Re: Altering old tools - I concur - to a point...
John Aniano in central NJ...
>Stephen,
I also agree that older tools shouldn't be modified, up to a point. In my opinion, your example of removing the tang from an older twist drill is correct - it shouldn't have been done. They ruined a good tool - they should have bought a new twist drill for their modern drill. You said it - these tools aren't being made anymore.
Here is where we differ though. If there is a very common tool, one made in great quantities, making slight modifications might be appropriate, especially if the tool's function is improved. I rarely modify older tools and usually ask myself if the modification I'm making would have been though an improvement by the original maker. If so, I proceed; if not, I'll simply restore the tool.
Further, at what point do we say a particular "modification" is just that, or is it really simply a required restoration?...
First example - I own a nice Scottish badger plane, made in the mid- to late-19th century. The mouth is quite gaping. Should I refrain from installing a wooden patch to close the mouth thinking that I'll improve the tool's performance? In this particular case, the badger plane's open mouth doesn't seem to affect how well it cuts, especially on the end grain cuts of a raised panel. Thus, if I had installed the wood patch, I might have diminished the plane's performance. Thus, another of my general rules - try the tool out first and assess how well it works. More than likely, with the proper sharpening, etc. it will work just fine. Saves you time, effort and keeps an older tool more in it's pristine condition.
Second example - I also have a very nice John Green wooden toothing plane. Rare stamp with the "J" in John, not the "I". When I got the plane to my shop, I noticed that the blade was so tightly wedged in the stock that when finally freed, it was not going to go back in. The wooden stock blade opening had, over the years, shrunk to maybe 1/16" less than the blade. Thus, what to do? This toothing plane was far more valuable than the Scottish badger plane, yet without reducing the original blade width, I'd never be able reassemble the plane let alone use it. So I carefully marked the blade and ground away the original metal to get the blade to again fit the stock. All the while grinding, I felt bad doing this. Yet, I reassured myself that if the blade was not reduced in width, eventually the wooden stock would have split due to the pressure. So, I argued to myself, I was "saving" the plane.
Some might disagree with my actions, but I still feel these tools were meant to be used, but used in the manner in which they were conceived. If you think you have to make a modification, think long and hard before doing it and keep in mind a tool's pedigree and rarity before proceeding.
OK, I'm off my soap box!
Take care,
John