Re: So how in the 18th c?
mikew
>"So how do you think they did it in the 18th c?"
Pretty much how I described. Disston was a product of the refinements made at least by the end of the 18th century. When he began, he was a mere 1/2 a generation away. He was from England and I suspect that either him or the person he worked for brought the then-current technology with them. American patents don't seem to shed any light on the subject for that time period, so I think the above is a reasonable assumption until such time research can answer with certainty.
"The taper in Seaton's saws isn't quite as great as Disstons, and it seems a little inconsistent (as if it was ground). They may have just used big grinding wheels, but I don't see how they could have done that to hardened steel. It would had to have been annealed since the grind stones weren't that great- at least the few I've used aren't great."
Your assumption is that the steel received by Kenyon was already hardened--do we actually know this? If I was working in the great industrial towns of England where on any given street it seems are 10 saw makers, and steel mills at the end of every block [OK, that was a bit of an exaggeration], I would have bought the rolled steel--which they had--in the pre-hardened state, shape the saw, taper grind and cut the teeth in, and take the plates back for hardening and tempering.
The Kenyon Sash is probably the most wildly tapered saw in the group of 6. And why taper a sash saw anyway? It's got a back. My guess is it was a reject from making other, larger saws and then further thicknessed by files in the shop in the hardened state. A grind stone would have produced a better taper--less obvious transitions in thickness--albeit really slow. That is my working theory anyway.
Another assumption is that Kenyon represents the state-of-the-art of 18th century saw making. Or even that the 6 saws in the Seaton chest were the best ones, or even ones of average quality. I've only handled two Kenyon saws. Both tenons. Neither had tapered blades and the saw plate was pretty even. However, both were early 19th century.
"I think Andrew wants to try this himself. And aside from the Mike Wenz, I'll just spend three hours on it method, I think the only way to do this practically is to start with annealed steel. Thoughts?"
Why thank you for that bit of sarcasm. I think. There were two parts to the question. One dealt with history, one with the therefore how to do it today. I tried giving an answer. It was easy, it seemed to me, to extrapolate backwards from there. Going from the known to the unknown type of thing.
Annealing would be an option. It is the hardening and tempering and dealing with the saw plate post process which would be the issue. The plate will not be flat when done. At least I do not think it would. And it would take a good size furnace to evenly reharden. I think the best bet is to deal with the hardened stock.
The Japanese use a sen. A link had already been given re sen. A sen is used on a bit harder steel and if I was going to do a one-off, I would use a sen and files, followed by polishing stones. That would be for leaving the steel in the hardened state.
The issue to me is that unless a person wants to do this madness for a living, is 3 hours really a bad investment of time?
So questions for you, Adam. Do you believe a saw plate even needs tapering? Benefit or not? Why?
Take care, Mike
PS, it no longer takes 3 hours...