Some further thoughts.....
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
>I'm going to 'answer myself' here, rather than post this under someone else's post. This is in the sense of dialogue, rather than challenge someone else's choice of tools.
Here's a thought that I received offline, and it precisely coincides with my own experience.....I rarely have the problem of needing to remove lots of wood. In starting with roughsawn 4/4 lumber, the issue far more frequently is to maintain final dimension of 13/16" to 7/8". The lumber is usually about 1" thick off the bandsaw at the mill, and dry. I am trying to dress this lumber into straight boards that are 13/16" or thicker. Don't want to take off more than 5/32", say. So what do you do? Well, you lightly skin the board to see the figure; mark it up roughly into parts for the project; and crosscut it a bit oversized. Then you take the crosscuts and rip them a bit oversized. Cause the main thing is to end up with a 13/16"+ board.
By cutting to rough length/width dimensions to start with, you minimize how much wood will have to be wasted to get the boards flat. But now the issue is to dress them down with minimum waste.
That's where true jacks and fores come into their own. Because they are efficiently flattening as they remove the high spots. The one thing you don't want to do in this situation is remove wood from a low spot, because that lick is coming off the final thickness of the board. Plus creating unnecessary work to cut the whole board down to the new low you've just made. I'm talking about true jacks now, and true fores--not just any plane that is 14-15" long or 18-20" long. These are cambered blade planes, the jack more than the fore. I get more feedback out of the jacks and fores than out of a scrub, because their channels read like a topo map of the whole board you're working on. Incidentally, a modified 5-1/4 fits my definition of a jack more than a scrub. The cambered blade makes the woodie act 'heavier' in the sense that it is pulling itself aggressively into the cut--you're not having to hold it in the cut (talking temperate zone hardwoods now). The feedback is fantastic, because the camber narrows the cut, pulls the plane into the cut, and the plane tracks beautifully on line. And unlike most metal scrubs, the jacks and foreplanes are readily adjusted for depth of cut--the woodies with a hammer, the metal planes with their adjuster. Woodie scrubs have this advantage also. Ready depth adjust is an important advantage, in my experience, when your goal is to minimize waste and end up with fat finished stock. A metal scrub w/o adjuster is harder to adjust for depth on the fly, and if the cut is a hair too heavy, it's really easy to cut below the finished thickness you have in mind. Let alone tearing out peppercorns of curl on figured wood.
Now if the conversation changes to surface preparation of the desert ironwoods of the world (either hemisphere), then I agree that a heavy scrub is the way to go--preferably with an HSS blade and diamond media for sharpening. However, for temperate zone hardwoods of Europe and North America, the weight works against you, IMO, if you have a stack of lumber to do.
Do I sound a little intense? I'm not really. I really want people to use and enjoy the tools that they personally like. I just happen to have a passion for woodie jacks and fores. True jacks and fores, with cambered blade--no resemblance to a No. 5, 5-1/2, 62-1/2, or No. 6 with a straight blade. It really makes surface prep from roughsawn a fairly pleasurable experience.
Wiley