode, sometimes pull. In the case of dovetails, if you pull, the fuzz from the kerf obscures the line on the near side. You can see better if you push, "incorrect" though it may be.

I think it wise to avoid saying "proper method" or "correct method" on a forum like this. I find myself cringing even in cases where the method described coincides with the one I use.

Re: Fret saw sources

#12

Maybe so, but .... *LINK*

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Would you prefer "recommended" method? The point remains that the the frame is under less stress when the blade is set up to cut on the pull.

"Care must be taken when fitting the blade so that the teeth point towards the handle. If the blade is fitted the opposite way the coping saw will be very difficult, if not impossible, to use."

Link to this quote below.

Regards from Perth

Derek


"The Coping Saw"

Re: Fret saw sources

#13

Re: Maybe so, but ....

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Derek, if you write "recommended by V. Ryan", I will not complain.

Thank goodness we do not have a Central Authority that specifies what can be recommended. There are differences of opinion. There are many on this forum who have done things for years that some like V. Ryan consider "very difficult if not impossible".

Re: Fret saw sources

#14

Re: It may be how you use it...?

paul womack

>If (and only if...) the frame is rigid enough, tension blade saws can happily cut on the push stroke.

Here's an extreme example:

http://www.wkfinetools.com/contrib/bSmalser/z_art/copingSaw/copSaw1.asp

(with apologies for all the adverts)

BugBear