Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Murland International Auction

Posts

Murland International Auction

#1

Murland International Auction

Steve Oreolt


>I Flew over to England to attend the Murland International tool auction and would seriously question [edited] what went on there. The star of the show was a dubious, never seen before Norris plane that was a cross between a Stanley 85 and an a low angled mitre plane. Apparently made in 1941, it did not have a mark on it and could have been made yesterday (more on that later). This plane had an estimate of 20,000-30,000 English pounds and there was only 1 serious bidder once the money went over 10,000. Tony Murland and Pat Leach were the other 'bidders' [edited].

These two [edited] lifted the bidding to 21,500, at which point the only bidder still left, dropped out and the hammer fell at this price, well above the lower estimate set for the plane.

After the sale, the bidder that pulled out at 20,000 was approached by Murland in the car park and told that the plane didn't hit reserve. How can that be? (the hammer fell above the low estimate and it is illegal to set the reserve above the lower estimate). The bidder was asked if he was still interested and was offered the plane for 16,000, which was accepted. [edited]the plane made a lot more than it should have. And hey, if you were running a reputable auction house wouldn't you wait 48-hrs after the sale and make out the deal fell through, before offering a second chance offer. [edited]

Oh, I almost forgot, Murland is doing a limited edition of replicas of the 20,000 pound Norris. There was disbelief on the faces of all present when drawings were circulated around.[edited]

Re: Murland International Auction

#2

Re: Murland International Auction

Art Geiger


>Yes, [edited] Leach is always at Murland's side at every English auction. [edited] I bet the buyer of that plane is pissed at the idea of replicas. I agree with you about Leach's preaching on Ebay. He's [edited] is on my don't trade with list.

Re: Murland International Auction

#3

Re: Murland International Auction

mikew


>Well, I'll obviously be surprised if this thread hangs around long...

Patrick doesn't need my "sticking up for him," and I have no idea what went on over there.

My dealings with Patrick have always been sound and fair, both on the Bay and off. Same goes with Murland. My only problem with Murland is too often what is on his web site is sold by the time I see it.

Take care, Mike

Re: Murland International Auction

#4

Re: Murland International Auction

Ernie Miller


>I have bought some tools from Murland over the past years from his internet site and thought that I got a fair deal. I have no idea how the auctions are ran. That would not happen here in Kansas as you have to be liscensed and most auctions are either video or audio recorded for inspection if a dispute is filed. I know that some auctiuons take absentee bids and the auctioneer has employees who bid for them just like a live person so Than may have been what was happening. Just because somthing looks goofey dosen't make it so. But you know the saying if it looks like a duck? [edited] I do apreciate you openion and doubt that I will have the chance to attend one of there auctions any time soon.

Re: Murland International Auction

#5

Yes, but who are you?

woodburnbob


>I searched your name on handtools, the archive, and the current main board. I found nothing. I was curious to see a few of your earlier publications and posting as a news reporter and pundit,[edited] I do recognize Art's name from a couple years back. Did you guys team up to set all the rest of us straight on trading with Murland and Leach?

Over 5 or 6 years, I've bought about 25 items from Murland ranging from about $200 to about $400. Hadn't thought I was screwed on any of them. Accurate billing. Really fast shipping. Shipping as part of the price. Immediate emails from Nina, who runs things there. I'm not buying much the past year or two, but geez, what you say is so contrary to my experience with Murland.

Care to support your claim [edited] with some facts other than your impression on that one museum piece.

I think Leach is a witty guy...in print. I've never met either one of them in person. I bought one Bailey from him years ago, when I bought one Bailey from just about everybody. His was too expensive (comparatively), but in good shape and sold via OldTools rules as I recall.

The word just came to me: fragging. Is that what you're doing?

Re: Murland International Auction

#6

Re: Yes, but who are you?

Ernie Miller


>I had forgotten Nina she is on top of things why the boss is out playing.

Re: Murland International Auction

#7

Re: Murland International Auction

Ted Owen, Moderator


>Let's please be more careful with this thread. I've edited out some accusations, which forced edits to some well-intentioned references to those accusations.

Facts are welcome and helpful, opinions of other's character are likely prohibited personal attack.

Best, Ted

Re: Murland International Auction

#8

Re: Murland International Auction

Wayne Anderson


>Does anyone know where a photo of this plane might be found? Sounds interesting. -Wayne

Re: Murland International Auction

#9

Come to that, who are you?

John in New Mexico


>Is this some kind of club where number of posts equates some sort of oracle status? After all the editing, I'd say just 86 this silly thread and start over, or not, nothing good seems to be coming out of all this.

John

Re: Murland International Auction

#10

Re: Murland International Auction

Mike L (Orange County, CA)


>Ted,

I'm probably a little slow here but I'm not clear who is saying what. Did the "[edited]" portions come from your editing or are they just a clever way for the original poster to imply something negative without actually saying it. Just to be clear, I'm not implying anything negative about anybody, I'm just trying to follow the conversation.

Regards,

Mike

Re: Murland International Auction

#11

Re: in defense of Patrick...

George in Lowell, Mich.


>I have bought a few things from him. They were not cheap ,but appropriately priced , as advertised quality wise and with his money back guarantee how can you go wrong?

If you don't like a sellers product, don't buy from them. There is no need to rake them over the coals.

Work safe,

George in cooler Michigan

Re: Murland International Auction

#12

Sorry, yes, Mike, that means...

Ted Owen, Moderator


>I deleted some stuff. Next time I'll show the edits to be from a Moderator.

Best, Ted

Re: Murland International Auction

#13

Great question! But, I disagree.

woodburnbob


>"Is this some kind of club where number of posts equates [to] some sort of oracle status? After all the editing, I'd say just 86 this silly thread and start over, or not, nothing good seems to be coming out of all this."

This is kind of a club. Some people refer to it as a community. Others I think find it a source of entertainment, information and news. Sometimes it's a stage for melodrama. Sometimes it's a soapbox.

Generally, incivility and rudeness are received poorly in this community. Sometimes the authorities step in to keep the peace. That generally takes the form of statements, editing or deletion. We all benefit from seeing rules enforced and limits set occasionally. It keeps those of us capable of mannerly behavior in line. I'm just as potentially rowdy as the next guy.

I'm glad the thread hasn't, as you say, been "86"'d. A lot of people saw the unedited stuff. I think it is in everyone's interest to edit out that which is egregious and then politely air out the controversy to its natural conclusion.

As to the issue of number of posts and "oracle status", no, I'd don't think there's a relationship...unless it's inverse. One does acquire a sort of set of character traits from what one says or writes publicly though. It would be more direct to watch one's behavior in the world over a period of time. But that's impossible on a forum. So, the number of posts, ideas or words over a period of time becomes a sort of proxy. Aren't we all left making in that way some judgement about the veracity of what another says or writes ... unless, of course, one person's statements are as meaningful, wise and truthful as any other persons?

I know. You find this pompous and oracular. Just the same, I gotta respond. What would I be if I didn't.

Re: Murland International Auction

#14

OK People, show's over, move along...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA


>I for one would love to see a pic of it. Everything else is...

"El Garande Toro Poo-poo"

Let's all play nice!

Re: Murland International Auction

#15

Re: Amen Bob

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI


>It does tend to make a person wonder about someone's character if their first post here is about something so very negative about someone that is highly regarded in the tool community. There is no way for us to know what axes are being brought to the grindstone. I sometimes wonder if I was the sucker born during my minute, but have to say I am thankfully getting much more cynical as I grow older. I think the best advice I recieved when I mentioned growing more cynical with age was to "embrace it". So I look at someone's post whom I don't know their character, and the post is my first impression of their character.

Re: Murland International Auction

#16

Point conceded...

John in NM


>I suppose I was thinking that the OP's intentions were pretty clear from the content, and looking for a history was beside the point. Rereading your post, though, I now see your meaning. This thread is so edited by now its really more a collection of odd non-sequiters than any kind of useful discussion, hence the preference for its quietly going away. Politely airing the controversy to its natural conclusion is fine, but editing posts just changes their meaning, making the conclusion rather un-natural.

John

Re: Murland International Auction

#17

Re: Murland International Auction

tony murland


>I was astonished to read the incorrect information regarding my auction posted by Steve Oreolt. I suggest before slanderous statements are publicly made that people obtain the correct facts.

The plane was not dubious ,that is a most unpleasant lie,and a preposterous suggestion displaying ignorance and malice. Had the author asked me about it ,I could have introduced him to the 83 year old owner of the plane who was at the auction and had needless to say owned it since 1941.

I think that this shows that the author of these comments is adept at changing the truth and thus i am sure it is plain that the same skill at altering facts has been used on the rest of these pathetic claims. If customers have a question regarding a tool we always answer them . We do not waste time with people who for reasons best known to themselves, decide to spread untruths .

I would like to point out that it is is not illegal to set the reserve above the lower estimate ,i did not approach anyone in the carpark.I was asked by the vendor to approach a particular bidder who he had seen and spoken to before the sale ,this i did ,and the plane was sold for 16000 pounds .If anyone has any particular questions please contact me.

As for the poor attempt at malicious humour regarding the replicas,i would ask steve to stay at home the next time we hold an auction and practise telling the truth.thank you tony murland

Re: Murland International Auction

#18

Re: in defense of no one . . .

Bob Hutchins in central TX


>But George, I must, respectfully, disagree with your premise. If a seller is engaging in nefarious or even questionable practices -- or even if one disagrees with a seller's practices, questionable or not -- I think everyone who comes here has equal right to express their opinion so long as they are not libelous or slanderous. While Murland and Leach might be sacred cows to some, they certainly are not to me; nor do I think they should be given different treatment because some here have bought from them. For myself, I have never done business, knowingly, with either Murland or Leach; for I have always thought their prices far too high for the product offered. Others obviously find their prices acceptable, but their evaluation does not invalidate mine.

I appreciate Ted Owens' job as moderator because he is protecting Ellis and WoodCentral thereby doing us all a great service. But I 'think' Ted will agree that comments and opinions that are not libelous, slanderous or otherwise scurrilous will be left as posted if they don't risk causing harm to Ellis.

Please correct me if I've misspoken or if I've stated your position incorrectly Mr. Owens.

FWIW

BobH

Re: Murland International Auction

#19

Re: Murland International Auction

tony murland


>I have now seen an unedited copy of the original posting and i am called a crook. I suggest that the author makes himself known ,using his real name ? then we can judge his comments with a face to match .

I would like to thank all the very positive and supportive postings from people who obviously have seen through the smoke and know that this is a poor attemt to throw some mud on my name and business.

Perhaps we can 'interview' the gentleman in question at a forthcoming tool meet .thank you all once again .tony murland

Re: Murland International Auction

#20

Perhaps more on the plane?

woodburnbob


>Good job on the rebuttal. I hope it survives edits. It should.

Looks to me like the policy is that what triggers edits is stuff that is both "personal" (individual and specific) and hostile. For instance, if you say "George is a liar", this will get editted out. If instead you say, "The idea that the world is flat is wrong, and here's why:....", it will stand uneditted. This is just what I've gleened from watching things for awhile.

To further neutralize bad feelings, it would be great, Tony, if you could post a photo and some description of the historical significance of that plane. There are plenty of fans of British planes here on this forum. If you can't do it now, anytime would be better than never.

Re: Murland International Auction

#21

Re: Murland International Auction

tony murland


>A last note.............i have checked auction day records and there was no one registered at the auction by that name OREOLT,

there is no one on our data base by that name, so i think we are dealing with someone who has decided to fabricate a malicious posting ...what a very poor thing to do ,many of my best friends have been made within the world of woodworking ....i have never had a bad cheque at a woodworking show....i have never had a tool stolen at a show .........this is a sad day ...........things have obviously changed. tony

Re: Murland International Auction

#22

Re: Murland International Auction

St.Patrick of Tool


>Where to begin with this deliberate and hateful post, which

is certainly actionable for libel on legal grounds (and believe

me, I'm going to investigate pursuing that to the fullest!)?

This forum is seemingly being overrun by folks with major

league axes to grind. 99% of you are fine folks, many of whom

I've had the good fortune to meet face to face. Those of you

who I haven't met, but have done business with over the past 14

years, are most appreciated here as your support has permitted

me to pursue something I never imagined - taking my passion of

old tools and making it my job. It's impossible for me to express

my debt of gratitude to you all, but a heartfelt thanks to each

and every one of you for allowing me to do what I do.

It's the sneaky, petty, and jealous people here that are giving

this community a black eye. When I first read Mr.Oreolt's post, I

thought I was back in high school, where some envious clique decided

to spread lies to besmirch someone they've never met. People like

this, be it online or in person, have serious problems with self-worth

and instead of concentrating on bettering their lives, they try to

mend their hollow ego by going on the attack

As an aside, I do excuse the laughable Pambolina's tirades, actually

finding them quite good sporting fun, since she never misses an

opportunity to give me a public slapping (her recent 'bel canto' to

Leach was pulled from the thread). Here's a warm thanks to you, Pammy,

for lighting up my life. Don't go changing just to please me, I love

you just the way you are!

What prompted Mr.Oreolt's lies, however, posted using an email

address that bounces (brave lad that he is) is anyone's guess, his

motivation only known to him.

Furthermore, if Mr.Oreolt believes Mr.Murland to be a crook, why did

he travel to the auction in the first place? And, if he actually was

at the auction, I'd like for him to discuss the venue, giving some

description of the setting as proof that he was there.

That said, here are the facts of the matter, which should make

it clear that Mr.Oreolt hasn't the remotest clue what he's talking

about, and that he deliberately set out to tarnish two people's

reputations, and, one assumes, damage their livelihood:

1). The plane is not a fake. It is the real thing.

2). The fellow who consigned the plane was at the auction,

and was filmed by BBC1. The segment was aired many times

nationally as well as on BBC East Anglia.

3). The plane was marked as being made by Norris, as well as

being dovetailed, on the toe.

4). Nearly all auctions in the UK operate with reserves, set

by the consignor to protect him. This is a major distinction

between American auctions, where most items are sold sans

reserves. If you plan to bid in UK auctions, this is something

you must resolve in your mind before you decide to bid.

5). Mr.Murland let it be known what the reserve was to anyone

who asked.

6). Mr.Murland does no live bidding - I have never seen him bid

at any auction, either in the UK or in the US.

7). The plane was bid on by myself, for my collection. I do

collect planes, and was fascinated by this unique item.

8). I dropped out of the bidding well below the reserve, with

my final bid of 15,000 quid. Had I the funds, I would have

taken it to 20,000, still below the reserve.

9). Mr.Murland's auctioneer, Tyrone Roberts, is the fastest

auctioneer in the world, and uses a peculiar (to us in the

US) method for bid calling. He spends roughly 10 seconds on

each item, and even I have a difficult time figuring out

who bought what and for how much.

10). The fellow who now owns the plane, the most serious buyer

of Norris planes, bought it at a price a bit below his last

bid, after Mr.Murland consulted with the consignor.

11). Mr.Murland has no plans to make a reproduction of the plane.

It would cost several thousand quid just to make one!

For any of the naysayers here, I invite you to contact Mr.Murland

directly. I'm certain that he will gladly send anyone who asks a free

catalogue to illustrate that the plane is the real thing and not a

modern fake. If you need to get in touch with him, email you and I'll

hook you up.

As for my reputation on ebay - 'mr.peabody' for those of you who

don't know - I'll let my feedback speak for itself.

Perhaps you can, if you're brave enough Mr.Oreolt and Mr.Gieger,

make your user names public so that we can judge for yourself.

I have appended the entire original postings, as made by Mr.Oreolt and Mr.Gieger, so that they may stand on their own as the poisonous, malicious, and preposterous commentary that they are.

I ask that the moderators leave this post as is so that all can see

who is speaking the truth and who isn't.

Patrick

Original posts follow........

=====================================================================

Subject: Murland International Auction Posted By: Steve Oreolt soreolt@compuserve.com

Date: Friday, 4 August 2006, at 1:41 p.m.

I Flew over to England to attend the Murland International tool auction and would seriously question the legality of what went on there. The star of the show was a dubious, never seen before Norris plane that was a cross between a Stanley 85 and an a low angled mitre plane. Apparently made in 1941, it did not have a mark on it and could have been made yesterday (more on that later). This plane had an estimate of 20,000-30,000 English pounds and there was only 1 serious bidder once the money went over 10,000. Tony Murland and Pat Leach were the other 'bidders' (schilling the bids that is). These two crooks lifted the bidding to 21,500, at which point the only bidder still left, dropped out and the hammer fell at this price, well above the lower estimate set for the plane. After the sale, the bidder that pulled out at 20,000 was approached by Murland in the car park and told that the plane didn't hit reserve. How can that be? (the hammer fell above the low estimate and it is illegal to set the reserve above the lower estimate). The bidder was asked if he was still interested and was offered the plane for 16,000, which was accepted. Obviously, the attempts by Leach and Murland to schill the bids backfired, but even with a discount the plane made a lot more than it should have. And hey, if you were running a reputable auction house wouldn't you wait 48-hrs after the sale and make out the deal fell through, before offering a second chance offer. I knew already that Murland was a crook, but his patsy Leach is no better and he has the front to put up that holier than thou crap on Ebay. All I'll say is the only skanky slime on Ebay is him and his buddy Murland. Oh, I almost forgot, Murland is doing a limited edition of replicas of the 20,000 pound Norris. There was disbelief on the faces of all present when drawings were circulated around. Well, 100 are as easy to make as one.

**************************************************

Subject: Re: Murland International Auction Posted By: Art Geiger arthurggeiger@hotmail.com

Date: Friday, 4 August 2006, at 2:37 p.m. In Response To: Murland International Auction (Steve Oreolt)

Yes, they do it every time and Leach is always at Murland's side at every English auction. I think the auctioneer must be in Murland's 'pocket' too as he must know the bids are schilled. It ought to be reported to the auctions regulator. I hope the Admin guys keep this posting up for those that don't know about these con artists. Does the man have no shame! I bet the buyer of that plane is pissed at the idea of replicas. I agree with you about Leach's preaching on Ebay. He's that last person to quote morals and is on my don't trade with list.

Re: Murland International Auction

#23

OT: fragging (etymology content) *LINK*

woodburnbob


>This forum never fails to prompt me to learn something interesting. I got to thinking about my metaphorical use of "fragging" and read up on the real thing.

Almost weekly I'm accused of being paradoid, to which I reply, "No, I just don't really trust anyone."

It was a poor metaphor for this situation. It implies the victim somehow, at some level of primitive thinking, deserves what he got.


Wikipedia on fragging

Re: Murland International Auction

#24

Re: Murland International Auction

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX


>Gee, thanks, Patrick. Now, why Ted hasn't deleted your message is beyond me. He was trying so hard to help you and Tony (with whom I have no, as in zero, problems), and you come here (only whenever your name is mentioned, God forbid that you contribute even semi-regularly) threatening a law suit. Warms the coffers of my heart.

Pam

Re: Murland International Auction

#25

Re: OT: fragging (etymology content)

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX


>Throw in a little recursion and it looks like maybe you fragged yourself. :)

Pam