Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Altering old tools

Posts

Altering old tools

#1

Altering old tools

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>This is in response to the discussion previously about English Oval Bolstered Mortice chisels below.

There is nothing more frustrating than encountering an old tool that has been 'butchered' by some subsequent owner to meet their demands. Cutting off a tapered tang from a nice early twist bit to fit in a modern power tool has forever distroyed the original, remember they don't make this stuff anymore.

There is nothing wrong with proper restoration of tools, and they were originally made to be used, properly used and not abused and they should be used. Old tools that are neglected can deteriorate, so it is a good idea to use them.

However altering an old tool to fit your new needs is just wrong. I have passed on hundreds of old tools that have been 'altered', somebody ruined them for posterity.

Please restore and use the old tools, but if you alter them then it is on your hands, you have changed history forever.

Stephen

Re: Altering old tools

#2

get off the cross...

Rob Brophy...lost in Niagara

>...we need the wood.

I suspect anyone reading this forum has already saved a fair number of tools from destruction/enhancement. Perhaps you should post your thoughts on a few power tool forums.

Do you live in an old house Stephen? Have you changed it in any way? What have you done with the car you were driving thirty years ago? Have you ever refinished a piece of furniture?

A lot of these tools were modified when they were a few years old and readily available.

Rob

Re: Altering old tools

#3

Re: Altering old tools

paul womack

>Please restore and use the old tools, but if you alter them then it is on your hands, you have changed history forever.

It's merely a question of degree. If I take an old coffin smoother, and restore it for use (as you suggest), and evidence of old sharpening techniques is forever gone from the blade.

I have a "NOS" Ibboton plane blade; if I ever use it, any evidence of Ibbotson's production bevel grinding will be lost.

In short, even "minor" restoration also constitutes modification.

Your argument therefore needs qualifying (I suggest) by the rarity and age of the tool being modified, and degree of modification.

BugBear

Re: Altering old tools

#4

Perhaps

jim reed @ tallahassee

>there are some tools that are so special and so unique that they should be maintained exactly as found. Most tools, however, are made for use. I manufacture tools on a small scale. My tools are made to common patterns. If a user wants to modify the tool then I am delighted. Nothing was sacred about my original design. Some tools are just starting points. Witness the number of Stanley combo plane cutters that have been reground. A modified tool is a tool that was used and that is its real purpose.

Re: Altering old tools

#5

Re: Perhaps

paul womack

>A modified tool is a tool that was used and that is its real purpose

Further, a modified tool may tell us LESS about the manufacturer, but it tells us MORE about the user.

Who's to say which is the more important?

An anecdote - I was talking to a tool dealer, who sold a very good condition adze (with a good handle) to a carpenter. Who promptly sawed the handle very short. Turns out he was working in cramped condition in the roof space of Windsor castle during the restoration...

BugBear

Re: Altering old tools

#6

Re: Altering old tools

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Oh, boy, this is going to be another long thread. Tools are made to be used, and if it's necessary to modify a tool to suit my needs, I'll do it rather than going through a selling/buying cycle. So, Record 043 and 044 plough planes ship with imperial blades. What's the harm in grinding a few of the blades down to metric?

Pam

Re: Altering old tools

#7

Re: Altering old tools

Ernie Miller

>I think there is a differance between abusing a tool beyond use and altering one that will be left to rust or tossed into the trash into one that will be used. I have several of them tangless drill bits and will pick up a few more as time passes. they work great in my slow 1/2" drill they will zip thru a large plank faster than any new bits I have seen. I will chuck a 5/8" one in the drill this weekend and boor holes in studs of a sun room I am building for the misses this weekend. I do hate the way people continue yo pound away on a socket chisel long after the handle has split away. but to say History in on your hands for cuttin off a drill bit is a little far over the edge of reason. I have never cut a drill bit they are to hard and it is to much work. now that I have a cut off saw aI could give it a go but no need as I have enough. I'm probably wrong for cutting saw blades up into scrapers in you book.

Re: Altering old tools

#8

Re: Altering old tools

Ernie Miller

>Pam? Your in America what ios with this metric stuff? This is going to be a long thread Lets both remember to think then type and bite out toung when necessary. Days don't get any better than this. cool morning great cup of coffee on the patio and now this when I get to work.

Re: Altering old tools

#9

Re: Altering old tools - I concur - to a point...

John Aniano in central NJ...

>Stephen,

I also agree that older tools shouldn't be modified, up to a point. In my opinion, your example of removing the tang from an older twist drill is correct - it shouldn't have been done. They ruined a good tool - they should have bought a new twist drill for their modern drill. You said it - these tools aren't being made anymore.

Here is where we differ though. If there is a very common tool, one made in great quantities, making slight modifications might be appropriate, especially if the tool's function is improved. I rarely modify older tools and usually ask myself if the modification I'm making would have been though an improvement by the original maker. If so, I proceed; if not, I'll simply restore the tool.

Further, at what point do we say a particular "modification" is just that, or is it really simply a required restoration?...

First example - I own a nice Scottish badger plane, made in the mid- to late-19th century. The mouth is quite gaping. Should I refrain from installing a wooden patch to close the mouth thinking that I'll improve the tool's performance? In this particular case, the badger plane's open mouth doesn't seem to affect how well it cuts, especially on the end grain cuts of a raised panel. Thus, if I had installed the wood patch, I might have diminished the plane's performance. Thus, another of my general rules - try the tool out first and assess how well it works. More than likely, with the proper sharpening, etc. it will work just fine. Saves you time, effort and keeps an older tool more in it's pristine condition.

Second example - I also have a very nice John Green wooden toothing plane. Rare stamp with the "J" in John, not the "I". When I got the plane to my shop, I noticed that the blade was so tightly wedged in the stock that when finally freed, it was not going to go back in. The wooden stock blade opening had, over the years, shrunk to maybe 1/16" less than the blade. Thus, what to do? This toothing plane was far more valuable than the Scottish badger plane, yet without reducing the original blade width, I'd never be able reassemble the plane let alone use it. So I carefully marked the blade and ground away the original metal to get the blade to again fit the stock. All the while grinding, I felt bad doing this. Yet, I reassured myself that if the blade was not reduced in width, eventually the wooden stock would have split due to the pressure. So, I argued to myself, I was "saving" the plane.

Some might disagree with my actions, but I still feel these tools were meant to be used, but used in the manner in which they were conceived. If you think you have to make a modification, think long and hard before doing it and keep in mind a tool's pedigree and rarity before proceeding.

OK, I'm off my soap box!

Take care,

John

Re: Altering old tools

#10

Re: Altering old tools

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>When I started woodworking again about seven years ago, I found myself constantly converting between metric and imperial, which was also a big problem in working on various cars and motorcycles; so I simply declared my shop metric to the extent possible. I happen to prefer whole numbers and find millimeters a much better standard unit than fractions of inches.

It is a beautiful day; but we've had this discussion before, and it was always long. :)

Pam

Re: Altering old tools

#11

Re: Altering old tools

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>Stephen,

You appear to be very passionate about maintaining tools in their original state. Certainly nothing wrong with that. However the history of woodworking and those who work with tools is much about the craftsmen who have modified tools to best work for them and achieve the results they seek in their craft. It's not a new phenomenon by any means.

Tom

Re: Altering old tools

#12

Re: Altering old tools

Wayne

>I collect old coins and used to get mad when I would encounter one with a hole in it. It would have been worth a bunch of money if the hole wasn't there. Then a light came on and I remembered using nice standing liberty quarters or buffalo nickels to make rings out of or poking holes in them to hang around my neck. Well now they are scarce but then they were just a nickel or quarter and had only that value. So we work with what we got and hope for the best and that what we cut up isn't a Rembrant or how ever you spell the painters name. Man I whish I had all those Barber Half Dollars I once had!!

Re: Altering old tools

#13

There's nothing sacred about history....

John in New Mexico

>You're making it right now, as are the rest of us. As someone pointed out above (Jim or Paul I think), modification of a tool tells us -- or more importantly the potential future historian -- a lot about how a craftsman worked. Even the continued use of hand tools in the age of power has historical significance, and modifications are part of the history. Your example fits that perfectly -- a tool that is useless except as a collector's item or for a craftsperson who works exclusively with hand tools, is modified to work better with a modern tool than the modern bits available (brace bits are bigger than twist drills, and speedbores make nasty ragged holes). Conservators (like my sister) may shudder in horror, but in 100 years someone may write a thesis on the evolution of drill bit design, and may be very happy to find this butchered piece of evidence.

John

Re: Altering old tools

#14

Re: Altering old tools

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Hi Pam,

I too work back and forth between Imperial and metric, it's not too difficult to do, but I prefer metric. As you said it's simple to move a decimal or work in a whole number. This indeed has been a long topic in the past. :-)

My 10 year old daughter does not know how many feet are in a yard or even in a mile, she actually does not know what a mile is, or a quart, or a gallon....she's 100% metric and a part of me smiles to know she is.

Take care,

Jim

Yes, this could become a long post but doing a search in the WC files would be good enough.

:-)

Re: Altering old tools

#15

have to disagree mostly

Ron in Kokomo

>A tool that is scarce and therefore of some historical noteworthiness should be preserved.

This does not apply to the great majority of what we come across in our lives. The value of a tool is its utility. So change it as you need to to get the job done in your situation.

Lets not get emotional over a twist drill bit. ( even a Jennings) They made them by the box car loads and the only museums that care have plenty of them.

My $.02

Re: Altering old tools

#16

Re: Altering old tools

Ron in Kokomo

>Pam

You and I sometimes disagree. Not on this obe, have a Great day!

Re: Altering old tools

#17

Re: Altering old tools

mikew

>Hmm. An interesting thesis which as Pam noted could grow long--or not. Who knows?

I made the assumption you are not referring to such issues as making a blade fit a shrunken body as surely even an original owner would have done so.

I keep coming back to the point someone made about rarity. At what point is a rare thing worth preserving and a commom thing worth altering? Ever?

The opposite poles seem to be either don't use it [pure collection] or modify at will. Surely each one of us draws a line on a case by case basis which fits somewhere between [or at either end].

I think there are too many examples demonstating that a given owner in or close to the period of manufacture altered tools to meet their needs. So the question is, does being so close to the date of a tool's creation make that OK? Is it therefore wrong for someone generations past to do the same?

Me? I'll modify any tool I own if I believe it will improve the tool for my needs. Then again, I doubt I'll ever purchase such a rare tool that even I wouldn't modify or use it.

Take care, Mike

Re: Altering old tools

#18

collector vs user

Bill Tindal, E.TN

>When I buy an old, or new tool, to use I don't share your philosophy that it must be preserved in its original state. It is a tool after all. On the other hand, I would agree that it makes no sense to alter something that was a tool that now for whatever reason is a rare collectors item or work of art. If I owned a plane made by Krenov, to take a recent example, I certainly would not cut 3" off it if I needed a shorter plane. I would buy another shorter plane. Back when I lived in the frozen north and ice fished, a 2" socket chisel welded to a pipe made a very fine spud for chopping holes in the ice. The old socket chisel was of no value to me and less value to others than the value of the spud.

Re: Altering old tools

#19

Re: Altering old tools

wilbur

>A rare tool that I don't use because it needs modification isn't a tool. It's a paperweight.

Re: Altering old tools

#20

Re: Altering old tools - I concur - to a point...

Dave Anderson Chester, NH

>Most excellent examples John. I have a 24" Chapin by Union Fore plane and a 28" jointer by the same maker where the bodies shrunk to clamp the irons very tightly in place and make them difficult to remove. I, like you, ground the irons a bit, but I also used my floats to slightly widen the escapements. Both planes are extremely valuable to me, not for thier rarity, but because they were my Great-G-G Grandfathers and I am fortunate enough to be the current custodian. Both are quite usable and do get taken down from their display racks when they have a job to do. I didn't feel the least bit guilty doing the minor alterations to keep them usable and to prevent them from being destroyed at some later date. I feel that my ancestors all would have approved of my actions since 3 generations made their livings with these tools.

Re: Altering old tools

#21

Model / pattern / mock-up tools . . .

s.mackay@worldnet.att.net

>Yup, theres still a few of us out here. While I DO restore a lot of tools to original condition, I've adapted the same amount to fit my needs when no other tool will do a job. I figure its like books . . . once you own a book its your's. If you feel like making notes or underlning, knock yourself out. There are few " new & improved " tools out there that do a job as well as an old one. If you feel the need to adapt that old tool to earn your bread or blow your hair back, its your tool. Mr. Lee and others ( but his are better ! ) have storehouses full of vintage tools saved away for posterity. When I'm dead and gone the craftsman who gets my tools at the estate sale might just find what he did'nt know he was looking for.

Re: Altering old tools

#22

Way I see it....

Todd Hughes

>I think it depends alot on the tool and what was done to it and how it was done. I see lots of "modified" tools and some you have to say to yourself "OH my god what was that guy thinking" while others you can't help but say "Thats pretty neato"

I don't get upset seeing a auger bit with a cut off tang, yeah I know that is one less original auger bit but I guess we have about, what a zillion more, eh?. A little different that time I saw a matching set of Ibotson center bits...all with thier shanks ground round [well sort of round!] to fit in a modern chuck. Now that was a shame.

.. A carefully owner made fence fitted on a 1920s Stanley no. 4 is pretty neat and I think adds alot to the planes interest and probably even vaule and I think a real point could be made that while not "original" it certainly is part of the planes history....On a no. 1 it might not be such a good thing.

I'm alot more forgiving if the alteration was done carefully and for a reason other then if it looks like it was done by Helen Keller on a pogo stick because she couldn't find a hammer.

I actually used to sort of collect tools that had interesting repairs....sure it deep sixes any $ vaule they have but to me it made them more interesting because it linked them more to thier owners and showed what people would do to fix somthing and not buy a new tool. Just kind of neat.

I think the danger of not coming out strong against modifying tools is that it might encourage slowheads to do things to things they shouldn't. Say Talk about making a rabbet plane out of a Regular Stanley no. 4 . a neat modification that I don't really see anything wrong with, sure enough some Gomer is going to find that No. 4 type 1 and get to a cutting and filing after tossing the original box in the trash.

...Of course while it's hard to think like this today when common old tools are ...well common, someday they won't be. I recently got some old gun magazines where they talk about sporterizing and modifying common [at that time] military guns and no one thought anything about it because well they were common, cheap and no one thought they would be anything other then that...Now we look at this work and think why couldn't that guy just left it alone.Actually a pretty brisk bussines in "Un Modifying" such things today.

Guess it all comes down to a case by case question, eh?.......Todd

Re: Altering old tools

#23

Re: Altering old tools

Ron in Kokomo

>Yes we have, and yes it is, and that's the nature of these sites the newbies come in and ask "new questions" like pins vs tails first.

all that's OK . You can use partions of a dollar bill as your standard os measurement if you choose to do so. I just hope someone doesn't try to tell us that Metric is "More accurate" than inches and fractions.

Re: Altering old tools

#24

yep well said

Ron in Kokomo

>

Re: Altering old tools

#25

You are Right

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Hi Ron,

You are right....one is not more accurate than the other...it's what ever standard you are comfortable working with that will be your choice in my experience.

I see it in my working day as well, airframers who work in one standard making conversion mistakes going to another measurement standard, as a supplier it is often the ball we catch and resolve, but it is demanding. Understanding and being able to work the most common measurement system in the world (metric) and being able to work back and forth in Imperial to metric makes us more flexable.

Reproducability and repeatability make any measurement system effective as you know.

Take care,

Jim