Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

In Direct Contrast to Dirk

Posts

In Direct Contrast to Dirk

#1

In Direct Contrast to Dirk

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native now in Jax Fl.


>Got to do a little work on my new bench today after not touching it for a week or so. Yesterday, much against my Nature and Grain I went out and bought 18 brand new 2x4's to make the top out of. I chose trhis route versus using the scavenged ones I had on hand because some of them where too short and for some reason I just didn't feel like going thru the add'l steps to cut and splice the shorter ones to make them longer. Maybe old age is setting in eh?

At any rate, today I got around to boring all the holes to run the threaded rods thru, but didn't feel up to starting the glue up today as Time was getting on. Perhaps tomorrow.

The top is just under 30" wide at this time and 8' long. As you can see there is plenty of over hang on either end of the base, and under them I shall put a few little cabinets with drawers to store more tools in of coarse.

In the background you see two cabinets hanging on the wall. One is for planes, spokeshaves, scrapers, and a few other odds and ends, and the other one is for chisels, my stones, a few drawknives, brace, bits, and few other doo-dads. I got to thinking today that once I'm done with this bench I'll build two more very similiar to the these, only from floor to ceiling. These little cabinets are only about 30"x30", but surprisingly they hold a fair amount of often used tools. I can hardly imagine what the tall ones will hold. The great thing about them is that they are low profile--only 7 3/4"

Hopefully between these two tall cabinets and the drawers beneath the workbench overhang I'll have just about everything I need in a small compact area. We'll see.

Todd O.

Re: In Direct Contrast to Dirk

#2

OOPS! Here's the pic 

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native now in Jax Fl.



img

Re: In Direct Contrast to Dirk

#3

Looks good Todd, but...

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.


>If you bought "fresh" 2 x 4s from a big box store, those aren't remotely dry enough for a bench top. Chances are that your flat setup will turn into a pretzel once these babies get to acclimate to the shop's humidity... Hope yours turn OK.

Been there, done that, got the t-shirt... My top turned ugly, more than an inch of twist...

DC

Re: In Direct Contrast to Dirk

#4

Re: OOPS! Here's the pic

Frank Mutchler in Colorado Springs


>Todd, I made a bench for 2 of my grandsons over a year ago. I used 2 x 6 lumber which I ripped in half and glued up for the bench top. It's been over a year and the top is just as flat as when I finished it. Maybe some borg lumber is drier than others??

Re: In Direct Contrast to Dirk

#5

Re: OOPS! Here's the pic

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native now in Jax Fl.


>Believe it or not these 2x4's are in fact quite dry. I don't have a moisture meter so I can't tell you the exact moisture content, but I feel that they are dry enough to use straight away.

I dunno what's going on around here lately, but the Borgs seem to be having plenty of nice looking, straight, dry 2x4's lately.

Appreciate the concern none-the-less Denis.I don't care what Ernie says, I think you're you're alright. ;~)

T.O.

Re: In Direct Contrast to Dirk

#6

Work surface vs. footprint . . .

Steve Mackay


>Just a rookie and not bashing here but . . . how do you have a working area that size with a floor footprint that size ? I know you're not going to throw a Harley on it but will this set up be stable with larger pieces ? Just wondering. I'm sue there are guidlines for this .

Re: In Direct Contrast to Dirk

#7

Re: Work surface vs. footprint . . .

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native now in Jax Fl.


>I dunno Steve, never had such a large working surface with such a small footprint. You do bring up a good point tho, so unless somebody already has some insight into the question than I guess we'll all learn together. I guess I did get to wondering something along the same lines today tho. I got to wondering if perhaps there was too much overhang, and if they'd ever sag. Got to thinking that if they did I'd either have to shorten them, or put some legs under them.[the overhangs]

Anybody see a problem with this design that I don't?

Got 'er glued up this morning. Took 1.5 hours and I could of used at least 4 more hands, but I got it done. Probably won't get to get started on leveling the top until next weekend. :~( thank goodness for 3 day weekends. :~)

T.O.


img

Re: In Direct Contrast to Dirk

#8

Too much overhang for me

jimreed@tallahassee


>I danced for a few years with a lightweight bench. It was like my first wife--every time I got serious, she moved. Had to drop that bench just like the wife. Now I have a stable bench and a good wife. I guess sometimes you just need to dance a while to see how it works. Good luck

Re: In Direct Contrast to Dirk

#9

Are the threaded rods just to aid glue-up?

Ian Smith (Sydney Australia)


>Or do they remain a feature of the bench?

I'm planning to build a nice bench one day (whenever that is) and I initially thought of doing the top the way you have done Todd. But then I got to thinking that the threaded rods, once the nuts are tightened up, might not allow for adequate expansion of the wood in the bench top.

If the rods are to become a permanent feature then do you think that this will be a problem or not? Would the wood tend to be constrained in the areas immediately surrounding the rods and be free to expand in the areas between the rods and ultimately produce a kind of rippled edge (Does this explanation make sense)?

Regards,

Ian.

Re: In Direct Contrast to Dirk

#10

Re: Too much overhang for me

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native now in Jax Fl.


>Jim,

Send pic of wife! ;~)

Bench too.

T.O.

Re: In Direct Contrast to Dirk

#11

Re: Are the threaded rods just to aid glue-up?

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native now in Jax Fl.


>Ian,

The rods sort of pull double duty. Primarily they are for aiding glue up, but I leave them in permanetly. I built a top like this back in '98, and so far I have seen no problems caused by the rods, and it is still dead flat. I put another 2x4 over them just to dress up the edge. Also have to mark where they are because when boring my doghole in my first tip I hit one of them.

The holes are 5/8" and the rod is 1/2" so I really don't think they restrict the wood from moving.

It will be interesting to see how this top works out. Two solutions to potential problems should they arise(and they probably will) would be to shorten the top, or lengthen the base. More than likely if a problem does arise I'd shorten the top little by little by little as I'm really liking the looks of this "small footprint" idea so far.

As far as attaching the top to the base I'm playing with two different idea. Either bore a hole one each end thru the top into the base frame and bolt it down, or attach a cleat to the underside of the top than attach the cleat to the base. I do have an idea on how to make the top's height adjustable(Thanks Sir William)but am hee-hawing on incorperating it right away. I guess I better see how this top is going to perform before I start getting two complex.

T.O.

Re: In Direct Contrast to Dirk

#12

Re: Work surface vs. footprint . . .

Bill Houghton, September summer in Sebastopol, CA


>The force from a clamp is said to radiate outward from the clamp head at 45 degrees - it looks like 45 degrees from the end of your benchtop is outside of the base. I think you've got tippiness in the future with that bench.

Re: In Direct Contrast to Dirk

#13

Todd, how about adding....

Frank Mutchler in Colorado Springs


>an 18" drawer bank on either side of your base. I'm just guessing at the 18". They could be whatever width you need to stablize the top a little better. All that rust you've been collec.....err acquiring could be stored real handy then. You might even come up with an idea for some unique handles for each of the drawers....right, Ernie ;>)??

Re: In Direct Contrast to Dirk

#14

Re: Work surface vs. footprint . . .

Bob Hackett


>If it was me I`d think about moving the framework/tool cabinet down to one end and leaving a foot or less overhang.Then I`d cobble up a set of legs to put on the other end.

I`m not saying everybody`s as slow as me but I am truely adept at tipping things over.There would definately come a time when I`d pile too many parts on one end and then do something stupid like trying to cut a mortice with all that stuff on the same end.

I trust you get the picture.

Mainely,Bob-Who`s pretty good at scaring himself too.

Re: In Direct Contrast to Dirk

#15

Re: OOPS! Here's the pic

Ernie Miller


>You know Todd last time Frank and I got together for dinner I didn't say a single derogatory thing about you. but next time we meet in Denver for dinner look out. I might even slide done south to the Springs next time. And by the way that bench looks funny as hell. I'm betting it is going to be like plaining on a rockling horse with such a small tressel. Hell a decent vise will tip that thing over. You would think that several houndred years of history would teach you that benches are large and heavy for a reason. Ha Frank now that I have started a pile feal free to jump on Oll Todd O can take it.

Re: In Direct Contrast to Dirk

#16

Re: Todd, how about adding....

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native now in Jax Fl.


>Well, as it turns out thr bench is tippy, so if you're all going to pig-pile on me better do it in the center of the bench. ;~)

What I did was to clamp the top to the bench, and with very little pressure on the ends it did in fact tip. I didn't even bother too clamp a board to it and see if it would tip or rock or dance while planing as there is no doubt that it would.

As was suggested I put a 45 angle on the end of the top and it did come to just outside of the base. So, I've decided to lop off 24" which will give me an 18" overhang on each end. With this measurement the 45 degree goes to the center of the base. IF after this modification the problem still persists I'll lengthen the base a little as I want the top to me no less than 6'.

I dunno why I didn't forsee this problem myself. Guess I was blinded by my own design. Coarse, if I had than I wouldn't of had to go out and buy all those new 2x4's at a cost of about $40. :~(

T.O.

Hey! Who's there behind the bushes?! Ernie!! Is that you?!

ARRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRGH!!!!!!!

Re: In Direct Contrast to Dirk

#17

A couple other thoughts...

Ted Owen, Pittsburgh


>How about:

1. Just make a couple longer rails for the base?

or 2. If you're going to lop off, how about just one end and re-center?

Best, Ted

Re: In Direct Contrast to Dirk

#18

Re: Todd, how about adding....

ken


>Two things come to mind. First, if you push down 12" in from each end, is that less tippy enough? Just want to make sure the result would be satisfactory before you cut. Also, I don't know what your floor is, but you could just bolt it down and keep the length.

Ken

Re: In Direct Contrast to Dirk

#19

I have to agree with Ted...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA


>I'd make the base a little longer and not sacrifice the length of the top.

Re: In Direct Contrast to Dirk

#20

Re: Work surface vs. footprint . . .

Steve Mackay


>Just for kicks, and future reference . . . let us know what you wind up with. When you hit a proportion between the two thats "just right" and "stable". I've been asked weirder things before !

Re: In Direct Contrast to Dirk

#21

Me Too, FWIW

Hank Knight from SC

Re: In Direct Contrast to Dirk

#22

Re: Are the threaded rods just to aid glue-up?

Ernie Miller


>Why don't you shorten the legs to 16"~ and make a coffee table out of it? with it being that short it won't be able to tip very much. and if you just have a couple cups of tea and some books on it you are bound to be safe. Put a nice finish on it and the wife will think you made her some thing.

Re: In Direct Contrast to Dirk

#23

Re: Are the threaded rods just to aid glue-up?

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away


>Ted,

I hear what your saying about longer rails at the bottom of the base to make it more stable, but that would

1)just give me something else to trip over

2) Be a PITA when I want to move the bench

When I do lop off some of the top, yes, I will take it all off of one end as I might be able to find a use for that cut-off.

Ken,

Oh yes, I've tried that and moving one end so that it has only a 12" overhang makes for a more stable bench. Coarse, it could be that with the add'l over hang on the other end just makes it seem that way, but I'm sure that the shorter overhang is the answer.

bolting it to the floor is not an option as I want to be able to move back up against the wall just in case I need to use the shop as a garage again during severe weather.

Ernie,

You may be on to something a giant coffee table Japanese style. I know the cats would love it!

T.O.

Re: In Direct Contrast to Dirk

#24

Bench

Jim Reed @ Tallahassee


>Here is the bench that does not dance. Sorry for the dark picture. Overhang is a slight 3" on one end and just 12" on the vise end with the vise closed.


img

Re: In Direct Contrast to Dirk

#25

And

Jim Reed @ Tallahassee


>Here is the vise end.


img