Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Altering old tools

Posts

Re: Altering old tools

#26

Re: You are Right

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>That's true, metric is not intrinsically more accurate than imperial; but it is normally more accurate to use one or the other when it matters. I hated having to measure stuff repeatedly just to know which tool to use; and then there's the proclivity to get that wrong from time to time. Remember the Challenger (or some later shuttle crash) that was caused because some engineer misunderstood that a part should have been metric and substituted imperial, which little mistake cost us billions.

Pam

Re: Altering old tools

#27

Re: Way I see it....

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>some Gomer is going to find that No. 4 type 1 and get to a cutting and filing after tossing the original box in the trash.

No, I think Jim knows the difference between a typr 1 and say a type 16, tho I cannot vouch for what he'd do with the box. ;~)

Just this past sunday I modified my T.C Toles quick release woodworking vise. It had two stops, one of the fase of the vise itself, and one on the handle, which engaged and prevented the handle from being able to rotate past 360 degrees. This was particularily annoying because the thread of the shaft is very coarse, so 9 times out of 10 when I put a piece of wood between the jaws and shoved it closed the teeth wouldn't engage in jaw. What I'd have to do is wiggle the vise open a bit more than put a shim between the vise and the work as since I couldn't rotate the handle past 360 degrees I couldn't really cinch the vise up tight. This was quite annoying, so I sawed the stop off of the handle and now I can rotate it past 360 degrees and cinch it up tight without worring about finding a shim.

So, did I ruin a valuable or rare vise? I dunno, and at this point I really don't care. To me it was useless as it was, and now it is very useful. I paid $12 for this vise back in '88, so not one to cry over spilt milk if it turns out to be worth $1,200 or $12,000 in it's orignal condition than oh well, so be it I guess. I did think about for quite sometime before I did it, and decided that to me the modification really didn't spoil the vise as a vise and in my opinion actually improved it, so I did the deed and have no remorse.

Bob Hackett always says( and just where is Bob these days?)that a tool is nothing more than a kit awaiting to be modified and after much soul searching I can pretty much agree with that sentiment.

Now, I'm not advocating the slaughter of tools just for the sake of it, and I do agree that due to extreme rarity that some tools shouldn't be modified for prosperity sakes, but other than that I say modify as you need to customize the tool to your needs, heck, your adding to the tools History by doing so.

I, like Todd also find interest in craftsman made repairs, and also in craftsman made tools. I have the coolest homemade Stanley #71 that I got for $1.00 at a flea market a few years back, and I have a homemade bandsaw that works just as slick as you could want that I paid $20 and totally re-habbed.

T.O.

Re: Altering old tools

#28

You may be thinking of that Jupiter satellite...

John in New Mexico

>Maybe it was Saturn. Three or four years ago a major research effort ended when the satellite crashed into the planet it was going to when one of the engineering teams forgot to convert some of their work from imperial to metric.

John

Re: Altering old tools

#29

Re: You are Right +1

ThomD

>" If I owned a plane made by Krenov, to take a recent example, I certainly would not cut 3" off it if I needed a shorter plane."

Neither would I, but the reason is probably more economic that some other value. Krenov got fed up with the American tool culture (last I heard), and gave away his planes, and made ugly replacements for them. He appears to be trying not to be too sentimental about it, so why should we be sentimental.

It's too bad if people "senselessly" wreak stuff like burning 36" diameter Osage trees because they like the way they form coals. It worked for them but some of us see the possibility of something more. Maybe they would be heart broken to learn how much the wood they burned was worth, or maybe they wouldn't care, but the option of an informed choice is something they might appreciate.

The problem with this kind of discussion is that there isn't any ultimate value set to use. The person burning the wood may prize their fuel independence more than the value of the wood. Someone else might see it through a different lens.

History, anthropology are the kind of egghead things that used to command respect, back when professional intellectuals hadn't been replaced with various media figures, or before schools got so dumbed down. Nowadays ideas like historical value are pretty inflated. So many new claims have been laid one can barely keep track. It's like air mile points or the barely collectible coins the mint keeps issuing. If I was in the garbage business I would cringe at the thought of all this stuff getting handed in.

One of the oddities of collecting is that often the worst garbage, commands the highest prices at least in recent centuries. There has to have been enough of the stuff for people to want it, but the supply needs to be constrained. It's hard to think of cast iron planes in the same light as the dead sea scrolls.

"That's true, metric is not intrinsically more accurate than imperial; but it is normally more accurate to use one or the other when it matters."

So true. There are some bad seeds in the Client State measurements (metric). It's easy to loose one's place in longer measurements there are so many repeated places on the tape that look the same. Problem for stuff like boatbuilding, but hardly ever on furniture. Also calipers seem to be about half as accurate at .05 client state, vs. .001" in Imperial.

Overall there is something nostalgic about the whole debate. Takes me back to a little town in Canada, at a private school, were we learned lots of science, because it was the space age and we would all be technical people. Metric was a badge of pride. If you got metric that made you one of tomorrow's people. Though exactly what relevance it has to the actual growth industries of our day like porn, marketing coffee, or teaching pilates, remains unclear.

Re: Altering old tools

#30

Software translation

Jim Reed @ Tallahassee

>Seems to me the space probe error was in the software that mixed miles per second with meters per second and ended up going too fast.

Re: Altering old tools

#31

Re: You are Right +2

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Well, there have to be some keepers of the light so when this north american culture wakes up, the knowledge will still be there, maybe just a little harder to find.

You guys are right that it wasn't the Challenger, think that was the frozen O-ring that Feynman diagnosed; but I'm pretty sure it was another shuttle trip, maybe the one that cracked up on descent and spread itself all over Texas and Louisianna.

Pam

Re: Altering old tools

#32

Just for the record...... *LINK*

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>John's on the right track. It was the Mars Climate Orbiter, lost in 1999. The Orbiter was entering Mars' atmosphere, and its trajectory was controlled by thruster engines (through a complex mechanism I can't explain). Anyway, a subcontractor Lockheed Martin was performing thrust computations for project management at NASA. Lockheed was delivering its thrust data to NASA in lb(force)-seconds, rather than Newton-seconds.

It was determined fairly early that something was going wrong, but the engineers were unable to track down the source of the error in time to prevent loss of the space craft.

It was a stunning incident, as all will remember. A detailed account of the problem is given in the link below.

Wiley


Mars Climate Orbiter nightmare

Re: Altering old tools

#33

Surley You Must Be Joking Mr Feynman

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Hi Wiley,

I am a fan of the late Dr. Feynman, I have read most of his books...but you mentioned his name and it brought a smile to my face...but way OT!

:-)

Take care,

Jim

Re: Altering old tools

#34

Re: Just for the record......

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Thanks, John and Wiley, great info. Of course, it was metric vs imperial at the heart of the problem, got that part right. :)

Pam

Re: Altering old tools

#35

Re: Altering old woodworkers?

Adam Cherubini

>Forget about altering old tools, I'm wondering if its right or even possible to alter old woodworkers? Take you for example, John. You've got a lot of great functionalities. But do you think its possible to modify you into something more useful? A plumber perhaps?

As for me, I've been working on learning some practical skills....OOps, gotta go, fries are up!

Adam

Re: Altering old tools

#36

Re: get off the cross...

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Yeah, it's hard to find dogwood that size anymore.

I don't frequent power tool forums (I don't own any power tools) so I thought this was appropriate.

I do not live in an old house but I have worked on over 40 buildings on the National Historic Registery, and left them 'older' than I found them.

As for the vehicle I drove 30 years ago was my ex-wifes truck, she is still driving it. The vehicle I drove 40 years ago (1953 Jag Mark VII Saloon), has been fully restored by its present owner.

I have never 'refinished' a single piece of furniture, but I have repaired, restored and conserved 100's and 100's of pieces of furniture, that is what I do. I have work in a dozen museums across the country.

I have made scrapers and other tools from old broken hand saw blades and I have reused the wrought iron in old wagon wheels to make tools.

Stephen

Re: Altering old tools

#37

Re: get off the cross...

Ernie Miller

>You sure know how to take the fun out of a tuesday morning tumble down a hill. I can see you have a differant perspective than the rest of us but an auger bit is an auger bit. I shipped off three sets to people here in the last few weeks. they are not rare or collectable. and if they are modified to make ones job eiser that so be it. I can't see modifing any of my old woodies when it is almost as easy to make a new one. but that is a differant story. I do have a pile that would make better fire wood than tools but I haven't gone that far yet.

Re: Altering old tools

#38

Re: Altering old woodworkers?

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Adam,

John has a lot of hidden skills (shhh John, I'll never tell, okay), I am not sure about his issues with alterations, but vision is always important.....and listening for the Fry beeper is a reflex, getting them out in time is skill!

LOL

take care,

Jim

Re: Altering old tools

#39

Re: Altering old woodworkers?

wilbur

>John's not an old woodworker. :@)

Re: Altering old tools

#40

I agree but would qualify -kinda long and boaring

Derek

>I do agree that using one measurement system is important to reduce errors. This is because conversions require calculations which is a source of errors.

I use "imperial" measurements in the shop for the simple reason that almost everything I deal with uses that measurement system. I have a feel for it that I do not have for metric measurements because I do not use them in my daily life much. I learned metric measurements in grade school, over 45 years ago, and am comfortable with them in a general sense.

I would prefer to use them because I believe there is simplicity in using one set of numbers rather than two (meters rather than inches and feet). There is an inherent issue with the imperial system in converting from inches to feet and inches and back, however. I work around this, most of the time, by using inch measurements whenever possible. Factors of 12 are not as intuitive as factors of 10 since we normally work and think in base 10 (and most of us have 10 fingers rather than 12).

Though I agree that there is no inherent accuracy difference between metric and imperial, there is certainly less to convert in metric than in imperial measurements. It is easier to catch an error which is a factor of 10 or 100 off (e.g converting cm to meters, for example) than an error of 10/12 or 12/10. This is really the only place I feel the metric system has an advantage over the imperial system.

In summary, though, almost everything in my life uses the imperial system. Because of this, I tolerate the 10/12 and 12/10 conversions. Rooms in my home are imperial. Wood is sold in imperial measurements (most of it anyways). Lots of things are measured in imperial measurement. I have a feel for it. I intuitively know what an inch is and a foot and 6'7" means something to my poor brain. I do not deal with 157 cm so it is not intuitive. I stick with imperial for this reason.

I am more accurate with imperial. The system is not more or less accurate, but I am.

Re: Altering old tools

#42

Philosphically Speaking

David Miller from Iowa

>Interesting that this is such a heated debate.

When I was a kid in the 1960s I can remember helping my grandmother clean out her attic. We made a huge pile of antique furniture, hundred year old clothes, beaver skin hats, spinning wheels, old paintings, giant bibles - you name it � stuff that had been accumulating in this huge attic since the house was made about 1870 - there was even a Union Civil War uniform and a bunch of Civil War papers. Then my Grandmother lit it on fire and burned it all � she just wanted it out of her house. Obviously pre-Antiques Roadshow.

My mother flipped because of the �lost value� - she knew she could have gotten some bucks out of the deal. My grandmother had enough money to be comfortable and didn�t want people �pawing through her things�. I sided with my grandmother � it was her stuff and I figured she could do with it as she pleased (it was a glorious bonfire).

I still feel this way � we may disagree with what people do with their possessions and declare it waste and unconscionable and rant about loss of history, but it is our absolute right to do what we want with our own stuff.

Re: Altering old tools

#43

Re: get off the cross...

Rob Brophy...lost in Niagara

>Stephen,

I agree with your sentiment but few like to be 'preached at'.

Repairing, restoring and conserving antiques is a good trade...there has always been and will always be demand for craftsmen to undo the work of the previous generation's conservators.

How exactly does one leave a building 'older' than one finds it? If anything messes with history, a later generation's interpretation of how it -might- have been done two hundred years ago would be it. Why not just repair whatever 'needs fixin' in a craftsmanlike manner using the best available materials?

Gotta admit that while I have cut up my fair share of broken iron planes for fun I have never cut up a saw for scrapers...how small does a saw blade have to be to be useless for sawing? It could be worried right down to a keyhole saw before it was done. They're not making old saws anymore...Lee Valley sells scrapers at very reasonable prices.

And I have reported your heresy to the wagon wheel collectors guild :-)

Rob...who's always considered a computer to be a power tool

Re: Altering old tools

#44

Re: Philosphically Speaking

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>"I still feel this way – we may disagree with what people do with their possessions and declare it waste and unconscionable and rant about loss of history, but it is our absolute right to do what we want with our own stuff."

My dad turned 81 Monday. He calls it 'lightening the load'.

Re: Altering old tools

#45

I probably will not cut the tang of this one

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>This is a Cooks Patent 1851. This is a few years before Jennings and Gedge. It is in the style of Gedge but earlier. It is two inches in diameter and this style actually cuts a clean hole.

Stephen


img

Re: Altering old tools

#46

Here is the Maker's Stamp 

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>


img

Re: Altering old tools

#47

Re: I probably will not cut the tang of this one

MikeW

>Whether new (ask Rob Lee) or vintage, I am pretty fearless about tool modifications.

Your bit is a good example of one I wouldn't modify though. Too many newer bits out there if one wishes to cannabalize one.

Cool looking bit, Stephen.

Take care, Mike

Re: Altering old tools

#48

Re: Philosphically Speaking

ThomD

>"Though I agree that there is no inherent accuracy difference between metric and imperial, there is certainly less to convert in metric than in imperial measurements. It is easier to catch an error which is a factor of 10 or 100 off (e.g converting cm to meters, for example) than an error of 10/12 or 12/10. This is really the only place I feel the metric system has an advantage over the imperial system."

Be of good cheer, it is a lot easier to divide 12 17/32" in half than 318.3 mm, though neither is particularly difficult.

I can't say I feel too strongly about either system. Neither was designed to meet our particular needs. In that regard, Japan seems to have had a system that what more tailored to carpentry needs, possibly because large building where among their major design achievements at the time of contact. In that regard even such maters as a math based naval architecture came along after the client state measure and imperial measures where invented. It's all a kluge for most technical purposes. I largely find it amusing when people defend one system over another as though the underlying design where actually particularly useful to most people. Imperial has the advantage that the units therein spontaneously occur in many other systems. So if one prefers that kind of co-incidence to stuff like what was cutting edge science in the 18th century, one has a personal winner.