Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Name that wood!

Posts

Name that wood!

#1

Name that wood!

Scott in Douglassville

>Ok, sideways gloat here: Meet my new baby:


It's a Seneca Competitor View 5x7 camera. Made around 1915. Shoots 5x7 sheet film. Sweet...

Ok, here's the point - there's a little woodwork to be done to it, and I need to know what kind of wood it is. The only info I can find about it says, "mahogany-finished wood (but not mahogany)". So here're a bunch of pictures, close-up:


















Anyone have any ideas?

Thanks,

Scott

Re: Name that wood!

#2

Re: Name that wood!

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away

>Alot of it looks like softwoods such as spruce/fir/pine, and the next to the last pic liiks like sycamore a.k.a. lacewood.

Where was this camera made? Might give a clue to it's materials.

I know you don't want to but can you dent any of it with your thumbnail?

T.O.

Re: Name that wood!

#3

New York, baby!

Scott in Douglassville

>Hey, Todd-O,

Seneca operated out of Rochester, NY. A lot of cameras then were mahogany, walnut, or cherry; this model, specifically, was intended to be less expensive than the others, though I don't know what that says about the wood.

I haven't tried the dent test. Will give that a go later. Have to fold some laundry afore Momma gits home... ;^)

Scott

Re: Name that wood!

#4

Re: Name that wood!

Scott in Douglassville

>Well, the bed of the camera (the base part) is dentable. I'm guessing that's spruce or some local softwood. Long-term, I'll make a new one, longer, out of mahogany. The body of the camera, though, is not dentable. Mahogany?

Re: Name that wood!

#5

Nice camera Dude!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>The part with the rack and pinion looks like cherry to me. The body look too tight of a grain to be mahog IMHO.

I'm pretty much clueless on the rest, but what's nutin' new...

Re: Name that wood!

#6

Looks like mahogony to me

Dave Thompson

>BTW, how many mega pixels is it? (duck and run)

I still have all of my old dark room equipment, though my local chemistry suppliers have all disappeared... Large format always use to look like a fun hobby to me.

enjoy,

Dave

Re: Name that wood!

#7

Re: Name that wood!

Gary Karner

>I say Cherry

Re: Name that wood!

#8

Megapixels

Jerry Nicholson

>That lens is probable worth 30 line pairs per millimeter at its optimum aperture. That comes out about 81 megapixels as figured in a digital camera but you would need about 4 times that much to properly record the detail that the lens could provide. If you were to scale the sensor in a typical 10 megapixel Nikon or Canon Digital SLR (DLSR) up to 5 x 7 inches, you would have a 560 megapixel digital image. You might be able to get a sensor like that for $200,000 or so. On the other hand, scanning the negative at 1600 dpi with a $150 scanner would yield a 269 megabyte file (uncompressed) at a color depth of 24 bits.

Jerry

Re: Name that wood!

#9

Re: Megapixels

Dave Thompson

>Ha! well I wasn't seriously asking... but since you took the time to give a serious answer...

If I interpret your reply correctly, your guestimate is based on a lens limitation, but the comparison is on the dSLR sensor. Ofcourse, a dSLR could be looked at that way too, and then perhaps variance based on which lens chosen.

I suppose had I been serious with the question, it would have been better of me to ask, what is the typical silver halide crystal granularity density of the film you use multiplied by the film area exposed, and then is any of that lost in contact print transfer to paper?

I'm not asking, because I think there really isn't much point. I don't think that one would use a full format camera solely for resolution alone, though this may have been a driving reason in the 35mm film days. There's alot more to it than that. I think most people on a woodworking handtool forum are receptive to the idea that there is a lot more to the journey than just arriving at the end point...

Regarding woodworking handtool content, the second to the last picture kind of looks like hand plane marks on the wood, though the choice of a box joint looks less likely that it's neander-project. I like the finish on it. A couple of years ago, I did some old mahogony reproduction finishes on a large furniture project. To get a similar old mahogony look, I actually used cherry (for cost) and stained with a red oak stain, and then covered with a 2lb cut of orange shellac. Ofcourse grain pattern is not exact, but only a wood worker would know it. ... yes I know...stain on cherry is a sin.

enjoy,

Dave

Re: Name that wood!

#10

Re: Megapixels

Jerry Nicholson

>I understood your question on pixels to be tongue in cheek but I thought it might be fun to generate a few numbers. There is no good way to make a 1 to 1 comparison of digital and film camera resolution except in the ability to make a satisfactory final print. It appears to me that a critical analysis of the nature of the digital sensor in a DSLR and the signal processing required to create the final digital image would lead one to conclude that the DSLR is quite inferior to its film equivalent (approximately 1/2 of a 35mm film frame). However, that is not the case. The results I get with my Nikon D70 are at least as good as my past efforts with Nikon and Leica film cameras. Of course I take a lot more pictures to choose from now :) And one could argue that I didn't do a very good job in the first place.

I never had a 5 x 7 camera but I have had a number of 4 x 5 cameras including a very old Corona View. And I took a few pictures with a 1915 model 3 1/4 by 4 1/4 Folmer & Schwing Graflex Reflex.

Jerry

Re: Name that wood!

#11

OT: Megapixels and 35mm

Dave Thompson

>I agree it is problematic and the ambiguity can swing negative both ways on such a pixel count. However, if we're talking 35mm film, I would be hard pressed to still find any advantage that format has over what is available in dSLR offerings in process and final result. Advantages in resolution and even exposure lattitude is a thing of the past. These along with simple white balance adjustment and instant ISO adjustment are four main reason why my film bodies are collecting dust. I could probably name a couple dozen other significant advantages, though would be hard pressed to swing the other way with 35mm film format.... except maybe some very important ones like nastalgia, reminiscing... ;-) I was actually scanning ebay a few months back toying with the idea of buying a 60's or 70's vintage all manual SLR, just for the fun of going back to basics, ...well and maybe picking up a relatively cheap F1.2 lens.

Ofcourse, this is all a digression as the original post had nothing to do with 35mm. Full and medium format are quite a different matter, and are still quite commercially viable. A friend of mine runs a business still using these format cameras.

btw, Regarding the 1/2 of a 35mm file frame comment... there are several full frame dSLR sensors... Canon 5d, 1dsm2, Nikon now has one, and even more APS-H (1.3 crop).

enjoy,

Dave

Re: Name that wood!

#12

Re: OT: Megapixels and 35mm

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>The biggest problem I've had with digital is color, not resolution, although that's significant, too. Most of the current processors average the colors and store that average, which means, among other things, purple/blue edging on backlit objects. Now you say, Photoshop will save you; but it won't. I was real pleased when I recently bought a video camera that the colors are stored in separate pixels, no averaging involved.

Pam

Re: Name that wood!

#13

Re: OT: Megapixels and 35mm

Joel

>Before I started TFWW I was a serious fine art photographer and except for speed of work I still prefer shooting on film.

IMHO the weakest film format compared to digital is 35mm. But the digital images that have replaced it are as a group way too contrasty and to get the equivient quality to my current 35mm would be a lot more money then I care to spend. We do all the catalog photography using a cheap digital. For anything serious, catalog covers or ads we use either 2 1/4" or 4x5. The reason isn't pixel count - it's the lenses. we can control depth of field and we get amazingly smooth color gradations- to the point when we originally tried to compress the shot below for quick download we got ugly patches of color not a smooth gradient because the gif compression couldn't deal with it. And franky this image doen't do the original justice. Notice how the front edge of the handle pops out of the picture and the palm of the hand is out of focus. Really hard to do with a smaller camera - trival in 2-1/4" because there is so much less depth of field.

THe digital version of the camera we used (twin lense mamiyaflex - which is 40 years old and paid for) would be thousands of dollars which we cannot justify as long as there is a film lab down the block. When we move in a few months we will probably switch to more digital - because of convinence not quality but it will require a serious upgrading up equipment.


img

Re: Name that wood!

#14

Re: OT: Megapixels and 35mm

Dave Thompson

>The biggest problem I've had with digital is color, not resolution, although that's significant, too. Most of the current processors average the colors and store that average, which means, among other things, purple/blue edging on backlit objects.

Different manufacturers and different models amongst those individual manufacturers are going to have different ways of handling the color.

White balance adjustment is trivial with most cameras.... The days of having an orange cast from tungsten lightbulbs is over. No skylight filters necessary. Those were all to adjust to film being tuned to the color of sunlight. Doing a custom white balance is even easy on small point and shoot camera.... Great for when you have multi colored lights in a room like, e.g. tungsten, flourescent, and sunlight.

If you're unhappy with the color, I'd suggest looking into how to adjust the colors on your camera or get a different camera. All I can say is I'm ecstatic about the colors I get. For 25 years I shot with and delt with inconveniences of Kodachrome and Fujichrome Velvia film to get color saturation I wanted...along the lines of national geographics magazine. I was never quite satisfied. With a digital SLR, and right settings I find it now closer to the norm.

Regading the processing comment youmade...those apply to JPEG images. Many digital SLR support a raw mode, where nothing is processed. The images are quite a bit larger, but you get the raw data which can be tweeked, and processed to your liking on the computer. Ofcourse this can be done in JPEG too, but not to the same degree or quality.

enjoy,

Dave

Re: Name that wood!

#15

Re: OT: Megapixels and 35mm

Dave Thompson

>I agree that the lenses have alot to do with it. The picture can only be as good as the light let through the lens. FWIW, there are some phenominal high end lenses out there for the digital SLR market made by all the major companies Carl Zeiss, Leica/Lietz, and of course Canon and Nikon.

Depth of field is controlled by aperature which many cameras may support adjustment for. The lower the number, the smaller the depth of field will be... On a digital SLR with a minimum aperature of lets say f1.8, taken at 2 feet gives a depth of field of 1/16" which may be less than you're showing in your photo. Starting at $70, you can get a Canon lens that will do this. Though the camera body will cost much more (start around $600). I agree with you though... I don't know of a point and shoot with an aperature control that wide.

With regards to GIF, while this is likely the best format for cartoon like images, it's a pretty poor choice for photos. GIF has a maximum of 256 colors. The entire palette of colors must be drawn from this 256, so you'll get some rough color gradations like you said.

enjoy,

Dave

Re: Name that wood!

#16

Re: OT: Megapixels and 35mm

Joel

>No real issue about anything you say except I don't think a $70 lens will give me anywhere the resolution and color definition that my current crop of professional lenses will. All a digital camera is is a box with a digital film recorder on it instead of a bit of film. The cost of film is trivial compared to the cost of set-up time and the capital cost of replacing what I have for the same quality digital is about 4k if I stick with 35mm equiv or 10-20k if I want a camera with a large format back and most importantly shifts and tilts. I trade off speed of seeing the result but that's not a big deal. THe longer I wait to switch over (which I will at some point) the better value the equipment I buy will be. the camera that I used for the shot I posted, a mamiyaflex cost me $100 (used - it's from the 1960's) with two sets of lenses about 15 years ago. And I get giant very high res-pictures out of it.

Re: Name that wood!

#17

Re: OT: Megapixels and 35mm

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Hey, Dave, I'm not blithely unhappy with the color of one camera. I'm a very experienced photographer, even pro for a couple of years, and do know what I'm talking about. I do love the automatic white balance, one of the best things about digitals; but the fringing on backlit subjects is real and almost universal. Why don't you test it? Photograph a backlit object and blow it up in Photoshop. If you can successfully segregate all the fringing in short order, I'll be truly amazed.

Pam

Re: Name that wood!

#18

I know Exactly what that wood is!

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Birch, was used to imitate mahogany because when stained a mahogany color, birch accepts the stain well, it looks just like mahogany. It is available in the New York area and was a common substitute for mahogany on lesser grades of both photographic equipment and philosophical (scientific) instruments of the period.

Other wet plate camera makers also offered lesser grades than mahogany including 'mahogany stained birch'. Early examples of these cameras have also been found made of pine and painted and grained to look like mahogany.

Stephen

Re: Name that wood!

#19

Re: OT: Megapixels and 35mm

Dave Thompson

>I can't say that I've seen what you're describing.... Here are a couple of ideas:

It sounds like you're discribing vignetting... where the outer edges are darker than the center. Depending on the severity, you can see it by taking a picture of a blank white wall that is evenly lit. Sometimes, a blank sky will show it also.

Though the color variation sounds like chromatic aberration. This is more apparent when looking at large shifts of light, e.g. bright light on dark. One can see color fringe on the edge of a sharp border.

If back lit from a strong source is important, then perhaps you're seeing some flaring. This also can drasticly reduce color and contrast.

Could be one or more of the above issues. All of these are primarily a functions of the lens, though not the body or sensor type. Wider lens tend to be more flare susceptable. A lens hood can help. Longer lenses, especially telephotos are more suceptable to chormatic aberration. Vignetting has more to do with lens design and manufacturing, and also usually aperature setting dependent.

I have heard talk of digital sensors more flare susceptable ( because of more reflection off of sensor than film does). Some lens manufacturers have lens coatings for dSLR's, though I always suspected marketing ploys to get people to buy new lenses they didn't need. One of my best lenses was developed pre-digital days and is spectacular with a dSLR. Best way to diagnose an issue is to post a picture of what you are seeing to one of the dSLR forums. www.dpreview.com is a high traffic one that is populated with lots of photo-geeks that would love to get into it ;-)

enjoy,

Dave

Re: Name that wood!

#20

Re: OT: Megapixels and 35mm

Dave Thompson

>I've borrowed that lens (Canon 50mm f1.8), and while it is a great value, I went for a little better optics too. I would venture a guess that your mamiya is not in the same league as that lens. As an aside though, It's affectionately known in Canon circles as the "fantastic plastic" lens. A lot of people still use it. Check out this link if you're interested (7500 pictures shot with it)... Some are quite effective at humbling lens snobs. ;-)



http://www.flickr.com/search/?q=Canon%2050mm%20f1.8&w=all&s=int

I agree that it's a big jump. The longer you wait, like any high tech thing, the better the value of camera you'll likely get when you finally do. Not sure the lenses will change much though. fwiw, tilt shift lenses are made for dSLR too. They are pricey (to me who doesn't have a need), though with the prices you're talking for that functionality, I'm guessing you might consider them dirt cheap.

enjoy,

Dave

Re: Name that wood!

#21

Re: OT: Megapixels and 35mm

Joel

>I'm no expert but in the link you gave me - just looked at the first page - the pictures looked to me as having totally artifical contrasts, heavily processed, and truly crappy bokah. But each to their own.

BTW Mamiya MF lenses were and are known for excellence. The main disadvantage of their twin lens cameras is weight but the mamiyaflex was a very popular because it has interchangable lenses and really long bellows extension. It's a good studio cam. I had always wanted one of their rangefinder 6x7 ( which used to be a very popular wedding camera) but it was out of my budget.

I get told all the time that this digital camera or that is just as good as film - no- better, and depending on the application it can be true. But from a cost standpoint I get better results with film for what I want to do and even the best digital SLR cannot produce a picture with anywhere the resulution of 6x6cm or 4x5". The latter producing negatives you can get lost in. And of course the 8x10" shooters will tell me - quite correctly - that an 8x10 negative is something else entirely - and they are right.

Re: Name that wood!

#22

Fringing

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>OK, I'm talking into the wind. Seems pretty clear to me that blue/purple fringing is just that. Given the current processors, there is no solution. So, I can limit my photography to no backlit objects, which is not only tough but not desireable in landscape photography, or use film. The digital comes in handy for proofing, love the fact I can easily switch from B&W to color. I say that if a photographer hasn't seen this it's because s/he hasn't looked sufficiently close.

Pam

Re: Name that wood!

#23

Re: Fringing

Dave Thompson

>Hi Pam, I hear what you are saying, though more information is necessary. Vingnetting, chromatic aberration and flare are three things that could produce something described as "blue/purple fringing". A photo of what you're talking about would likely provide all the info necessary to nail down exactly what the issue is.

Regarding your premise that digital sensors or subsequent processing are responsible for blue/purple fringing, all I can do is be more blunt and say I think this is more than likely a mis-attribution, and absolutely an incorrect generalization.

enjoy,

Dave

Re: Name that wood!

#24

Re: OT: Megapixels and 35mm

Dave Thompson

>Just in case there was any misunderstanding I wanted to say I'm well aware of the excellent quality of Mamiya lenses. In no way did I mean to imply that a $70 lens would stack up optically. That $70 lens came up in the context of depth of field control might have been your primary reason. The rebuttal was depth of field can be controlled to the same extent with a $70 lens. In no way did I intend to imply that that this particular lens is in the same league other than for the size of the depth of field control. There are many other that likely could be though.

While I don't disagree that large format film still able to hold it's own in the resolution department, I think it's just a matter of time. I think what started this thread was a discussion on the problems of charactering resolution in film. In the printing industry, magazine quality images are 300 dpi. An 8x10 image would then be 8x300x10x300 = 7.2MP. Currently, dSLR's get up to 22MP, which is getting pretty close to a 16x20 image (actually 28MP).

enjoy,

Dave

Re: Name that wood!

#25

Re: OT: Megapixels and 35mm

joel -( tools for working wood)

>300 dpi for a magazine is the minium that looks ok - high end publications where the photo is important print at much much higher resolutions. and it makes a difference. we pumped the resolution of our last catalog cover just a little (I forget to how much) and even the printer who said it didn't really matter called us up to tell us how much better it looks. We typcially do ads at 600 dpi.