Re: You are Right +1
ThomD
>" If I owned a plane made by Krenov, to take a recent example, I certainly would not cut 3" off it if I needed a shorter plane."
Neither would I, but the reason is probably more economic that some other value. Krenov got fed up with the American tool culture (last I heard), and gave away his planes, and made ugly replacements for them. He appears to be trying not to be too sentimental about it, so why should we be sentimental.
It's too bad if people "senselessly" wreak stuff like burning 36" diameter Osage trees because they like the way they form coals. It worked for them but some of us see the possibility of something more. Maybe they would be heart broken to learn how much the wood they burned was worth, or maybe they wouldn't care, but the option of an informed choice is something they might appreciate.
The problem with this kind of discussion is that there isn't any ultimate value set to use. The person burning the wood may prize their fuel independence more than the value of the wood. Someone else might see it through a different lens.
History, anthropology are the kind of egghead things that used to command respect, back when professional intellectuals hadn't been replaced with various media figures, or before schools got so dumbed down. Nowadays ideas like historical value are pretty inflated. So many new claims have been laid one can barely keep track. It's like air mile points or the barely collectible coins the mint keeps issuing. If I was in the garbage business I would cringe at the thought of all this stuff getting handed in.
One of the oddities of collecting is that often the worst garbage, commands the highest prices at least in recent centuries. There has to have been enough of the stuff for people to want it, but the supply needs to be constrained. It's hard to think of cast iron planes in the same light as the dead sea scrolls.
"That's true, metric is not intrinsically more accurate than imperial; but it is normally more accurate to use one or the other when it matters."
So true. There are some bad seeds in the Client State measurements (metric). It's easy to loose one's place in longer measurements there are so many repeated places on the tape that look the same. Problem for stuff like boatbuilding, but hardly ever on furniture. Also calipers seem to be about half as accurate at .05 client state, vs. .001" in Imperial.
Overall there is something nostalgic about the whole debate. Takes me back to a little town in Canada, at a private school, were we learned lots of science, because it was the space age and we would all be technical people. Metric was a badge of pride. If you got metric that made you one of tomorrow's people. Though exactly what relevance it has to the actual growth industries of our day like porn, marketing coffee, or teaching pilates, remains unclear.