Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

I got my cast iron plate!!!!!!

Posts

I got my cast iron plate!!!!!!

#1

I got my cast iron plate!!!!!!

George Allchin

>The plate will definitely need to be machined. Its surfaces are all slightly convex. I will probably mill it flat and then surface grind it.

The diamond paste (0-2micron & 36-60 micron) is pretty wild stuff! I spread some on a hardened steel plate and then tryed lapping a small piece of what I thought was pretty smooth (surface ground) steel. Wow, 2 different grits and now I see how unsmooth the ground surface was! I can't wait to try this on a piece that matters!!!

George in rainy Lowell, Michigan

Re: I got my cast iron plate!!!!!!

#2

Re: I got my cast iron plate!!!!!!

paul womack

>I spread some [small diamonds] on a hardened steel plate

You know the diamonds are meant to go on the soft surface, and (conterintuitively) wear away the hard surface, right?

BugBear

Re: I got my cast iron plate!!!!!!

#3

Re: I got my cast iron plate!!!!!! *LINK*

Miles

>I have been looking into this as well, and I found a company (Kemet, in Kent, UK) that sells nothing else but precision lapping supplies - diamond abrasives and either cast iron or composite lapping plates. The composite plates are not some common material, they appear to be specifically composed for the purpose. http://www.kemet.co.uk/about_kemet.html is a good place to start. There is plenty of choice of abrasives in particular.

After a helpful discussion with one of their technical people, I have had a quote for some lapping plates -

342743 6" Cast Iron Plate �51.00

342705 8" Cast Iron Plate �61.60

E04069 Kemet GP4 Sheet 6" x 2" x 18mm Thick �14.38 Each

Please note item 3 has a minimum order quantity of 10

The cast iron is pretty expensive - If enough people were inspired to try the Kemet GP4 material, we could reach the minimum order size (I would buy 2 sheets and use them with 2 grit sizes). I would be happy to be the intermediary.

There does seem to be a general view that this is a good way to go for sharpening, so it would be great to 'solve' the 'no cast iron plates available' problem.

hope this helps

Miles (Cambridge, UK)


Kemet International

Re: I got my cast iron plate!!!!!!

#4

Re: I got my cast iron plate!!!!!!

Alice Frampton, UK

>Miles, we might be able to rustle up enough demand amongst interested parties on UK Workshop. Although to be honest, if Rob Lee is really going to push cast iron lapping plates up the Lee Valley to-do list, it might be worth holding out a little longer.

Cheers, Alf

Re: I got my cast iron plate!!!!!!

#5

Re: I got my cast iron plate!!!!!!

Rob Lee

>Hi Alf -

Even if we push it up the list - it's still months away....

Tooling lead times are long... we're working on product for Christmas right now..

Cheers -

Rob

Re: I got my cast iron plate!!!!!!

#6

Re: I got my cast iron plate!!!!!!

Alice Frampton, UK

>Oh yes, I understand that, but thought it was worth mentioning rather than provoking a "if only I'd known" reaction down the line. :~)

Cheers, Alf

Re: I got my cast iron plate!!!!!!

#7

too small

bill tindall

>The sizes you mention are too small in my opinion. For these prices you should be able to buy cast iron blanks and have then ground sufficiently flat.

I have found lots of suitable cast iorn at junk yards. Often one side is already ground so that only the side needs to be cut.

I like a long plate for hand holding the tool. Our plates are 12" and that length provides a comfortable "stroking" distance. Longer would be even better except then they could be difficult to store.

for lathe tool honing (same principle, hollow grind on wheel and hone the bevel with diamond, about 15 micron) we made plates 1 x 5 x 3/8". The 6" composit material would be ideal to cut into strip for this task.

Re: I got my cast iron plate!!!!!!

#8

be cautious of contamination, 60 micron issue

bill tindall

>I would not recommend taking a tool from the 60 micron to the 1 micron plate. I think you will get contamination of the 1 micron by the coarser grit. An intermediate stroke or two on some fixed abrasive may eliminate the carry over of grit problem we have experienced.

I think 60 micron works better on acrylic as it embeds better, but I would like to hear other's opinion on this matter.

Re: I got my cast iron plate!!!!!!

#9

Re: I got my cast iron plate!!!!!!

Miles

>Alice, Rob, this makes me wonder why existing makers/suppliers of suitable stuff cannot be co-opted to provide it for LV catalog(ue) purposes - after all it is the link from the consumer to the OEM that is hard for individuals to make. With LV able to sell 'large' numbers of plates (there is clearly pent-up demand for these) then Kemet would probably be able to make them out of their *very proven* grade of cast iron or of GP4 to the size required, at much better rates than I was quoted. At least with a supplier like this, the technical excellence of the product is unimpeachable - it is their only business after all.

Rob, would you talk to Kemet about this, maybe get some items in your catalogue without the hassle of making them, and see what happens? Even if margins are small, at least they would be there... or did you talk to them already?

Alice, if UK Workshop folks want to buy some Kemet GP4 plates that would be great - I was told that it works even better than cast iron, the only unknown is how flat it stays but I am sure we can find out. I travel to the US quite often, so I can carry some over and post them to US buyers at low cost too. We might ask for some longer bits (Bill T's concern) if that was a consensus (I'm not sure it's mandatory).

Enough talking about it - how about a show of hands... you know you want to :-)

Miles

PS I go from 80 or 120 grit on belt sander, to 15micron (red) DMT or oilstone, to blue honing compound on flat leather - seems to work well, but DMT is the weak link as it can't be refreshed.

Re: I got my cast iron plate!!!!!!

#10

Re: I got my cast iron plate!!!!!!

Rob Lee

>Hi Miles -

We're in the middle of doing something similar to what you're suggesting.

Cheers -

Rob

Re: I got my cast iron plate!!!!!!

#11

the problem with "real" lapping plates

bill tindall

>They are too good (flat) and hence too expensive, as well as the fact that they are not the right size or shape for our needs. These things don't need to be flat to 0.0000000" to deal with a plane iron. Somebody recently quoted what a cast iron jointer table cost, less than $50 as I recall. I have located US sources of custom ground plates of perfect size for less than $25, in modest quatities. One can imagine how little a foreign sourced plate would cost in large quantity.

Rather than chase the "real" lapping plate option, it makes more sense to find local sources of cast iron and a local source of grinding it fairly flat( any machine shop). Local sources could be junk yards, metal supply businesses, foundries, metal casting businesses, machine shops. My first plates came from a bar of cast iron a machine shop had on hand. Cost me $30 to get 3 plates made. On our next adventure we purchased contunuously cast bar stock, and had it sawed to size and ground. These plates were less than $20 each. We sawed 6 nice plates from a 12"long machine shop cast iron angle plate. As you can see there are numerous possibilities to get perfect sized plates from a variety of cast iron sources and the services of a machine shop. The cost will depend on how close the cast iron piece is to the final size desired. Eventually someone will decide to make a business of this opportunity and offer affordable plates to all.

Re: I got my cast iron plate!!!!!!

#12

Re: the problem with "real" lapping plates

Miles

>All absolutely true of course... but for many people the hassle involved in doing it for the fewest cash $ is worth more than the actual cash price. If I can get super-quality lapping stuff for �14 ($28) a piece, knowing it is optimised for the application, the non-optimised solution would have to be 'free' to really compete in my estimation.

It's great that Bill has the option to do both and get results - I have tried here without as much success, so it was cool to find a 'real' lapping plate option that might be feasible. I wanted to see what everyone thought about it, and we have a good set of answers now - and Rob's hint of LV options too :-)

A related question - why has no-one made a reciprocating drive for moving the flat rectangular stone/diamond/whatever under a fixed blade, rather than always defaulting to rotary motion... not too hard I would think, although a bit of mech-eng needed. Would allow everyone to use their favourite old stones with a bit less elbow grease.

cheers

Miles

PS Bill, given the degree of sharpening perfectionism shown here sometimes, I'd be careful suggesting a sub-optimal solution in case your reputation never recovers ;-)

Re: I got my cast iron plate!!!!!!

#13

good points.....

bill tindall

>especially the last! However, I can't over emphasize the utility of a 12" vs 8" surface, especially for hand-held sharpening.

Re: I got my cast iron plate!!!!!!

#14

Re: be cautious of contamination, 60 micron issue

George Allchin

>Paul,Bill,& all

You are correct in pointing out the contamination issue. Paul, when I got my diamond paste I had a 4x6 inch piece of hardened steel that was soon to be put in the wire EDM that I run. I also had a small block of CRS that I am using to make a core for a short run mold that I am making for myself. This is why I lapped the soft steel on the hard plate. ;^)

I have yet to cut and grind the cast iron, but will probably do it on Sat. while I am at work. I am thinking that I will probably list 2 of the 1x4x12 inch pieces in the classified section. The down side to this whole thing is that I paid $15.00 to ship it (44#) from Aurora, Ill. to Grand Rapids, Mich. Oh well, over all I think it still will work out well for me.

George in sunny Lowell, Mich.

Re: I got my cast iron plate!!!!!!

#15

Re: be cautious of contamination, 60 micron issue

Dan Donaldson

>There are at least a few of us here in Michigan that might be interested. With the price of gas, it might actually cost more than the shipping, but would possibly be a good excuse to meet another Islander.

Re: I got my cast iron plate!!!!!!

#16

Re: I got my cast iron plate!!!!!!

Thom D

>I already have my lee valley cast iron plate. Everything old is new again!

Re: I got my cast iron plate!!!!!!

#17

shipping iron

Clay C in Miami

>Several 1x4x12's would fit in one of the 'shirt-shaped' USPS flat rate boxes, and these ship Priority Mail for $8.10 regardless of weight or (US) destination. The only limit on those is that they must be under 70 pounds per box. When I go west for the summer, I ship my hand tools in these - one box last summer was 55 pounds, sent from Miami FL to Ft. Bragg CA -- I thought that was a real bargain for barely over 8 bucks.

Clay