Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

English Mortice Chisels

Posts

Re: English Mortice Chisels

#26

Re: Why would metric mortise chisels make a differ

Adam Cherubini

>Mark,

The problem I've encountered with metric chisels is they are often the wrong size for english stock. When working 4 and 5 quarter stock, we really need chisels that are 1/4" and 5/32", and maybe 3/8". If you look at the english measurements of Hirsch's current line up, you'll find several tools "missing".

Adam

Re: English Mortice Chisels

#27

Re: Why would metric mortise chisels make a differ *LINK*

Mark Harrison - Brisbane, Australia

>Well that is an interesting perspective. The Hirsch chisels do indeed seem to come in a limited range of sizes. Their cousins from Two Cherries comes in the range of 3mm to 16mm in 1 mm increments.

5/32" is 3.96875 mm which is close enough to 4mm that I expect that it makes no difference. 1/4" is 6.35 mm. 3/8" is 9.525 mm. 1/2" is 12.75 mm.

If the metric "equivalent" sizes were slightly over the English sizes then I would concede the argument. Is there something else I am missing here?

I'm not arguing the merits or demerits of the bolstered mortise chisel just the metric Vs English thing.


http://www.fine-tools.com/zim.htm

Re: English Mortice Chisels

#28

Re: Why would metric mortise chisels make a differ

Patrick Gibbons, Houston, TX

>It's not that metric is bad. I've bought into the concept of tool slaving as the most efficient way to use tools. So I want all my tools to be metric or imperial but not a mixture. That way I don't have to make adjustments for using a mortise gage that is permamently set to 1/4" with a mortise chisel that is metric and a plow that's imperial with a bench chisel that's metric with a drill bit that's imperial, etc., etc. It's not an issue with just the mortise and the tenon. But it is once you introduce other tools in the project that conflict. Why should my tools hinder me? I have enough trouble with all the players on the same team.

Re: English Mortice Chisels

#29

Re: Why would metric mortise chisels make a differ

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Seems to me that if you take measurements from the tools rather than according to a ruler, it makes much less difference what unit the tools come in. I prefer metric, find the millimeter a much more useful whole number than the fractional imperial system; but I can fairly easily accommodate imperial because before marking for a cut I measure the chisel directly.

Pam

Re: English Mortice Chisels

#30

Agree it's a good idea to measure

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Coupla thoughts....Yeah, a lot of times it doesn't matter the precise chisel width. But f'rinstance on a haunched frame and panel, it's nice if the chisel width and plough cutter width are the same. You're sizing the tenon to the chisel width, but the tenon has to fill _both_ the mortise and the haunch portion of the groove cut by the plough. Nice if they're the same.

Funny thing about measuring chisel widths, something I never do. But I did mike my Imai mortise chisels for the above reason, and guess what. The widths are extremely close to the Imperial measures of 1/4", 5/16", 3/8", not to the metric near-byes. So close he has to be doing it on purpose. Have you mic'ed the mortise chisels you're using (Tasai?)--check and see what he's actually doing.

Wiley

Re: English Mortice Chisels

#31

Re: Agree it's a good idea to measure

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>No, sure haven't mic'd any chisels. The mistake most people make is they think forging is an exact science. Well, it may almost be from a materials standpoint, but not from a finished product standpoint. I suppose the smith could, and probably does to some extent, grind them to an almost exact width. Then add in the complexities of wrapping hot iron with tool steel.

I agree with you on the desirability of having at least some tools the same nominal size, which is why I aim for all metric, often without success; just not sure we can ever count on being there. I also don't understand why you'd plow a haunch's mortise (part of a long groove?); but even so, it's easy enough to trim the haunch and/or mortise.

That would be a bummer for me if chisels I ordered as metric showed up imperial. In fact, it's one of my main problems in ordered from Japan Woodworker, I'm sure they specify imperial to their vendors.

And then there are all the tools that get narrower as they're used. :)

Pam

Re: English Mortice Chisels

#32

Or, in summary of my last post ...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>I think it's a sure thing to develop methods that aren't reliant on a given tool being exactly some nominal width and/or length, whether imperial, metric, shaku (is this what the Japanese system is called?), or whatever.

Pam

Re: English Mortice Chisels

#33

You want the mortise chisel and the plough

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>cutter to be the same width. Both the mortise chisel and the plough cutter are relieved, and will change slightly over time. You still want them to be the same.

If they're the same, you can plough an unstopped groove, locate and chop the mortise within the groove, and the tenon/haunch you saw will neatly fill up both the mortise and the end of the groove.

Agree that it doesn't matter what nominal units you're talking in, as long as you can hold the plough cutter to the mortise chisel and make a match.

Wiley

Re: English Mortice Chisels

#34

If you chop the mortise first...

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>and if you have a short skate plow, you can plow from and to the mortises. (If I were a frog I'd be a Prince.) On door styles I can usually use a standard plow to shoot stopped plows. Or a little chisel work, with the same size chisel cleans it up. I sometimes reset and shoot from the back side to finish up. Rails are easy.

The advantage of having mortise chisels and plows the same size. I prefer the King's measure.

Stephen

Re: English Mortice Chisels

#35

Re: If you chop the mortise first...

Mark Harrison - Brisbane, Australia

>Okay, I can accept the argument about standardisation to other tools. In particular for frame and panel construction. Otherwise...

Re: English Mortice Chisels

#36

Re: You want the mortise chisel and the plough *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>I suppose it might be useful to get a plough involved when doing frame and panel, since the groove would run the length of the stiles and rails; but in other M&T situations, it seems like overkill, I chisel the haunch seat just like the main mortise.

Pam


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Image:MortiseHaunch.png

Re: English Mortice Chisels

#37

Trade practice

Don McConnell

>Hi Wiley et al,

I believe the trade practice amongst cabinet-makers was to chop the mortises before ploughing the groove. An approach a couple of others have already mentioned.

This allows the mortise gauge to be adjusted according to the width of the mortise chisel being used, and helps insure uniformity between the mortise and tenon even if there is a sight discrepancy between the mortise chisel and the plough plane iron. This generally presents no real difficulty in mortises on the scale done in cabinet work (door stilles, e.g.), especially if one begins the groove at the far end and slowly works back at the beginning of subsequent passes with the plough plane.

While you don't want a lot of discrepancy between your mortise chisel and your plough plane iron, small discrepancies present no real difficulties with this approach.

If the plough plane iron is slightly wider than the mortise chisel/gauge-lines, you have a couple of choices. If the size of your face moulding dictates a certain size/placement of the fillet adjacent to the groove, you can simply set the plough plane so that it just cuts to the gauge line closest to the face of the material, and let it cut slightly past the gauge line on the back side. If you have lee-way regarding the size and placement of your moulding, then you can simply set the plough plane to cut down the center of the stock, obliterating the gauge lines on either side. The accuracy of the joinery isn't affected, since the mortises have already been chopped and the cheeks of your tenons have been sawn. Needless to say, in this case, the thickness of the border of your panel needs to be gauged to the groove rather than the gauge lines.

If the plough plane iron is slightly narrower than your mortise chisel, then you can set your plough plane to cut just to the gauge line closest to the face, then slightly widen the groove to the rear gauge line with your side rabbet or T-rabbet planes.

Don McConnell

Eureka Springs, AR

Re: English Mortice Chisels

#38

Re: Trade practice

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Don,

Yes, the standard texts say 'mortise first'. I did say groove first, and still do, but that is not really my point. My point is about the haunch fit if you have a mismatch between plough iron and mortise chisel.

Here is my point. I'll try this first without a picture or drawing. Let's say you go mortise first, then come in over top with a plough iron that is wider. Say it's a 6mm chisel and a 1/4" plough iron. And go end to end on the stile with the plough. You then saw a haunched tenon that, at all costs, has to fit the mortise. So you saw a 6mm tenon. Now the haunch will also be 6mm, but you have a 1/4" haunch seat. There will be a good fit of the tenon to the mortise, but the haunch will be visibly small in its seat. If this is a cabinet door, this mismatch will be seen from the top of the door when you open that door. It will have to be filled. If the tools match, this doesn't arise.

Wiley

Re: English Mortice Chisels

#39

Re: Trade practice

mikew

>Hmm. I understand your point, Wiley.

In practice if there is a mismatch--and at some point in time sharpening a traditional plow iron there will be a mismatch to an oval bolstered mortise chisel even if there isn't one to begin with--one has a couple options when the plowed groove is larger than one's mortise chisel.

On the other forum I left off what I typically do on the small groove mismatch. For a smaller groove than mortise, I simply do use a pair of side rebates most times to widen the groove a skosh. When the groove is slightly larger than the mortise, I use a non-best practice of paring the mortise a bit wider. I then regauge off of the groove when I cut the tenons or shape the panels.

In a perfect world--including my chopping of the mortises and use of the plows--both sets of tools would match over the course of their lives. I could take the time to make the widths match--but both recourses above are too quick to bother.

Take care, Mike

Re: English Mortice Chisels

#40

Re: Trade practice

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Ah, but I consider the haunch part of the M&T, not part of the groove, which means I wouldn't plough over any part of the mortise.

Pam

Re: English Mortice Chisels

#41

Haunch

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>A haunch joint is done to allow the groove on the styles to run full length over the mortice. Then the void is filled by stepping or haunching the tenon on the rails to fill the groove.

I think a haunched joint is of lesser quality than a stop plow m&t.

Stephen

Re: English Mortice Chisels

#42

I thought a haunch was used to prohibit flex.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>

Re: English Mortice Chisels

#43

And I still think so.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>

Re: English Mortice Chisels

#44

Re: Trade practice

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Pam,

However anyone likes to work is cool with me. I have enough on my hands taking care of my own business. I would only observe that a key advantage of the haunched tenon joint in a grooved frame and panel is that it allows one to avoid making a stopped plough cut.

Now Stephen ploughs from mortise to mortise, and deepens the entry and exit with a chisel, because he believes (see next post down) the haunched joint is inferior, and wants to avoid it. Well, OK.

But if you're going to do haunched joints, it seems simpler to take advantage of straight-through ploughing.

There are many variations of the frame and panel, not all of them grooved--some are rebated to take the panel, for example. So starting from the original poster's question, we're now looking through a magnifying glass at a single example. Furthermore, some don't think it's a big deal anyway whether the plough cutter and mortise chisel match as to width (see Mike Wenzloff's post). In summary, I would just say that this is one little example where it can be rationally argued that it does make a difference for tooling to match up. But no need for me to be dogmatic about it, because people work different ways for different reasons. It's all good.

Wiley

Wiley

Re: English Mortice Chisels

#45

Re: Trade practice

mikew

>Hey Wiley,

I should clarify like I did on Roger's site. In an ideal world my plow irons and chisels would all match. It does save time and thought.

My seemingly cavilier attitude about my own use of plows and chisels is related to the fact only a couple of my "pairs" do match. And so it seems either I need to make the others agree via sweat all at once, or as I work. Being the lazy bugger I am, I simply do it at the time of making the grooves and or mortise.

Because my traditional wooden plow's irons taper in width up the shank, even if they matched my mortise chisels today, they wouldn't down the road.

Perhaps this "oddity" is why all my iron plows have [nearly] parallel width irons? I suspect the Howarth irons in my wedge-arm plow are taper-shaped thus in order to provide clearance in deep plowing?

I don't have answers to those questions. What I do know is I cannot be the first person to need to deal with the effects--just how did someone in 1800 deal with this issue?

Back to Stephen's original post. While I think OBM mortise chisels have a greater advantage over sash-pattern mortise chisels in speed whacking out deeper mortises, having a square-sided rectangular corss-section mortise chisel which itself has no taper up its length also has this advantage...its width doesn't change. Paired with a plow iron which also doesn't change then would ensure a match over the life of both tools.

While it is mostly my tradition which has compelled me to use the tools in the way I do, all this wonderful discussion has encouraged me to give my next sets of frame and panels a go with both the sash mortise chisels and a metal plow. Ones which already match in width .

Take care, Mike

Re: English Mortice Chisels

#46

Re: You want the mortise chisel and the plough

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>That's a great point WIley,

Matching the cutter to the chisel, never really thought of that, it would save a lot of time fitting.

take care,

Jim

Re: English Mortice Chisels

#47

I'd agree....kinda....

John in New Mexico

>Not sure I'd use the term "flex", but a haunched tenon does have the advantage of resisting cupping in the rail due to moisture changes in the rail. We're probably thinking of the same thing, just using different words. No idea if it will eventually break the sides off the dado in the stile, but I suppose that too is possible. Last entry door I built I really regreted not haunching both sides of the rail tenons. On big doors, and outdoors ones in particular the sides of the dados in the rails are especially suseptible to movement. On cabinet doors I haunch tenons simply for ease of cutting the dado, which I always try to make smaller than the mortise, then widen the dado at the haunch. Personally, I wouldn't call it inferior as Stephen does, but whatever, to each their own. I even recall that blind haunches were once the "correct" method -- best of both fussy worlds that way.

John

Re: English Mortice Chisels

#48

Re: Trade practice

Joel

>"....While I think OBM mortise chisels have a greater advantage over sash-pattern mortise chisels in speed whacking out deeper mortises, having a square-sided rectangular corss-section mortise chisel which itself has no taper up its length also has this advantage...its width doesn't change....."

Modern OB Mortise chisels have the same width at the back going from cutting edge to bolster. So this concern is not an issue. I have certainly seen old ones that taper, but I don't know if they were manufactured like that or 100 year of rust remove by old tool dealers did a number on the geometry. I also know that in 19th century tool catalogs several greades of OB mortise chisels are listed and I don't know the difference between them. Since the chisels of that time were all forged by eyeball with no real regard for specfic to the thou size one difference could be is how accurate the sizing was. I don't know.

However I was trained using the Moxon method (we didn't know at the time that's what it should be called) which fell out of favor over the centuries. By sizing the mortise to whatever you want and then chopping with the next smallest chisel, then paring the sides perfect accuracy is ensured, you can chop increditly fast and sloppy and taper or exact size of chisel or plane iron is irrelevent.

Re: English Mortice Chisels

#49

Re: Trade practice

mikew

>"However I was trained using the Moxon method (we didn't know at the time that's what it should be called) which fell out of favor over the centuries. By sizing the mortise to whatever you want and then chopping with the next smallest chisel, then paring the sides perfect accuracy is ensured, you can chop increditly fast and sloppy and taper or exact size of chisel or plane iron is irrelevent."

Hi Joel--I didn't know/recall that was Moxon's method either--guess I should reread Schwarz's fairly recent article which he talked about different methods. I sorta skimmed over it when it arrived.

So thanks for the info.

One of these days I will have to hunt down all these neat books like Moxon et al.

Take care, Mike

Re: English Mortice Chisels

#50

Re: I'd agree....kinda....

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Double haunches, very interesting, John. I think we are talking about diminishing the ability of the rail to stile joint to twist for whatever reason. In shoji building I prefer blind haunches, at least partly because the joint is then protected as much as possible from humidity changes.

Pam