Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Emmert Vice and bench

Posts

Emmert Vice and bench

#1

Corey Megal

Emmert Vice and bench

Corey Megal


>I've found an old bench with an Emmert attached, I wasn't able to inspect it, and I'm not really sure what to look for. So, I have two questions:

1. What do I look for in an Emmert? Is there a typical part missing/broken, what constitutes something not worth buying?

2. If the vice is in decent shape, does $645 sound like a decent price to pay for the bench with the vice attached?

I did notice the shoulder vice on the other end of the bench had what seemed to be decently done dovetails.

I'm looking at using this and don't care much about the "collectibility" of either item. Not that I won't take care of both and treat them with the respect they deserve, but i'm not looking to acquire this just to look at.

Thanks Much, I always appreciate the straight advice on the forum.

Corey

Re: Emmert Vice and bench

#2

Re: Emmert Vice and bench

Vlad


>I'm not an emmert expert but there are some parts that are found missing - adjustment mechanism me thinks. Perhaps someone else will chime in.

If the bench is in decent shape, go for it. The emmerts alone are going for $400 US. and a bench for $275 ain't bad. Talk them down to $500 cash. Worth a try.

Good luck.

Vlad

Re: Emmert Vice and bench

#3

Re: Emmert Vice and bench

Dave Anderson Chester, NH


>Hi corey, My experience is that the most common problem with Emmerts is that someone has broken the hinge plate which is bolted into the bench top. Also common is the missing tilt jaw though this doesn't effect the operation of the vise and many folks never even know that there is supposed to be a tilt jaw.

Re: Emmert Vice and bench

#4

Re: Emmert Vice and bench

Todd Hughes


>There was a guy at the last PATINA tool meet that had a beautiful BIG bench with cabinets under it and a nice damage free Emmert mounted. He was asking $450 he told me for it and took it home because he couldn't sell it. Several emmerts went unsold at $275 -$300.....$645 sounds like High retail to me though with out seeing the bench a little hard to say. If it makes you happy though go ahead and spend it........Todd

Re: Emmert Vice and bench

#5

Corey Megal

Re: Emmert Vice and bench

Corey Megal


>Any chance you have that guy's name? I've never even seen an Emmert before this, although I admit, I haven't been killing myself trying to find one. I think it's a bit steep as well, this was an antique store (one of the nicer ones around) so I think they're shooting for the "use it for decoration" crowd.

I'm not dying to spend $600 on it, but I would if I thought it was worth it. (and with SWMBO's apporval of course)

Corey

Re: Emmert Vice and bench

#6

Corey Megal

Re: Emmert Vice and bench

Corey Megal


>Thanks, Dave, at least that's something I can check for. I'm still struggling with myself over this. Do I really need a $600 bench? not really, but man, it would be sweet to have the Emmert.....

Re: Emmert Vice and bench

#7

Re: Emmert Vice and bench

cooper suter


>Corey,

This is a long shot, but if that bench/vise is in an antique mall in Maumee OH, I can pretty much guarantee the dealer is open to offers ;).

Coop

Re: Emmert Vice and bench

#8

Some thoughts

jim reed @ tallahassee


>If the vise is in good shape it could have decent resale value. A clone costs $200+. That means that the bench is about $400 or less by itself. Not bad if it is a good bench. Here is what I would look for. Square dog holes. Good top. Good end vise for the dogs. No racking. The bench should be heavy enough and tight enough so that it will not move when you are planing. Good luck with your decision.

Re: Emmert Vice and bench

#9

Stuff to look for...

Bryan in Broad Ripple, IN


>Often the tilt adjustment bar and mounting bracket are missing. People often take the vises off of the bench, and forget to remove this additional hardware that is mounted underneath the bench top. Also, check the unit over carefully for cracks and repairs. For that price, the unit should not be damaged or repaired in any way. Also, make sure that the main nut that the screw engages into isn't damaged. That seems to be a weak point of the vise. FWIW, I really like my Emmert, and wouldn't part with it.

-Bryan

Re: Emmert Vice and bench

#10

Corey Megal

Re: Stuff to look for...

Corey Megal


>Thanks! That's really the type of info I was looking for.

Corey

Re: Emmert Vice and bench

#11

Re: Emmert Vice and bench

Garrett in Victoria BC


>The Taiwanese Emmert clones retail at Woodcraft and other stores for about $230. A real Emmert usually goes for more, often much more, depending on condition.

I bought a clone a couple of years ago. It's an excellent vise, but I find I don't use most of its funtionality. The class of the class these days, however, is Lee Valley's Tucker, and it's priced accordingly.

Cheers, Garrett