Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

anyone remember the list of 10?

Posts

anyone remember the list of 10?

#1

redcoat

anyone remember the list of 10?

redcoat

>Hi folks,

I haven't been here for years- literally. Sorry. Events and such. Anyways, back in the days of Badger Pond, there was a discussion started by someone who had a child with a school project. The projects was to make a model covered wagon, and put in it 10 items to start a farmstead on the prairies. The discussion went around what tools could multi-task, what tools could be made from other tools and found goods, or the remains of the wagon, or the ox.

Can anyone remember the list?

Justin- formerly in NC, then MD, then Wales, now in Canada

Re: anyone remember the list of 10?

#2

redcoat

Re: anyone remember...I ask because

redcoat

>I'm off to a cob building class next week, and I received an e-mail "bring what tools you want". Arg!!! What tools do they have? What won't they have for the timber framing part? And I still haven't got an answer from them, and I have to walk the last 4 miles to the site, with camping gear, so weight is an issue...

Re: anyone remember the list of 10?

#3

Re: anyone remember...I ask because

Ernie Miller

>Have you checked the badger pond archives? I posted the original question I think it was a project for my niece she allways had me help her with her home work. you people let it get a little out of hand. There was a show on PBS about a man who hiked in and built a cabbin real interesting any way here is my list

SAW X cut and rip

Chisels

make a mallet on site

Ax

File for saw

stone

square

pencil

tape

draw knife

drill & Augers

string line

level

I'm sure I left some thing out but this is a start.

Re: anyone remember the list of 10?

#4

Re: not to start it all over again, but. . .

Dave Mount

>I don't remember the original discussion -- I don't think I was watching the hand tools board as carefully back then.

I guess your perspective on this depends a lot on what you assume one will have to do and what your starting materials will be. Also, I suppose if one were doing the covered wagon thing, you'd be thinking more about weight and/or volume than the number of tools. All that said, I was surprised by some of the list -- some thoughts:

If one assumes that trees were to be your starting material, this list seems light on the tools to bring trees down to manageable pieces. One item that missing in my mind is a hewing hatchet or broad axe. While axes come in many designs for different purposes, you could probably find an ax that would be a reasonable compromise between felling and splitting, but hewing is a different operation altogether and I think would warrant including a single bevel hatchet or ax for the purpose.

With regard to saws, I'm not sure exactly what was intended by "x-cut and rip", but I would think that you would want to include a "tree size" saw for felling and crosscutting trees. While combo tools rarely do any operation well, I'd think more about having a heavy saw and a lighter saw than just whether they were x-cut or rip. Besides the woodworking, you're probably going to have some firewood to buck up. Maybe just bringing blades and fittings to make a bowsaw or two if one were trying to stay lighter. . .

The tape and square surprise me. While they are no doubt handy things, you can make a square suitable for wilderness work. Likewise, you can make a tape or at least a measuring stick. In fact, if I were to bring a measuring device, I would think a compass might be a better option. With it, you could make a pretty accurate measuring stick (inches and centimeters are arbitrary units of measure anyway) and would be able to do some other kinds of layout as well (e.g., using it as a coarse marking gauge). You could make a compass also; the point is just that I thought a compass might be a more "core" measuring tool than a tape.

I would think a scratch awl a more valuable marking tool than a pencil -- a pain sometimes compared to a pencil, but it doesn't wear out as fast and has some other uses. Could make one of those too if things like nails, etc. are available.

If tool count were all that mattered, I might cheat and choose a plumb bob (with string attached) instead of just a string (two tools in one). Maybe the string line was assumed to have a body that would serve as a plumb bob as many modern ones do.

Finally, the absence of a plane surprised me. Admittedly, this would only be needed for finer work, but having something that naturally tends toward cutting a straight line rather than having to drawknive to a mark using a tool that doesn't have a reference plane seems like it could be pretty handy, and tough to make a first one without having one (assuming you had an iron along).

Interesting to think about, but I'm content to sit in my modern shop and think about it, rather than live it. . .

Dave

Re: anyone remember the list of 10?

#5

There's a big underlying assumption

Ian (in Sydney, Australia)

>and that is the skill level of the person

my list would include

a selection of axes and azes,

a large rip saw for cutting boards from a felled tree,

a large x-cut saw for tree felling

a plumb bob and string

chalk (though very fine clay is probably a substitute)

splitting wedges

sledge hammer

auger and bits

large mortice chisel

in skilled hands the right edge tool (axe or aze) can turn a felled tree into a squared beam or even (if you don't mind the work) a flat board

you can now build almost anything using wedged or pinned M&T joints

Re: anyone remember the list of 10?

#7

Re: anyone remember the list of 10?

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>I'd be tempted to add a slick to my list. But for sure I'd want a set of log tongs to hitch a horse or mule to move logs or heavy timbers for me. Might want a block and tackle too.

Tom

Re: anyone remember the list of 10?

#8

I would want a shovel

Bill Tindal, E.TN

>

Re: anyone remember the list of 10?

#9

Re: I would want a shovel

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>"10 items to start a farmstead on the prairies

Justin,

First off, it's good to see you again! Seems like you're really getting around. Last I knew you was in Wales having some problems with some type of tyrantical school master.

I've got to wonder just what you're up too now. You planning on walking into the back woods of Canada and living off of the land? you still got your "Colony" wife? ;~)

at any rate, it does seem to me that most of the replies center on woodworking, which of coarse is normal considering the subject of the Island, but starting a FARMSTEAD is a whole different animal that starting a backwoods woodworking shop.

I know that if I was to do that I dng sure wouldn't limit myself to only 10 tools, that's simply ridiculous IMO.

Among some items I'd take is:

-A very strong and long crowbar

-A heavy sledgemammer

-Something to use as an anvil.

-A pair of Vise Grips

-A good hole digging shovel--i.e. a long handled spade.

-A firearm of some type

-An Ax

-A magnifiing glass--great as a solar powered fire starter

-Books on Backwoods living--you can't remember everything you know

-A large heavy chain

-A sythe/sickle--for harvesting grasses for winter horse/livestock feed

-Wrenches to take off wagon wheels for repair or whatever other purpose.

-A mirror of some type.

-A scrub plane

-Some files--for sharpening the ax, spade and scrub plane

-Pot, pans, and storage containers.

I'm sure there is more, but you get the idea.

T.O.

Re: anyone remember the list of 10?

#10

redcoat

great responses- lost info

redcoat

>Yeah, this was the spirit of the original thread! I'm not off farmsteading- I'm off to a cob building class. I think I mentioned in the 2nd post tha I have to CARRY my tent, clothes, gear for a week, AND tools. Yes, weight and volume is an issue. I know cob is mud, but they are doing the timber frame the first week, but won't say what tools they alrady have, if any, on site. What a lark, eh?

Have packed the following

small mallet (make a maul on site if need be)

framing hammer 22 oz

tenon saw (hope they have a x, rip or combi and bow!)

1.5 and 3/4 framing chisels, 1/4 bench

brace and 1-3/8, 1 , 7/8, 3/4, 1/2 and 3/8 auger bits, 3 twist bits

assorted screw driver heads for brace

marking gauge

bevel gauge

large draw knife

spoke shave

small scrub plane

froe

tape, string, nail (makes a plumb bob, scratch awl)

8" torpedo level (tie it to a 2x4 for a long level, use a hose, eye)

army surplus folding shovel W. Ger, 1954 issue, strong, also good for trench warfare

I'll take 2 iron rings, 3" to use as ferrals for made on site gluts

not taking a hatchet, wedge, all around ax

BTW for those who remember me

I got sick in early 04

Spent a while in hospital

while in hospital, wife returned to Canada with son

I joined em in Canada

Would put up with a sick husband

on disability and fumbling around with 1/2 brain

justin

Re: anyone remember the list of 10?

#11

Moses Yoder

Re: great responses- lost info

Moses Yoder

>Have to say I have never heard of cob building. I have heard of corn cobs, and corn cob pipes. If they sent this same message out to everyone attending I guess you could see in about 3 seconds who knows what they are doing and who doesn't have a clue based on what tools they bring. I guess if you are only walking 4 miles, the tremendous weight that will be added to the pack with all your tools won't be so bad. You could always make one trip with your gear and another with the tools, but it sounds like your tools are probably going to weigh 30 pounds or so by themselves. How about renting a team of oxen and a wagon for the week?

Re: anyone remember the list of 10?

#12

Re: great responses- lost info

Ernie Miller

>Fly me up and feed me I'll be you sharpa for a week. I'll hike your gear in sit around and watch you cob all week and hike it all out no problem.

Re: anyone remember the list of 10?

#13

redcoat

Re: great responses- lost info

redcoat

>Moses- cob, I understand, is a bit like wattle and daub, without the wattle. I understand a shovel, feet and water are uften sufficient. The tools are for the timber frame. The "tools show your skill level" is a very good idea.

Re: anyone remember the list of 10?

#14

Re: It's 4 miles!

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>If you've never been a Scout, or a Scoutmaster, then you've never seen what can end up in a backpack...

There was one trip where mine, as a Scoutmaster, weighed in at over 75 lbs, because of the crap the boys packed in. I reached down, as I recall, the second day into the Yosemite backcountry, to steady a sliding sleeping bag on one boy's frame, and hit a six pack of Coca Cola. ;-)

Four miles, 75 lbs. No problem, then at least. Now, 20 years later, not so easy.

Re: anyone remember the list of 10?

#15

Moses Yoder

Re: packing

Moses Yoder

>I just finished packing my pack for Isle Royale next week. My wife's uncle and I plan on hiking in around 15-1/2 miles in a day and a half, living there for a few days and then hiking back out. I had to pack some heavy clothing because the nights get cold and the days are probably rainy and I am packing fishing equipment, an 8 weight fly rod and reel with extra leader, tippet material, and flies. This is my first backpacking trip and I didn't want to spend the money on the most expensive/lightest gear. I was a little concerned as I started putting stuff into the bag but everything fits and it is still just shy of 40 pounds which is a big relief. If I eat quite a bit the first few days the pack will be around 35 pounds ;) No 6 pack of coke in it though.

Re: anyone remember the list of 10?

#16

Re: packing

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>That's an intelligent load. But for 4 miles, I could drag almost anything, with a good pack frame. The gear has been in the attic for the last 8-10 years now, except when the now-grown sons want to go somewhere. My dear wife likes to camp at the Marriott, and eat in the better restaurants...

Re: anyone remember the list of 10?

#17

Re: packing

Paul in NJ

>Hey Moses, if you are a good fisherman you don't need to pack so much food:) I am a lousy one so I make sure to bring enough. I always pack my polypropylene long underwear. It is a lot of warmth for not a lot of weight and will keep you warm even when wet. Hope the fishing is good!

Paul Dzioba

Re: anyone remember the list of 10?

#18

gotta tell you Moses

VLParisian

>You Suck.

Enjoy your trip. There are a few among us who want to hear the details.

The Good, The Bad and The Ugly. Which end of the Island, which boat?

Victor - Another Saturday morning in Hot and Humid Houston.

Re: anyone remember the list of 10?

#19

redcoat

Re: packing

redcoat

>I'll report when I get back on the timber framing, but a neighbour I told this planned adventure to, suggested that what an island full of hippies and crafters needs is a freight delivery service...and then pointed at his wheelbarrow and nodded.