Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

steel for plane irons and saw blades

Posts

steel for plane irons and saw blades

#1

steel for plane irons and saw blades

Andrew Lunn

>Hi everybody. I'm wondering if any of you who make your own planes and saws could share with me a good source for the steel to make the irons/blades. I'm aware of Hock blades, but some of the planes I want to make are moulding planes. Also, can any of you tell me how to go about tapering the blade of a handsaw? How did they do it, for instance, in the 18th century?

Thanks in advance for any information.

Andrew

Re: steel for plane irons and saw blades

#2

Re: steel for plane irons and saw blades

Bob Fawcett

>you can get O1 here.

http://www.victornet.com/cgi-bin/victor/productlist.html

Re: steel for plane irons and saw blades

#3

Re: steel for plane irons and saw blades

Thom D

>Hop straight over to Bladeforums.com. They have a pretty good resources for all things so related.

O1 tool steel is readily available at all kinds of metal and industrial supply stores. If you have the need of a fair amount of the stuff, then you might consider buying wide stock since it is much cheaper, though it requires more finishing. You have to be able to do your own heat treating which is relatively easy with O1 steel. Heat treating is like any skill and simply following a formula does not give you the ultimate edge. A fair amount can be done to improve your results with O1. Or you can consider various super steels, though there is no such thing as a steel that is perfect so using high tech steels is not necesarily the solution, there are downsides to everything.

MSC carried medium hardness roll stock, and the exact order numbers have been given in here alaready. I don't personally make saws at the moment, I have dabbled in the past. So I'll leave it to others.

I would imagine that in the old days they scraped saws, as some Japanese saws are still. There is a saw scraper building tutorial here, it is the same tool as used to scrape swords: http://www.dfoggknives.com/handwork.htm

There is resurgent interest in hand scraping, and yahoo even has a forum.

Molding planes can easily be draw up in cad and templates for the blade can be stretched in proportion to the slope of your bedding angle. This is a quick way to come up with patterns for the body and blade. There are a variety of ways of making the plane itself, and LN is carrying a video that covers the traditional western method.

Re: steel for plane irons and saw blades

#4

Re: steel for plane irons and saw blades

Todd Hughes

>18th century saws did not have tapered blades

I would just pick up some old saws for a $1 or $2 and use thier blades to make the saws you want. Good steel that is already hardened and tempered and tapered too if you want such. I made a backsaw out of an old grain shovel befor but kind of stupid.

...I have seen more then a few old hand made molding and other narrow wood planes where files were used for the cutters and this is what I would use. I've made many hundereds of knives out of files with nothing but good results.....Todd

Re: steel for plane irons and saw blades

#5

Re: steel for plane irons and saw blades

Dean J in MN

>18th century saws did not have tapered blades

Are you sure? Moxon describes taper ground blades IIRC and the pannel saws in the Seaton chest were taper ground.

-Dean

Re: steel for plane irons and saw blades

#6

Right

Adam Cherubini

>Yeah, looks like at least some 18th c saws were purposely taper ground. Anybody know how they did it?

I've read about how Disston did it. Pretty sure they ground hardened steel. IME this is very slow going.

Adam

Re: steel for plane irons and saw blades

#7

Disston tapering

Dave Thompson

>If I remember correctly, Disston had some very large grinding wheels that the steel would pass between and come out tapered. They showed some drawings of the tapering machine at a saw patent talk at the MWTCA in St. Charles last year. The large size of the wheels had more to do with the slight angle of the taper than anything else.

Dave

Re: steel for plane irons and saw blades

#8

Re: Right

mikew

>Hey Adam, howzit?

Disston ground it pre-hardening. Later, Disston figured out they could roll it tapered and save a lot of work and actually have a more consistent taper. Teeth were also cut in pre-hardening.

Once hardened, they did continue to grind following hammering/tensioning, but that was really to remove the marks from tensioning as much as anything. Then on to being polished.

I'll I need is an extra 60 acres and I could have my own steel mill...

Take care, Mike

Re: steel for plane irons and saw blades

#9

thanks for the link Bob

Andrew Lunn

>

Re: steel for plane irons and saw blades

#10

Re: steel for plane irons and saw blades

Andrew Lunn

>Thanks for the information Thom. Forgive my ignorance, but what does MSC stand for, or what is their web address? I couldn't find them doing a search with just msc and 01 steel. Thanks.

Re: steel for plane irons and saw blades

#11

So how in the 18th c?

Adam Cherubini

>So how do you think they did it in the 18th c? The taper in Seaton's saws isn't quite as great as Disstons, and it seems a little inconsistent (as if it was ground). They may have just used big grinding wheels, but I don't see how they could have done that to hardened steel. It would had to have been annealed since the grind stones weren't that great- at least the few I've used aren't great.

I think Andrew wants to try this himself. And aside from the Mike Wenz, I'll just spend three hours on it method, I think the only way to do this practically is to start with annealed steel. Thoughts?

Adam

Re: steel for plane irons and saw blades

#13

Re: So how in the 18th c?

Andrew Lunn

>Yep, that's right Adam. I think it would be fun/interesting to start from raw material and make a taper ground handsaw. And I'm just wondering how folks who do already make their own saws deal with the taper grind. Looking back to how it was done a long time ago I thought might give some insights. I suppose I could start with an old saw blade that is already taper ground, like Todd suggested, but I really wanted to try it from scratch.

Given that I do not actually know how to do it, or how it was done, here are my thoughts from just looking at the problem and thinking about it--maybe it could be done with a very coarse flat stone, like the side of a large slip stone, applying more pressure toward the spine of the blade. The taper doesn't have to be all that much really. I'm not so sure this would be as labor intensive as it looks like it'd be--with a coarse stone and not needing to remove all that much. If you only are making a few saws, especially. Could this be how they did it back when folks made their own tools and didn't need to make that many of them?

Re: steel for plane irons and saw blades

#14

Re: So how in the 18th c? *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>The Japanese used a tool called a "sen" for this. The handmade saw makers still do. A sen looks like something of a cross between a big, crude spokeshave and a drawknife.

A few toolmakers in the US also use/make them, such as Dave Burnard.

Pam


Yataiki using a sen

Re: steel for plane irons and saw blades

#15

Re: So how in the 18th c?

mikew

>"So how do you think they did it in the 18th c?"

Pretty much how I described. Disston was a product of the refinements made at least by the end of the 18th century. When he began, he was a mere 1/2 a generation away. He was from England and I suspect that either him or the person he worked for brought the then-current technology with them. American patents don't seem to shed any light on the subject for that time period, so I think the above is a reasonable assumption until such time research can answer with certainty.

"The taper in Seaton's saws isn't quite as great as Disstons, and it seems a little inconsistent (as if it was ground). They may have just used big grinding wheels, but I don't see how they could have done that to hardened steel. It would had to have been annealed since the grind stones weren't that great- at least the few I've used aren't great."

Your assumption is that the steel received by Kenyon was already hardened--do we actually know this? If I was working in the great industrial towns of England where on any given street it seems are 10 saw makers, and steel mills at the end of every block [OK, that was a bit of an exaggeration], I would have bought the rolled steel--which they had--in the pre-hardened state, shape the saw, taper grind and cut the teeth in, and take the plates back for hardening and tempering.

The Kenyon Sash is probably the most wildly tapered saw in the group of 6. And why taper a sash saw anyway? It's got a back. My guess is it was a reject from making other, larger saws and then further thicknessed by files in the shop in the hardened state. A grind stone would have produced a better taper--less obvious transitions in thickness--albeit really slow. That is my working theory anyway.

Another assumption is that Kenyon represents the state-of-the-art of 18th century saw making. Or even that the 6 saws in the Seaton chest were the best ones, or even ones of average quality. I've only handled two Kenyon saws. Both tenons. Neither had tapered blades and the saw plate was pretty even. However, both were early 19th century.

"I think Andrew wants to try this himself. And aside from the Mike Wenz, I'll just spend three hours on it method, I think the only way to do this practically is to start with annealed steel. Thoughts?"

Why thank you for that bit of sarcasm. I think. There were two parts to the question. One dealt with history, one with the therefore how to do it today. I tried giving an answer. It was easy, it seemed to me, to extrapolate backwards from there. Going from the known to the unknown type of thing.

Annealing would be an option. It is the hardening and tempering and dealing with the saw plate post process which would be the issue. The plate will not be flat when done. At least I do not think it would. And it would take a good size furnace to evenly reharden. I think the best bet is to deal with the hardened stock.

The Japanese use a sen. A link had already been given re sen. A sen is used on a bit harder steel and if I was going to do a one-off, I would use a sen and files, followed by polishing stones. That would be for leaving the steel in the hardened state.

The issue to me is that unless a person wants to do this madness for a living, is 3 hours really a bad investment of time?

So questions for you, Adam. Do you believe a saw plate even needs tapering? Benefit or not? Why?

Take care, Mike

PS, it no longer takes 3 hours...

Re: steel for plane irons and saw blades

#16

A couple clarifications

Adam Cherubini

>No. I don't think taper grinding is necessary. I'm currently using an untapered 4tpi rip saw (.043"), purpose built for ripping pine (which tends to close its kerf a bit more than other woods and whose sap doesn't exactly lubricate the blade). So, for me, in my mind, saying "I think" refers to my opinion, but that opinion is based on ACTUAL USE, not theory. The biggest difference I noticed in using an untapered saw was its weight. Jury is still out whether that is good or bad. (I'm not saying this in response to anyone, BTW)

So I'm saying to you Andrew- Green light to make untapered saws. And to the rest of you, don't look down your nose at untapered rip saws from the likes of Mike Wenz. I think there are several differences between a new, well made saw (I have 4 of my own making) and an antique:

1) There's no such thing as a $5 saw. Its a $5 saw that needs several hours of restoration.

2) Its difficult to find the "right" saw, just like its difficult to find a specific molding plane. Surface planes are different in that they are much more generic.

3) I'm not trying to sell saws for anybody. But as someone who advocates their use, I don't think its any more practical to rely on antique saws in questionable condition than it is to rely on antique planes. Imagine where we'd be without LN and LV. In short, we as a community need sawmakers. We also need fitting planes BTW. And new center bits would be nice. I suspect I'll see all of this in my lifetime.

As for Kenyon and tapering saws:

Adam

"I don't see how they could have done that to hardened steel. It would had to have been annealed since the grind stones weren't that great- at least the few I've used aren't great."

Mike Wenz

Your assumption is that the steel received by Kenyon was already hardened--do we actually know this?

We know that Kenyon made steel. A quick internet search turns up that by the beginning of the 19th c, they probably had two locations- a rolling mill on the river Sheaf, not far from Greaves (Sheafworks)in Forge Lane and another property to the West in Hollis Croft. The other property made saws and files and the like. The rolling mill made spring steel. My guess is they cold rolled their tapers, but who knows.

The point I was trying to make is that with limited industrial capability, its not practical to taper grind a saw. For Andrew and any other would be tool makers, saw making probably wasn't a cottage industry done with simple tools. You may not be able to make tapered saws. Moreover, it may not be necessary.

One other thing: Disstons tapers often exceed .020" That doesn't sound like a lot of metal, but across a broad plate it might as well be an acre. Kenyon's taper was less.

Adam

Re: steel for plane irons and saw blades

#17

Re: A couple clarifications

mikew

>Well said.

Obviously you know my stance on tapering because we've discussed it. That said, I do like relieving the top edge down a little. Even to the point of slight rounding on the very edge. Not much. Just enough not to create friction or "bite" on the back stroke inside the kerf.

And Pine is one of the worse due to the fibrous nature left in the cut. Grabby stuff.

Part of the discussion is academic, of course. This part can get bogged down in minutiae and on my part, speculation. For me it is fun. But it doesn't help in so far as Andrew is concerned.

So my advice is to make it without taper. Play a little with set for the type of woods generally used. One can always taper it afterwards.

Take care, back to work.

Mike

Re: steel for plane irons and saw blades

#18

Re: A couple clarifications

Thom D

>I don't know squat about old western saws, but:

1) Where they hardened, differencially heat treated, or where the blades iron with a steel edge. Presumably they weren't made out of pre-hardened roll steel, so the amount of work that would be required to thin then could vary a great deal from modern practices.

2) did they forge the stock, or cold work it. Either way it could be drawn out during fabrication, and this can improve the stock's straighness and refine it's memory so it stays straight. Scythes are an example of extremely fine steel that is drawn out cold.

3) If you look at the Sen link I gave at the top of this thread, that is a perectly effective way of remouving metal it's like using a drawknife on wood as far as it's agressiveness is concerned, you get shavings.

Re: steel for plane irons and saw blades

#19

Re: A couple clarifications

Todd Hughes

>I think it is clear that saws were ground after they were hardened and tempered.

.....Disston were very clear that they did it that way. In thier 1900s "handbook of saws" which tells of how saws were made.Steps are.. rolling the steel to gauge,blanks cut out with shears,cut teeth,then hardened and tempered,.After the tempering they are "smithed" which makes them flat...only then are they ground "to gauge and to taper so that the back will be thinner then the cutting edge" Disston also said that" A saw not ground to proper taper cannot be ranked as a high class tool"

....The English did it simular. In the book "Some 19th Centurt English Woodworking tools" it has a section from an 1879 article that tells how saws were made in Sheffield. Rolled sheet is cut to shape with a paring machine,punch cuts the teeth out,then hardened and tempered using hot oil. Afterward it is straightened. Said this used to be done by hand but now large machines are used. Only now does it go to the grinder where "Great Skill and judgement are required on the part of the workman in reducing the face of the saw into a perfectly level surface" It then shows a man grinding a saw blade which is attached to a wooden "Scorching" board.The man is actually standing leaning into a large grindstone wheel with a cable attached to his belt so that he doesn't fall.Is interesting if you notice no mention was made in the earlier English account of grinding a taper into the blade but rather they were trying to get a "level surface"

I think the need for specialised machinery like these large grindstone probably caused small saw makers to farm out the saw grinding. In an interview with a David Bickley in 1890 this worker of 50 years with Disston talks about how when he started in 1840 the grinding was not done by the maker [Disston] but instead he had to push wheelbarrow full of saws to two different grinders in Philadelphia. I imagine these grinders used large grinding wheels probably run off water power

I still do not think that a 1700s saw blade was normaly tapered, at least not what we would think of a tapered saw blade to be, like a 1900s Disston. I have many older saws from the early to mid 1800s and they are not tapered like you see on later saws It was just a case of a tool evolving into a better design with time and technology.Also probably due to lower quality steel early saws often seem to be thicker then a saw from 1900 and maybe the thicker back was needed more to keep the saw from bending.

So Adam what type of restoration do you think a good clean $5 saw needs that takes "several hours" ? Even in the old tool hell I live in is no trouble to find good straight saws that maybe at most needs to be sharpened befor use, which even if you buy a new saw it will also need too probably sooner then later.Even if for cosmetic reasons I want to clean a saw up it is the rare one that takes more then 15 to 20 min.With good high quality vintage saws so common and cheap I just don't know why somebody would buy a new made one unless they just needed a repo older type saw for historical reasons. These cheap old saws that today are so easy to find probably represent the zeneth in saw manufacturing and I don't know what more a user could want .....Todd

Re: steel for plane irons and saw blades

#20

Saw restoration

Adam Cherubini

>So Adam what type of restoration do you think a good clean $5 saw needs that takes "several hours" ?

I guess I don't see good and clean. I see clean and I see good. I scrape rust with a razor blade then wet sand. And quite frankly, I have spent many hours sanding. Maybe I should have used something more aggressive, maybe the saw didn't need to have any bare metal exposed. Only a few of my saws are actually shiny.

Then there's often a slight bit of handle work to be done. I'e scarfed on horns, repaired cracks etc. That usually involves removing the handle.

After that, there's the standard sharpening. A good sharpening takes me 45 minutes or so. A touch up, maybe half that.

I've cleaned up probably 2 dozen saws and used them to make furniture. This is probably 1/100th of what you have done.

Cleaning saws is one of those things like writing software. When you think of it, its only a few minutes work. But after its done, you wonder where the time went. At least that's been my experience.

Adam

Re: steel for plane irons and saw blades

#21

Re: Saw restoration

paul womack

> I scrape rust with a razor blade then wet sand. And quite frankly, I have spent many hours sanding.

This is odd. I've cleaned a few saws; probably 12-18.

If I can get the handle off (quite the question, that one), removing rust normally takes 15-30 minutes. With the handle in the way, maybe 45.

I use 600-800 grit SiC wrapped around a very flat aluminium (*) block, working wet.

I place 3-4 layers of newspaper on the worktop; this absorbs any runaway water, and grips the saw blade (once it's a little damp).

Once the rust is off, I polish using Solvol Autosol chrome cleaner on 0000 wire wool. This is both attractive, rust resistant, and lower friction a tad.

Maybe the saws I'm buying are as clean as Todd's.

BugBear

(*) in the USA you could use Aluminum as a substitute

Re: steel for plane irons and saw blades

#22

Re: Saw restoration

Todd Hughes


>The saws I clean up for the most part are ones that I will be selling so they have to be clean and attractive more so then if I was just cleaning them to "Use". I don't polish them shiny bright but I do like them to be clean showing no rust.On non split nut saws I always take the handle off.With the handles I spray them with WD40 and clean them using fine steel wool. Since the amount of time it takes to clean saw affects my bottom line so to speak I tend to keep track of it pretty well and I do know how long it takes me.

....I sand them dry using some cheap chinese sandpaper on a sanding block..imagine about 220 grt though not certain.In my experance no need to go finer or to do it wet.I never use a razor blade to scrape them but know some do.

...I try not to buy a saw that is heavly rusted or pitted , same I don't understand buying a saw with a damaged handle that you have to patch etc. Hey if you like to do that stuff OK but with so many good saws out there you don't have to in order to have a good saw. Actually I see many saws that don't need any cleaning to use and quite a few where the teeth are still very sharp...certainly not hard to find a saw that just needs a touch up filing to get it ready to use.

...Vintage Saws are very common and doesn't take much looking in the wild to find good ones so why buy junk....or pay the big bucks for a new one?.... Todd

Re: steel for plane irons and saw blades

#23

Did they use a VERY large grinder ?

Ian Neuhaus


>Somewhere I've seen an old photo of knive grinders at work somewhere in France. Things that stood out were that the grinding wheel(s) were wet (and driven by water?), were about 6 foot in diameter (or possibly even larger), that 3 or 4 knife grinders lay on the stomachs all day when using the grinder, (and each had a large dog which spent the day lying on the back of its masters legs to keep the master warm). I'm not sure if the grinder was one large cylinder or a number of narrower ones.

So would using a grinder of this size make it relatively easy to taper grind a saw blade?

Also, might the saw maker partially create the taper by cold working the blade prior to grinding the smooth taper?

just some possible options

Re: steel for plane irons and saw blades

#24

Thanks Ted

Andrew Lunn

Re: steel for plane irons and saw blades

#25

Re: A couple clarifications

Andrew Lunn


>Thanks for the input, Mike. You said in an earlier post that you would recommended dealing with the hardened steel, as rehardening it would require a large furnace. So does that mean the stock you buy from supply places comes hardened already? The flat ground tool steel I found at a link supplied above by Bob says it is "oil hardening." Does that mean it comes hardened, or does it come soft and you have to harden it? I suspect it must come hardened. Here is the link:

http://www.victornet.com/cgi-bin/victor/productlist.html

Is tempering the saw as problematic as hardening it? Are you able to do it with a torch, or several torches?