Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Recommendations of a decent scrub plane

Posts

Recommendations of a decent scrub plane

#1

Recommendations of a decent scrub plane

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown PA

>More and more, I'm finding that I really need a good scrub plane. I haven't seen any of the old Stanleys around (been flea marketing and garage sale-ing, but didn't check the 'bay yet). Are there any decent planes to look for to use as a scrub. My main use is likely to flatten boards to use in a planer (I know, killing electrons and all). I've been using my LV LA Jack to get the boards relatively flat, but I find that it's length can get in the way when trying to remove small areas, plus it's kinda unwieldy to use one handed.

Thanks in advance!

Re: Recommendations of a decent scrub plane

#2

Re: Recommendations of a decent scrub plane

Frank D. in Montreal

>Hi Stephen,

I use a wooden Ulmia scrub plane that i like; it's very similar to the ECE scrub sold by Lee Valley. I like the wooden body because it's light and easy to take short fast strokes with (what you do with a scrub). Others prefer metal-bodied scrubs because of the weight, though.

I was wondering what kind of camber you have on your LV jack. A real scrub has between 2" and 3" radius of camber on the blade, which IMO renders it almost useless for fine woodworking, unless you have a huge amount of wood to take off and don't want to saw. A scrub can take out huge chunks of reversing grain or figure, and sometimes these chunks go well below the final surface you're aiming for. On the other hand, you'd be surprised how fast a 1/8" crown on the blade of a jack plane can take off wood. If you don't have any camber on your LA jack, IMO you're using it like a panel plane, not a jack. I'd also be surprised if you could use a scrub one-handed. The chips are really chunky (they are not shavings), and you need a lot of momentum or force behind the cutting edge.

HTH

Re: Recommendations of a decent scrub plane

#3

Re: Recommendations of a decent scrub plane

wilbur

>There are several options:

1. eBay: Start searching for "Stanley 40" or "scrub plane", and you should find several at any one time. Used Stanley 40's go for $40-60, depending on auction fever.

2. Shiny new toy: Lie-Nielsen ($145), Lee Valley ($109), and ECE ($80) all currently make scrub planes. The first two are metal bodied, the last is wooden.

3. Convert a plane you already have: Jack planes seem to be the candidate of choice for this. If you get a second blade for your jack plane, grind and sharpen it so that it has a more pronounced camber, and set it so that it protrudes more from the mouth, you'll have a serviceable scrub plane.

I've got an ECE wooden bodied scrub that does well for me. I found it on eBay.

One question: you mentioned that that your low angled jack plane is unwieldy to use one handed. I can't imagine trying to use a scrub plane one handed, given the amount of wood that gets hogged off with each pass. Am I missing something in your question?

Re: Recommendations of a decent scrub plane

#4

Re: Recommendations of a decent scrub plane

wilbur

>After reading Frank's reply, I really need to learn to type faster, or stop spending time embedding links into my posts. :@)

Re: Recommendations of a decent scrub plane

#5

Re: Recommendations of a decent scrub plane

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>I have one of the Shiny New Toys that Wilbur mentions (Veritas), and it's a great tool, this one's staying in my shop.

This said, you can make a substitute out of a cheap smoother or jack. The inexpensive Indian planes (Groz, Anant, Award) are a good choice for this, as they are often lighter than the Stanley counterparts, and the rougher machining of these planes become a non-issue. Grind a good camber, open the mouth wide, and go at it. Not as good as a dedicated scrub, but quite serviceable.

DC

Re: Recommendations of a decent scrub plane

#6

Look for

jim reed @ tallahassee

>german scrub plane that is listed in my ebay store. It is a $29 buy it now.

Re: Recommendations of a decent scrub plane

#7

I suspect

John Hoffman

>The reason that the jack plane is not getting the "small" areas is that it it flattening the work. In order for it to get the small areas it has to bring the high spots down rendering the board flat. I have a scrub and have tried to make a board flat with it and it is very difficult. The reason is that is hogs off material and with its short sole it does not reference off the high spots. I wound up overcompensating here and there. When I use a fore plane 14" to 18" in length, heavily cambered, I get the ability to make the board flat while taking off material. I then hit is with the jointer the smoother. Following Chris Shwarz's coarse medium and fine approach.

Regards

JH

Re: Recommendations of a decent scrub plane

#8

Re: I suspect

Dean J in MN

>I'll second John's assessment. If you want flat, a scrub isn't the way to go. A fore/jack is the tool of choice. If you want to get flat fast you want a fore with a good amount of camber to make it easy to take thick shavings. For me, a metal (or horned) scrub is too short to make a board of any appreciable size flat.

One of the sticky points of the BU jacks is the amount of extra camber you need compared to a BD. The geometry is working to lessen the curve on the blade when used BU. So, I'd suggest trying a good dose of camber on your BU jack. The length of your jack should be an asset in flattening.

-Dean

Re: Recommendations of a decent scrub plane

#9

Best tool for the job (IMO!)

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>is a true jack plane and/or a fore plane--in my opinion/experience. That LV low angle jack is not a jack plane. It fits the British notion of a panel plane--a big smoother. Unless you put a 6" radius camber on the blade--then it becomes a jack.

Take a look at John Hoffman's post below. True jacks and foreplanes are really a pleasure for rapid flattening, and they won't tear peppercorns of curl out of figured wood. I especially like woodies for jacks and foreplanes, but that's another story...

Wiley

Re: Recommendations of a decent scrub plane

#10

Re: Recommendations of a decent scrub plane

ThomD

>I'm guessing the "more and more I need" isn't emotional, but rather project related? If that's the case, do as frank sayd and get a wood one. I took a replacement blade from an ece and made my own, this is the ultimate easy plane making job, about 45 minutes. Keep the mout enormous, provide lots of room all around for the shaving to exit, and it will be a favorite tool. I have heard some interesting observations about the late origins of the scrub plane, but whatever the case, the coarse tool for blowing off unneeded wood is mostly a product of the pre machine age, and metal ones are not efficient. Maybe I could be sold a composite foam and carbon one, but I say save the sewer pipe for something else. This thing comes as close to a hatchet as any plane, and it needs a lightweight wood handle.

Re: Recommendations of a decent scrub plane

#11

Re: Recommendations of a decent scrub plane *LINK*

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>the coarse tool for blowing off unneeded wood is mostly a product of the pre machine age, and metal ones are not efficient. Maybe I could be sold a composite foam and carbon one, but I say save the sewer pipe for something else. This thing comes as close to a hatchet as any plane, and it needs a lightweight wood handle.

Interesting comments Thom. My view is somewhat different.

As others of pointed out, a scrub is for removing waste efficiently. When there is little to remove, then one does not need a formal scrub plane - a cambered jack will do very nicely. But when there is a lot of timber to get rid of so that a flat surface can be created (not necessarily a smooth, flat surface), then the scrub comes into its own. It removes, as we know, chips rather than shavings. OK, all I am saying is that there is a place for a scrub plane.

When making a recommendation of a scrub my first question is "what type of wood are you going to use it on?" In my experience, working predominantly with hard woods, the heavier the scrub plane the better. The added momentum makes for less work, not more. For this reason I do not like using light woodies or even a Stanley #40. I like the LV Scrub and, even better, a Stanley #5 1/2 with a 3" radius cambered blade (same camber as the #40 and LV). Man, this just ploughs through Jarrah! Lighter planes just hop and skip, forcing you to apply more down force to keep them on the surface.

For softer woods, the Stanley #40 is great. It has a light, delicate feel (if one can say such a thing about a scrub plane!). I have not used the LN, but its weight places it between the Stanley and the LV, and I could only extrapolate from this.

Interesting (well I find it so :) ), Mike Wenzloff sent me his re-treaded Stanley #5 1/4-into-scrub to look after until he comes to his senses (about planes designed post 18c). This is the same dimensions and weight as the LV, if anyone is looking at a derelict #5 1/4.

See below for a link to the review I wrote on the LV, with comparisons to the #40 and a ECE-type woodie.

Regards from Perth

Derek


The LV Scrub Plane - a review

Re: Recommendations of a decent scrub plane

#12

Re: Recommendations of a decent scrub plane

ThomD

>On momentum, you can pound a 500 grain, 45 caliber, bullet through an elephant at relatively low velocities, end for end. Halve that weight to 250 grains, and he might decide to return the bullet personally, or so I have heard. On the other hand, where I to double the weight of my scrub plane, it still refuses to continue the cut when I let go of it, probably this is because my 220 is so large a part of the cutting force that even where the plane to weigh 40 pounds it would still be a junior partner. What I do notice, is the drag of the metal plane sole, and the weight carried on the return stroke. Literally a case of different strokes I guess. Since the work is usually pretty rough, wax could be used to overcome the drag of the sole, but the weight still remain.

Re: Recommendations of a decent scrub plane

#13

Re: I suspect

paul womack

> I have a scrub and have tried to make a board flat with it and it is very difficult.

Yeah - I suspect you were trying/hoping to do more with the scrub than is in its nature.

As you say, the skill/judgement in making a board flat efficiently is to use each plane in the sequence for the right amount of time, on the journey from "rough to smooth", as you say.

The complexity comes from the sheer variability in both scrubs and jacks.

Scrubs can be set quite fine, and the degree of camber on a jack can vary from a 1/16" up to 1/4", depending on preferance, and reference century of choice.

The correct tuning and mode of use of each plane in the sequence MUST surely relate to the tuning (and sheer quantity :-) of the other planes in the sequence.

BugBear

Re: Recommendations of a decent scrub plane

#14

Re: I suspect

Bart Leetch

>Well I quickly reviewed to scrub plane review very interesting.

Now I realize I may be going over plowed ground again but what about as a temporary solution putting in a cambered blade in corrugated #6 I have extra blades & I think I may even have a tapered blade.

If that won't work I'll just use the power Jointer & planer to remove down close & finish with hand planes.

Re: Recommendations of a decent scrub plane

#15

modified 5-1/4

dave brown

>I use a modified 5-1/4 as my scrub plane and it works great.

Scrub planes are of more value than one might think. Their obvious use is to take a huge amount of wood off in a hurry. When you set the blade to take a light cut it can take off smaller amounts of wood with little effort. Because it is so short, it can get into areas that a try or jack plane can't. Sometimes a jack plane is just too big for the job but with the scrub you know exactly where it's going to cut -- like piloting a big 4x4 through Baja when you'd have more fun in a dune buggy. ;-) And as Derek said the scrub gives you a lot more sensory feedback. I even use mine to remove paint when I'm recycling wood from old projects -- does a much quicker job than a scraper.

Re: Recommendations of a decent scrub plane

#16

Re: I suspect

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>I have wanted a #40 for a long time, but I'm not sure why. I have an extra #5 with a cambered blade and wide open mouth that has served me well for years. It will take off just as much wood as my arms will allow.

There really is no reason for me to get that 40, other than just wanting it.

Bruce

Re: Recommendations of a decent scrub plane

#17

Here comes the rain

jim reed @ tallahassee

>Sorry to rain on your parade, but my experience is that bench planes make lousy scrub planes. For one thing, the blade is too thin (1/16"). I have had scrub sessions that lasted for hours and found that 3/16" is the proper blade size.

Re: Recommendations of a decent scrub plane

#18

Re: Here comes the rain again

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>That was a good song...

As I said, "Not as good as a dedicated scrub", so we somewhat agree. But they're not that bad, better than nothing at least... And the irons are usually thicker than 1/16" (not by much sometimes, though).

DC

Re: Recommendations of a decent scrub plane

#19

Rationale for buying tools

wilbur

>"There really is no reason for me to get that 40, other than just wanting it."

And this is different from any other potential tool purchase because.....?

:@)

Re: Recommendations of a decent scrub plane

#20

Re: Rationale for buying tools

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Scrub planes are very narrow, precisely because the job they do is hard on the arms.

Pam

Re: Recommendations of a decent scrub plane

#21

IMHO too!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>I prefer a "true" jack or fore plane also. I do find that a scrub plane does come in handy for removing the fuzz from realy ruff-cut wood. Then it's on to the jack or fore plane.

Re: Recommendations of a decent scrub plane

#22

how'd you like to come talk to my wife

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>about my tool purchases :-)))

Re: Recommendations of a decent scrub plane

#23

Some further thoughts.....

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>I'm going to 'answer myself' here, rather than post this under someone else's post. This is in the sense of dialogue, rather than challenge someone else's choice of tools.

Here's a thought that I received offline, and it precisely coincides with my own experience.....I rarely have the problem of needing to remove lots of wood. In starting with roughsawn 4/4 lumber, the issue far more frequently is to maintain final dimension of 13/16" to 7/8". The lumber is usually about 1" thick off the bandsaw at the mill, and dry. I am trying to dress this lumber into straight boards that are 13/16" or thicker. Don't want to take off more than 5/32", say. So what do you do? Well, you lightly skin the board to see the figure; mark it up roughly into parts for the project; and crosscut it a bit oversized. Then you take the crosscuts and rip them a bit oversized. Cause the main thing is to end up with a 13/16"+ board.

By cutting to rough length/width dimensions to start with, you minimize how much wood will have to be wasted to get the boards flat. But now the issue is to dress them down with minimum waste.

That's where true jacks and fores come into their own. Because they are efficiently flattening as they remove the high spots. The one thing you don't want to do in this situation is remove wood from a low spot, because that lick is coming off the final thickness of the board. Plus creating unnecessary work to cut the whole board down to the new low you've just made. I'm talking about true jacks now, and true fores--not just any plane that is 14-15" long or 18-20" long. These are cambered blade planes, the jack more than the fore. I get more feedback out of the jacks and fores than out of a scrub, because their channels read like a topo map of the whole board you're working on. Incidentally, a modified 5-1/4 fits my definition of a jack more than a scrub. The cambered blade makes the woodie act 'heavier' in the sense that it is pulling itself aggressively into the cut--you're not having to hold it in the cut (talking temperate zone hardwoods now). The feedback is fantastic, because the camber narrows the cut, pulls the plane into the cut, and the plane tracks beautifully on line. And unlike most metal scrubs, the jacks and foreplanes are readily adjusted for depth of cut--the woodies with a hammer, the metal planes with their adjuster. Woodie scrubs have this advantage also. Ready depth adjust is an important advantage, in my experience, when your goal is to minimize waste and end up with fat finished stock. A metal scrub w/o adjuster is harder to adjust for depth on the fly, and if the cut is a hair too heavy, it's really easy to cut below the finished thickness you have in mind. Let alone tearing out peppercorns of curl on figured wood.

Now if the conversation changes to surface preparation of the desert ironwoods of the world (either hemisphere), then I agree that a heavy scrub is the way to go--preferably with an HSS blade and diamond media for sharpening. However, for temperate zone hardwoods of Europe and North America, the weight works against you, IMO, if you have a stack of lumber to do.

Do I sound a little intense? I'm not really. I really want people to use and enjoy the tools that they personally like. I just happen to have a passion for woodie jacks and fores. True jacks and fores, with cambered blade--no resemblance to a No. 5, 5-1/2, 62-1/2, or No. 6 with a straight blade. It really makes surface prep from roughsawn a fairly pleasurable experience.

Wiley

Re: Recommendations of a decent scrub plane

#24

Thanks for the responses

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown, PA

>I think I'll definitely look for a good scrub plane, either a vintage Stanley or a new LV. I thought Derek's review was very nicely done. I certainly like old tools, but with limited time it's often easier to get a new one in absolutely perfect shape. I've got other LV tools and I've always been very pleased with their performance.

As for the question about using a scrub one handed, I was thinking of Cosman's video where he discusses liking the LN because you can use it one handed to nip off little spots on a board.

My general use of a scrub plane is to get a board flat enough on one side to go into a planer. I use the LV LA Jack with just the regular blade. It does get the job done but of course it's tough and takes a while. Plus, sometimes when trying to take down a few high spots it's tough to hold the longer plane steady to get a good shaving.

Now, do I go hit eBay or LV? I've noticed those old tool prices steadily climbing towards new tool prices myself ...

Re: Recommendations of a decent scrub plane

#25

Cosman's one hand technique

wilbur

>You also have to keep in mind that Rob Cosman uses a #8 for jointing, and a #4 1/2 where most of us mortals would use a #4.

He probably has all that arm strength as a result from lifting all of his nine kids. :@)