Re: not to start it all over again, but. . .
Dave Mount
>I don't remember the original discussion -- I don't think I was watching the hand tools board as carefully back then.
I guess your perspective on this depends a lot on what you assume one will have to do and what your starting materials will be. Also, I suppose if one were doing the covered wagon thing, you'd be thinking more about weight and/or volume than the number of tools. All that said, I was surprised by some of the list -- some thoughts:
If one assumes that trees were to be your starting material, this list seems light on the tools to bring trees down to manageable pieces. One item that missing in my mind is a hewing hatchet or broad axe. While axes come in many designs for different purposes, you could probably find an ax that would be a reasonable compromise between felling and splitting, but hewing is a different operation altogether and I think would warrant including a single bevel hatchet or ax for the purpose.
With regard to saws, I'm not sure exactly what was intended by "x-cut and rip", but I would think that you would want to include a "tree size" saw for felling and crosscutting trees. While combo tools rarely do any operation well, I'd think more about having a heavy saw and a lighter saw than just whether they were x-cut or rip. Besides the woodworking, you're probably going to have some firewood to buck up. Maybe just bringing blades and fittings to make a bowsaw or two if one were trying to stay lighter. . .
The tape and square surprise me. While they are no doubt handy things, you can make a square suitable for wilderness work. Likewise, you can make a tape or at least a measuring stick. In fact, if I were to bring a measuring device, I would think a compass might be a better option. With it, you could make a pretty accurate measuring stick (inches and centimeters are arbitrary units of measure anyway) and would be able to do some other kinds of layout as well (e.g., using it as a coarse marking gauge). You could make a compass also; the point is just that I thought a compass might be a more "core" measuring tool than a tape.
I would think a scratch awl a more valuable marking tool than a pencil -- a pain sometimes compared to a pencil, but it doesn't wear out as fast and has some other uses. Could make one of those too if things like nails, etc. are available.
If tool count were all that mattered, I might cheat and choose a plumb bob (with string attached) instead of just a string (two tools in one). Maybe the string line was assumed to have a body that would serve as a plumb bob as many modern ones do.
Finally, the absence of a plane surprised me. Admittedly, this would only be needed for finer work, but having something that naturally tends toward cutting a straight line rather than having to drawknive to a mark using a tool that doesn't have a reference plane seems like it could be pretty handy, and tough to make a first one without having one (assuming you had an iron along).
Interesting to think about, but I'm content to sit in my modern shop and think about it, rather than live it. . .
Dave