Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

steel for plane irons and saw blades

Posts

Re: steel for plane irons and saw blades

#26

Re: A couple clarifications

Andrew Lunn


>Adam said: "One other thing: Disstons tapers often exceed .020" That doesn't sound like a lot of metal, but across a broad plate it might as well be an acre." Point taken.

I think I will make one without taper to begin with. Like Mike said, anyway, you can always try to taper it later.

Does the added weight to the untapered saw seem to help it in any way? From things I've read it sounds as though heavier saws handle perhaps a little more nicely than leaner ones. Any truth to that?

Re: steel for plane irons and saw blades

#27

Re: A couple clarifications

Andrew Lunn


>Adam said: "One other thing: Disstons tapers often exceed .020" That doesn't sound like a lot of metal, but across a broad plate it might as well be an acre." Point taken.

I think I will make one without taper to begin with. Like Mike said, anyway, you can always try to taper it later.

Does the added weight to the untapered saw seem to help it in any way? From things I've read it sounds as though heavier saws handle perhaps a little more nicely than leaner ones. Any truth to that?

Re: steel for plane irons and saw blades

#28

Thanks for the link Pam

Andrew Lunn

Re: steel for plane irons and saw blades

#29

Jury's out on heavy saws

Adam Cherubini


>As soon as I get a breather I'm going to hit the road with my saws and I promised one to a friend. I hoping to get others' views. Case in point, I brought my 19" tenon saw with me to Pennsbury. I filed pretty coarse teeth in it and am not sure I love it. Warren tried it and liked the teeth but didn't like the length. It may be that we haven't come across the job this saw was made for yet. In any case, different people have different experiences. Chris Schwarz has a story on his blog page about his. That saw is similar to mine but finer toothed.

The taper is a significant contributor to the overall weight of my rip saw. But that saw also has a rectangular blade shape that makes it toe heavy.

So to answer your question, I'm not sure if the weight is good or bad. I'd like to get some more user's opinions before we decide weight is helpful or harmful. I can say my particular saw cuts fast. But that may have more to do with its teeth than its weight or handle angle, etc etc.

Sorry this is no answer.

Adam

Re: steel for plane irons and saw blades

#30

Re: Saw restoration

Adam Cherubini


>Again, I'm not interested in selling saws new or otherwise. I've bought exactly one new western saw in my life and several japanese saws that I don't prefer.

I don't keep track of how long it takes me to restore saws (because I'm not selling them) but I do keep track of how long it takes me to use a saw to "lay a slit" in a board. So I'm usually not looking for a "clean" saw but a saw of the right length, thickness with decent toe height and roughly right number of teeth. When I find such a saw, I'm willing to clean it, repair its handle etc.

What I find are clapped out 26" 6 tooth saws which I find pretty much useless. An 8tpi #12 doesn't help me, no matter how clean it is.

So the primary reason to choose a new saw (whether you buy it or make it) is that you can get exactly what you want. There are some saws that are both useful and common. And its smart to buy these used, imho. But just like you're not going to find a high angle smoother on ebay, there are some useful saws you won't find. The only reason there aren't more saw makers is because woodworkers literally don't know what they're missing. Boutique saws are a slippery slope all their own, so beware!

Adam

Re: steel for plane irons and saw blades

#31

Re: A couple clarifications

mikew


>Hi Andrew,

I purchased stock from both MSC and McMaster-Carr. Already hardened and tempered. Tempering can be done in a kitchen oven if it is big enough.

The suggestion by Adam of either leaving the saw non-tapered--and it really has little value insofar as cabinet making--or scraping/samding/polishing the hardened steel is the best solution.

To obtain acceptable results as regards sawing dry woods, little set is required and if anything just a bit of tapering and or rounding on the blade's top edge is all that is required.

If you were making saws for construction materials, or processing less than dry woods, or handsawing funky shapes, then tepering is more an issue.

The latest Kenyon saw I made, the panel saw, is a 26", 8 ppi saw with taper. It was a beast to do--but I think the results are worth it from a historical perspective. Even at that, I didn't fully match the original. Though they probably varied, as did Disstons pre-rolling the taper. Maybe even after then. Point is, the saw cuts extremely well. It doesn't bind even with the comparitively little set it has.

Take care, Mike

Re: steel for plane irons and saw blades

#32

Re: Saw restoration

Dean J in MN


>Boutique saws are a slippery slope all their own, so beware!

Tell me about it -- right Mike?? :)

Re: steel for plane irons and saw blades

#33

Re: Saw restoration

mikew


>Who's Mike?

Take care, Mike

who better get back out to the shop...

Re: steel for plane irons and saw blades

#34

Re: Jury's out on heavy saws

Dean J in MN


>I can only say that I agree the jury is out on heavy saws. I have the same Kenyon/Seaton saw as Chris Schwarz, Mike filed mine a little different, but I agree with what Chris has found. The saw, in spite of being large and "heavy" handles as if it were a lot smaller and lighter. Compared to a Disston 16" backsaw the Kenyon saw is nimble and a joy to use. The Disston feels like a brick in hand, and is a lot more difficult to use. I need to weigh the Disston, but a lot of what I think is causing the difference in feel is the combonation of hang and tooth configuration. Tooth count, rake angle and any fleam make a big difference. Mike can share his thoughts on this topic, as he managed to set the tenon saws up very well. I need to revisit the teeth on my Disston and see if I can make it a bit more user friendly.

Sorry, also not an answer...

-Dean

Re: steel for plane irons and saw blades

#35

Re: Saw restoration

Todd Hughes


>So tell me a couple examples of saws that you think are to hard to find in the wild that you need.

...This does beg the question that if these "special" saws you need are so essential why was it that not many other woodworkers thought so since apparently not many ever got sold if they are so rare today.....Todd

Re: steel for plane irons and saw blades

#36

Re: Jury's out on heavy saws

mikew


>Dean's large--and it is large at 19" blade length and a 1" wide brass back--tenon saw is filed somewhere around 2-4 degrees of rake and about 2-3 degrees of fleam. It is a 10 ppi saw. Chris' was the first one I did. It is filed with progressive rake with about 6 or so degrees rake the norm. The set is a little wider than Dean's saw for the type of woods expected. They both cut similar, though I would give the nod to Dean's as faster.

One thing about these large tenon saws I was unsure about is the saw plate thickness. It is .025" and the usable height is about 4 1/2" at the toe, rising 1/2" or so at the heel. That's a lot of unsupported blade hanging out there for as thin as the plate is. It is important to keep the saws waxed now and again to reduce friction and hence a little plate distortion.

The handle is certainly a compfortable handle. And the hang of it in relation to the length of the saw is about perfect. Guess John Kenyon knew what he was doing . I can only hope to one day understand as much as the old makers.

Many larger Disstons use .040" saw plate as I think they expected abuse of the jobsite and or use in a miter box. That is a significant amount of kerf difference which will affect the saw's ability to cut quickly.

I have always enjoyed heavier, longer saws for tenons. All things being equal insofar as sharpening, a longer stroke for me means fewer strokes and perhaps less chance of error. The weight of these is great. No real amount of pressure is needed to enable the saw to cut.

Oh, many thoughts--and even more work to get done. I'll check back later to see if there are other questions. Today is a part computer day, part actual work...

Take care, Mike

Re: steel for plane irons and saw blades

#37

Saw taper

Adam Cherubini


>I think saw taper isn't the answer for a kerf that is closing on you. No amount of taper will stop that. The solution to that problem is a wedge. I think taper reduces friction in a normal kerf. If my saw rusts it may be difficult to use. As it is I rub the blade with beewax and the saw runs smoother faster on the backstroke. This test supports my theory. Keeping a relaxed grip helps a lot as well.

Adam

Re: steel for plane irons and saw blades

#38

Re: Saw taper

mikew


>Absolutely to each point.

I have several wedges I made years ago from some Teak scrap I keep in a couple places around the shop. At the saw horse [such as it is], at the bench and on a shelf just in case I'm sawing outside I can leave the others alone.

Wax is invaluable in the cabinet shop for use on saws [ok, and other tools]. My grandfather use to use kerosene, probably due to the logging influence where it was used as the lubricant of choice.

Take care, Mike

Re: steel for plane irons and saw blades

#39

Adam's Saw

Warrren in Lancaster, PA


>I tried Adam's tenon saw on Sunday. I really liked the cutting action - I think many of today's saws have teeth too fine for efficient work. If I had this saw I would use it, especially for larger tenons, say over 2" wide. The weight of the saw made it seem a little clumsy in my hands and I thought having to support and manipulate 18" of saw was too much. Later I wondered if a thinner gauge would have made it more to my liking.

Re: steel for plane irons and saw blades

#40

Re: Adam's Saw

Adam Cherubini


>Maybe a thinner gauge of brass you mean. The saw plate is .025. The brass is .093.

How thick is your brass Mike?

Oh, and my saw is 19" long.

Adam

Re: steel for plane irons and saw blades

#41

Re: A couple clarifications

Andrew Lunn


>Again, thanks for the info, Mike. Can you tell me what kind of tool steel you buy? O1? W1? And when you buy it, do you have to specify that it be tempered and hardened for you, or is that just how it comes by default? Thanks.

Re: steel for plane irons and saw blades

#42

Re: Jury's out on heavy saws

Andrew Lunn


>Actually, I do have a couple other questions. Sorry they're kind of slow in coming. My internet access is very touch and go this week.

First, how you do cut the blank for the saw from the sheet you order? Do you use a hacksaw? Or a backsaw? Or sheers? Is one method preferrable to the others?

Secondly, with backsaws, what method do you recommend for bending the brass for the spine?

Re: steel for plane irons and saw blades

#43

Re: Jury's out on heavy saws

Andrew Lunn


>Adam, I seem to recall reading somewhere where you said something about how you thought the teeth of a handsaw (rip and crosscut) would ideally be filed. I seem to recall that one or both of them involved varying the number of teeth from the toe to the heel. I can't remember where I saw this. Would you mind recapping your thoughts and explaining why the tooth count should vary across the blade's length?

Re: steel for plane irons and saw blades

#44

Re: Saw restoration

Andrew Lunn


>I second Todd's request for Adam; I'd be very curious to hear what saws would perhaps be especially worth making.

Re: steel for plane irons and saw blades

#45

...one more question

Andrew Lunn


>Is there a jig of some kind you should use for filing in the teeth? And do you lay all of the teeth out on the blade, or does the jig itself provide for proper spacing? Thanks a lot Mike.

Re: steel for plane irons and saw blades

#46

Large Tenon Saws!

Paul in NJ


>I have never seen a large tenon saw at flea markets or at regional tool shows. I am talking about an 18" backsaw, filed rip style, at least 4" in depth, and 8-10 ppi. I am sure there must be some out there but I have never seen one. There are miter box saws that you can cut down, retooth, and file rip but their blades tend to be thicker at .040 inch. Does anyone know how thick the original Kenyan tenon saw was?

Paul Dzioba

Re: steel for plane irons and saw blades

#47

Re: ...one more question

mikew


>Hi Andrew,

The steel is 1095 spring steel and is already hardened.

Re the teeth, I punch them out using one of a couple retoothers. I have cut teeth in by hand and it is not that difficult. With a steel ruler you can find a scale which corresponds to the number of teeth per inch you desire and using a felt pen, mark each graduation corresponding to that spacing.

Then take a file, I've used knife and cant files for this, cut a notch at each mark, go back and deepen them a little, then switch to a saw file.

You can also use a computer to lay out lines in a drawing program to the spacing you want, lay the printout over the saw blade and using the cant file create marks at each line.

Take care, Mike

Re: steel for plane irons and saw blades

#48

Re: Large Tenon Saws!

mikew


>Hi Paul, the 19" Kenyon as found in the Seaton chest was a nominal .026".

The ones I have been making I have used .025".

Take care, Mike

Re: steel for plane irons and saw blades

#49

Re: Jury's out on heavy saws

mikew


>Hi Andrew.

Shortest possible answer: go to Leif's website...

http://www.norsewoodsmith.com/ww/dovetail/bs-index.htm

He has a step by step how he does it.

Take care, Mike

Re: steel for plane irons and saw blades

#50

Thanks for the link, Mike

Andrew Lunn