Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Workbench top design (long)

Posts

Workbench top design (long)

#1

Workbench top design (long)

Dirk Vogel


>Hi there,

after much reading about the subject, here as well as in some books, I came to the conclusion that I should discuss my latest ideas about the design of my future workbench right on this messageboard, for there seem to be several experts of this issue I'd love to get an opinion from :-)

My starting points are :

1. I'm a beginner who don't really know in which ways a workbench can be used. Rather than building a very easy one, trying it out and deciding how my "real" bench should be, and building a second one after some time, I decided to design a bench with various possibilities (especially about vises), for two reasons : first, this way I'll indeed be able to try several ways to work wood, and second, I'll get some experience working on a difficult project (I love challenges).

2. I'm already quite sure about what I want to do and how : my woodworking will be about furniture, and I'll use exclusively hand tools. As to employed techniques, I foresee to do dovetails, face and edge joining boards, bolts, mortises and tenons, surfacing panels ... regarding my projects, narrow and very large stock will have to be worked. I won't do dados, relief carving, or sculpting, and I won't use machines.

3. I'll have 360 degree access to the bench. There won't be a shavings holder (tool tray). The size of the bench top should be about 8' of length and 32" to 35" of width. I'll use custom wooden vises (diameter 2"), trying to avoid other metal pieces as well.

As I didn't find out how to place a picture in the middle of a thread, I've to comment on my drawing before showing it :-) So here it comes :

� The most eye-catching item is that kind of integrated shoulder vise. I'm curious about your opinions.

� The tail vise is similar to the Veritas� Twin-Screw Vise, only it's made of wood vises, and you can attach two "classic" tail vises on it (in the drawing light-grey), like you can admire here (look at the pictures of the chapter "Building an unconvential tail vise") :

http://www.bitmover.com/lm/wood/bench/

� The second front vise can be placed in other positions (see arrow). That's why my benchdog holes are square, they're used in both directions (from front and end vises).

� The apron (dark grey in the drawing) is going to be walnut, everything else maple.

Finally, this is the design I came up with so far. Thanks for your comments. :-)


img

Re: Workbench top design (long)

#2

Re: Workbench top design (long)

DeanJ in MN


>2. I'm already quite sure about what I want to do and how : my woodworking will be about furniture, and I'll use exclusively hand tools.

If the above is the case -- you will be building furniture with hand tools exclusively -- I'd suggest looking back to the folks who did just that. See what their benches looked like, and compare that to your bench idea. I think you will find their benches are much much simpler, yet their furniture was anything but simple.

I find it more useful to think of operations you need to perform, and how your bench will assist you. A simple Roubo bench will meet the needs of a hand tool worker, and despite its seemingly simple look it is an amazingly flexible tool. Holdfasts and battens can go a long way.

How will you edge joint/match plane with your bench?

Can you use fenced planes without your vises interfearing?

Have you considered a planing stop rather than tail vises?

Is all that width needed? The handtool benches we know about from 17th-18th C. were longer, and narrower.

Don't discount dados -- casework often calls for dados, and having a way to use dado planes is important. Can your bench fit this need?

Having said that, there is no perfect bench, despite the efforts of WoodCentral! :-) These are just ideas to throw on the table.

-Dean

Re: Workbench top design (long)

#3

Re: Workbench top design (long)

John Clifford in Chicago


>OK Dirk, I'll bite. Being a beginner myself, (only been at it since 2003) I think I can give you a realistic opinion. Although your design looks very intersting, it is far more complicated than it needs to be. In fact your design looks more complicated than a Frank Klaus style bench, and they can take quite a while to build. I think a Klaus is as complex a bench as anyone should attempt to build, mostly because more complex is not necessary, but also because you want to finish the bench in this life time. Many great woodworkers of the past and present have built some of the finest furniture you'll ever see on quite simple benches. What I'm getting at is the bench is a means to an end and not the end in itself. It only has to hold your work, a relatively simple task. There is a guy who had a web site about all this, I think his name was Bob Key. His first bench was his "ultimate" work bench and it took him YEARS to finish. He goes on to highly reccomend and show you how to build a simple, easy, cheap, and fast work bench that will do everything you could want. Another example is the Roubo bench, which looks deceptively spartan but by all accounts is a great bench. The way I look at it is the sooner you finish the bench the sooner you can get on to what you really want to do - build furniture.

Sorry for the long post, and of course this is only my two cents. Good luck in your search for the right bench for you.

Re: Workbench top design (long)

#4

Simple bench (long)

Dirk Vogel


>Hi Dean,

thanks for your criticism. Like I said, I'm a beginner, and my idea about this surely complicated design was just the hope to meet most possible operations without really knowing how exactly I'll have to use my bench ;-)

About holdfasts and battens : I tried to avoid them because it seems to me that their use is a quite cruel form to hold down something, possibly harmful to your work if used improperly (hammering down on something does not require a certain force ? Excuse me if I'm mistaken). I thought that the use of vises offers a more elegant, less intrusive way of fixing wood ...

So I don't know if my design allows to edge joint/match plane, or to use fenced planes without the vises interfearing. Tell me ! If not, where should I change my plans ?

The use of a planing stop rather than tail vises is possible. I thought the twin tail vise's use should be fixing large panels for dovetailing.

All that width is a consequence of the incorporated shoulder vise. I feared the bench to be too weak if it was smaller.

But well, I'm here to learn from you :-) Thanks again,

Dirk

Re: Workbench top design (long)

#5

Complexity ...

Dirk Vogel


>... is surely something unnecessary, dear John, and I accept your criticism as well as that of Dean. The only point of my drawing is to give me the opportunity of trying more than one technique of fixing wood. I can't know which one will work out best for me right now. So some of all these vises will be probably used less than others after a while, I am aware of it. But the difference that counts for me is the one between something maybe complex but nevertheless functional and reasonable, and something only crazy and badly designed. That's the main purpose of my posting : to see of which category my plan belongs, and why.

Thanks for your bite ! ;-)

Dirk

Re: Workbench top design (long)

#6

Re: Simple bench (long)

Dan Donaldson


>A properly designed and used hold down is no more damaging to the work than a vise. You don't have to beat on them to set them, and the force is no more than a vise. The foot spreads the force so that it doesn't damage the work.

Re: Workbench top design (long)

#7

Re: Complexity ...

John Clifford in Chicago


>Dirk, if you can, find some woodworkers in your area and see if you can arrange to try out thier benches. A bench is a lot of work for trial and error to see what you like and what works for you. Post where you live here and I bet you'll find some or at least one woodworker nearby. But make sure you have fun with it. I enjoyed building my first "woodworking" bench so much last fall that I'm going to be building one for my father as soon as we work out the details. I'm trying to push him toward the Roubo bench. In fact I would have made my first one a Roubo had I been aware of it before I started mine. Again, good luck in your search Dirk.

Re: Workbench top design (long)

#8

Re: Simple bench (long)

Dirk Vogel


>Hi Dan,

ok, I see, my mistake. I didn't saw anybody use holddowns so far, that's why I imagined something rude :-)

Re: Workbench top design (long)

#9

Re: Complexity ...

Dirk Vogel


>John, this is another good idea from you :-) I'm not quite sure, however, to find folks with workbenches as different as they should be to allow me to try really different concepts of woodworking ... but I'll see. And I'm not worried about fun while working on this project either. Thanks !

Dirk

Re: Workbench top design (long)

#10

My comments

GolfSteve in Calgary


>Hi Dirk...great subject

You might get something out of the following thread on the Australian Woodworking Forum. They have a ten page discussion on "Redefining the Aussie Workbench". That bench was not solely directed at handtool work as yours is intended to be. I personally didn't get much out of the discussion, but there was a bunch of discussion about alternative construction techniques, vices, etc.

Redefining the Aussie Workbench

Here's a shot of what I think they eventually ended up with:


At the end of the day it looks a lot like a standard cabinetmaker's bench except for the sliding dogs and the trestle base.

Personally I'm a bit doubtful about some of the features in your design.

Let's look at one common hand-tool job: flattening a board:

I'll assume you're right handed. If you're left handed some of the comments may not be corrrect.

When flattening a board you need to have the board fully supported along it's lenghth. It's a bit questionable to have the board spanning the opening for your integrated shoulder vice, so that leaves you half the length of the bench at the top of the picture to do that job, or you can use other side of the bench where the two face vices are located.

In both cases you have the non-conventional tail vices to deal with...these aren't always perfectly aligned with the rest of the bench, so you may have to deal with high or low spots caused by the vices. You also shouldn't put a lot of downwards pressure on the tail vice to avoid damaging them, so that limits the usefulness of about 1/4 of the workbench length.

If you are flattening a long board using the bottom edge of the bench (with the two faces vices on it), those face vices will get in your way as you are moving along the length of the bench (they will hit your hip). Much cursing and swearing will result (I know...my old bench had a face vice along it's length that was always in my way when dimensioning wood).

So, I see some limitations with the common task of dimensioning a long board.

I kind of like the twin screw vice with the double tail vice. One problem I see with the twin screw vice is that there are only three dogholes in it...located at the extreme ends and one lonely dog hole in the middle. Why don't you have five dogholes in it to line up with the five rows in the benchtop? If I were you, I would have five dog holes lining up with the holes in the bench, and I would find a way to extend the two rows of dogholes in the bench, which stop short, all the way to the vice.

Next, the integrated shoulder vice does not look very useful to me. The best thing about a normal shoulder vice is that it can hold a wide board while you work on the end of the board. With a normal shoulder vice, the whole width of the board is facing the worker making jobs like dovetailing easy. With your integrated shoulder vice, only the edge of the board is facing the worker, and you cannot saw across the boards, etc....

I would ditch the integrated shoulder vice. The only advantage it seems to offer to me is that it doesn't stick out the way a normal shoulder vice does. If you really wanted a vice with that arrangement (which holds a board perpedicular to the user), I would make one of your tail vices twice as wide. Then the tail vice is doing exactly the same job as the integrated shoulder vice without all the complexity and without removing a large chunk of useful working surface.

Lastly, I see some wood expansion/movement problems with wrapping a solid maple top with the walnut edging. It looks great, but unless you match the grain direction of the walnut with the grain direction of the maple, you might have expansion problems.

I like the ability to move the face vice to different locations, kind of a nice idea, but I would probably just locate the vice in the middle of the doghole area and be done with it.

For the bottom left face vice, I think I would put a third row of dogholes in the middle of the vice...looks a bit too far between dogholes at the moment. A row of dogholes in the middle also lets you hold narrow stock in the middle of the vice without putting lateral pressure on the vice mechanism.

I recently built my dream bench...basically a copy of a traditional European cabinetmaker's bench a'la Frank Klausz. So far I have no regrets although I can see why a tool tray may not be wanted, especially if you can work on both sides of the bench. I wrote-up a long description of how I built my bench...perhaps it might help you as another source of information on some of the construction process details...

Building my workbench (4.3 MB)


The only thing I might seriously consider changing is using a twin screw vice instead of a tail vice.

Cheers,

Steven

Re: Workbench top design (long)

#11

I would encourage parsimony...

David Barnett - SW Florida


>...in every aspect of your life and thinking.

Re: Workbench top design (long)

#12

Re: Simple bench (long)

DeanJ in MN


>

About holdfasts and battens : I tried to avoid them because it seems to me that their use is a quite cruel ...

I nearly never use the holdfast to hold the wood I'm working, rather I use the holdfast to hold the batten in place. The batten is then used as a stop, or I just bank the work off the holdfast shafts when I am, for example, cutting dados. As you get used to working with the pieces "free" on your benchtop you will find you need fewer battens. I use them less often as I am learning how to control stock under my planes. (This is probably also a side effect of lowering my bench as well.)



So I don't know if my design allows to edge joint/match plane, or to use fenced planes without the vises interfearing. Tell me !


I would say, no on both accounts. All those vises are going to get in your way. As stated elsewhere in the thread, your hip is going to be sore as well.

If not, where should I change my plans?

I'd put a crochet on the front left, and that is all. Drill holes in the legs, toss a 2x4 on two wooden pins placed in the holes and you can edge joint a 8+ foot board. Perhpas 5-6 holdfast holes and you are done. This bench can take you a long way. If you want to be extra fancy, a twin screw on the front right.



The use of a planing stop rather than tail vises is possible. I thought the twin tail vise's use should be fixing large panels for dovetailing.


To be fair, I have a twin screw vise on the front right of my bench, and I do use it for dovetail work. But I'd give that vise up before I'd give up the holdfasts and crochet and planing stop. My first bench had a tail vise -- I don't miss it one bit. And for reference, I work by hand from rough lumber to finished product.

-Dean

Re: Workbench top design (long)

#13

Re: Workbench top design (long)

Thom D


>First I am sympathetic to the idea of a slightly more complicated bench. For two reasons. One of these reasons is good and the other perhaps less so. Here goes:

1) There has been a perfect storm of nonsense about simple benches recently. It's perhaps a combination of some very good information about the Roubo bench and some very solid video information about hand planing stock square (not brain surgery) that emphasizes the non-use of vises.

Roubo and simplicity are not new fads. When Landis kicked off the workbench book craze, perhaps the two simplicity icons were the Roubo bench re-created by Rob Tarule, and the Japanese beam benches notably by Carl Swensson. Tarule and Swensson should probably speak for themselves, but I don't think these benches were never exceeded. Swensson has marketed his own refined version of the shaving horse, a vise on legs, and as the current issue of FWW shows has adapted his beam methods to a European bench. Last I heard the Roubo bench from The Workbench book was not in service, and I think it may have been mostly an experiment rather than a mainstay. In any case the Roubo bench did have a vise.

The history lesson is that workbenches evolved to carry vises, they weren't invented as a marketing scheme in the 21 st century. That said, it's pretty sensible to start simple with the planing beam part and build a bench with expansion in mind, rather than start with unnecessary complexity and end up never using it or struggling around it.

2) The possibly less valid reason for a little more complexity in benches is that a lot of us use a variety of tools. Some of us have crazy tool combinations that may work best with different bench formats. I use both Japanese pull tools and Western push. I came by it honestly from the dark days of the late 70s when the best tools available were Japanese. They still are, but totally pro tools are available in a number of nationalities and historical periods and probably a serious hand tool person would be advised to choose a format. But I haven't and it creates problems, or can.

There are also real world reasons like the fact people like to do all kinds of work from chairs to guitars to architectural, I never know what will need to be done next. This means one isn't just a framer or a cabinetmaker etc... and it creates additional requirements for versatility.

And it can go further. I try not to ever use my workbench for anything other than wood, but others may have to fix bicycles etc... and one shouldn't really sneer they are probably a little more connected to their reality than most.

As to your design Dirk:

- I like the fact it is long, most benches are too short I think your bench should be a little longer than the average ceiling height you work with, there can be other measures but that is certainly one that will come up time and again. Also most benches will not hold wood as long as they are. and the face vises get in the way so the argument for length just gets ramped up.

- I would budget for one good vise like an Emmert or a Veritas. With it you can attach wood in the maximum number of orientations. In practice this kind of vise doesn't need to be integrated to the bench. A bench that was an uninterrupted beam/top with a tail vise, combined with Satellite emmert and another wide plank vise, and a shaving horse would pretty much be ideal. But barring that, I would take your two screw tail vise, the emmert on one side and an L vise for stuff like dovetails as on the German style benches.

-I like two screw tail vises like the Veritas. One other nice tail vise Veritas built was the more conventional type and it had one stop on it in the vise area, meaning one could only clampitems about 17" shorter than the bench itself, no advantage there. You have some of the same problem. Your vise may be unconventional, but it also seems without much merit. It can't be skewed unless you install joints at the ends, and you are loosing lots of useable rugged space along the edge of the bench. If I wanted that versatility and was going to go for such a hugely wide bench, I would install the double style on 2/3rds of the bench and the standard tail vise on the other third. That way you would have more clamping options, a strong top on one side, and so forth.

- I don't know what you want to do in the top vise that cuts into the bench top. This is 90 degree the wrong angle to get into panel joinery like dovetails and every other vise looks like the wooden kind that has a few inches of lateral bite, and needs inconvenient clamp support. As a cabinetmaker you have 5 vises and nowhere special to hold casework.

-American walnut is too soft for most bench use, I would not do the contrasting colours thing because it's a little obvious, but if I did do it I would use some of the heavier woods from South America that have become available and are more in the maple range.

-You have framed the bench 360 degrees which means there isn't any of the normal accommodation for wood movement, a big no no, or at least that is the way it looks

-You have dog holes in the corners where from what one can make out there is minimal strength.

-I would require a pretty complicated trestle to support your top vise, and I don't know how you would hold a long boards there without a lot of strain.

-The spots inboard of your conventional tail vises where your dark wood takes a dogleg would require scarf joints with 12-1 slope to get back to full top strength, just so you can have your colour thing happening. That seems like a complex solution to a self-inflicted wound.

-I don't like really wide tops since the stuff I need is always out of reach and I have to walk around to get it, in fact my idea of lowrider bench cool, is a narrow bench. If I was making a wide bench I think I would make one side at a different height than the other. That would be cool and have some real value.

-You are right to think that hold downs died for a reason, but they can also be useful. In modern hand tool shop a good argument can be made for go bars. The main advantage being they don't penetrate the bench and mess up storage space, or have throat limitations. I'm an open base guy, but I do leave some stuff under the bench so I never can get too excited about having long iron tails banging around down there. I am hoping to try them out on my country bench that needs to be theft proof and mostly outdoors, so I won't be using any vises.

Re: Workbench top design (long)

#14

Re: My comments

Thom D


>Cool link! That really does look like the ultimate committee project. I had to say that before I read the link, cause I bet they have their reasons.

Re: Workbench top design (long)

#15

Re: Complexity ...

Thom D


>One thing, how are you going to build this thing? Do you have a workshop with tools and a bench now? That is the most difficult thing about the modern self-apprenticeship, no master and no tools to learn all the tricks and techniques and make all the tools. How does one start?

I had the chouice between buying a bench and a planer to make the bench out of.

Re: Workbench top design (long)

#16

Re: Workbench top design (long)

George Makowski


>Dirk, I will second the opinion that you should take a hard look at the vises used by production hand woodworkers of the past with an eye to those designed for general work.

I will also second the motion that it is no fault to start simple or cheap. My workbench, now in use for over 10 years, is a 2x4 base with a doubled 1/2" plywood top. I have a front vise, a <$20 special from Lowes with widened wooden jaws. I use stops clamped to the end of the bench and battens when needed. Lots of things are held to the edge with C clamps. My "end vise" is a block clamped to the edge of the bench against which the work is pressed by a block on the end of the vise with another C clamp. On one end I have holes drilled to mount a 5" metal working vise since I do have to use the bench to fix mechanical items.

Is it my dream bench? No. Have I made lots of things on it? Yes.

Don't let the lust for perfection slow you down.

I suggest making something strong, simple, and adaptable. You can always make another one later if you want. What you may find is that the workbench teaches you as much as you try to form the bench.

Anyway, good bench building!

George in AL

Re: Workbench top design (long)

#17

Re: Simple bench (long)

Dirk Vogel


>Hi Dean,

many thanks for your patience ! I'll have to ask you for some more, however ;-)

So you use the holdfasts to hold battens, ok, I understood that bit. (By the way : I found the following statement somewhere, "The easiest way is to simply use a piece of dowel for a dog and drill holes in your bench-top that will fit. This is fast and easy, but it doesn�t last as well as square holes. The round holes tend to elongate over time causing the dog to climb out of its hole under clamping pressure. This makes a pretty useless system � so I always use square dogs." Shouldn't it be the same with prolonged use of holdfasts ? Won't round dogholes become oval ?) And you're saying I should use a crochet, so be it. Evidently you've got experience with it, so tell me please : won't the inner curbed surface of the crochet get edgy when you stick in shelves repeatedly ? And a little bit further you wrote something about a twin screw on the front right � wouldn't that get in the way of long boards ?

As I'm German, I didn't understand your expression "toss a 2x4 on two wooden pins placed in the holes", I beg your pardon. What do you mean by "2x4" ?

Something else I liked very much was your statement that you work by hand from rough lumber to finished product. That's what I'd like to do, too ... :-)

Thanks, Dirk

Re: Workbench top design (long)

#18

How am I going to ...

Dirk Vogel


>... build my bench ? I'm lucky : I got to know a cabinet maker who lives about 5 minutes far from where I live. He's 70, doesn't work anymore, but owns a fully equipped shop. What is more : I bought already my tools :-) So there should be no problem on that side ...

Re: Workbench top design (long)

#19

Re: Workbench top design (long)

Deirdre Saoirse Moen


>I'm a relative beginner, and I am certainly no workbench expert. However, the way you've got the shoulder vise set up, it can't really be used as a shoulder vise. One of the ways a shoulder vise really stands out is in helping you dovetail drawers, so it really needs to be facing out lest it limit you in the depth you can select. So I'd turn that around the top left corner and have it stand proud of the bench proper. This will also give you more working surface.

Oh, and another thing -- all those possible dog hole points where you don't have dog holes -- you'll likely find that you need them for longer work (or intermediate sizes), so just put them in anyway. :)

Re: Workbench top design (long)

#20

Re: Simple bench (long)

DeanJ in MN


>Won't round dogholes become oval ?

I have not noticed my holes getting oval. My top is 4-1/4" hard maple.

And you're saying I should use a crochet, so be it. Evidently you've got experience with it, so tell me please : won't the inner curbed surface of the crochet get edgy when you stick in shelves repeatedly ?

I made my crochet of maple, and haven't seen any major wear of the inside, at least nothing that concerns me. It is a workbench after all, it will get wear. On the other hand, I don't forsee having to replace the crochet in the next few decades either.



And a little bit further you wrote something about a twin screw on the front right � wouldn't that get in the way of long boards ?


Good eye! Yes it does, and is one reason I'd give it up if I had to do it over. That said, it comes off real quick, so in the end it hasn't been in my way for typical work I do.



As I'm German, I didn't understand your expression "toss a 2x4 on two wooden pins placed in the holes", I beg your pardon. What do you mean by "2x4" ?


Sorry, a 2x4 - typical construction framing lumber, nominal 2inch x 4inch softwood. But any scrap of wood between the pegs in the legs works, the end result is a little shelf to rest the wood on.



Something else I liked very much was your statement that you work by hand from rough lumber to finished product. That's what I'd like to do, too ... :-)

My simple bench serves me well, it may not serve others, I offer my input as suggestion and points to ponder.

-Dean

Re: Workbench top design (long)

#21

Re: Simple bench (long)

Thom D


>It may be that round dog holes are the most useful. I have a few on my bench due to the fact that I have some Veritas vises. I just hate them though. They just don't look right to me, and I find that they are a tight fit a lot of the time the Veritas brass ones anyway, have quite a strong spring for the size of hole. I doubt they would ovalize a hole in a solid bench top of sufficient depth. I have two in some 9" maple, I had to devise something to push them back up with.

I don't use round wood because it's a little weak for the section involved.

Veritas has a lot of useful things that use the round holes so it makes sense.

Re: Workbench top design (long)

#22

Re: My comments

Dirk Vogel


>Hi Steven,

your exhaustive comments are incredibly kind ... I never hoped to get such a detailed analysis of my ideas :-) Thank you very much !

I'll read the Aussie discussion once I'll have responded to everybody trying yo help me here ... starting with you.

About your concern flattening a board ... I wouldn't have suspected that tail vises could have problems with alignment, but of course I believe your experience. I didn't think about pressure either. I imagined a 7' board clamped between the upper and the middle bench dog of my twin-screw tail vise and the benchdogs near the "shoulder vise", flattening it from the tail vise to the center of the bench, then turning it and doing the other half � because it's evident I couldn't apply pressure on the hole of my shoulder vise. This way, front vises wouldn't get in my way.

Doing this job on the bottom edge of the bench could be possible if, like I planned it, the central front vise can be unmounted. The left end front vise can't possibly be a problem � nearly every workbench has a vise in that corner ! Or do I miss something there ?

The three dogholes of my twin-screwed tail vise can very easily become five. I had indeed a drawing with 5 rows, and I changed only because my workbench resembled a Swiss cheese ...

Ok, let's say I ditch the "shoulder vise", trying to do the job with a large tail vise. How could I assure a smooth gliding of such a large structure without distorsion ? It'll be attached to the bench only on one side, and no auxiliary runners should be allowed, because otherwise it wouldn't resemble a shoulder vise ...

About grain directions : walnut would be the wood of the apron of my bench. Now, on the lenghth side, grain directions will match, but on the end cap of the short bench side, grains won't never match, even if the wood was the same. I can't find out how to prevent this; but lots of benches have got end caps without serious problems, haven't they ?

And my bottom left face vice can't have a bench hole in its middle because there is the screw ! The only way to have the middle hole would be by shifting the vise to the right or left. But wouldn't rack the vise more easily in that case ?

Finally, thank you for your detailed description of your benchmaking ! I appreciate it very much.

Many greetings,

Dirk

Re: Workbench top design (long)

#23

Re: My comments

GolfSteve in Calgary


>Hi Dirk. I obsessed over my bench for two years before I got around to building it. At the end of the day I ended up with a very traditional bench.

First, sorry I did not realize you were from Germany. I usually take more care to use good and proper English when I know a person may have some trouble with English short-cuts.

I found the Aussie discussion interesting because they did not want to be bound by tradition when designing a workbench, but after much discussion the final product resembles a traditional workbench.

I'll respond to some of your comments: I wouldn't have suspected that tail vises could have problems with alignment...if the bench is well built and fairly new there should be no alignment problems, but after a few years of wear and tear, especially with wood mechanisms, there is bound to be some sagging of the assembly.

I didn't think about pressure either. I imagined a 2134 mm board clamped between the upper and the middle bench dog of my twin-screw tail vise and the benchdogs near the "shoulder vise", flattening it from the tail vise to the center of the bench, then turning it and doing the other half. First, the pressure of normal planing shouldn't hurt a tail vice but you don't want to do any hammering on top of the tail vice. Second, you might have some trouble "turning it and doing the other half" because when you turn the board around you might be planing against the grain of the wood.

Doing this job on the bottom edge of the bench could be possible if, like I planned it, the central front vise can be unmounted. The left end front vise can't possibly be a problem � nearly every workbench has a vise in that corner ! Or do I miss something there ? No, you have it correct. If you remove the central front vice (and you are right handed), then the bottom of the bench is set-up well for planing long boards.

The three dogholes of my twin-screwed tail vise can very easily become five. I had indeed a drawing with 5 rows, and I changed only because my workbench resembled a Swiss cheese ... or even a more German Emmentaler cheese.

Ok, let's say I ditch the "shoulder vise", trying to do the job with a large tail vise. How could I assure a smooth gliding of such a large structure without distorsion? I would argue that the arrangement of the integrated shoulder vice is not that useful and could be eliminated altogether. For the small number of situations where holding a piece of wood that way would be useful, a tail vice of 150 mm width would be plenty. My tail vice is 135 mm wide and has no problem, but I used metal hardware. The limitation of a tail vice compared to the shoulder vice is that the tail vice does not have a jaw than swivels.

About grain directions : walnut would be the wood of the apron of my bench. Now, on the lenghth side, grain directions will match, but on the end cap of the short bench side, grains won't never match, even if the wood was the same. I can't find out how to prevent this; but lots of benches have got end caps without serious problems, haven't they ? The way a traditional bench allows for wood movement is to glue one end of the end-cap to the benchtop, but to only bolt the other end of the end-cap onto the bench. In the picture below you can see my workbench where the right side of the end-cap is glued (and securely bolted) to the bench top. The left side of the end-cap is loosely bolted (no glue) to the bench top and the bolt passes through a slotted hole in the end-cap.

What happens with this arrangement is that the benchtop is allowed to expand to the left. The slotted bolthole in the end-cap allows the bolt to move with the benchtop. The tool-tray bottom is built in such a way as to allow 12 mm of benchtop expansion.


Most of the benches that I have seen, which do not have a tool-tray, do not wrap wood all the way around the bench. Most seem to wrap the front and the two sides, but leave the back-side open to allow for wood expansion. I have seen pictures of benches that completely wrap an apron completely around the bench and make no allowance for wood expansion...but I think it's a bad idea.

And my bottom left face vice can't have a bench hole in its middle because there is the screw ! The only way to have the middle hole would be by shifting the vise to the right or left. But wouldn't rack the vise more easily in that case ? Hmmm...good point. Maybe you can have a shallow doghole in the vice jaw, and not start the matching dogholes in the bench until after the end of the vice screw?

ps. do you mind telling us where you are from in Germany? I have a number of relatives in the Sindelfingen/Stuttgart region, and I occasionally visit Neu Beckum (near Muenster) for work.

pps. If you don't already have a number of resources, I found that refering to workbench building books and magazine articles really helpgul. Two good ones are "The Workbench Book" by Scott Landis, and "The Workbench" by Lon Schleining. I also thought the article in the October 2004 Issue of "The Woodworker's Journal" by Frank Klausz was excellent.

Re: Workbench top design (long)

#24

Build a quick bench now, a fancy bench later.

Roy Anderson


>Dirk,

One of the best things I ever read as I was obsessing over what type of bench to build as a beginner (not that long ago) was from a fellow named Bob Keys who used to have a web site up. His point was build a simple, pretty good bench now and spend all the extra time doing projects and improving your skills. In a year or two (about the time you would finish the bench you're thinking about) you will have a very mature vision of what you need and where you want to go. And you will have the skills to get there.

Best of luck.

Re: Workbench top design (long)

#25

How to use battens, crochets, planing stops *LINK*

Pete Ducklow


>Dean neglected to show you his excellent series of photos of his bench in action. He shouldn't be so modest. I've learned a lot from them.

Pete


http://woodcentral.com.ldh0138.uslec.net/cgi-bin/a