Re: Workbench top design (long)
Thom D
>First I am sympathetic to the idea of a slightly more complicated bench. For two reasons. One of these reasons is good and the other perhaps less so. Here goes:
1) There has been a perfect storm of nonsense about simple benches recently. It's perhaps a combination of some very good information about the Roubo bench and some very solid video information about hand planing stock square (not brain surgery) that emphasizes the non-use of vises.
Roubo and simplicity are not new fads. When Landis kicked off the workbench book craze, perhaps the two simplicity icons were the Roubo bench re-created by Rob Tarule, and the Japanese beam benches notably by Carl Swensson. Tarule and Swensson should probably speak for themselves, but I don't think these benches were never exceeded. Swensson has marketed his own refined version of the shaving horse, a vise on legs, and as the current issue of FWW shows has adapted his beam methods to a European bench. Last I heard the Roubo bench from The Workbench book was not in service, and I think it may have been mostly an experiment rather than a mainstay. In any case the Roubo bench did have a vise.
The history lesson is that workbenches evolved to carry vises, they weren't invented as a marketing scheme in the 21 st century. That said, it's pretty sensible to start simple with the planing beam part and build a bench with expansion in mind, rather than start with unnecessary complexity and end up never using it or struggling around it.
2) The possibly less valid reason for a little more complexity in benches is that a lot of us use a variety of tools. Some of us have crazy tool combinations that may work best with different bench formats. I use both Japanese pull tools and Western push. I came by it honestly from the dark days of the late 70s when the best tools available were Japanese. They still are, but totally pro tools are available in a number of nationalities and historical periods and probably a serious hand tool person would be advised to choose a format. But I haven't and it creates problems, or can.
There are also real world reasons like the fact people like to do all kinds of work from chairs to guitars to architectural, I never know what will need to be done next. This means one isn't just a framer or a cabinetmaker etc... and it creates additional requirements for versatility.
And it can go further. I try not to ever use my workbench for anything other than wood, but others may have to fix bicycles etc... and one shouldn't really sneer they are probably a little more connected to their reality than most.
As to your design Dirk:
- I like the fact it is long, most benches are too short I think your bench should be a little longer than the average ceiling height you work with, there can be other measures but that is certainly one that will come up time and again. Also most benches will not hold wood as long as they are. and the face vises get in the way so the argument for length just gets ramped up.
- I would budget for one good vise like an Emmert or a Veritas. With it you can attach wood in the maximum number of orientations. In practice this kind of vise doesn't need to be integrated to the bench. A bench that was an uninterrupted beam/top with a tail vise, combined with Satellite emmert and another wide plank vise, and a shaving horse would pretty much be ideal. But barring that, I would take your two screw tail vise, the emmert on one side and an L vise for stuff like dovetails as on the German style benches.
-I like two screw tail vises like the Veritas. One other nice tail vise Veritas built was the more conventional type and it had one stop on it in the vise area, meaning one could only clampitems about 17" shorter than the bench itself, no advantage there. You have some of the same problem. Your vise may be unconventional, but it also seems without much merit. It can't be skewed unless you install joints at the ends, and you are loosing lots of useable rugged space along the edge of the bench. If I wanted that versatility and was going to go for such a hugely wide bench, I would install the double style on 2/3rds of the bench and the standard tail vise on the other third. That way you would have more clamping options, a strong top on one side, and so forth.
- I don't know what you want to do in the top vise that cuts into the bench top. This is 90 degree the wrong angle to get into panel joinery like dovetails and every other vise looks like the wooden kind that has a few inches of lateral bite, and needs inconvenient clamp support. As a cabinetmaker you have 5 vises and nowhere special to hold casework.
-American walnut is too soft for most bench use, I would not do the contrasting colours thing because it's a little obvious, but if I did do it I would use some of the heavier woods from South America that have become available and are more in the maple range.
-You have framed the bench 360 degrees which means there isn't any of the normal accommodation for wood movement, a big no no, or at least that is the way it looks
-You have dog holes in the corners where from what one can make out there is minimal strength.
-I would require a pretty complicated trestle to support your top vise, and I don't know how you would hold a long boards there without a lot of strain.
-The spots inboard of your conventional tail vises where your dark wood takes a dogleg would require scarf joints with 12-1 slope to get back to full top strength, just so you can have your colour thing happening. That seems like a complex solution to a self-inflicted wound.
-I don't like really wide tops since the stuff I need is always out of reach and I have to walk around to get it, in fact my idea of lowrider bench cool, is a narrow bench. If I was making a wide bench I think I would make one side at a different height than the other. That would be cool and have some real value.
-You are right to think that hold downs died for a reason, but they can also be useful. In modern hand tool shop a good argument can be made for go bars. The main advantage being they don't penetrate the bench and mess up storage space, or have throat limitations. I'm an open base guy, but I do leave some stuff under the bench so I never can get too excited about having long iron tails banging around down there. I am hoping to try them out on my country bench that needs to be theft proof and mostly outdoors, so I won't be using any vises.